Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-5wvtr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-16T22:29:55.589Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Shut in with thee’: the Morning Meeting among Scottish Open Brethren, 1840s–1960s

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Neil Dickson
Neil Dickson*
Affiliation:
University of Stirling
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Brethren movement had its origins in the early nineteenth century in Ireland and the south of England, first appearing in Scotland in 1838. The morning meeting gave quintessential expression to the piety of the members and was central to its practice. In the 1870s a former Presbyterian who was looking for the ideal pattern of the Church witnessed his first meeting in the village of K-. Converted in the revivals of the 1860s, he was eventually to join the movement.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 35: Continuity and Change in Christian Worship , 1999 , pp. 275 - 288
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Dickson, Neil, ‘Scottish Brethren: division and wholeness 1838-1916’, Christian Brethren Review Journal, 41 (1990), pp. 5–41.Google Scholar

2 During this period assemblies existed in Kirkficldbank, Lanarkshire, and Kcmnay, Aberdeenshire; the latter is the more likely identification in view of the origins of this anonymous individual’s publisher, John Ritchie, in neighbouring Inverurie.

3 Anon., , How I was Led Outside the Camp (Kilmarnock, nd), [pp. 5–7].Google Scholar

4 For the latter term cf. Rowdon, Harold H., The Origins of the Brethren 1825-1850 (London, 1967), p. 299 Google Scholar n.190.

5 For the various Brethren groupings sec, Roy Coad, F., A History of the Brethren Movement, 2nd edn (Exeter, 1976).Google Scholar

6 J. G. Bcllct to James McAllister, Q. G. Bellet et al], Interesting Reminiscences of the Early History of ‘Brethren’ with Letter from J. G. Bellet (London, nd), pp. 7-8.

7 Murray, Derek B., ‘The influence of John Glas’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society [hereafter RSCHS], 22 (1984), pp. 45–56.Google Scholar

8 Rowdon, Harold H., ‘Secession from the Established Church in the early nineteenth century’, Vox Evangelica, 3 (1964), pp. 76–88 Google Scholar; idem, ‘The problem of Brethren identity in historical perspective’, Biblioteca Storica Toscana, 11 (1988), pp. 159-74; Grayson Carter, ‘Evangelical scccdcrs from the Church of England, c.1800-1850’ (University of Oxford D. Phil, thesis, 1990), pp. 287-9.

9 Cf. Ncatby, W. B., A History of the Plymouth Brethren (London, 1901), p. 28.Google Scholar

10 [ Miiller, George], A Narrative of Some of the Lord’s Dealings with George Miiller, written by Himself, 6 vols, 9th edn (London, 1895), 1, p. 281 Google Scholar; cf. James Alexander Haldanc, A View of lhe Social Worship and Ordinances Observed by the First Christians (Edinburgh, 1805).

11 Stunt, Timothy C. F., ‘Irvingitc Pentecostalism and the early Brethren’, Christian Brethren Research Fellowship Journal, 10 (1965), pp. 40–8.Google Scholar

12 Ian S. Rcnnic, ‘Aspects of Christian Brethren spirituality’, in Packer, J. I. and Wilkinson, Lorcn, eds, Alive to God: Studies in Spirituality (Downers Grove, IL, 1992), p. 201.Google Scholar

13 Stunt, Timothy C. F., Early Brethren and the Society of Friends, Christian Brethren Research Fellowship Occasional Paper, 3 (Pinner, 1970).Google Scholar

14 A. Borland, The Lord’s Supper’, The Believer’s Magazine [hereafter BM], 61 (1951), p. 122.

15 Anon., , ‘Plain words about the morning meeting’, The Witness [hereafter W], 57 (1927), p. 87 Google Scholar; Robert Rendall to the editor, W, 75 (1945), p. 79.

16 Callahan, James Patrick, Primitivist Piety: the Ecclesiology of the Early Plymouth Brethren (Lanham, MD, 1996).Google Scholar

17 The similarity of Glasite worship and that of the Brethren was shown by the reprinting among the latter of a correspondence initiated in New York (and printed there in 1820) among churches of a primitivist type as Letters Concerning their Principles and Order from Assemblies of Believers in 1818-1820 (London, 1889). In this correspondence several Scotch Baptist churches in Scotland described their customs in terms sufficiently close to those of the Brethren to be mistaken later for an earlier form of the movement in the country by C. J. Pickering et al., 1865-1965: The Half-Yearly Meetings of Christians in Glasgow ([Glasgow, 1965]). p. 3.

