Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Cited by 1
  • Print publication year: 2015
  • Online publication date: November 2015

9 - Napkin Art: Carmina contra paganos and the Difference Satire Made in Fourth-Century Rome

from Section A - Pagans and Religious Practices in Christian Rome

Summary

It has become ever more clear that late ancient Rome's Christian writers were capable of sheer invention. Prudentius’ blood-drenched taurobolium has lately been forced to come clean as the fantasy it was: a burlesque of a far more sober rite still traceable in other sources. Similar, if less sensational, fictions surely underlie the outrage punctuating the roughly contemporary anti-pagan verse polemics considered in this chapter. Yet rather than quarantine these carmina contra paganos – or Prudentius’ lurid fantasy – simply because they bear the mark of deceit, the proper historical task entails their reintegration into a world where, as otherwise agreed, textual practices often had serious motivations and real consequences. The patent attraction of these verses to the tired clichés and vituperative zeal of pre-Constantinian apologetic, that is, should not be permitted to render this poetry irrelevant to the religious debates of the age. Indeed, that these broadsides – embedded in well-known poems or stranded among the manuscripts of other Christian authors – were ever intended to be taken for the kind of truth conceded to objective reportage or fair representation can hardly be the case. Truth, however, is manifold, an assertion whose validity crystalizes in the relentlessly satiric voices of this contra paganos poetry. What follows, then, is a bid for better understanding of how the “banal” fictions of this late fourth- and early fifth-century verse contributed to the work of forging Christian identity in a city where the problems well-heeled Christians faced had as much (or more) to do with resolving the issues dividing them than with fending off the challenges of pagan cult.

Ad Hominem?

