Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-vsgnj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T04:47:47.215Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Application of the vortex breakdown phenomenon in the attenuation of trailing vortices

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 July 2016

L. W. Traub ,
S. Mani ,
S. F. Galls  and
O. K. Rediniotis
L. W. Traub
Affiliation:
Aerospace Engineering Department , Texas A&M University Texas, USA
S. Mani
Affiliation:
Aerospace Engineering Department , Texas A&M University Texas, USA
S. F. Galls
Affiliation:
Aerospace Engineering Department , Texas A&M University Texas, USA
O. K. Rediniotis
Affiliation:
Aerospace Engineering Department , Texas A&M University Texas, USA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

An experimental investigation to determine the effectiveness of a wing-tip device designed to attenuate the trailing vortex of a lifting, flat-plate wing is detailed. The induced-breakdown vortex attenuation device (IBVAD) is essentially a toed-in, vertically-oriented sheared tip. Results are presented comprising force-balance, water tunnel flow visualisation and wake studies using a seven hole probe. The data shows that compared with an equal span rectangular wing, variations of the IBVAD device can reduce drag at moderate-to-high lift coefficients, as well as reduce die maximum rotary velocity of the trailing vortex by 28%. Axial vorticity in the wake vortex was significantly attenuated compared with the rectangular wing, with a 52·6% reduction in the magnitude of die maximum vorticity. The vortex core radius was also seen to be larger than die rectangular wing. However, even substantial attenuation and redistribution of trailing vorticity may be insufficient to reduce the wake hazard.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Aeronautical Journal , Volume 102 , Issue 1018 , December 1998 , pp. 439 - 444
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Aeronautical Society 1998 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Francis, M.S. and Kennedy, D.A. Formation of a trailing vortex, JAircr, 1979,16,(3), pp 148–154.Google Scholar
2. Spreiter, J.R. and Sacks, A.H. The rolling up of the trailing vortex sheet and its effect on the downwash behind wings, J Aeronaut Sciences, January 1951, pp 21–32.Google Scholar
3. Bilanin, A.J. and Donaldson, C D. Estimation of velocities and roll-up in aircraft wake vortices, J Aircr, 1975,12, (7), pp 578–585.Google Scholar
4. El-Ramly, Z. and Rainbird, W.J. Flow survey of the wake behind wings, J Aircr, 1977,14, (11), pp 1102–1108.Google Scholar
5. Yuan, S.W. and Bloom, A.M. Experimental investigation of wingtip vortex abatement, Ninth Congress of the International Council of the Aeronautical Sciences, Haifa, Israel, 25-30 August 1974.Google Scholar
6. Patterson, J.C. and Fletchner, S.G. An exploratory wind-tunnel investigation of the wake effect of a panel up-mounted fan-jet engine on the lift-induced vortex, NASA TN D-8083, September 1975.Google Scholar
7. Van Dam, C.P., Holmes, B.J. and Pitts, C. Effect of winglets on performance and handling qualities of general aviation aircraft, J Aircr, 1981,18, (7), pp 587–591.Google Scholar
8. Traub, L.W. and Nurick, A. Effects of wing-tip vortex flaps, J Aircr, 1993,30, (4), pp 557–560.Google Scholar
9. Spillman, J.J. Wing tip sails; progress to date and future developments, Aeronaut J, 1987, 91, (10), pp 445–453.Google Scholar
10. Traub, L.W. Aerodynamic effects of delta planform tip sails on wing performance, J Aircr, 1994, 31, (5), pp 1156–1159.Google Scholar
11. Dunham, R.E. Unsuccessful concepts for aircraft wake vortex minimization, NASA Symposium on Wake Vortex Minimization, NASA SP-409, 25-26 February 1976, pp 221-249.Google Scholar
12. Patterson, J.C. Vortex attenuation obtained in the langley vortex research facility, J Aircr, 1975, 12, (9), pp 745–749.Google Scholar
13. Corsiglia, V.R. and Dunham, R.E. Aircraft wake-vortex minimization by use of flaps, NASA symposium on Wake Vortex Minimization, NASA SP-409, 25-26 February 1976, pp 305-338.Google Scholar
14. Rossow, V.J. Effect of wing fins on lift-generated wakes, J Aircr, 1978, 15, (3), pp 160–167.Google Scholar
15. Cornelius, K.C. Analysis of vortex bursting utilizing three-dimensional laser measurements, J Aircr, 1995, 32, (2), pp 297–306.Google Scholar
16. Robinson, B.A., Barnett, R.M. and Agrawal, S. Simple numerical criterion for vortex breakdown, AIAA J, 1994, 32, (1), pp 116–122.Google Scholar
17. Traub, L.W., Rediniotis, O.K., Klute, S.M, Moore, C.T. and Telionis, D.P. Instabilities of vortex breakdown; their structure and growth, AIAA Paper 95-2308, June 1995.Google Scholar
18. Patterson, J.C, Hastings, E.C. and Jordan, F.L. Ground development and flight correlation of the vortex attenuating spline device, NASA Symposium on Wake Vortex Minimization, NASA SP-409, 25-26 February 1976, pp 271-303.Google Scholar
19. Traub, L.W. A Subsonic Wind-tunnel Investigation of the Effect of Sharp Edged Sheared Tips on a Moderate Aspect Ratio Flat Plate Wing, MS thesis, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa, June 1992.Google Scholar
20. Brown, C.E. Aerodynamics of wake vortices, AIAA J, 1973, 11, (4), pp 531–536.Google Scholar