Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-m8s7h Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T15:29:12.672Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Emergence of the Nonconformist Social Gospel in England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 February 2016

David M. Thompson
David M. Thompson*
Affiliation:
Fitzwilliam College, Cambridge
Get access

Extract

Anyone who sets out to examine the theology behind Nonconformist social thought and action in the late nineteenth century has to answer two questions: Did such a theology exist? and Was it important? The second question is more fundamental. Twenty years ago John Kent argued that the realities of politics put an increasing strain on the late Victorian claim to a Christian conscience in public affairs, and that in any case Nonconformists did not enjoy a monopoly of moral concern in politics. Like other Liberals, they ‘found themselves trying to reconcile the older Cobden-type ideals of liberty, peace, arbitration and anti-militarism with a new belief in the positive values of an allegedly Christian British Empire’. The result was that ‘the struggle for political power coarsened their moral sensibility’. In such an analysis the emphasis falls on action rather than thought, and in domestic affairs particularly on the political campaigns for social purity, temperance, or against gambling, where they are easily dismissed as the result of evangelical pietism, class moralism, or social reaction. David Bebbington deliberately eschewed theology in his study of the Nonconformist Conscience. ‘Because the focus is on political issues that concerned Nonconformists en masse’, he wrote, ‘the theological views of their leaders, and even their versions of the social gospel, do not loom large.’ In his thesis he also commented that ‘theology was largely unfashionable, even in sermons’, citing Charles Berry, a leading Congregationalist, as an example. Nevertheless, he did not deny that there was a theology.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History Subsidia , Volume 7: Protestant Evangelicalism , 1990 , pp. 255 - 280
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1990 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Kent, J., ‘Hugh Price Hughes and the Nonconformist Conscience’, in Bennett, G. V. and Walsh, J. D., eds, Essays in Modem English Church History (London, 1966), pp. 195, 204Google Scholar.

2 Bebbington, D.W., The Nonconformist Conscience: Chapel and Politics, 1870–1914 (London, 1982) p. xGoogle Scholar.

3 Bebbington, D. W., ‘The Nonconformist Conscience: a study of the political attitudes and activities of Evangelical Nonconformists, 1886–1902)’ (Cambridge Ph.D. thesis, 1975), p. 1Google Scholar.

4 Helmstadter, R., ‘The Nonconformist Conscience’, in Marsh, P., ed., The Conscience of the Victorian State (Hassocks, 1979), p. 167Google Scholar.

5 Norman, E.R., Church and Society in England, 1770–1070 (Oxford, 1976), pp. 1–14,180–6Google Scholar.

6 P.d’ Jones, A., The Christian Socialist Revival, 1877–1914 (Princeton, 1968), p. 307CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Troeltsch, E., The Social Teaching of the Christian Churches, trans. Wyon, O. (London, 1931), 1, p. 25Google Scholar.

8 Hilton, B., The Age of Atonement (Oxford, 1988)Google Scholar.

9 Ward, W.R., Theology, Sociology and Politics: The German Protestant Social Conscience, 1890–1933 (Bern, 1979), p. 14Google Scholar.

10 Rae, J., ‘Social Philosophy’, Cont. Rev., 45 (1884), p. 295Google Scholar.

11 Bettany, F. G., Stewart Headlam: A Biography (London, 1926), pp. 39–40,79–87Google Scholar.

12 Shaftesbury, Lord, “The Mischief of State Aid’, The Nineteenth Century, 14 (1883), p. 935Google Scholar; see also, Wohl, A. S.. ed., The Bitter Cry of Outcast London (Leicester, 1969)Google Scholar; Wohl, A. S., The Eternal Slum (London, 1977), pp. 200–49Google Scholar.

13 Hilton, , Age of Atonement, pp. 73–114Google Scholar.

14 Bebbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in Modern Britain (London, 1989), pp. 211–14Google Scholar; White, R. C., Jr. and Hopkins, C. H., The Social Gospel: Religion and Reform in Changing America (Philadelphia, 1976), pp. xvi—xviiGoogle Scholar; Dorn, J. H., Washington Gladden: Prophet of the Social Gospel (Ohio, 1966), pp. 182–6Google Scholar.

15 Hooft, W. A. Visser’t, The Background of the Social Gospel in America (Haarlem, 1928), p. 14Google Scholar; White, and Hopkins, , Social Gospel, pp. 150–2, 167Google Scholar; Hutchison, W. R., ‘The Americanness of the Social Gospel: an inquiry in Comparative History’, ChH, 44 (1975), pp. 367–81Google Scholar; Mann, A., ‘British Social Thought and American Reformers of the Progressive Era’, Mississippi Valley Historical Review, 42 (1955-6), pp. 672–92Google Scholar.

