Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-2xdlg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-04T19:22:44.849Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

17 - Literary theory and polemic in Castile, c. 1200–c. 1500

from V - VERNACULAR CRITICAL TRADITIONS: THE LATE MIDDLE AGES

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 March 2008

Alastair Minnis
Affiliation:
Ohio State University
Ian Johnson
Affiliation:
University of St Andrews, Scotland
Get access

Summary

The first signs of a critical stance towards poetic composition in the Castilian vernacular are to be found in the clerkly metre of cuaderna vía, which accompanied the emergence in the early thirteenth century of a new class of university–trained clerics. Writers such as Gonzalo de Berceo and the anonymous poets of the Libro de Alexandre and Libro de Apolonio introduced their narratives with self–conscious statements about their ‘clerical ministry’ (mester de clerecía) and their role as intermediaries between the laity and the received wisdom of bookish authority. Theirs, they claimed, was a new poetic movement, superior to the work of juglares (minstrels), and characterised by its metrical polish and civilising goals. These prefatory remarks are undeveloped (and have been variously interpreted), but they are nonetheless significant. They are evidence for the fact that, for the period in question, what may loosely be called ‘literary theorising’ was undertaken fundamentally in order to establish a social relationship: it is, so to speak, literary theory ‘in action’. This is to say that those who wrote for a lay public were less concerned with philosophising about an abstract category later to be called ‘literature’, than with defending their status as writers, and confronting the problems that attended the composition and interpretation of their own work. Thus, although theoretical treatises were written during this period, theory and criticism find expression principally through the medium of the literary text itself, prologues and, later, commentaries on specific works in the Castilian vernacular tradition.

