No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Discovering America: From Paul Bunyan to Peter Grimes
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 July 2015
Abstract
Britten and Auden’s ‘choral operetta’ Paul Bunyan, written in New York in 1939–41, has often been seen as out of touch with its American context and as an anomalous precursor to the triumphant Peter Grimes (1945). A closer look, however, suggests a more complex engagement with American musical life and with the problem of American operatic populism. Indeed, if Paul Bunyan offered one set of answers to this problem, toying with popular genres and smaller forms, the rejection of this approach in Peter Grimes also seems tied to shifting American ideas about contemporary opera. Attention to Paul Bunyan in its American context highlights the transatlantic nature of both American and British operatic developments in the mid-twentieth century, while also recasting Britten’s operatic trajectory, restoring a sense of scepticism and uncertainty to his operatic project at its very beginnings.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © Cambridge University Press 2015
Footnotes
*
Heather Wiebe, King’s College London; heather.wiebe@kcl.ac.uk.
References
1 William Mann, ‘Paul Bunyan’, The Times (London) (7 June 1976).
2 Graf, Herbert, Opera for the People (Minneapolis, 1951), 188–190 Google Scholar.
3 Fauser, Annegret, Sounds of War: Music in the United States During World War II (Oxford, 2013), 161–162 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
4 Goehr, Lydia, Elective Affinities: Musical Essays on the History of Aesthetic Theory (New York, 2008), 258–259 Google Scholar.
5 Weill, Kurt, ‘The Future of Opera in America’, Modern Music 14 (1937), 186 Google Scholar.
6 See Mason, David, ‘The “Civitas” of Sound: Auden’s Paul Bunyan and New Year Letter ’, Journal of Modern Literature 19 (1994), 120 Google Scholar.
7 See Tippins, Sherill, February House (New York, 2005)Google Scholar.
8 Auden, W.H., Paul Bunyan: The Libretto of the Operetta by Benjamin Britten (London, 1988), 72 Google Scholar.
9 Auden, , Paul Bunyan, 30 Google Scholar.
10 On when the ‘Lullaby’ was cut, see Mitchell, Donald, ‘The Origins, Evolution and Metamorphoses of Paul Bunyan, Auden’s and Britten’s “American” Opera’, in Auden, Paul Bunyan, 111, 143–144 Google Scholar.
11 Auden, , Paul Bunyan, 70 Google Scholar.
12 Auden, W.H., ‘Opera on an American Legend’, New York Times (4 May 1941)Google Scholar.
13 See Wasley, Aidan, The Age of Auden: Postwar Poetry and the American Scene (Princeton, 2011), 3–5 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 21–5. David Mason draws a similar set of comparisons between Paul Bunyan and New Year Letter (‘The “Civitas” of Sound’, 122).
14 Auden, W.H., Prose, Vol. II 1939–1948, The Complete Works of W.H. Auden, ed. Edward Mendelson (Princeton, 2002), 66 Google Scholar, quoted in Wasley, The Age of Auden, 5.
15 See Mason, , ‘The “Civitas” of Sound’, 122 Google Scholar.
16 Wasley, , The Age of Auden, 26 (quoting Charles Miller, Auden: An American Friendship (New York, 1989), 44)Google Scholar.
17 Wasley, , The Age of Auden, 24 Google Scholar.
18 Auden, W.H., Collected Poems, ed. Edward Mendelson (New York, 1991), 201 Google Scholar.
19 Olin Downes drew a connection to The Cradle Will Rock in ‘Official Opening for Paul Bunyan’, New York Times, 6 May 1941, 25. No For an Answer is mentioned in Henry Simon, ‘Paul Bunyan Gets a Fitting for Opera’, P.M. (May 1941), both at the Britten-Pears Library (hereafter BPL). On Bauman, see Reuss, Richard A. and Reuss, JoAnne C., American Folk Music and Leftwing Politics, 1927–1957 (Folkestone, 2000), 117 Google Scholar; Denning, Michael, The Cultural Front: The Laboring of American Culture in the Twentieth Century, 2nd edn (London, 2010), 289 Google Scholar, 521.
20 Paul Bunyan programme, Brander Matthews Hall, Columbia University, 5 May 1941, 2 (BPL). On the Group Theatre as collective, see Sidnell, Michael, Dances of Death: The Group Theatre of London in the Thirties (London, 1984), 257 Google Scholar.