16 Marx, K. and Engels, F., ‘Manifesto of the Communist Party’, in Selected Works (Moscow, 1962), 1, p. 62Google Scholar.

17 Keeble, S.E., Industrial Day-Dreams (London, 1896), pp. 62–3Google Scholar.

18 Westcott, B. F., Social Aspects of Christianity (London, 1887), pp. 96, vGoogle Scholar.

19 Coupland, W. C., Aurora Leigh, South Place Religious Society Discourses no 17 (London, 1887), p. 101Google Scholar.

20 Clifford, J., ‘The New City of God’, Baptist Handbook (1889), pp. 66–95Google Scholar; see also Thompson, D. M., ‘John Clifford’s Social Gospel’, BQ, 31 (1986), pp. 199—217Google Scholar.

21 Bebbington, , Nonconformist Conscience, p. 85Google Scholar.

22 [ Draper, W. H.], Recollections of Dean Fremantle (London, 1921), pp. 101–2Google Scholar; Edwards, M. L., S. E. Keeble (London, 1949), p. 26Google Scholar.

23 Paton, J. L., John Brown Paton: A Biography (London, 1914), pp. 67–71Google Scholar; Marchant, J., J. B. Paton (London, 1909), pp. 47–8Google Scholar; Dale, A. W. W., Life of R. W. Dale of Birmingham (London, 1905), pp. 125–8Google Scholar.

24 Paton, , J. B. Paton, p. 175Google Scholar.

25 Review of Reviews, American edn., 3 (1891), p. 510, quoted in Houghton, W. S., ed., Wellesley Index to Victorian Periodicals, 1824–1900, 1 (Toronto, 1966), p. 212Google Scholar. For Bunting, see DNB, 2nd Supplement, li, pp. 256–7; Bebbington, , Nonconformist Conscience, pp. 44–5,64–5Google Scholar.

26 Paton, , J. B. Paton, pp. 174–7Google Scholar; Marchant, , J. B. Paton, pp. 268–71Google Scholar; Wellesley Index, li, pp. 210–13.

27 Dale, R. W., ‘Mr Bright’, Cont. Rev., 55 (1889), pp. 646–7Google Scholar.

28 Dale, , ‘Mr Bright’, Conl. Rev., 55 (1889), pp. 647–8Google Scholar.

29 Harrison, F., ‘Leon Gambetta:a Positivist Discourse’, Cont. Rev., 43 (1883), p. 311Google Scholar.

30 Dale, R. W., ‘M. Gambetta: Positivism and Christianity’, Cont. Rev., 43 (1883), pp. 476, 490, 493Google Scholar.

31 Ibid., p. 494.

32 Dale, Life of Dale, pp. 325, 707; Dale, R. W., Christian Doctrine (London, 1894), pp. 213, 215–17Google Scholar; The Atonement (London, 1897), pp. 410–40.

33 Fairbairn, A. M., ‘Experience in Theology: A Chapter of Autobiography’, Cont. Rev., 91 (1907), pp. 568–8Google Scholar; quoted in Selbie, W. B., Life of Andrew Martin Fairbairn (London, 1914), pp. 40–1Google Scholar.

34 Jubilee Lectures (London, 1882), 1, p. xix. This introductory chapter was subsequently expanded by Fairbairn as chapters 4–6 of Studies in Religion and Theology (London, 1910).

35 Ibid., 1, pp. xxvi-xxvii.

36 Fairbairn, A. M., ‘The churches and the ideal of religion’, Cont. Rev., 45 (1884), pp. 368–9Google Scholar; Fairbairn, , Studies in Religion, pp. 132–4Google Scholar.

37 Fairbairn, A. M., The Place of Christ in Modern Theology (London, 1894), pp. 516–17Google Scholar.

38 Fairbairn, , Studies in Religion, pp. 99–100Google Scholar.

39 Quoted in Selbie, Life of Fairbairn, pp. 143–4.

40 Fairbairn, , ‘The churches and the ideal of religion’, pp. 354–5, 375–6Google Scholar.

41 Selbie, , Life of Fairbairn, pp. 297–304Google Scholar.

42 Marchant, J., Dr John Clifford (London, 1924), pp. 59, 83–4Google Scholar; Handy, R. T., ed., The Social Gospel in America, 1870–1920 (New York, 1966), p. 102Google Scholar; Gladden, W., Recollections (London, 1909), pp. 323–4, 357Google Scholar; Gladden, W., Tools and the Man (London, [1893]), p. iiiGoogle Scholar.

43 Ward, , Theology, Sociology and Politics, p. 26Google Scholar.

44 Paton, J. B., The Inner Mission (London, 1888), pp. 26–7Google Scholar.

45 Ibid., pp. 51, 61; see also Paton, , J. B. Paton, p. 338Google Scholar.

46 See Welch, C., Protestant Thought in the Nineteenth Century, i, 1799–1870 (New Haven, 1972), pp. 194–6, 218–19, 274–82Google Scholar.