18 Bowes, John, The Autobiography: or the History of the Life of John Bowes (Glasgow, 1872), pp. 221–32.Google Scholar

19 Beattic, David J., Brethren: the Story of a Great Recovery (Kilmarnock [1939]), p. 202.Google Scholar

20 John Smith-John Bowes, 12 Oct. 1848, quoted in Bowes, Autobiography, pp. 454-7.

21 John Bowes, The work of God at Dundee and Lochee’, The Truth Promoter ¡hereafter TP]. 7 (1859-61), p. 11.

22 ‘Extracts from the journal of John Bowes’, TP, 3 (1853-5), pp. 238-40; 6 (1858-9), pp. 127-8.

23 Kent, John, Holding the Fork Studies in Victorian Revivalism (London, 1978), p. 116 Google Scholar; Bcbbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in Modern Britain: A History from the 1730s to the 1980s (London, 1989), p. 117.Google Scholar

24 Dickson, Neil, ‘Brethren and Baptists in Scotland’, The Baptist Quarterly, 33 (1990), pp. 372–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

25 Idem, ‘Scottish Brethren’, pp. 16-20.

26 Insch, Fordyce Hall, Minute Book 1873-91, p. 1.

27 Caldwell, J. R., ‘Object of the Lord’s Supper’, W, 22 (1892), pp. 126–7.Google Scholar

28 Hy P[ickcring], The order of the morning meeting’, W, 54 (1934), p. 85.

29 F. A. B[anks], The feast of remembrance and testimony’, The Northern Witness [hereafter NW], 16 (1886), pp. 74-5; cf. ‘Question CCXXV, ibid., p. 80; ‘Question CVT, NW, 12 (1882), p. 111; The believer’s question box’, BM, 37 (1927), p. 90.

30 E.g., Clare, W. H., Pioneer Preaching or Work Well Done (London and Glasgow [1925]), p. 88.Google Scholar

31 For a description of the breaking of bread in the Churches of God, see G. Willis and B. R. Wilson, The Churches of God: pattern and practice’, in Wilson, B. R., ed., Patterns of Sectarianism: Organisation and Ideology in Social and Religious Movements (London, 1967), Appendix, pp. 285–6.Google Scholar

32 D[arby], J. N., Hints on the Tabernacle, the Sacrifices, the Day of Atonement, the Feasts, and the Coverings of the Holy Things (London, nd), pp. 25–59 Google Scholar; C H. Mackintosh], Notes on Leviticus, 2nd edn (London [1861]).

33 Borland, A, ‘The Lord’s Supper’, BM, 61 (1951), pp. 1–2.Google Scholar

34 W. R. Lewis and E. W. Rodgers to the editor, W, 82 (1952), p. 120.

35 E[wan], I. Y., ‘When should the bread be broken?’, Present Testimony [hereafter PT], 6 (1940-1), pp. 984–8.Google Scholar

36 R[odgers], J., ‘In the beginning’, PT, 4 (nd), pp. 1110–12 Google Scholar; Andrew Borland, The Lord’s Supper’, in J. B. Watson, ed., The Church: a Symposium (London, 1949), p. 78.

37 Borland, A., ‘The Lord’s Supper’, BM, 60 (1950), pp. 73–5 Google Scholar; Lewis and Rodgers to the editor, W, 82 (1952), p. 120; G. C. D. Howley, ‘The Church and its members’, in A New Testament Church in 1955 (Rushden [1956]), p. 2r.

38 Caldwell, J. R., Epitome of Christian Experience (Glasgow [1917]), p. 111.Google Scholar

39 See the correspondence in NW, 8 (1878), pp. 17-18; W, 29 (1899), pp. 82-4; W, 30 (1900), pp. 131-2; W, 33(1903), pp. 34-6; W, 41 (1911), pp. 33-4; W, 44(1914), p- 177; W7. 45 (1915), pp. 176-7; W, 48 (1918), pp. 18-19, 26-8, 43-4, 60, 90-1; W, 55 (1925), pp. 112-13; W, 56 (1926), pp. 208-9, 384-5; W, 57 (1927), pp. 153, 159; W, 59 (1929), pp. 280-1; W, 60 (1930), p. 66; W, 74 (1944), pp. 95-6: W, 75 (1945). pp. 15-16, 21-2; W, 77 (1947). p. 141; cf. BM, 31 (1921), pp. 55-6.

