Dystrophinopathies are a group of X-linked genetic diseases characterized by dystrophin gene mutations. They may be associated with various phenotypes including Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy, isolated quadriceps myopathy, asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic hyperCKemia, X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy, cognitive disorders, and symptomatic female carriers.Reference Wicklund 1
Diagnosing symptomatic female carriers without affected male relatives may be challenging because these women’s symptoms may simulate limb-girdle muscular dystrophy.Reference Golla, Agadi and Burns 2 - Reference Tasca, Monforte and Iannaccone 5 The correct diagnosis is of utmost importance for adequate genetic counseling and cardiac follow-up.
Patients and Methods
A retrospective case series study of symptomatic dystrophinopathy carriers was conducted. Medical charts review was performed with evaluation of relevant clinical and serum muscle enzyme levels, imaging, muscle biopsy, and molecular studies. Data analysis was performed with approval of the institutional scientific and ethical committees.
Inclusion criterion was female patients with muscle weakness detectable in at least one muscle group with dystrophin gene heterozygous mutation.Reference Soltanzadeh, Friez and Dunn 3 Exclusion criteria were asymptomatic carriers and patients presenting with cramps, myalgia, exercise intolerance, or raised serum muscle enzyme levels without evidence of muscle weakness.Reference Soltanzadeh, Friez and Dunn 3 , Reference Lee, Lee, Lee and Choi 6
Mutation (deletion or duplication) detection in the dystrophin gene was performed through the multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification technique with SALSA P034 and SALSA P035 kits (MRC-Holland).
From 116 dystrophinopathy female carriers admitted from 1997 to 2015 in a neuromuscular reference clinic, 10 (8.6%) symptomatic carriers were selected.
The clinical history from each patient is outlined in the following paragraphs and key clinical and laboratorial findings are summarized in Tables 1 and 2. Patient 1 was a 40-year-old woman that had started, at the age of 35, having frequent falls and progressive difficulty climbing stairs. Patient 2 was a 36-year-old woman that reported that she did not speak until she was 4 years old and, at the age of 24, started having upper left arm weakness. Patient 3 was a 15-year-old girl that presented with frequent falls and difficulty walking and climbing stairs. Patient 4 was a 28-year-old woman that had started, in childhood, losing the incapacity to run and progressive difficulty climbing stairs. Patient 5 was a 26-year-old woman admitted with a history of elbow joint contractures since childhood, at age of 16 she started having difficulties raising from chairs, and at age of 18 started having myalgia, difficulties climbing stairs, and raising her arms. Patient 6 was a 68-year-old woman admitted with generalized myalgia and cramps since the age of 58; at age 63, she started having lumbar pain, frequent falls, and difficulties climbing stairs; she had dyslipidemia and had used statins for several years. Patient 7 was a 44-year-old woman with the inability to climb stairs without support since age 38; at age 44, she started having difficulties raising her arms. Patient 8 was a 33-year-old woman that had started, at the age of 12, having a progressively abnormal gait, frequent falls, and difficulty standing up; at age 33, she started having difficulty climbing stairs and raising her arms. Patient 9 was a 48-year-old woman with abnormal, unstable gait and difficulty running and climbing stairs; at age 46, she began having frequent falls and difficulties raising her arms. Patient 10 was a 42-year-old woman that had acquired independent gait at the age of 3, and, at the age of 28, started progressive gait abnormality, cramps, and difficulty climbing stairs.
Age=age at admission; calf (+)=increased calf volume; NA=not available; NR=not reported; start: age at first symptoms.
Serum creatine kinase times increase referent to each age-dependent reference values.
Imaging age=age at image studies and time elapsed between first symptoms and imaging examination; mosaic=dystrophin immunohistochemistry with positive and negative or decreased intensity fibers; NR=not reported.
Five patients (1, 2, 3, 5, and 6) were initially submitted for muscle biopsy with immunohistochemistry before subsequent molecular investigation. Five patients (4, 7-10) were not submitted for muscle biopsy and their diagnosis was confirmed by clinical, imaging, and molecular correlations.
Patients’ ages at admission ranged from 15 to 68 years, with a mean of 38.1 years. The age range of first symptoms varied from the ages 2 to 58, with a mean of 27.8 years (Table 1). Half of the patients did not present any affected male relatives (Table 1). Gowers maneuver was present in seven of eight patients, and patient 5 presented with early elbow contractures at initial clinical presentation (Table 1). Serum creatine kinase levels varied from 648 to 4509 IU/l, which corresponded to a ratio of 3.9 to 27.3 times the respective reference values, with a mean increase of 9.7 times the reference values (Table 2). Creatine kinase levels are higher in younger patients than in older patients, when necrotic process of muscle fibers is active.
Patients 1, 3, 5, 7, and 8 underwent computed tomography scanning at the time of the investigation. Patient 6 underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on 1.5-Tesla equipment, including coronal and axial T1-weighted sequences, coronal and axial short T1 inversion recovery sequences, and axial fat-saturated T2-weighted sequences. Muscle imaging studies demonstrated predominant asymmetric muscle fat replacement (Figures 1 and 2, Table 2). Severe muscle fat replacement was observed as follows.