Type
Chapter
Information
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aguirre, Elvira, Die ‘Arte de trovar’ von Enrique de Villena (Cologne, 1968).Google Scholar
Alfonso, el Sabio X, Complete Works, ed. Kasten, L. and Nitti, J. (Madison WI, 1986).Google Scholar
Alfonso, el Sabio X, General estoria: primera parte, ed. Solalinde, A. G. (Madrid, 1930).Google Scholar
Alfonso, el Sabio X, General estoria: segunda parte, ed. Solalinde, A. G., Kasten, L. A. and Oelschläger, V. R. B. (2 vols., Madrid, 1957–61).Google Scholar
Asís, María Dolores, Hernán Núñez en la historia de los estudios clásicos (Madrid, 1977).Google Scholar
Baena, Juan Alfonso, Cancionero, ed. Azáceta, J. M., Clásicos Hispánicos (3 vols., Madrid, 1966).Google Scholar
Balaguer, Joaquín, ‘Las ideas de Nebrija acerca de la versificación castellana’, in his Apuntes para una historia prosódica de la métrica castellana (Madrid, 1964).Google Scholar
Becker, F. G.Pamphilus, ed. Mittellateinisches Jahrbuch, 9(Düsseldorf, 1972).Google Scholar
Beltrán, Vicente, ‘Los trovadores en la corte de Castilla y León (II): Alfonso X, Guiraut Riquier y Pero da Ponte’, Romania, 107 (1986).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Birkenmajer, A., ‘Der Streit des Alonso von Cartagena mit Leonardo Bruni Aretino’, Beiträge zur Geschichte der Philosophie des Mittelalters, 20 (1917–22), Heft 5 (1922).Google Scholar
Boccaccio, Giovanni, Genealogie deorum gentilium libri, ed. Romano, V. (Bari, 1951); in part tr. Osgood, C. G., Boccaccio on Poetry: Being the Preface and the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Books of Boccaccio's ‘Genealogia deorum gentilium’ in an English Version with Introductory Essay and Commentary (Princeton NJ, 1930).Google Scholar
Boccaccio, Giovanni, tr. Osgood, C. G., Boccaccio on Poetry: Being the Preface and the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Books of Boccaccio's ‘Genealogia deorum gentilium’ in an English Version with Introductory Essay and Commentary (Princeton NJ, 1930).Google Scholar
Brann, Ross, The Compunctious Poet: Cultural Ambiguity and Hebrew Poetry in Muslim Spain (Baltimore MD, 1991).Google Scholar
Brown, Catherine, Contrary Things: Exegesis, Dialectic, and the Poetics of Didacticism (Stanford CA, 1998).Google Scholar
Brownlee, Marina Scordilis, The Status of the Reading Subject in the ‘Libro de buen amor’ (Chapel Hill NC, 1985).Google Scholar
Cartagena, Alonso, Un tratado de Alonso de Cartagena sobre la educación y los estudios literarios, ed. Lawrance, J. N. H. (Barcelona, 1979).Google Scholar
Cátedra, Pedro M., ‘Enrique de Villena y algunos humanistas’, in Nebrija y la introducción.
Cátedra, Pedro M., Exégesis-ciencia-literatura: la exposición del salmo ‘Quoniam videbo’ de Enrique de Villena (Madrid, 1985).Google Scholar
Cherchi, Paolo, ‘Brevedad, oscuredad, synchysis in El Conde Lucanor (parts II-IV)’, Medioevo romanzo, 9 (1984).Google Scholar
Clarke, Dorothy Clotelle, ‘Juan del Encina's Una arte de poesía castellana’, Romance Philology, 4 (1953).Google Scholar
Dagenais, John, ‘A Further Source for the Literary Ideas in Juan Ruiz's Prologue’, Journal of Hispanic Philology, 11 (1986–7).Google Scholar
Dagenais, John, The Ethics of Reading in Manuscript Culture: Glossing the ‘Libra de buen amor’ (Princeton NJ, 1994).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
d'Heur, J. M.Cancioneiro da Biblioteca Nacional, ‘L'Art de trouver du chansonnier Colocci-Brancuti’, ed. Arquivos do Centro Cultural Português, 9 (1975).Google Scholar
d'Heur, Jean-Marie, Troubadours d'Oc et troubadours galiciens-portugais: Recherches sur quelques échanges dans la littérature de l'Europe au Moyen Âge (Paris, 1973).Google Scholar
Di, Camillo Ottavio, El humanismo castellano del siglo XV (Valencia, 1976).Google Scholar
Faulhaber, Charles, ‘Las retóricas hispanolatinas medievales (siglos XIII–XV)’, Repertorio de historia de las ciencias eclesiásticas en España, 7 (1979).Google Scholar
Faulhaber, Charles, Retóricas clásicas y medievales en bibliotecas castellanas, Ábaco, 4 (Madrid, 1973).Google Scholar
