Pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 (EC 184.108.40.206) is involved in the endogenous proline synthesis from glutamate and pyrroline-5-carboxylate.Reference Elijah and Leonard1,Reference Perez-Arellano, Carmona-Alvarez and Martinez2 Its deficiency (MIM#616420) is caused by biallelic variants in PYCR2. Proline is an important amino acid for central nervous system and connective tissues.Reference Perez-Arellano, Carmona-Alvarez and Martinez2 Less than 30 patients have been reported in the literature.Reference Nakayama, Al-Maawali and El-Quessny3–Reference Bick, Fraser and Gutzeit6 The clinical features include global developmental delay, acquired microcephaly, movement disorder, seizures, and failure to thrive.Reference Nakayama, Al-Maawali and El-Quessny3–Reference Bick, Fraser and Gutzeit6
We report a new patient with a known pathogenic homozygous PYCR2 variant who presented with early infantile onset severe global developmental delay, acquired microcephaly, failure to thrive, and delayed myelination in brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Additionally, we summarized all patients published in the literature for their phenotype and genotype in this case report.
This 2-year 2-month-old girl was born to healthy consanguineous Egyptian parents. The pregnancy was remarkable for maternal hypothyroidism and thyroid hormone treatment. She was delivered by an elective caesarian section at 37 weeks of gestation. Birth weight was at the 3rd percentile. Her apgars were 9 and 10 at 1 and 5 minutes, respectively. She was formula-fed due to lack of breast milk production. There was persistent vomiting and failure to thrive from the first few months of life. She was started on oral ranitidine at 4 months of age and vomiting was improved, but not failure to thrive. Developmental delay was noted from the first few months of age.
She had her first generalized tonic seizure lasting 1 minute at the age of 7 months. Her electroencephalography (EEG) showed intermittent diffuse 2–3 Hz delta slowing indicating cortical encephalopathy with no epileptogenic discharges at the age of 8 months. She underwent video EEG recording, which showed four brief myoclonic jerks during drowsiness and wakefulness with generalized 2.5–3 Hz spike- and polyspike-and-wave complexes. There was intermittent sharply contoured slow-wave activity over bilateral temporal head region during sleep. She was started on levetiracetam.
At the age of 18 months, she was attempting to reach objects, roll from prone to supine, and was babbling. She did not achieve unsupported sitting or acquired any words at the age of 26 months. Her weight, height, and head circumference were below the 3rd percentile. She had full eyebrows, upslanting palpebral fissures, long eyelashes, bulbous nasal tip, absent antihelix bilaterally and plagiocephaly. She had central hypotonia. Muscle stretch reflexes were +2 and symmetrical.
Chromosomal microarray, ammonia, lactate, acylcarnitine profile, plasma amino acids, total and free carnitine, total homocysteine, very long chain fatty acids, transferrin isoelectric focusing, urine organic acids, urine oligosaccharides and urine creatine, and guanidinoacetate were normal. Brain MRI showed delayed myelination and thin corpus callosum. Clinical whole-exome sequencing identified a known pathogenic homozygous variant c.796C>T (p.Arg266*)Reference Zaki, Bhat and Sultan4 (NM_013328.3) in PYCR2 confirming the diagnosis of pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency. Both parents were heterozygous for the same variant.
We summarized clinical and neuroimaging features and genotype results of 24 patients including our current patient with pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency in Table 1. We listed demographics, birth history, detailed clinical features including dysmorphic features, skeletal and ophthalmological features of 25 patients with pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency in Supplemental Table 1.Reference Nakayama, Al-Maawali and El-Quessny3–Reference Bick, Fraser and Gutzeit6 Twelve PYCR2 variants in 18 families were identified and 7 of them (58%) were missense and 5 of them (42%) were truncating. Eight patients had a homozygous known p.Arg266* variant in PYCR2. We grouped patients into two groups based on the type of variant (truncating variants in 12 patients and missense variants in 12 patients), to compare the frequency of seizures, hyperkinetic movements, and non-ambulation. In both groups, seizures (50%) and non-ambulation (92%) were reported at the same frequency. Whereas hyperkinetic movements seemed to be more common in patients with truncating variants (67%) compared to missense variants (50%). We also grouped patients into two groups including patients with the p.Arg266* variant (8 patients) and patients without the p.Arg266* variant (16 patients). In both groups, seizures (50% in both groups) and non-ambulation (87.5% of the patients with the p.Arg266* variant and 94% of the patients without the p.Arg266* variant) were reported at the similar frequencies. Whereas, hyperkinetic movements seemed to be more common in patients with the p.Arg266* variant (75%) compared to patients without the p.Arg266* variant (50%). Phenotype was variable in a sibling pair with the homozygous p.Val193Met variant: older sibling had seizures at the age of 15 years and was nonambulatory, whereas younger sibling did not present with seizures and was walking with a walker at the age of 12 years. The PYCR2 p.Arg266* variant has been reported in the five nonrelated Egyptian families and a Moroccan family.Reference Zaki, Bhat and Sultan4,Reference Meng, Donti and Xia5 This variant could be a founder variant in the north African population.
FTT = failure to thrive; GDD = global developmental delay; Hmz = homozygous; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; NA = not available.
a ,b,c,d,e,f,gSibling pairs.
h Arginine at 266 is encoded by three bases CGA (NM__013328.3). Some patients are reported with c.796C>T, which is the first base change and some patients are reported with c.796G>A, which is the second base change. According to current NM__013328.3, c.796G>A should have been c.797G>A. Both base pair changes affect arginine at 266 and results in stop codon. As c.796G>A is reported in the literature, we did not correct this in the table.
None of the reported patients have had a biochemical derangement to provide a diagnostic clue to guide molecular genetic confirmation of pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency. This inherited metabolic disease is restricted to central nervous system. Cerebrospinal fluid metabolomic analysis might identify a potential biomarker to increase our understanding and might help us to search for treatment targets. It is not certain, if the disease onset is prenatal and if proline supplementation during pregnancy or in the neonatal period would provide any benefit in patients.
Pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency is classified as hypomyelinating leukodystrophy-10 (OMIM#616420) by Nakayama et al.Reference Nakayama, Al-Maawali and El-Quessny3 Delayed myelination, demyelination, cerebral atrophy, thin corpus callosum, and cerebellar atrophy in brain MRI were also reported in patients.Reference Zaki, Bhat and Sultan4–Reference Bick, Fraser and Gutzeit6 Hypomyelination and delayed myelination have a similar appearance on a single MRI. The diagnosis of hypomyelination requires another MRI at least 6 months apart from the first MRI to see if myelin content has been increasing. An increase in the myelin content is called delayed myelination. No change in the myelin content between two MRIs is called hypomyelination.Reference Schiffmann and van der Knaap7 After the first report by Nakayama, none of the patients had hypomyelination in brain MRI. To the best of our knowledge, none of the patients had two MRIs to differentiate delayed myelination from hypomyelination.
Pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency is a rare inherited metabolic disorder affecting central nervous system. Hyperkinetic movements seem to be more common in patients with truncating variants and the p.Arg266* variant in PYCR2. Identification of more patients might expand the phenotypic spectrum of pyrroline-5-carboxylate reductase 2 deficiency.
We would like to thank our patient’s parents for allowing us to present their child’s results.
Statement of Authorship
Dr. Afroze drafted the manuscript, reviewed the literature, and approved the final version of the manuscript.
Dr. Mercimek-Andrews supervised and mentored Dr. Afroze for data analysis and completeness of manuscript.
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
To view supplementary material for this article, please visit https://doi.org/10.1017/cjn.2020.5.