No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
‘God and Mammon’ religious protest and educational change in New England from the Revolution to the Gilded Age
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
Extract
I hasten at the start to point out that I am not an ecclesiastical historian, but a historian of America who is interested in church history since the field in which I work - educational history - desperately needs to be studied in a wider historical context. Then, as now, educational ideas, and the functions people ascribe to education, cannot be dissociated from the political, social, and economic background. Of all the many factors bearing upon the evolution of education in New England from approximately the 1780s to the 1880s religion was in several ways of central importance. Most studies have been interested in the religious nature of the mass of colleges founded from 1780 to 1860. My interest here is entirely different. Although the rhetoric naturally changed in emphasis, it seems to me that right from the seventeenth century to the late nineteenth century religious forces in New England, but of course not just there, used schools and colleges as cardinal agencies in efforts to restrain secularism and a growing materialism.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1972
References
page no 351 note 1 See Tewksbury, D. G., The Founding of American Colleges and Universities before the Civil War; with Particular Reference to the Religious Influences Bearing Upon the College Movement (New York 1932)Google Scholar; and The Colleges and the Public, 1787-1862, ed Crane, T. R. (New York 1963)Google Scholar.
page no 351 note 2 Quoted in Bushman, [R. L.], [From Puritan to Yankee: Character and the Social Order in Connecticut, 1690-1765] (Cambridge, Mass, 1967) p 188 Google Scholar.
page no 351 note 3 In 1639 Robert Keayne was accused by the elders of the First Church in Boston of excessive profit making, which it was maintained was not only a crime but a sin; see The Apologia of Robert Keayne, ed Bailyn, B. (New York 1965 Google Scholar).
page no 352 note 1 Bushman, , p 189. See Greene, [J. P.], [‘Search for Identity: An Interpretation of Selected Patterns of Social Response in Eighteenth Century America’], in Journal of Social History, IV (Berkeley 1970) pp 189–220 Google Scholar.
page no 352 note 2 Quoted by Greene, p 213. See McAnear, B., ‘ College Founding in the American Colonies, 1745-75 ’, in M[ississippi] V[alley] H[istorical] R[eview], XLII (New Orleans June 1955) pp 24–44 Google Scholar. See also, The Great Awakening: Event and Exegesis, ed Rutman, D. B. (New York 1970)Google Scholar.
page no 353 note 1 Wood, [G. S.], [The Creation of the American Republic, 1776-87] (Chapel Hill 1969) pp 115, 476 Google Scholar; William, Goddard, The Prowess of the Whig Club (Baltimore 1777) quoted by Wood, p 477 Google Scholar.
page no 353 note 2 Austin, Benjamin, in the Boston Independent Chronicle, 6 December 1787; Charleston, Columbian Herald, 23 September 1785, quoted by Wood, pp 477, 484-5.Google Scholar
page no 353 note 3 Hartford, , Connecticut Courant, 20 November 1786.Google Scholar
page no 354 note 1 Dickinson, John, Letters of Fabius, quoted in Wood, p 507 Google Scholar; George Washington to John Jay, 18 May 1786, quoted by Fischer, [D. H.], [The Revolution of American Con servatism] (New York 1965) p 379 Google Scholar.
page no 354 note 2 Essays on Education in the Early Republic, ed Rudolph, F. (Cambridge, Mass, 1965)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Post, T., ‘Historical Address’, in Centennial of Lennox Academy (Lennox 1903) p 11 Google Scholar.
page no 354 note 3 Connecticut Courant, 4 July 1791; George Cabot to Rufus King, 14 August 1795, quoted in Fischer, p 4; ‘North West Ordinance’, Article 3, in Documents of American History, ed Commager, H. S. (5 ed New York 1949) p 131 Google Scholar.
page no 355 note 1 Middlekauff, R., Ancients and Axioms: England (New Haven 1963) pp 129-30Google Scholar.
page no 355 note 2 Undated MS of Samuel Phillips, Jr, quoted by Fuess, [C. M.], [An Old New England School] (Boston 1917) p 56 Google Scholar; Constitution of Phillips Academy, reprinted in Sizer, [T. R.], [Age of the Academies] (New York 1964) pp 79–89 Google Scholar.
page no 356 note 1 Sizer has a useful introduction.
page no 356 note 2 Fuess, , p 171; Constitution of Phillips Exeter Academy, reprinted in Crosbie, [L. M.], [The Phillips Exeter Academy, A History] (Norwood, N.H., 1923) p 308 Google Scholar; Act of Incorporation, in Crosbie, p 311.
page no 356 note 3 Crosbie, pp 304, 308.