Faulhaber, Charles, Latin Rhetorical Theory in Thirteenth and Fourteenth Century Castile (Berkeley CA, 1972).Google Scholar
Fraker, Charles, Studies on the ‘Cancionero de Baena’ (Chapel Hill NC, 1966).Google Scholar
García, la Concha, Víctor, , ‘La impostación religiosa de la reforma humanística en España: Nebrija y los poetas cristianos’, in Nebrija y la introducción.
Geoffrey, Vinsauf, Poetria nova, ed. Faral, F. in Les Arts poétiques du XIIe et du XIIIe siècle, Bibliothèque de I'École des hautes études, 238 (1923; rpt. Geneva, 1982).Google Scholar
Gerli, E. Michael, ‘Recta voluntas est bonus amor: St Augustine and the Didactic Structure of the Libro de buen amor’, Romance Philology, 35 (1981–2).Google Scholar
Gómez, Moreno, Ángel, , ‘Clerecía’, in Alvar, C. and Gómez Moreno, Á., La poesía épica y de clerecía medievales (Madrid, 1988).Google Scholar
Gómez, Moreno, ‘La teoría poética en los estudios de literatura medieval española’, in Alvar, C. and Gómez Moreno, A., La poesía lírica medieval (Madrid, 1987).Google Scholar
Gómez, Moreno, El ‘Proemio e carta’ del marqués de Santillana y la teoría poética del siglo XV (Barcelona, 1990).Google Scholar
Gómez, Redondo F., Aires poéticas medievales (Madrid, 2000).Google Scholar
Ibn'Ezra, Moses, Kitab al-muhadara wal-mudakara, Spanish tr. Mas, M. A. (Madrid, 1986).Google Scholar
Imperial, Micer Francisco, ‘El dezir a las syete virtudes’ y otros poemas, ed. Nepaulsingh, C. I. (Madrid, 1977).Google Scholar
Johnston, Mark D., ‘Literary Tradition and the Idea of Language in the Artes de trobar’, Dispositio, 2 (1977).Google Scholar
Johnston, Mark D., ‘Poetry and Courtliness in Baena's Prologue’, La Corónica, 25:1 (Fall, 1996).Google Scholar
Johnston, Mark D., ‘The Translation of the Troubadour Tradition in the Torcimany of Lluis d'Averçó’, Studies in Philology, 78 (1981).Google Scholar
Joset, Jacques, Nuevas investigationes sobre ‘El libra de buen amor’ (Madrid, 1988).Google Scholar
Juan, Gil Zamora, Dictaminis epithalamium, ed. Faulhaber, C.,Biblioteca degli studi mediolatini e volgari, n.s. 2 (Pisa, 1978).Google Scholar
Juan, Manuel, El conde Lucanor, ed. Blecua, J. M. (Madrid, 1985).Google Scholar
Juan, Manuel, Libro de los estados, ed. Tate, R. B. and Macpherson, I. R. (Oxford, 1974).Google Scholar
Keightley, R. G., ‘Alfonso de Madrigal and the Chronici canones of Eusebius’, Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies, 7 (1977).Google Scholar
Keightley, Ronald G., ‘Alfonso de Madrigal and the Chronici canones of Eusebius’, Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies, 7 (1977).Google Scholar
Keightley, Ronald G., ‘Enrique de Villena's Los doze trabajos de Hércules: A Reappraisal’, Journal of Hispanic Philology, 3 (1978–79).Google Scholar
Kohut, Karl, ‘Der Beitrag der Theologie zum Literaturbegriff in der Zeit Juans II von Kastilien: Alonso de Cartagena (1384–1456) und Alonso de Madrigal, genant el Tostado (1400?–55)’, Romanische Forschungen, 89 (1977).Google Scholar
Kohut, Karl, ‘La posición de la literatura en los sistemas científicos del siglo XV’, Iberoromania, n. s. 7 (1978).Google Scholar
Kohut, Karl, ‘La teoría de la poesía cortesana en el Prólogo de Juan Alfonso de Baena’, in Hempel, W. and Briesemeister, D. (eds.), Actas del coloquio hispano-alemán Ramón Menéndez Pidal (Tübingen, 1982).Google Scholar
Kohut, Karl, Las teorías literarias en España y Portugal durante los siglos XV y XVI: estado de la investigación y problemática (Madrid, 1973).Google Scholar
Lawrence, Jeremy N. H., ‘Humanism in the Iberian Peninsula’, in Goodman, A. and MacKay, A. (eds.), The Impact of Humanism on Western Europe (London, 1990).Google Scholar
Lawrence, Jeremy N. H., ‘La Traduction espagnole du De libris gentilium legendis de Saint Basile, dédiéeau Marquis de Santillane (Paris, BN Ms esp. 458)’, Atalaya, 1 (1991).Google Scholar
Lawrence, Jeremy N. H., ‘The Spread of Lay Literacy in Late Medieval Castile’, Bulletin of Hispanic Studies, 62 (1985).Google Scholar
