Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Tables
- Acknowledgments
- 1 The Rise of China: Political Worldview and Chinese Exceptionalism
- 2 Chinese Political Worldview: IR with Chinese Characteristics
- 3 Who is China?
- 4 Chinese National Image and Global Leadership
- 5 The Belt and Road and the Path to Chinese Greatness
- 6 Perceiving China: Case Studies from Indonesia and Vietnam
- 7 Deciphering China: Views from Singapore
- 8 Conclusion: From Chinese Exceptionalism to Chinese Universality
- 9 Afterword: Covid-19 and the Limits of Chinese Exceptionalism
- Bibliography
- Index
6 - Perceiving China: Case Studies from Indonesia and Vietnam
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 May 2021
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Tables
- Acknowledgments
- 1 The Rise of China: Political Worldview and Chinese Exceptionalism
- 2 Chinese Political Worldview: IR with Chinese Characteristics
- 3 Who is China?
- 4 Chinese National Image and Global Leadership
- 5 The Belt and Road and the Path to Chinese Greatness
- 6 Perceiving China: Case Studies from Indonesia and Vietnam
- 7 Deciphering China: Views from Singapore
- 8 Conclusion: From Chinese Exceptionalism to Chinese Universality
- 9 Afterword: Covid-19 and the Limits of Chinese Exceptionalism
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
Abstract
This chapter examines the perspectives of Vietnamese and Indonesian elites towards China and the extent to which efforts to promote a positive Chinese national image have been successful in these two countries. Utilizing information gathered from field research, I argue that both countries perceive China as attempting to modify – not entirely revise – the rules of the international system to suit its purposes. Territorial issues remain a primary focus in the two countries’ relationships with China, and they also express concerns that China's growing influence will cause an unstable regional environment. Interviewees also expressed considerable doubt about the idea of Chinese exceptionalism and tended to perceive China as acting like any other big power.
Keywords: Vietnam, Indonesia, China, Southeast Asia, South China Sea
In Chapter 4, I analyzed the priorities of China as seen in the speeches from President Xi Jinping's first eighteen months in office. In these speeches and elsewhere, images of China as a flourishing civilization, a peaceful and progressive country, and a moral example for international politics are frequently expressed by Chinese leaders in reference to international relations. However, the important question of how the outside world perceives China also needs to be asked. Just as China's view of the world is reflected in its foreign policy actions and international behavior, how other countries react and respond to China provides important insights into how China is perceived and, more crucially, whether its political worldview and thinking about the proper form of the global order are finding international acceptance. This chapter discusses the view of China from elite perspectives in Vietnam and Indonesia, and Chapter 7 addresses the same in Singapore. Looking at the case studies not only allows me to understand how other countries interpret China's political behavior, but also whether they consider China to be exceptional – that is, different and superior to the West in terms of Beijing's claim to global leadership.
In this chapter I examine how Vietnam and Indonesia perceive China in reference to their political relations, particularly focusing on the situation of President Xi's regime from 2013 onwards. Vietnam's proximity to (and territorial disputes with) China means that it is highly sensitive to Chinese actions within its periphery.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- China's Political Worldview and Chinese ExceptionalismInternational Order and Global Leadership, pp. 145 - 176Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2021