21 Wasley, , The Age of Auden, 8 Google Scholar, 14–15.
22 On Paul Bunyan within Auden’s trajectory from verse plays to opera, see Carlson, Matthew Paul, ‘Auden and Britten’s Paul Bunyan and the Frontiers of Opera’, Modern Drama 54 (Winter 2011), 409–434 Google Scholar.
23 Britten to Hawkes, Ralph, 29 June 1939, in Letters From a Life: Selected Letters and Diaries of Benjamin Britten, Vol. 2, 1939–45, ed. Donald Mitchell and Philip Reed (London, 1991), 675 Google Scholar. On the work’s commissioning and production plans, see Auden, W.H. and Kallman, Chester, Libretti and Other Dramatic Writings, 1939–1973, ed. Edward Mendelson (Princeton, 1993), 533–534 Google Scholar; Mitchell, , ‘The Origins, Evolution and Metamorphoses of Paul Bunyan’, 88–91 Google Scholar. On Britten and The Second Hurricane, see Letters From a Life: Selected Letters and Diaries of Benjamin Britten, Vol. 1, 1923–1938, ed. Donald Mitchell and Philip Reed (London, 1991), 567; Britten to Copland, 8 May 1939, in Letters, II: 634. Boosey & Hawkes was also Copland’s main publisher beginning in 1938, thanks in part to Britten (Letters, I: 567). Britten and Copland saw each other regularly while Britten was in Brooklyn and Long Island: see Pollack, Howard, Aaron Copland: The Life and Work of an Uncommon Man (New York, 1999), 73–74 Google Scholar.
24 Paul Bunyan programme, 5.
25 Activities of the Alice M. Ditson Fund of Columbia University: Allocations and Administration, First Half Century 1940–1989, Book 1 (New York, 1989).
26 Paul Bunyan programme, 4. Also see Downes, Olin, ‘Chamber Opera: League of Composers Launches Plan to Help American Lyric Theatre’, New York Times (16 March 1941)Google Scholar.
27 Information about the Columbia Theatre Associates’ repertory is from ‘Columbia Theatre Associates 1893–1958’, Box 1, Columbia University Rare Book & Manuscript Library, New York.
28 Paul Bunyan programme, 2.
29 ‘Columbia Theatre Associates 1893–1958’; Graf, Opera for the People, 194, 142. Aside from A Tree on the Plains, which premiered at Converse College in 1942, these were all premieres.
30 Graf, , Opera for the People, 193 Google Scholar.
31 Graf, , Opera for the People, 188–190 Google Scholar. Graf points out that Grimes was also given a successful early performance by the opera workshop at Stanford University, founded in 1940 (192). This performance was in May 1948 (see ‘Players Give Peter Grimes’, Stanford Daily (17 May 1948)).
32 Britten to Ralph Hawkes, 19 October 1939, in Letters II: 712. Britten also publicly mentioned the possibility of a Broadway premiere in a 1940 interview: William G. King, ‘Music and Musicians’, New York Sun (27 April 1940) (BPL).
33 Kildea, Paul, Benjamin Britten: A Life in the Twentieth Century (London, 2013), 179 Google Scholar. Also see Mitchell, , ‘The Origins, Evolution and Metamorphoses of Paul Bunyan’, 88–91 Google Scholar, 97–8; Reed, Philip, ‘A Rejected Love Song from Paul Bunyan ’, Musical Times 129 (1988), 283 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Both Mitchell (91) and Reed (283–4) point out that Broadway increasingly accommodated political and social seriousness in the 1930s.
34 One article, which quotes Colin Graham, states, ‘Britten wrote it about three years before Oklahoma! was written and it is a real traditional American musical’ (East Anglian Daily Times (2 June 1976) (BPL)). Also see Dennis Barker, ‘London Letter’, The Guardian (5 June 1976) (BPL). The positioning of Paul Bunyan as a musical also had to do with the company performing it in 1976, the English Music Theatre Company, which replaced Britten’s disbanded English Opera Group and was meant to perform musicals as well as opera. On the ‘musical-isation’ of the work, also see Ward-Griffin, Danielle, ‘“The Wrong Piece in the Wrong Place”: Resituating the Operas of Benjamin Britten’, Ph.D. diss (Yale University, 2012), 237–238 Google Scholar.