Lomax, Derek W., ‘Notes sur un métier: les jongleurs castillans en 1316’, in Les Espagnes médiévales, aspects économiques et sociaux: mélanges offerts á Jean Gautier Dalché (Nice, 1983).Google Scholar
López, Mendoza, Íñigo, Marqués de Santillana, Obras completas, ed. GómezMoreno, A. and Kerkhof, M. P. A. M. (Barcelona, 1988).Google Scholar
López, Estrada, Francisco, , ‘El arte de poesía castellana de Juan del Encina (1496)’, in Redondo, A. (ed.), L'Humanisme dans les letters espagnoles: XIXe collaque internationale d'études humanistes (Paris, 1979).Google Scholar
López, F.Las poéticas castellanas de la Edad Media, ed. Estrada (Madrid, 1985).Google Scholar
Macpherson, Ian, ‘Don Juan Manuel: The Literary Process’, Studies in Philology, 70 (1973)..Google Scholar
Madrigal, Alfonso (EI Tostado), Comento de Eusebio (5 vols., Salamanca, 1506–7).Google Scholar
Mena, Juan, La coronación del marqués de Santillana, in Obras completas, ed. PérezPriego, M. A. (Madrid, 1989).Google Scholar
Menéndez, Pidal, Ramón, , Poesía judlaresca y orígines de las literaturas románicas: problemas de historia literaria y cultural (Madrid, 1957).Google Scholar
Miguel, Prendes Sol, El espejo y el piélago: la ‘Eneida’ castellana de Enrique de Villena (Kassel, 1998).Google Scholar
Murphy, J. J. (ed.), Three Medieval Rhetorical Arts (Berkeley CA, 1971).Google Scholar
Nader, Helen, ‘“The Greek Commander” Hernán Núñez de Toledo, Spanish Humanist and Civic Leader’, Renaissance Quarterly, 31 (1978).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nalle, Sara T.Literacy and Culture in Early Modern Castile’, Past and Present, 125 (1989).Google Scholar
Nebrija, Elio Antonio, De vi ac potestate litterarum, ed. Quilis, A. and Usábel, P. (Madrid, 1987).Google Scholar
Nebrija, Elio Antonio, Gramática de la lengua castellana, ed. Quilis, A. (Madrid, 1980).Google Scholar
(ed.), Nehbrija y la introducción del Renacimiento en España:Actas de la III Academia Literaria Renacentista (Salamanca, 1983).
Niedereche, Hans-J., Alfonso el Sabio y la lingüística de su tiempo (Madrid, 1987); tr. from the 1975 German edn.Google Scholar
Núñez, Hernán, Las trezientas del famosíssimo poeta Juan de Mena con glosa (Seville, 1499; 2nd edn, Granada, 1505).Google Scholar
Ovid, Pseudo-, De Vetula, ed. Robathan, D. M. (Amsterdam, 1968); also ed. Klopsch, P., Mittellateinische Studien und Texte, 2 (Leiden and Cologne, 1967).Google Scholar
Palafox, Eloísa, Las éticas del ‘Exemplum’: Los ‘Castigos del rey don Sancho IV’, ‘El conde Lucanor’, y el ‘Libra de buen amor’ (Mexico City, 1998).Google Scholar
Pérez, Priego, Miguel, Ángel, ‘De Dante a Juan de Mena: sobre el género literario de comedia’, 1616’. Anuario de la Sociedad Española de Literatura General y Comparada, 1 (1978).Google Scholar
Potvin, Claudine, Illusion et pouvoir: La poétique du ‘Cancionero de Baena’, Cahiers d'études médiévales, 9 (Montreal, 1989).Google Scholar
Recio, Roxana (ed.), La traducción en España, ss. XIV–XVI (León, 1995).Google Scholar
Recio, Roxana, ‘Alfonso de Madrigal (El Tostado): la traducción comoteoría entre lo medieval y lo renacentista’, La Corónica, 19:2 (Spring, 1991).Google Scholar
Rico, Francisco, ‘Crítica de texto y modelos de cultura en el Prólogo general de don Juan Manuel’, Studia in honorem prof. M. de Riquer (4 vols., Barcelona, 1986), I.Google Scholar
Rico, Francisco, Alfonso el Sabio y la ‘General estoria’ (2nd edn, Barcelona, 1984).Google Scholar
Rico, Francisco, Nebrija frente a los bárbaros (Salamanca, 1978).Google Scholar
Riquier, Guiraut, ‘La supplica di Guiraut Riquier e la risposta di Alfonso X di Castiglia’, ed. Bertolucci-Pizzorusso, V., Studi mediolatini evolgari, 14 (1966).Google Scholar
Rodrigues, Lapa M.Cantigas d'escarnho e de mal dizer dos cancioneiros medievais galegoportugueses, ed. (1965; 2nd edn, Vigo, 1970).Google Scholar
Round, Nicholas G., ‘Renaissance Culture and its Opponents in Fifteenth–Century Castile’, Modern Language Review, 57 (1962).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ruiz, Juan, Libro de buen amor, ed. Gybbon-Monypenny, G. B. (Madrid, 1988).Google Scholar