page no 357 note 1 Benjamin Franklin on Education, ed Best, J. H. (New York 1965)Google Scholar. For Jefferson’s deism and Republican support for dissenting sects see Kerber, L. K., Federalists in Dissent (Ithaca 1970) p 53 Google Scholar.
page no 358 note 1 By 1850 there were about 1000 academies, including some 800 non-incorporated ones; see Sizer, p 12; Griffin, C. S., ‘Religious Benevolence as Social Control 1815-60’, in MVHR, XLIV (December 1957)Google Scholar.
page no 358 note 2 Carter, James G., Letters to the Hon. William Prescott LL.D. on the Free Schools of New England with Remarks upon the Principles of Instruction (Boston 1824)Google Scholar. For the School Committee quotation I am indebted to professor Michael Katz.
page no 359 note 1 See Katz, M., The Irony of Early School Reform (Cambridge, Mass, 1969)Google Scholar.
page no 359 note 2 Pelatiah, Webster, The Weakness of Brutus Exposed (Philadelphia 1787)Google Scholar, quoted by Wood, American Republic, p 508; [James Russell], Lowell, [The Writings of James Russell Lowell] (London 1890) V, p 310 Google Scholar; see Smith, T. L., Revivalism and Social Reform: American Protestantism on the Eve of the Civil War (New York 1965)Google Scholar, and Thomas, J. L., ‘Romantic Reform in America 1815-65’, in American Quarterly, XVII (Philadelphia 1965) pp 658-81Google Scholar.
page no 360 note 1 Cotton, Mather, Magnolia Christi Americana (Hartford 1820), quoted by Fischer, p 4 Google Scholar. Various views of the Gilded Age can be found in The Gilded Age, ed Morgan, H. Wayne (rev ed Syracuse 1970)Google Scholar. On the reactions of patricians, see Blodgett, G., The Gentle Reformers (Cambridge, Mass, 1966) ch IICrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Sproat, J. G., ‘ The Best Men’: Liberal Reformers in the Gilded Age (New York 1968)Google Scholar.
page no 361 note 1 Lowell, VI, p 171; McQuaid, B. J., ‘Religion in Schools’, in The North American Review, CXXXII (Boston 1881) pp 332-44Google Scholar; Thomas Hughes to Fanny Hughes, 9 October 1870, quoted in Mack, E. C. and Armytage, W. H. G., Thomas Hughes (London 1952) p 182 Google Scholar.
page no 361 note 2 Lowell, V, p 195; Coit, H. A., ‘An American Boys’ School: What it Should Be’, in The Forum, XII (New York September 1891) p 5 Google Scholar; Coit, H.A., School Sermons (New York 1909) p 240 Google Scholar.
page no 362 note 1 [Endicott] Peabody, ‘The Boy and The Boarding School’, in The New York Times 26 September 1908; Peabody to bishop J. Atwood, 28 June 1897 and 17 February 1908, Endicott Peabody Papers, Houghton Library, Harvard University.
page no 362 note 2 Peabody to Atwood, 20 January 1888; William, Lawrence, ‘The Sermon Preached at the Consecration of St John’s Chapel, Groton School, on Saturday, 13 October 1900’, in [The] Consecration of St John’s Chapel, [Groton School, Croton, Massachusetts] (Boston 1900) p 9 Google Scholar; Peabody, , ‘The Aim of Groton School’, in The Church Militant, III (Boston April 1900) p 3 Google Scholar.
page no 363 note 1 Peabody to Father Sill [headmaster of Kent School], 10 January 1907; Peabody, ‘A Sermon preached at the Consecration of St John’s Chapel, Groton School on Sunday, 14 October 1900’, in Consecration of St John’s Chapel, pp 35-6, 29.
page no 363 note 2 [Horace Dutton Taft,] ‘Sermon’, 6 January 1935; Taft, H. D., Memories and Opinions (New York 1942) p 260 Google Scholar; ‘Sermon’, 22 September 1935. Horace Taft’s papers are in the school archives.
page no 364 note 1 Briggs, Le Barron R., School, College and Character (Boston 1901) p 11 Google Scholar. The concern of the pre-Civil War colleges for the moral ends of knowledge, embodied in the ‘liberal’ curriculum and collegiate principle, continued after the war more than has usually been recognised, see Peterson, G.E., The New England College in the Age of the University (Amherst 1964)Google Scholar, but on the survival of the older concepts in juxtaposition with new German ideas in the universities there is as yet no satisfactory study.
page no 364 note 2 See Potter, D. M., People of Plenty: Economic Abundance and the American Character (Chicago 1954)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Folwell, W. W., ‘Inaugural 1869’, in University Addresses (Minneapolis 1909)Google Scholar.