35 Mann, , ‘Paul Bunyan’ (BPL); Martin Cooper, ‘Britten Ingenuity Matches Auden’, Daily Telegraph (7 June 1976)Google Scholar (BPL).
36 See Fauser, , Sounds of War, 162 Google Scholar. On Broadway in the 1940s, also see Graf, , Opera For the People, 133–150 Google Scholar. On Porgy and Bess, Oklahoma! and the Theatre Guild’s development of ‘opera’ and ‘highbrow’ musicals on Broadway, see O’Leary, James, ‘ Oklahoma!, “Lousy Publicity,” and the Politics of Formal Integration in the American Musical Theater’, Journal of Musicology 31 (2014), 139–182 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, especially 148.
37 Marc Blitzstein, untitled (‘In America…’), Orson Welles Manuscripts, Lilly Library, Indiana University, Box 5, f22, quoted in Denning, The Cultural Front, 285.
38 Garafola, Lynn, ‘Lincoln Kirstein, Modern Dance, and the Left: The Genesis of an American Ballet’, Dance Research 23 (2005), 18–35 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Steichen, James, ‘The American Ballet’s Caravan’, Dance Research Journal 47 (2015), 69–94 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Copland could have been one point of contact with Kirstein (see Letters, II: 646). However, Auden knew Kirstein independently; indeed, it was Kirstein who provided funds for the Brooklyn house where Britten, Pears and Auden lived during the creation of Paul Bunyan ( Tippins, , February House, 37–38 Google Scholar). Britten went on to write Matinées Musicales for Kirstein’s American Ballet Caravan in 1941 (Letters, II: 646).
39 ‘American Lyric Theater [sic] Makes Debut May 18’, Chicago Daily Tribune (7 May 1939), 7, quoted in Jerry L. McBride, Douglas Moore: A Bio-Bibliography (Middleton, WI, 2011), 418. The performances were at the Martin Beck Theatre, at the start of the Broadway off-season.
40 See Garafola, , ‘Lincoln Kirstein’, 25; Steichen, ‘The American Ballet’s Caravan’, 71 Google Scholar. In its earliest stages, however, James Steichen has argued that the Ballet Caravan was not particularly focused on American identity, and was instead more continuous with the American Ballet’s European orientation, in a smaller-scale, more practical format (70–1).
41 ‘The Cultural Front’, Direction (March 1939), in Denning, The Cultural Front, Fig. 1. Also see Metzer, David, ‘The League of Composers: The Initial Years’, American Music 15 (1997), 55 Google Scholar; Garafola, , ‘Lincoln Kirstein’, 24 Google Scholar. Steichen points out that the Ballet Caravan’s collectivist image was somewhat illusory (‘The American Ballet’s Caravan’, 71, 77).
42 Steichen, , ‘The American Ballet’s Caravan’, 70–71 Google Scholar.
43 Garafola, , ‘Lincoln Kirstein’, 22 Google Scholar. Blitzstein similarly articulated the goal of reaching an audience new to the theatre (Denning, The Cultural Front, 286).
44 Walsh, Stephen, Stravinsky: The Second Exile: France and America 1934–1971 (New York, 2006), 256 Google Scholar.
45 On Broadway and universities (specifically Columbia) as an interlinked alternative to the opera house in wartime, also see Fauser, , Sounds of War, 168–170 Google Scholar.
46 Downes, Olin, ‘Official Opening for Paul Bunyan’, New York Times (6 May 1941)Google Scholar.
47 Downes, Olin, ‘Chamber Opera: League of Composers Launches Plan to Help American Lyric Theatre’, New York Times (16 March 1941)Google Scholar.
48 Reis, Claire R., Letter to the Music Editor, New York Times (30 March 1941)Google Scholar.
49 Brand, Max, ‘Challenge to America: A Procedure Whereby this Country Might Develop Its Own Opera’, New York Times (30 March 1941)Google Scholar.
50 Mitchell, , ‘The Origins, Evolution and Metamorphoses of Paul Bunyan’, 109–113 Google Scholar.
51 Goehr, , Elective Affinities, 262–268 Google Scholar.
52 Abravanel, Genevieve, Americanizing Britain: The Rise of Modernism in the Age of the Entertainment Empire (Oxford, 2012), 67 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
53 Abravanel, , Americanizing Britain, 68–69 Google Scholar.
54 Time (19 May 1941) (BPL).
55 Britten, Benjamin, ‘A Visiting Composer Looks at Us’, New York Times (24 March 1940)Google Scholar (BPL).
56 Bagar, Robert, ‘Britten Work Has Premiere at Columbia’, New York World-Telegram (5 May 1941)Google Scholar (BPL); E.B. (Eugene Bonner), The Musical Record (June 1941), 14; Time (19 May 1941) (BPL).