∙ Patient 1: bilateral medial, posterior, and anterior thigh; bilateral medial gastrocnemius; and left soleus
∙ Patient 3: bilateral glutei, bilateral adductor magnus, bilateral vastus intermedius, and left vastus lateralis
∙ Patient 5: right vastus lateralis, left quadriceps femoris, bilateral adductor magnus, bilateral biceps femoralis, left semimembranosus, bilateral soleus, bilateral peroneus, left gastrocnemius lateralis, and left gastrocnemius medialis
∙ Patient 6: right gluteus maximus, bilateral adductor magnus, bilateral semimembranosus, and right medial gastrocnemius
∙ Patient 7: right vastus lateralis, bilateral biceps femoris, right semitendinosus, right semimembranosus, bilateral adductor magnus, and left medial gastrocnemius
∙ Patient 8: bilateral vastus lateralis, bilateral vastus intermedius, left rectus femoralis, left biceps femoralis, left semitendinosus, left semimembranosus, bilateral soleus, left medial gastrocnemius, and right lateral gastrocnemius.
The most commonly involved muscle groups were glutei and thigh adductors, followed by posterior and anterior thigh and posterior leg muscles. Patients 1 and 8 presented the most severe muscle fat replacement, which corresponded to them having with the longest duration of symptoms: 14 and 21 years of disease progression, respectively (Figure 1, Table 2). All patients, except patient 1, presented sartorius and gracilis muscles preservation compared with other muscle groups.
Muscle biopsy was performed in patients 1, 2, 3, 5, and 6. A myopathic pattern was demonstrated in all patients, with a variation in fiber caliber. Immunohistochemical studies with serial sections with dystrophin-spectrin were performed, because spectrin is a marker of muscle fiber membrane integrity. Dystrophin immunohistochemistry demonstrated clear mosaic pattern in two patients (1 and 2) and only subtle reduction of dystrophin intensity in three patients (3, 5, and 6) (Figure 3). The intensity of dystrophin expression was compared with both preservation of spectrin expression in the same group of fibers in serial sections and intensity of dystrophin expression compared with normal fibers and control muscle (Figure 3).
All patients underwent molecular investigation and all presented dystrophin gene deletions (Table 2). The deletions were found in DMD gene exons 13, 13-17, 20-29, 20-41, 38-43, 45, 45-46, 46-55, 47-48, and 48-50 (Table 2). Heterozygous c.1554T>A, p.D518E missense mutation in exon 13, to the best of our knowledge, has not been previously described. This mutation was associated with immunohistochemical dystrophin mosaic pattern and considered functionally pathogenic (patient 3)(Table 2).
The majority of dystrophin female carriers are asymptomatic. The frequency of symptomatic carriers found in this study was 8.6%. These data are in accordance with previous studies that describe ratios from 2.5% to 17%.Reference Soltanzadeh, Friez and Dunn 3 , Reference Heide, Afenjar and Edery 7 There is clinical overlap between symptomatic female carriers with dystrophinopathy and limb-girdle muscular dystrophy.Reference Golla, Agadi and Burns 2 - Reference Lee, Lee, Lee and Choi 6 The differential diagnosis between both is of the utmost importance for adequate genetic counseling because limb-girdle muscular dystrophy presents with dominant or recessive autosomal inheritance and dystrophinopathy presents an X-linked inheritance.
In an UK epidemiological study, the prevalence of symptomatic female carriers was 0.43 per 100,000 inhabitants (from a total of 8.46 per 100,000 symptomatic dystrophinopathy men and women).Reference Norwood, Harling, Chinnery, Eagle, Bushby and Straub 8 The prevalence of symptomatic female carriers was similar to the prevalence of the most common limb-girdle muscular dystrophies, such as fukutin-related proteinopathy (LGMD2I) with 0.43 per 100,000 inhabitants and calpainopathy (LGMD2A) with 0.60 per 100,000 inhabitants.Reference Norwood, Harling, Chinnery, Eagle, Bushby and Straub 8 - Reference Albuquerque, Abath Neto, Silva, Zanoteli and Reed 10
Symptomatic female dystrophin carriers may present asymmetric lower limb muscular weakness that may be slight or as severe as rapidly progressive Duchenne-like muscular dystrophy.Reference Soltanzadeh, Friez and Dunn 3
Patient 6 presented with a late-onset muscular weakness that was noticed after dyslipidemia treatment and the hypotheses of statin-induced myopathy had been raised. The detection of asymmetric muscular weakness with right quadriceps femoris atrophy, increased creatine kinase levels, and a mixed electromyogram pattern raised the diagnostic hypotheses of muscular dystrophy or sporadic inclusion body myositis. Her muscle biopsy demonstrated one rimmed vacuole, myofibrillar disorganization, and 12- to 18-nm filamentous inclusions (Figure 3).
