Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2014
  • Online publication date: October 2014

5 - Legal obligation and authority

Summary

This chapter moves from conceptual questions about the nature of law to moral questions about the relationship between citizens and government. The notions of obligation and authority are central to the way we understand the role of law in society. If someone standing on a street corner told you to wear a helmet while riding your bicycle, you would probably reply, “says who?”, or something less polite. But if your town council got together and enacted an ordinance requiring bicycle riders to wear helmets within the town limits, you would probably conclude that you now have a reason to wear a helmet, even if you did not think you did before the new law was passed. One way to put this point is that law purports or claims to have authority over its subjects, even if sometimes it turns out not to have authority. A legal system claims to issue commands that its subjects regard as binding. The law says bicycle riders have to wear helmets … so they have to wear helmets. One must do what the law says because it is the law.

Authority can be understood as the right to command obedience. H. L. A. Hart criticized John Austin’s theory of law for resembling the threat of a gunman: “Hand over your wallet or I’ll shoot.” The gunman may have power to command the victim to hand over his wallet, but he lacks authority (i.e., the right to command action). Remember Hart’s distinction between being obliged (the gunman’s threat) and having an obligation? An obligation is correlated with a right. If a person or institution, A, does not have a right to rule over another, B, then B does not have an obligation to obey A’s command. If A has rightful authority over B, then B has an obligation to obey A. The town council may be a legitimate authority within its jurisdiction, in which case bicycle riders would have an obligation to wear helmets.

Raz, Joseph, “Authority, Law, and Morality,” in Ethics in the Public Domain (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1994), p. 215.
Shapiro, Scott J., “Authority,” in Coleman, Jules and Shapiro, Scott, eds., The Oxford Handbook of Jurisprudence and Philosophy of Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2002), p. 385.
Simmons, A. John, Moral Principles and Political Obligations (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press 1979), pp. 9–12
Gilbert, Margaret, A Theory of Political Obligation (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2006), pp. 26–42.
Ross, W. D., The Right and the Good (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1930).
Raz, Joseph, “The Obligation to Obey the Law,” in The Authority of Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1979).
Wolff, Robert Paul, In Defense of Anarchy (New York: Harper & Row 1970)
Smith, M. B. E., “Is There a Prima Facie Obligation to Obey the Law?,” Yale Law Journal 82: 950–76 (1973).
Greenawalt, Kent, Conflicts of Law and Morality (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1989).
Wolff, Robert Paul, “The Conflict Between Authority and Autonomy,” in Raz, Joseph, ed., Authority (New York: New York University Press 1990), pp. 26–27.
Flathman, Richard E., “Legitimacy,” in Goodin, Robert E., Pettit, Philip, and Pogge, Thomas, eds., A Companion to Contemporary Political Philosophy (Malden, Mass.: Wiley-Blackwell, 2d edn., 2012).
Plato, “Crito,” Tredennick, Hugh, trans., in Hamilton, Edith and Cairns, Huntington, eds., Plato: The Complete Dialogues (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press 1961).
Walker, A. D. M., “Political Obligation and the Argument from Gratitude,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 17: 191–211 (1988).
Locke, John, Second Treatise of Civil Government (1690), ch. IV, sec. 22.
Hume, David, “On the Original Contract,” reprinted in Barker, Ernest, ed., Social Contract (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1947), p. 151.
Applbaum, Arthur Isak, Ethics for Adversaries (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press 1999), pp. 116–20.
Pitkin, Hanna, “Obligation and Consent – I,” American Political Science Review 59: 990–99 [1965]).
Rawls, John, A Theory of Justice (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press 1971)
Freeman, Samuel, “John Rawls – An Introduction,” in Freeman, Samuel, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Rawls (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2003).
Hart, H. L. A., “Are There Any Natural Rights?,” Philosophical Review 64: 175–91 (1955)
Rawls, John, “Legal Obligation and the Duty of Fair Play,” in Freeman, Samuel, ed., John Rawls: Collected Papers (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press 1999).
Dworkin, Ronald, Law’s Empire (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press 1986), p. 255.
Tuck, Richard, “Hobbes,” in Great Political Thinkers (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1992).
Gilbert, Margaret, “Group Membership and Political Obligation,” The Monist 76: 119–31 (1993).
Wendel, W. Bradley, Lawyers and Fidelity to Law (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press 2010).
Shapiro, Scott J., Legality (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press 2011).
Simmons, A. John, “Associative Political Obligations,” Ethics 106: 247–73 (1996), pp. 256–57.