57 Downes, Olin, ‘Official Opening for Paul Bunyan’, New York Times (6 May 1941)Google Scholar.
58 E.B., The Musical Record, 14 (BPL).
59 Evans, Peter, The Music of Benjamin Britten (London, 1979), 97 Google Scholar.
60 Chowrimootoo, Christopher, ‘The Timely Traditions of Albert Herring ’, Opera Quarterly 27 (2011), 398–399 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
61 Sidnell, , Dances of Death, 204–205 Google Scholar.
62 Evans, , The Music of Benjamin Britten, 103 Google Scholar.
63 On the ‘sensuous’ use of the saxophone in Mont Juic and other laments, see Allen, Stephen Arthur, ‘“O Hurry to the Fêted Spot of Your Deliberate Fall”: Death in Britten, 1936–1940’, in Rethinking Britten, ed. Philip Rupprecht (Oxford, 2013), 26–27 Google Scholar, 32. He notes that Britten may have connected the saxophone less with jazz than with the classical saxophonist Sigurd Rascher, whom he met in 1934, while also noting the erotic associations of this meeting: it was on an outing with the 13-year-old Wulff Scherchen (27). Britten met Rascher again in New York in 1939, and contemplated writing a concerto for him in 1941 (Letters, II: 743).
64 ‘Messalina’ is an anonymous poem from Henry Youll’s madrigal collection Canzonets to Three Voices (1608).
65 Many critics and listeners, to be sure, hear the song as more straightforward. See Evans, The Music of Benjamin Britten, 71; and Peter Pears, ‘The Vocal Music’, in Benjamin Britten: A Commentary on His Works from a Group of Specialists, ed. Donald Mitchell and Hans Keller (London, 1952), 61. Mitchell is one of the few critics to hear something amiss (Britten and Auden in the Thirties: The Year 1936 (Seattle, 1981), 41).
66 On the sensuous quality of this saxophone passage, see Allen, , ‘O Hurry to the Fêted Spot’, 32 Google Scholar.
67 Mitchell, , Britten and Auden in the Thirties, 122 Google Scholar.
68 Auden, W.H., Plays and Other Dramatic Writings, 1928–1938, ed. Edward Mendelson (Princeton, 1988), 350 Google Scholar. There are multiple versions of this section of The Ascent of F6. In Britten’s manuscript, it is set for chorus, with two pianos and percussion (British Library Add. MS 60622, ff. 43–46v, www.bl.uk/manuscripts/FullDisplay.aspx?ref=Add_MS_60622). In some early performances it was sung as a solo by Hedli Anderson, for whom Britten wrote the Cabaret Songs (Sidnell, Dances of Death, 196–7).
69 Here I am referring to the version in Add. MS 60622, cited above.
70 The recording is held at the BPL (BPLCD00018).
71 Mitchell, , ‘The Origins, Evolution and Metamorphoses of Paul Bunyan’, 98 Google Scholar; Kildea, , Benjamin Britten, 180 Google Scholar.
72 Auden, , Paul Bunyan, 79 Google Scholar. This number was cut in the 1976 revival and does not appear in the published score. The manuscript score is reprinted in Reed, ‘A Rejected Love Song’, 284–7.
73 Auden, , Paul Bunyan, 79 Google Scholar.
74 Auden, W.H., ‘Some Reflections on Opera as a Medium’, Tempo (Summer 1951)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, reprinted in Auden, , Prose, Vol. III 1949–1955, ed. Edward Mendelson (London, 2008), 252 Google Scholar.