40 John Dickie to the editor, 4 July 1855, TP, 4 (1855-6), p. 95; The believer’s question box’, BM, 57 (1947), p. 317; Borland, The Lord’s Supper’, pp. 97-8.

41 The believer’s question box’, BM, 45 (1935), pp. 22-3.

42 See the correspondence in NW, 16 (1886), p. 80; W, 54 (1924), p. 422; BM, 45 (1935), pp. 22-3, 134, 190-1; John Ritchie, BM, 29 (1919), p. 71; BM, 43 (1933), p. 48.

43 Hy P[ickering], ‘Questions and answers’, W, 49 (1919), p. 176.

44 Hopkins, S. R., ‘Questions and answers’, W, 59 (1929), pp. 18–19.Google Scholar

45 Hopkins, R. T., ‘Friday’s Conference’, Northern Evangelistic Intelligencer, 2 (1872), p. 73 Google Scholar; cf. [J. L. Harris], ‘On Christian ministry’, The Christian Witness, 1 0an. 1834), p. 9.

46 Tillicoultry, Bankfoot Evangelical Church, ‘Minute Record of the Assembly & Oversight Business Meeting. From 1st Jan. 1925 - Ann St. Gospel Hall, Tillicoultry’, Half Yearly Business Meeting, 20 March 1926.

47 Caldwell, J. R., From the Cross to the Kingdom, rpt (Glasgow, 1983), p. 188 Google Scholar; Alexander Stewart, Salvation Truths (Kilmarnock, nd), p. 10; John Ritchie, From Egypt to Canaan (Kilmarnock, nd), pp. 21-3.

48 Caldwell, J. R., ‘The weekly gathering of saints’, W, 38 (1908), pp. 173–5.Google Scholar

49 Rowdon, Harold H., ‘The Brethren concept of sainthood’, Vox Evangelica, 20 (1990), pp. 91–102.Google Scholar

50 Rennic, ‘Brethren spirituality’, p. 205.

51 Murray, J., ‘Cause and condition’, BM, 57 (1947), pp. 178–9 Google Scholar; cf. Mackintosh], Leviticus, pp. 86-8.

52 Ritchie, John, Assembly Privileges and Responsibilities (Kilmarnock, nd), p. 5.Google Scholar

53 Callahan, Primitivist Piety, pp. 51 -4.

54 Caldwell, J. R, ‘Christ the sin offering’, W, 24 (1894), p. 56.Google Scholar

55 Hy P[ickcring], , ‘What is meant by the breaking of bread?’, W, 56 (1926), pp. 283–4.Google Scholar

56 J. R. C[aldwcll], W, 24 (1894), p. 84; John Ritchie, ‘The Church in its worship’, BM, 28 (1918), p. 77; John Douglas, Lessons from the Kings of Israel andjudah (Ashgill, 1997), p. 14.

57 A[dam], G. and C[aldwell], J. R., ‘Questions and answers’, W, 24 (1874), p. 84.Google Scholar

58 Marshall, Alexander, ‘The Lord’s two ordinances’, W, 19 (1889), pp. 164–6.Google Scholar

59 J. R Caldwell, The breaking of bread: the meaning, mode, and practical observance. Notes on I Corinthians xi. 23-6’, W, 39 (1909), p. 78.

60 Bcbbington, Evangelicalism, pp. 78-97.

61 Caldwell, “The breaking of bread’, pp. 77-9.

62 Caldwell, Christian Experience, pp. 102-3.

63 The Believers Hymn Book (Glasgow [1885]), no. 129.

64 Caldwell, J. R., ‘The oneness of the Body’, W, 38 (1908), p. 190.Google Scholar

65 Cowan, John, ‘Self-control’, BM, 60 (1950), pp. 255–6.Google Scholar

66 Caldwell, J. R., ‘Questions and answers’, W, 22 (1892), p. 127.Google Scholar

67 E[wan], I. Y., ‘When should the bread be broken?’, PT, 6 (1940-1), p. 987.Google Scholar

68 Dickson, Neil, ‘Modern prophetesses: women preachers in the nineteenth-century Scottish Brethren’, RSCHS, 25 (1993), pp. 89–117.Google Scholar

69 Ritchie, Assembly Privileges, p. 4.

70 [Alex Buchan], ‘First Message in York Street Hall by Mr. Alex Buchan on 26th June, 1965’ (cyclostylcd sheet, nd: author’s collection).

