Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-nmvwc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-22T06:40:03.515Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Scottish Presbyterianism and the National Education Debates, 1850–62

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2019

Ryan Mallon
Ryan Mallon*
Affiliation:
Queen's University Belfast
*
*School of History, Anthropology, Philosophy and Politics, Queen's University Belfast, 25 University Sq, Belfast, BT7 1NN. E-mail: rmallon11@qub.ac.uk.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article examines the mid-nineteenth-century Scottish education debates in the context of intra-Presbyterian relations in the aftermath of the 1843 ‘Disruption’ of the Church of Scotland. The debates of this period have been characterized as an attempt to wrest control of Scottish education from the Church of Scotland, with most opponents of the existing scheme critical of the established kirk's monopoly over the supervision of parish schools. However, the debate was not simply between those within and outside the religious establishment. Those advocating change, particularly within non-established Presbyterian denominations, were not unified in their proposals for a solution to Scotland's education problem. Disputes between Scotland's largest non-established churches, the Free Church and the United Presbyterian Church, and within the Free Church itself over the type of national education scheme that should replace the parish schools severely hampered their ability to express common opposition to the existing system. These divisions also placed increasing strain on the developing cooperation in Scottish Dissent on ecclesiastical, political and social matters after the Disruption. This article places the issue of education in this period within this distinctly Dissenting context of cooperation, and examines the extent of the impact these debates had on Dissenting Presbyterian relations.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 55: CHURCHES AND EDUCATION , June 2019 , pp. 363 - 380
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Paz, D. G., The Politics of Working-Class Education in Britain, 1830–50 (Manchester, 1980), 142–3Google Scholar; Stevenson, John, ‘Scottish Schooling in the Denominational Era’, in Anderson, Robert, Freeman, Mark and Paterson, Lindsay, eds, The Edinburgh History of Education in Scotland (Edinburgh, 2015), 133–52Google Scholar, at 135–40.

2 Akenson, Donald H., The Irish Education Experiment: The National System of Education in the Nineteenth Century (London, 1970), 113–22Google Scholar; Coolahan, John, Irish Education: Its History and Structure (Dublin, 1981), 15–16Google Scholar.

3 Brown, Stewart J., The National Churches of England, Ireland, and Scotland, 1801–1846 (Oxford, 2001), 164CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 169.

4 Ibid. 213–15, 239–42, 341–4; Newbould, Ian D. C., ‘The Whigs, the Church, and Education, 1839’, JBS 26 (1987), 332–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Machin, G. I. T., Politics and the Churches in Great Britain, 1832 to 1868 (Oxford, 1977), 151–60Google Scholar.

5 Machin, Politics, 165.

6 Gerald Parsons, ‘Reform, Revival and Realignment: The Experience of Victorian Anglicanism’, in idem, ed., Religion in Victorian Britain, 1: Traditions (Manchester, 1988), 14–66, at 59–60.

7 Report of the Proceedings of the Public Meeting of the Friends of National Education, in the Music Hall, Edinburgh, on Wednesday, January 24, 1854 (Edinburgh, 1854), 3–5.

8 Larsen, Timothy, Friends of Religious Equality: Nonconformist Politics in Mid-Victorian England (Woodbridge, 1999), 137–67Google Scholar.

9 The National Education Association of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1850), 1–3.

10 Report of the Proceedings, 56, 65–7.

11 Withrington, Donald J., ‘Adrift among the Reefs of conflicting Ideals? Education and the Free Church, 1843–55’, in Brown, Stewart J. and Fry, Michael, eds, Scotland in the Age of the Disruption (Edinburgh, 1993), 79–97Google Scholar; Stevenson, John, Fulfilling a Vision: The Contribution of the Church of Scotland to School Education, 1772–1872 (Eugene, OR, 2012), 90–118Google Scholar.

12 Stevenson, ‘Scottish Schooling’, 133.

13 Hutchison, I. G. C., A Political History of Scotland 1832–1924: Parties, Elections and Issues (Edinburgh, 1986), 73Google Scholar.

14 Drummond, Andrew L. and Bulloch, James, The Church in Victorian Scotland, 1843–1874 (Edinburgh, 1975), 90–1Google Scholar.

15 Stevenson, ‘Scottish Schooling’, 148.

16 Lewis, George, Scotland a Half-educated Nation, both in the Quantity and Quality of her Educational Institutions (Glasgow, 1834), 75Google Scholar; Withrington, Donald J., ‘The Free Church Educational Scheme, 1843–50’, RSCHS 15 (1964), 103–15Google Scholar, at 104.

17 Guthrie, David K. and Guthrie, Charles J., Autobiography of Thomas Guthrie, D.D., and Memoir by his Sons, 2 vols (New York, 1875), 2: 291Google Scholar, 295.

18 Brown and Fry, Scotland, viii–ix.

19 Brown, Callum G., The Social History of Religion in Scotland since 1730 (London, 1987), 98–9Google Scholar.

20 Stevenson, ‘Scottish Schooling’, 137.

21 Elizabeth Ritchie, ‘“Alive to the advantages of education”. Problems in using the New Statistical Account to research Education: A Case Study of the Isle of Skye’, Northern Scotland 7 (2016), 85–92, at 86; Withrington, ‘Adrift’, 80.

22 This relationship between religious Nonconformity and political radicalism, and its challenge to the political and religious establishment, particularly regarding state education, was also a common feature in English Dissent: see, for example, Koss, Stephen, Nonconformity in Modern British Politics (London, 1975)Google Scholar; Larsen, Friends, 137–67.

23 ‘Scottish National Education’, North British Review 12 (1849–50), 260–76, at 267; Fletcher, Joseph, Education: National, Voluntary, and Free (London, 1851), 74Google Scholar.