Russell, P. E., ‘Las armas contra las letras: para una definitión del humanismo español del siglo XV’, in Temas de la ‘Celestina’ y otros estudios: del ‘Cid’ al ‘Quijote’ (Barcelona, 1978).Google Scholar
Russell, P. E., Traducciones y traductores en la Península Ibérica (1400–1550) (Bellaterra and Barcelona, 1985).Google Scholar
Sáenz–Badillos, Angel, and Borrás, Judit Targona, Gramáticos hebreos de Al Andalús (siglos X–XII): filología y biblia (Cordova, 1988).Google Scholar
Santiago Lacuesta, Ramón, ‘Sobre “el primer ensayo de una prosodia y ortografía castellanas”: el Arte de trovar de Enrique de Villena’, Miscellanea barcelonensia, 42 (1975).Google Scholar
Santillana, Marqués. See: López de Mendoza, Íñnigo
Schiff, Mario, La Bibliothéque du Marquis de Santillane (1905; rpt. Amsterdam, 1970).Google Scholar
Segovia, Pero Guillén, La gaya ciencia, ed. CasasHoms, J. M. (Madrid, 1962).Google Scholar
Seidenspinner–Núñez, Dayle, ‘Readers, Response, and Repertoires: Rezeptionstheorie and the Archpriest's Text’, La Corónica, 19:1 (Fall, 1990).Google Scholar
Seidenspinner–Núñez, Dayle,‘On “Dios y el mundo”: Author and Reader Response in Juan Ruiz and Juan Manuel’, Romance Philology, 42 (1988–9).Google Scholar
Street, Florence, ‘Hernán Núñez and the Earliest Printed Editions of Mena's Laberinto de Fortuna’, Modern Language Review, 61 (1966).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tavani, Giuseppe, ‘La satira morale e letteraria’, Grundriss der romanische Literaturen des Mittelalters, 6 (1968).
Taylor, Barry, ‘Don Jaime de Jérica y el público de El Conde Lucanor’, Revista de Filología Española, 66 (1986).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, Barry, ‘Juan Manuel's Cipher in the Libro de los estados’, La Corónica, 12 (1983–4).Google Scholar
Thomas, Antoine, Jean de Gerson et l'éducation des dauphins de France (Paris, 1930).Google Scholar
Valle Rodríguez, Carlos del, El diván poético de Dunash del Labrat: la introductión de la métrica árabe (Madrid, 1988).Google Scholar
Villena, Enrique, ‘El Arte de trovar de don Enrique de Villena’, ed. SánchezCantón, F. J., Revista de Filología Española, 6 (1919).Google Scholar
Villena, Enrique, Traducción y glosas de la ‘Eneida’, ed. Cátedra, P. M. (3 vols., Salamanca, 1989).Google Scholar
Walsh, J. K., ‘Juan Ruiz and the mester de clerezía: Lost Context and Lost Parody’, Romance Philology, 33 (1979).Google Scholar
Walsh, J. K., Review of Brownlee, Reading Subject, in La Corónica, 14 (1985–86).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, ‘Juan de Mena's Coronación: satire or sátira?’, Journal of Hispanic Philology, 6 (1981–2).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, ‘Las “fermosas e peregrinas ystorias”: sobre la glosa ornamental cuatrocentista’, Revista de Literatura Medieval, 2 (1990).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, ‘Medieval Poetics and the Social Meaning of From’, Atalaya, 8 (1997 [1998]).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, ‘On the Conventionality of the Cantigas d'amor’, La Corónica, 26:1 (Fall, 1997) ; rpt. in D., W. D. (ed.), Medieval Lyric: Genres in Historical Context (Urbana IL, 2000).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, ‘Political Commentary: Hernán Núñez's Glosa a “Las trescientas”’, in Deyermond, A. and Lawrance, J. (eds.), Letters and Society in Fifteenth–Century Spain: Studies Presented to P. E. Russell on his Eightieth Birthday (Llangrannog, 1993).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, ‘Tiempo y materia en la poética de Juan del Encina’, in Ceballos, J. Guijarro (ed.), Humanismo y literatura en tiempos de Juan del Encina (Salamanca, 1999).Google Scholar
Weiss, Julian, The Poet's Art: Literary Theory in Castile c. 1400–60, Medium Ævum Monographs, n.s. 14 (Oxford, 1990).Google Scholar

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure coreplatform@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

Available formats
×