71 Summcrton, Neil, ‘The practice of worship’, Christian Brethren Review, 39 (1988), p. 36.Google Scholar

72 Stunt, , Brethren and the Society of Friends, pp. 23–5.Google Scholar

73 Rennie, ‘Brethren spirituality’, p. 195.

74 Ncatby, Plymouth Brethren, p. 278; Marsdcn, G. M., Fundamentalism and American Culture: the Shaping of Twentieth-Century Evangelicalism: 1870-1025 (Oxford, 1980), pp. 48–62 Google Scholar; J. A. H. Dempster, ‘Aspects of Brethren publishing enterprise in late nineteenth century Scotland’, Publishing History, 20 (1986), pp. 61-101.

75 Wilson, Bryan R., Sects and Society: a Sociological Study of Three Religious Groups in Britain (London, 1961), pp. 63–75.Google Scholar

76 Lcsmahagow, Hope Hall, Roll Book 1876-1907, p. 67; ‘Isaiah Stewart’, W, 64 (1934), p. 167; J. McCallum, ‘The Roll Call’ (author’s collection).

77 Ritchie, J., ‘The Lord’s Supper’, BM, 10 (1901), p. 140.Google Scholar

78 Hy P[ickering], , ‘Witness Watchtowcr’, W, 60 (1930), p. 114.Google Scholar

79 Ireland, J. A., ‘The breaking of bread’, W, 78 (1948), pp. 43–4 Google Scholar; R Eadic, ‘The Lord’s Supper’, W, 87 (1957), pp. 102-7; John Ritchie, ‘Hints for behaviour in the assembly’, BM, 16 (1906), p. 32; John Ritchie, The Church in its worship’, BM, 28 (1918), p. 76; A. Borland, ‘The Lord’s Supper’, BM, <5r (1951), pp. 1-2, 99, BM, 62 (1952), pp. 1-2, and BM, 63 (1953), pp. 17-19.

80 Ritchie, The Church in its worship’, p. 76.

81 Manson, Peter, ‘A Sunday morning meditation’, W, 78 (1948), pp. 17–18 Google Scholar; Ireland, ‘Breaking of bread’, pp. 43-4.

82 Borland, A., ‘The Lord’s Supper’, BM, 60 (1950), pp. 97–8, 266 Google Scholar; BM, 61 (1951), pp. 49- 51; idem, The Lord’s Supper’, pp. 75-6.

83 Caldwell, J. R., ‘Christ the peace offering’, W, 24 (1894), p. 137 Google Scholar; cf. Ritchie, The Lord’s Supper’, p. 141.

84 George Adam, The holiness of the Lord’s Table’, W, 30 (1900), p. 154.

85 Dickson, “Scottish Brethren’, pp. 23-36.

86 Ireland, J. A., ‘Why I sit at the Lord’s Table’, W, 70 (1940), pp. 121–3 Google Scholar; T. A. Kirkby, ‘Why wc prize the morning meeting’, W, 71 (1941), pp. 203-4; Borland, ‘The Lord’s Supper’, pp. 77-8.

87 Bebbington, Evangelicalism, pp. 157-9; Roger N. Shuff, ‘Open to closed: the growth of cxclusivism among Brethren in Britain 1848-195 3’, Brethren Archivists and Historians Network Review, 1 (1997), p. 12.

88 Dickson, ‘Scottish Brethren’, pp. 18, 38 n.62.

89 A Crucified Man, ‘Worship meetings’, The Northern Assemblies (1872), pp. 5-6.

90 Caldwell, J. R., ‘Ministry at the Lord’s Table’, W, 41 (1911), pp. 33–4.Google Scholar

91 W. E. Howie to the editor, W, 94 (1964), p. 230.

92 Ella [Jack] in Central View (the magazine of the Central Evangelical Church, Kilmarnock), 20 (March, 1994), pp. 10-11.

93 Cf. Summerton, ‘Practice of worship’, p. 3 5.

94 Ian M. Randall, ‘Movements of evangelical spirituality in inter-war England’ (University of Wales Ph. D. thesis, 1997), pp. 201-5, 218-20; Donald Bridge and David Phypers, The Meal that Unites (London, 1981), pp. 135-42, 175.

95 Hy Pjickcring], ‘What place is given to scripture at the morning meeting?’, W, 69 (1939), p. 109.

96 W. A. Thomson, W, 75 (1945), pp. 15-16.

97 Cf. Rennic, ‘Brethren spirituality’, p. 206.