24 A Voice from the Church, being a Review of the Resolutions and Speeches at the Public Meeting on National Education (Edinburgh, 1854), 3.

25 According to the 1851 religious census, the Free Church accounted for 32 per cent and the United Presbyterian Church 19 per cent of Scotland's churchgoing population. The established church also represented 32 per cent of Scots, while smaller Presbyterian denominations, such as the Reformed Presbyterian and Original Secession Churches, made up 2 per cent of churchgoers. The remaining 15 per cent comprised a growing Roman Catholic population, Episcopalians, Congregationalists, Baptists and Methodists: Brown, Social History, 61.

26 For example, see the Dissent-dominated Essays on Christian Union (London, 1845); Chalmers, Thomas, Churches and Schools for the Working Classes (Edinburgh, 1846)Google Scholar; Millar, Gordon F., ‘Maynooth and Scottish Politics: The Role of the Maynooth Grant Issue, 1845–1857’, RSCHS 27 (1997), 220–79Google Scholar.

27 Sinclair, George, A Letter addressed to the Non-established Presbyterian Communions of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1854), 18–30Google Scholar.

28 Guthrie and Guthrie, Autobiography of Thomas Guthrie, 2: 288–93.

29 The Education Question in Scotland (Cupar, 1853), 5.

30 Stevenson, ‘Scottish Schooling’, 138–41.

31 For a detailed overview of the divisions within the Free Church, see Withrington, ‘Free Church Educational Scheme’, 103–15.

32 Elgin Courier, 7 June 1850, 2; Guthrie and Guthrie, Autobiography of Thomas Guthrie, 2: 288; Montrose, Arbroath and Brechin Review, 5 July 1850, 7.

33 Withrington, ‘Adrift’, 79–80.

34 Stevenson, ‘Scottish Schooling’, 140–3.

35 Education Commission (Scotland), First Report by Her Majesty's Commissioners appointed to inquire into the Schools in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1865), 107; ‘National Education for Scotland’, Free Church Magazine n.s. 2 (1853), 529–33.

36 Fife Herald, 2 June 1853, 2.

37 Robert Smith Candlish, Letter to the Marquis of Lansdowne, on the Reform and Extension of the Parish School System of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1851).

38 Report of the Proceedings, 46, 61, 64–5; Caledonian Mercury, 12 November 1849, 2–3.

39 ‘Scotland’, Christian Witness and Church Members’ Magazine 7 (1850), 186–8, at 187.

40 ‘Tests, or no Tests’, MacPhail's Edinburgh Ecclesiastical Journal and Literary Review 11 (1851), 208–26, at 225.

41 ‘National Education’, United Presbyterian Magazine 3 (1849), 20–2; The Scotsman, 6 October 1849, 2.

42 ‘Scottish National Education’, 268; Caledonian Mercury, 5 November 1849, 2; ibid., 15 November 1849, 2–3.

43 Caledonian Mercury, 12 November 1849, 2–3.

44 Hutchison, Political History, 74.

45 Elgin Courier, 14 March 1851, 4.

46 Stevenson, ‘Scottish Schooling’, 144.

47 Guthrie and Guthrie, Autobiography of Thomas Guthrie, 2: 298.

48 ‘National Education for Scotland’, Free Church Magazine n.s. 2 (1853), 529–34, at 533.

49 Education Question, 5; Scottish Guardian, 13 January 1854, 2.

50 Report of the Proceedings, 72, 83–91; Voice from the Church, 3–5.

51 Dundee Courier, 15 February 1854, 4.

52 Aberdeen Press and Journal, 15 February 1854, 7.

53 Voice from the Church, 4.

54 ‘National Education’, United Presbyterian Magazine 8 (1854), 141–4, at 142.

55 Report of the Proceedings, 56, 65–7.

56 ‘Sir George Sinclair on Union between the Free and United Presbyterian Churches’, United Presbyterian Magazine 8 (1854), 352–6, at 353–4; Robert Rainy and James Mackenzie, Life of William Cunningham (London, 1871), 259.

57 Guthrie and Guthrie, Autobiography of Thomas Guthrie, 2: 300.

58 Richard Cobden to George Combe, 24 February 1854, in Anthony Howe and Simon Morgan, eds, The Letters of Richard Cobden, 3: 1854–1859 (Oxford, 2012), 16.

59 HC Deb (3rd series), vol. 130, col. 1167 (23 February 1854).

60 The Scotsman, 12 April 1854, 4.

61 The Witness, 29 April 1854, 5.

62 Guthrie and Guthrie, Autobiography of Thomas Guthrie, 2: 299–300.

63 The Witness, 29 April 1854, 5.

64 Glasgow Constitutional, 28 March 1855, 4.

65 Caledonian Mercury, 20 March 1857, 2; Paisley Herald and Renfrewshire Advertiser, 4 April 1857, 1.

66 Scottish Guardian, 27 July 1855, 1.

67 Proceedings and Debates in the General Assembly of the Free Church of Scotland, held at Edinburgh, May 1857 (Edinburgh, 1857), 255, 260–2, 266.

68 Glasgow Herald, 15 January 1859, 3.

69 Glasgow Herald, 4 May 1857, 2; John O'Groat's Journal, 18 July 1861, 2.

70 Elgin Courier, 26 April 1861, 5.

71 McCormack, Christopher F., ‘The Irish Church Disestablishment Act (1869) and the General Synod of the Church of Ireland (1871): The Art and Structure of Educational Reform’, HE 47 (2018), 303–20Google Scholar, at 319–20.

72 Stevenson, Fulfilling a Vision, 118.