47 Mill, J. S., ‘Auguste Comte and Positivism’, in Priestley, F. E. L. and Robson, J. M., eds, Essays on Ethics, Religion and Society (London, 1969), pp. 300, 321Google Scholar.

48 Webb, R. K., Harriet Martineau: A Radical Victorian (London, 1960), p. 308CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

49 Westcott, , Social Aspects,> p. vii+p.+vii>Google Scholar.

50 Ibid., p. xii; see also Vidler, A. R., F. D. Maurice and Company (London, 1966), pp. 272–4Google Scholar.

51 Westcott, B. F., The Gospel of the Resurrection, 5th edn. (London, 1884), pp. 250–1, 253–4, 263, 266–7, 272Google Scholar.

52 Westcott, A., Life and Letters of Brooke Foss Westcott (London, 1903), 1, pp. 43, 71, 75, 78Google Scholar.

53 Dale, R. W., Christ and the Controversies of Christendom (London, 1869), pp. 18–19Google Scholar, quoted in Dale, Life of Dale, p. 233.

54 Fairbairn, A. M., Studies in the Philosophy of Religion and History (London, 1876), pp. 1–57Google Scholar.

55 Clifford, J., Jesus Christ and Modern Social Life (Leicester, 1872), pp. 20–6, 29Google Scholar.

56 Caird, E., ‘The social philosophy and religion of Comte 11’, Cont. Rev., 25 (1879), p. 533Google Scholar.

57 Caird, , ‘Social Philosophy IV’, Cont. Rev., 26 (1879), p. 80Google Scholar.

58 Paton, , Inner Mission, pp. 112–14Google Scholar.

59 Fairbairn, , Studies in Religion, p. 99Google Scholar.

60 Fairbairn, , ‘The Churches and the Ideal of Religion’, p. 377Google Scholar.

61 Harrison, F., Politics and a Human Religion, South Place Religious Society Discourses, no. 4 (London, 1885), p. 2Google Scholar.

62 Harrison, F., “The radical programme’, Cont. Rev., 49 (1886), p. 265Google Scholar.

63 Hughes, H. P., Social Christianity (London, 1889), pp. xi–xiiGoogle Scholar.

64 Ibid., p. xii.

65 Dale, R. W., The Laws of Christ for Common Life (London, [1884]), pp. 267–8Google Scholar.

66 Bebbington, , Nonconformist Conscience, pp. 38–53Google Scholar.

67 Hughes, , Social Christianity, pp. 139–41Google Scholar.

68 Paton, , J. B. Paton, pp. 377–8Google Scholar; Paton, J.B., The Inner Mission of Great Britain (London, 1895), p. 6Google Scholar.

69 Nelson, Earl, ‘Christian Union’, Cont. Rev., 55 (1889), pp. 281–2Google Scholar.

70 Paget, S., ed., Henry Scott Holland (London, 1921), pp. 170–1, 243Google Scholar.

71 Paton, , J. B. Paton, pp. 437–46Google Scholar.

72 Ibid., pp. 190, 488–93; see also Jordan, E. K. H., Free Church Unity (London, 1956), p. 25Google Scholar; Bebbington, , Nonconformist Conscience, p. 63Google Scholar.

73 Paton, , Inner Mission of Great Britain, p. 12Google Scholar.

74 Ibid., pp. 16–17.

75 Dale, , Laws of Christ for Common Life, pp. 187–8Google Scholar.

76 Ibid., p. 204.

77 Clifford, J., ‘Religion and the State’, Cont. Rev., 67 (1895), p. 435Google Scholar.

78 Ibid., p. 436.

79 Clifford, , ‘Religion and the State’, Cont. Rev., 67 (1895), pp. 437, 438, 439, 442Google Scholar.

80 Fremantle, W. H., ‘Dr Clifford on Religion and the State’, Cont. Rev., 67 (1895), pp. 715–16Google Scholar.

81 Ibid., pp. 716, 720.

82 Horton, R. F., An Autobiography (London, 1917), pp. 63, 81–3Google Scholar; Peel, A. and Marriott, J. A. R., Robert Forman Horton (London, 1937), p. 155Google Scholar.

83 Powicke, F.J., ‘Frederick Denison Maurice (1805-1982): A Personal Reminiscence’, Congregational Quarterly, 8 (1930), pp. 169–84Google Scholar.

84 A Nonconformist Minister, Nonconformity and Politics (London, 1909), pp. 177–85, 198–220 (the quotation is on p. 220); see also Bebbington, , Nonconformist Conscience, pp. 157–8Google Scholar.