Five texts will illustrate here the evidential value of a body of verse too often marginalized as either historically inconsequential or poetically second-rate. Best known of this group, perhaps, is the Contra Symmachum. Prudentius most likely assembled the final version of this two-book rebuttal of Symmachus’ defense of the altar of Victory in late 402, long after Symmachus had sent his famous relatio to Milan in 384. Yet, although Prudentius almost surely drafted parts of Contra Symmachum book one in the mid-390s, attention later in this chapter focuses on lines 42–407, a long section devoted to ridiculing the pagan gods and their myths, which could, in fact, have been composed almost any time during these years.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Adkin, N.Juvenal and Jerome.” Classical Philology 89 (1994): 69–72.
Alexandre, R. “Prudence et les trois poèmes anonymes de polémique anti-païenne: un manifeste caché pour une satire christianisée?” in P. Galand-Hallyn and V. Zarini, eds., Manifestes littéraires dans la latinité tardive: Poétique et rhétorique (Paris, 2009), 71–88.
Barnes, T. Tertullian: A Historical and Literary Study (Oxford, 1971).
Barnes, T. Ammianus Marcellinus and the Representation of Historical Reality (Ithaca and London, 1998).
Bartalucci, A. <Contro i pagani> Carmen cod. Paris. lat. 8084 (Pisa, 1998).
Begley, R. “The Carmen ad quendam senatorem: Date, Milieu, and Tradition.” PhD diss. University of North Carolina (1984).
Blair-Dixon, K. “Damasus and the Fiction of Unity: The Urban Shrines of Saint Laurence,” in Guidobaldi, F. and Guidobaldi, A., eds. Ecclesiae Urbis: Atti del congresso internazionale di studi sulle chiese di Roma (Vatican City, 2002), 331–52.
Bogel, F. The Difference Satire Makes: Rhetoric and Reading from Jonson to Byron (Ithaca and London, 2001).
Braund, S. The Roman Satirists and Their Masks (London, 1996).
Bulson, E. “The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan (1963),” in K. Dettmar, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Bob Dylan (Cambridge, 2009), 125–30.
Cameron, A.Literary Allusions in the Historia Augusta.” Hermes 92 (1964): 363–77.
Cameron, A. The Last Pagans of Rome (New York and Oxford, 2011).
Cantwell, R. When We Were Good: The Folk Revival (Cambridge, MA, 1996).
Colton, R.Ausonius and Juvenal.” Classical Journal 69 (1973): 41–51.
Consolino, F. E. “Pagani, cristiani, e produzione letteraria latina da Giuliano l'Apostata al sacco di Roma,” in Franca E. Consolino, ed., Pagani e cristiani da Giuliano l'Apostata al sacco di Roma (Messina, 1995), 311–28.
Corsano, M.Un incontro problematico: cristiani e pagani in tre carmi adespoti.” Orpheus 21 (2000): 26–43.
Corsano, M. and Roberto Palla. Ps.-Paolino Nolano: <Poema Ultimum> (Pisa, 2002).
Corsano, M. Ps.-Cipriano: Ad un senatore convertitosi dalla religione cristiana alla schiavitù degli idoli (Pisa, 2006).
Cracco Ruggini, L. Il paganesimo romano tra religione e politica (384–394 d.C.): Per una reinterpretazione del “Carmen contra paganos.” Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei: Memorie. Classe di Scienze morali, storiche e filologiche 8.23.1(Rome, 1979).
Cunningham, M. Aurelii Prudentii Clementis Carmina (Turnholt, 1966).
Dalton, D. Who Is that Man? In Search of the Real Bob Dylan (New York, 2012).
Davies, J. Rome's Religious History: Livy, Tacitus, and Ammianus on Their Gods (Cambridge 2004).
Dettmar, K., ed. The Cambridge Companion to Bob Dylan (Cambridge, 2009).
Fariña, R. “Baez and Dylan: A Generation Singing Out.” Mademoiselle 59 (August 1964) reprinted in Thomson, E. and Gutman, D., eds., The Dylan Companion (Cambridge 2001), 81–8.
Filene, B. Romancing the Folk: Public Memory and American Roots Music (Chapel Hill and London, 2000).
Fontaine, J. Naissance de la poésie dans l'occident chrétien: Esquisse d'une histoire de la poésie latine chrétienne du IIIe au VIe siècle (Paris, 1981).
Freudenburg, K. Satires of Rome: Threatening Poses from Lucilius to Juvenal (Cambridge, 2001).
Freudenburg, K. ed. The Cambridge Companion to Roman Satire (Cambridge and New York, 2005).
Garambois-Vasquez, F. Les invectives de Claudien: Une poétique de la violence (Brussels, 2007).
Gilmore, M.Bob Dylan on His Dark New LP.” Rolling Stone 1163 (August 16, 2012): 15–16.
Goulon, A. “Les citations des poètes latins dans l'oeuvre de Lactance,” in Fontaine, J. and Perrin, M., eds. Lactance et son temps (Paris, 1978), 107–56.
Gray, M. Song and Dance Man III: The Art of Bob Dylan (London and New York, 2000).
Green, R. P. H. The Poetry of Paulinus of Nola: A Study of His Latinity (Brussels, 1971).
Green, R. P. H. The Works of Ausonius (Oxford, 1991).
Gunderson, E. “The Libidinal Rhetoric of Satire,” in Freudenburg, K., ed. The Cambridge Companion to Roman Satire (Cambridge and New York, 2005), 224–40.
Habinek, T. “Satire as Aristocratic Play,” in Freudenburg, K., ed. The Cambridge Companion to Roman Satire (Cambridge and New York, 2005), 177–91.
Hagendahl, H. Latin Fathers and the Classics: A Study on the Apologists, Jerome and Other Christian Writers (Göteborg, 1958).
Harries, J.Prudentius and Theodosius.” Latomus 43 (1984): 69–84.
Heylin, C. Bob Dylan: Behind the Shades Revisited (New York, 2001).