75 Auden, , ‘Some Reflections on Opera as a Medium’, 251 Google Scholar.
76 See Wiebe, Heather, ‘ The Rake’s Progress as Opera Museum’, Opera Quarterly 25 (2010), 6–27 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
77 For examples, see especially Robinson, Suzanne, ‘“An English Composer Sees America”: Benjamin Britten and the North American Press, 1939–1942’, American Music 15 (1997), 321–351 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Jack Westrup was especially vocal in his criticism of Britten on this account; see ‘The Virtuosity of Benjamin Britten’, The Listener (16 July 1942), 93, quoted in Kildea, Paul, Selling Britten: Music and the Marketplace (Oxford, 2002), 201–202 Google Scholar. On the issue of Britten’s ‘cleverness’, also see Brett, Philip, ‘Musicality, Essentialism, and the Closet’, in Queering the Pitch: The New Gay and Lesbian Musicology, ed. Philip Brett, Elizabeth Wood, and Gary C. Thomas (London, 1994), 19 Google Scholar.
78 F.B., ‘Playboy of Music: Benjamin Britten’s Piano Concerto’, Daily Telegraph and Morning Post (8 August 1938) (BPL).
79 Britten, Benjamin, ‘Piano Concerto, Op. 13 (1938)’, Op. 13 (1938)’, in Britten on Music, ed. Paul Kildea (Oxford, 2003), 363 Google Scholar.
80 The Piano Concerto was revised in 1945, and the original third movement was replaced with music taken from the radio play King Arthur (1937). See Paul Banks, ed., Benjamin Britten: A Catalogue of the Published Works, www.brittenpears.org/cataloguesearchresult.php?id=96# (accessed 4 March 2015).
81 ‘Promenade Concert: Benjamin Britten’s Concerto’, The Times (London) (19 August 1938) (BPL).
82 F.B., ‘Playboy of Music’.
83 ‘Violin Concerto’, Liverpool Daily Post (7 April 1941) (BPL).
84 For further examples, see Robinson, , ‘An English Composer Sees America’, 331 Google Scholar, 334, 344.
85 Downes, Olin, ‘Official Opening for Paul Bunyan’, New York Times (6 May 1941)Google Scholar (also quoted in Robinson, ‘An English Composer Sees America’, 335).
86 Kostelanetz, Richard, ed., Virgil Thomson: A Reader: Selected Writings 1924–1984 (New York, 2004), 224–225 Google Scholar.
87 Levy, Beth E., Frontier Figures: American Music and the Mythology of the American West (Berkeley, 2012), 295 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 298. Such suspicions were often linked with Copland’s Jewishness (300, 315), while critics have linked suspicions of Britten’s untrustworthy ‘cleverness’ with suspicions of his sexuality (see Brett, , ‘Musicality, Essentialism, and the Closet’, 19 Google Scholar).
88 Levy, , Frontier Figures, 295 Google Scholar.
89 In Susan Margaret Key, ‘“Sweet melody over silent wave”: Depression-Era Radio and the American Composer’, Ph.D. diss., University of Maryland, College Park (1995), 136–7, quoted in Levy, Frontier Figures, 304. Demands for sincerity have long been connected with democratic ideals, in ways that have haunted twentieth-century song, as Katherine Bergeron has suggested: see Bergeron, Voice Lessons: French Mélodie in the Belle Époque (Oxford, 2010), esp. 294–5.
90 See the reviews of the first production collected in Letters, II: 1253–65.
91 Britten, Benjamin, ‘Introduction’, in Ben jamin Britten: ‘Peter Grimes’, ed. Philip Brett (Cambridge, 1983), 148 Google Scholar.
92 Forster, E.M., ‘George Crabbe – The Man and the Poet’, in Benjamin Britten: ‘Peter Grimes’, 3–7 Google Scholar.
93 Wilson, Edmund, ‘An account of Peter Grimes from “London in Midsummer”’, in Benjamin Britten: ‘Peter Grimes’, 160 Google Scholar.
94 Wilson, , ‘An account of Peter Grimes from “London in Midsummer”’, 161 Google Scholar.
95 E.J. Dent to Bernard Stevens, 12 June 1950, in Letters, II: 1264.
96 See Howes, Frank, The Times (8 June 1945)Google Scholar, in Letters, II: 1253; Britten, ‘Introduction’, 149.
97 Kirk, Elise K., American Opera (Champaign, IL, 2005), 253–267 Google Scholar.
98 Graf, , Opera for the People, 139; Fauser, Sounds of War, 162 Google Scholar. City Opera performed Blitzstein’s Regina in an expanded version in 1953.
99 See Denning, , The Cultural Front, 319–321 Google Scholar.
100 Letters, II: 637.
101 Kerman, Joseph, ‘ Grimes and Lucretia ’, The Hudson Review 2 (1949), 278 Google Scholar.