Rimmed vacuoles have been previously described in a dystrophinopathy patient with Becker phenotype without calf volume increase and with dystrophin gene deletion.Reference de Visser, Bakker, Defesche, Bolhuis and van Ommen 11 In that study, transmission electron microscopy demonstrated autophagic vacuoles but no filamentous inclusions were detected.Reference de Visser, Bakker, Defesche, Bolhuis and van Ommen 11
It is not clear if the filamentous inclusion observed in patient 6’s muscle biopsy may be attributed to an unusual phenotype of symptomatic female carrier of dystrophinopathy or to a superposition of sporadic inclusion body myositis (double trouble). Even though some characteristics of sporadic inclusion body myositis were lacking, such as no finger flexors weakness compared with deltoideus muscle weakness, iliopsoas muscle weakness was worse than quadriceps femoris weakness and no lymphocytic inflammatory infiltrate was observed.Reference Rose 12 The autophagic vacuoles found may be secondary lysosomes that resulted from sublethal muscle fiber lesions.Reference de Visser, Bakker, Defesche, Bolhuis and van Ommen 11 No myofibrillar deposits were observed on patient 6’s muscle biopsy. The correct diagnosis of this patient was of utmost importance for genetic counseling of her children. No well-defined increased signal areas on short T1 inversion recovery sequences that could suggest edema and favor the diagnosis of sporadic inclusion body myositis were found on her muscle magnetic resonance imaging studies. Immunohistochemistry for MHC-1 was performed and no increased sarcolemmal reaction was observed; vessel MHC-1 reaction similar to the normal control was observed (Figure 4).
Muscle imaging studies presented as common characteristics: asymmetric muscle fat replacement in the thighs and legs, especially the posterior thigh and medial gastrocnemius with relative preservation of sartorius and gracilis as previously described (Figure 1).Reference Tasca, Monforte and Iannaccone 5 Multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification genetic analysis is not performed on a routine basis for all patients, but all muscle biopsy candidates undergo muscle imaging studies. Before any muscle biopsy, the neuromuscular clinic’s neurologists, neurophysiologists, pediatricians, radiologists, and pathologists review all noninvasive procedures that could be performed to elucidate the diagnosis. Diagnostic hypotheses are raised based on imaging studies in conjunction with clinical and laboratorial data. Patients 7 and 8 presented limb-girdle muscular weakness, pronounced calf pseudohypertrophy, increased muscle enzymes, and imaging studies that demonstrated asymmetric involvement with muscle fat replacement of the gluteus maximus and medius, biceps femoris, adductor magnus, and vasti as well as no muscle involvement of the sartorius and gracilis, consistent with the descriptions by Tasca et al.Reference Tasca, Monforte and Iannaccone 5
Duchenne muscular dystrophy, in male patients, usually presents widespread dystrophic pattern of fibroadipose replacement of the muscle tissue with numerous fibers with necrosis and phagocytosis. On the contrary, symptomatic female carriers may present a myopathic pattern only, with variation in fiber caliber and sparse necrosis and phagocytosis foci (Figure 3). A high suspicion level is necessary for the diagnosis; systematic performance of dystrophin immunohistochemical studies has been recommended by some authors.Reference Doriguzzi, Palmucci, Mongini, Chiadó-Piat, Maniscalco and Restagno 4 Besides that, a secondary sarcoglycan deficiency may be observed in patients with dystrophin gene abnormalities.Reference Draviam, Billington, Senchak, Hoffman and Watkins 13 , Reference Engel and Franzini-Armstrong 14
Joint contractures are common late findings in advanced stages of dystrophinopathy; early joint contractures as the first clinical presentation of dystrophinopathy, as observed in patient 5, are not expected (Table 1). Early contractures had been previously described in males with dystrophinopathy, but this may be the first description of early contractures in a symptomatic female carrier.Reference Doriguzzi, Palmucci, Mongini, Chiadó-Piat, Maniscalco and Restagno 4
Absent familial history of affected male relatives, early elbow contractures, and very late onset myopathy may occur in female carriers of dystrophinopathy. One novel dystrophin gene point mutation was described: heterozygous c.1554T>A p.D518E missense mutation considered pathogenic because it was observed in a patient with immunohistochemical dystrophin mosaic pattern.
The differential diagnosis between symptomatic female carriers with dystrophinopathy and limb-girdle muscular dystrophy is of utmost importance for adequate genetic counseling and cardiological follow-up.
The authors thank the families for their participation in the study. We thank Cleides Campos de Oliveira and Simone Ferreira do Nascimento for technical assistance.
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
Statement of Authorship
MMN, MMM, SVN, RXN, and APV performed the clinical diagnoses, collected the patients’ clinical data, and revised the manuscript. JV and EC were involved in analysis and interpretation of neurophysiological studies and revising the manuscript. CCS and RYT undertook the molecular investigation, were involved in interpretation of molecular data, and revising the manuscript. ALda-CJ was involved in the acquisition and interpretation of data regarding muscle image studies and revising the manuscript. EBS was involved in interpreting electron microscopy studies and revising the manuscript. AC and JFP were involved in conducting muscle biopsy studies, interpreting muscle biopsy results, and revising the manuscript. AC was involved in the conception, design, and drafting and revision of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.