Heylin, C. Revolution in the Air: The Songs of Bob Dylan, 1957–1973 (Chicago, 2009).
Heylin, C. Still on the Road: The Songs of Bob Dylan, 1974–2006 (Chicago, 2010).
Highet, G. Juvenal the Satirist: A Study (Oxford, 1954).
Hooley, D. Roman Satire (Malden and Oxford, 2007).
Kahlos, M. Vettius Agorius Praetextatus: A Senatorial Life in Between (Rome, 2002).
Kahlos, M. ed., The Faces of the Other: Religious Rivalry and Ethnic Encounters in the Later Roman World (Turnhout, 2011).
Kahlos, M. “The Shadow of the Shadow: Examining Fourth- and Fifth-Century Christian Depictions of Pagans,” in M. Kahlos, ed., The Faces of the Other (Turnhout, 2011), 165–95.
Kahlos, M “Who Is a Good Roman? Setting and Resetting Boundaries for Romans, Christians, Pagans, and Barbarians in the Later Roman Empire,” in M. Kahlos, ed., The Faces of the Other (Turnhout, 2011), 259–74.
Keane, C. Figuring Genre in Roman Satire (Oxford and New York, 2006).
Kelly, G. Ammianus Marcellinus: The Allusive Historian (Cambridge, 2008).
Knust, J. W. Abandoned to Lust: Sexual Slander and Ancient Christianity (New York, 2006).
Lomax, A., Guthrie, W., and Seeger, P.. Hard Hitting Songs for Hard-Hit People (Lincoln, 1999; original date of publication, 1967)
Long, J. Claudian's In Eutropium: Or, How, When, and Why to Slander a Eunuch (Chapel Hill and London, 1996).
Marie, S.Prudentius and Juvenal.” Phoenix 16 (1962): 41–52.
Markus, R. “Paganism, Christianity, and the Latin Classics in the Fourth Century,” in J. W. Binns, ed., Latin Literature of the Fourth Century (London and Boston, 1974), 1–21.
Matthews, J. “The Letters of Symmachus,” in J. W. Binns, ed., Latin Literature of the Fourth Century (London and Boston, 1974), 58–99.
Maxwell, J. “Paganism and Christianization,” in S. F. Johnson, ed., The Oxford Handbook of Late Antiquity (Oxford and New York, 2012), 849–75.
McGill, S. “Latin Poetry,” in S. F. Johnson, ed., The Oxford Handbook of Late Antiquity (Oxford and New York, 2012), 335–60.
McLynn, N.The Fourth-Century Taurobolium.” Phoenix 50 (1996): 312–30.
McLynn, N. “Pagans in a Christian Empire,” in Rousseau, P., ed. A Companion to Late Antiquity (Malden and Oxford, 2009), 572–87.
Niquet, H. Monumenta Virtutum Titulique: Senatorische Selbstdarstellung im spätantiken Rom im Spiegel der epigraphischen Denkmäler (Stuttgart, 2000).
Ogilvie, R. M. The Library of Lactantius (Oxford, 1978).
Osborn, E. Tertullian, First Theologian of the West (Cambridge, 1997).
Palmer, A.-M. Prudentius on the Martyrs (Oxford, 1989).
Petersen, A. K. “Othering in Paul: A Case Study of II Corinthians,” in M. Kahlos, ed., The Faces of the Other (Turnhout, 2011), 19–50.
Rauhala, M. “Devotion and Deviance: The Cult of Cybele and the Others Within,” in M. Kahlos, ed., The Faces of the Other (Turnhout, 2011), 51–82.
Ricks, C. Dylan's Visions of Sin (New York, 2004).
Rosenthal, R. and Rosenthal, S., eds. Pete Seeger in His Own Words (Boulder and London, 2012).
Ruggiero, A. Paolino di Nola: I carmi. Vol. I (Naples, 1996).
Sághy, M.Scinditur in partes populus: Pope Damasus and the Martyrs of Rome.” Early Medieval Europe 9 (2000): 273–87.
Sallmann, K., ed. Nouvelle histoire de la littérature latine, Vol. 4. L’âge de transition: De la littérature romaine à la littérature chrétienne de 117 à 284 apres J.-C. (Turnhout, 2000).
Salzman, M. R. The Making of a Christian Aristocracy: Social and Religious Change in the Western Roman Empire (Cambridge and London, 2002).
Salzman, M. R. and Roberts, Michael. The Letters of Symmachus: Book 1 (Atlanta, 2011).
Shanzer, D.The Date and Composition of Prudentius’ Contra orationem Symmachi libri.” Rivista di filologia e d'istruzione classica 117 (1989): 442–62.
Smith, J. Z. “What a Difference a Difference Makes,” in Neusner, J. and Frerichs, E. S., ed., “To See Ourselves as Others See Us”: Christians, Jews, “Others” in Late Antiquity (Chico, 1985): 3–48.
Sogno, C. Q. Aurelius Symmachus: A Political Biography (Ann Arbor, 2006).
Stein, G. The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas (New York, 1933).
Thomson, H. J. Prudentius: Volume II (Cambridge and London, 1949).
Tränkle, H. “Q. Septimius Florens Tertullianus,” in K. Sallmann, ed., Nouvelle histoire de la littérature latine, Vol. 4. L’âge de transition: De la littérature romaine à la littérature chrétienne de 117 à 284 apres J.-C. (Turnhout, 2000), 494–571.
Trout, D.The Dates of the Ordination of Paulinus of Bordeaux and of his Departure for Nola.” Revue des Études Augustiniennes 37 (1991): 237–60.
Trout, D. Paulinus of Nola: Life, Letters, and Poems (Berkeley, 1999).
Trout, D.The Verse Epitaph(s) of Petronius Probus: Competitive Commemoration in Late-Fourth-Century Rome.” New England Classical Journal 28 (2001): 157–76.
Walsh, P. G. The Poems of Paulinus of Nola (New York, 1975).
Walters, J.Making a Spectacle: Deviant Men, Invective, and Pleasure.” Arethusa 31 (1998): 355–67.
Ware, C. Claudian and the Roman Epic Tradition (Cambridge, 2012).
Watson, G. Saint Augustine: Soliloquies and Immortality of the Soul (Warminster, 1990).
Weston, A. Latin Satirical Writing Subsequent to Juvenal (Lancaster, 1915).
Wiesel, E. Legends of Our Time (New York, 1968).
Wiesen, D. St. Jerome as a Satirist: A Study in Christian Latin Thought and Letters (Ithaca and New York, 1964).