Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-r5zm4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-22T13:01:45.925Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Titian’s Christ with the Coin: Recovering the Spiritual Currency of Numismatics in Renaissance Ferrara

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Christopher J. Nygren
Christopher J. Nygren*
Affiliation:
University of Pittsburgh
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Titian painted Christ with the Coin for Alfonso d’Este around 1516. The painting served as the cover piece for a collection of ancient coins and has been read as a commentary on politics and taxation. Instead, this article reveals how the painting reconfigured Alfonso’s interaction with ancient coins, transforming the everyday activity of the collector into an occasion of spiritual reformation. Reading numismatic antiquarianism against the exegetical tradition that accrued around the Gospel pericope (Matthew 22:21) reveals the painting as the nexus of two regimes of virtue — one Christian, one classical — both of which turn upon coins as manifold objects.

Type
Research Article
Information
Renaissance Quarterly , Volume 69 , Issue 2 , Summer 2016 , pp. 449 - 488
Copyright
Copyright © 2016 Renaissance Society of America

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aquinas, Thomas Super Evangelium Matthaei lectura. Ed. Raffaele Cai. Turin, 1951.Google Scholar
Aquinas, Thomas Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected Out of the Works of the Fathers. Ed. John Henry Newman. 2 vols. Boonville, 2009.Google Scholar
Augustine. Opera Omnia. Vols. 32–46 of Patrologia Latina. Ed. J. P. Migne. Paris, 1841–42.Google Scholar
Augustine. Lectures or Tractates on the Gospel According to St. John in Two Volumes. Trans. James Innes. Edinburgh, 1874.Google Scholar
Baader, Hannah “Francesco Petrarca: Das Portät, der Ruhm und die Geschichte. Exempla virtutis (1355).” In Porträt, ed. Hannah Baader, Rudolf Preimesberger, and Nicola Suthor, 189–94. Berlin, 1999.Google Scholar
Baxandall, Michael “A Dialogue on Art from the Court of Leonello d’Este: Angelo Decembrio’s De politia litteraria pars LXVIII.” Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 26.3/4 (1963): 304–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bedos-Rezak, Brigitte Miriam. When Ego Was Imago: Signs of Identity in the Middle Ages. Leiden, 2011.Google Scholar
Bembo, Pietro Opere in Volgare. Florence, 1961.Google Scholar
Bentley, Jerry H. Humanists and Holy Writ: New Testament Scholarship in the Renaissance. Princeton, 1983.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bestor, Jane Fair “Bastardy and Legitimacy in the Formation of a Regional State in Italy: The Estense Succession.” Comparative Studies in Society and History 38.3 (1996): 549–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bibliorum Sacrorum Glossa Ordinaria. 6 vols. Venice, 1603.Google Scholar
Biffis, Mattia “Rendere a Cesare: Riflessioni sul tema della sovranità nel Tributo di Londra.” Venezia cinquecento 18/35 (2008): 155–73.Google Scholar
Boeft, Jan den “Erasmus and the Church Fathers.” In The Reception of the Church Fathers (1997), 537–72.Google Scholar
Bullard, Melissa Meriam “Possessing Antiquity: Agency and Sociability in Building Lorenzo de’ Medici’s Gem Collection.” In Humanism and Creativity in the Renaissance: Essays in Honor of Ronald G. Witt, ed. Christopher S. Celenza and Kenneth Gouwens, 85–111. Leiden, 2006.Google Scholar
Campbell, Stephen J. The Cabinet of Eros: Renaissance Mythological Painting and the Studiolo of Isabella d’Este. New Haven, 2006.Google Scholar
Campori, Giuseppe “Tiziano e gli estensi.” Nuova Antologia 27 (1874): 581–620.Google Scholar
Carli, Enzo Les Miniatures de Liberale da Verona. Milan, 1960.Google Scholar
Carter, Edward J. “Toll and Tribute: A Political Reading of Matthew 17:24–27.” Journal for the Study of the New Testament 25.4 (2003): 413–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carter, Warren “Paying the Tax to Rome as Subversive Praxis: Matthew 17:24–27.” Journal for the Study of the New Testament 22.76 (2000): 3–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cassidy, Richard “Matthew 17:24–27 — A Word on Civil Taxes.” Catholic Biblical Quarterly 41 (1979): 571–80.Google Scholar
Cavedoni, C. “Delle antiche monete in oro un tempo nel Museo Estense descritte da Celio Calcagnini intorno all’anno MDXL.” In Memorie della R. Accademia di Scienze, Letter e Arti di Modena 1 (1825): 3–38.Google Scholar
Celenza, Christopher S. Piety and Pythagoras in Renaissance Florence: The Symbolum Nesianum. Leiden, 2001.Google Scholar
Cherry, John “Healing through Faith: The Continuation of Medieval Attitudes to Jewellery into the Renaissance.” Renaissance Studies 15.2 (2001): 154–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cittadella, Luigi Napoleone Documenti ed illustrazioni riguardanti la storia artistica ferrarese. Ferrara, 1868.Google Scholar
Codice topografico della città di Roma. Ed. Roberto Valentini and Giuseppe Zucchetti. 4 vols. Rome, 1940–1953.Google Scholar
Cole, Michael “The Figura Sforzata: Modelling, Power and the Mannerist Body.” Art History 24 (2001): 520–51.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Corradini, Elena “Medallic Portraits of the Este: Effigies ad vivum expressae.” In The Image of the Individual (1998), 22–39.Google Scholar
Cranston, Jodi “Desire and Gravitas in Bindo’s Portraits.” In Raphael, Cellini and a Renaissance Banker, ed. Alan Chong, Donatella Pegazzano, and Dimitrios Zikos, 115–31. Boston, 2003.Google Scholar
Crowe, J. A., and G. B. Cavalcaselle. Titian: His Life and Times. With Some Account of His Family, Chiefly from New and Unpublished Records. 2 vols. London, 1881.Google Scholar
Cunnally, John Images of the Illustrious: The Numismatic Presence in the Renaissance. Princeton, 1999.Google Scholar
Cunnally, John “Of Mauss and (Renaissance) Men: Numismatics, Presentation, and the Genesis of Visual Literacy.” In The Rebirth of Antiquity: Numismatics, Archaeology, and Classical Studies in the Culture of the Renaissance, ed. Alan M. Stahl, 27–47. Princeton, 2009.Google Scholar
Cusanus, Nicholas De Ludo Globi — The Game of Spheres. Trans. Pauline Moffitt Watts. New York, 1986.Google Scholar
Dean, Trevor “Court and Household in Ferrara, 1494.” In The French Descent into Renaissance Italy, 1494–5: Antecedents and Effects, ed. David Abulafia, 165–87. Brookfield, 1995.Google Scholar
Devotio Moderna: Basic Writings. Ed. and trans. John van Engen. New York, 1988.Google Scholar
Dunkerton, Jill, Foister, Susan, and Penny, Nicholas. Dürer to Veronese: Sixteenth-Century Painting in the National Gallery. New Haven, 1999.Google Scholar
Einem, Herbert von Masaccios “Zinsgroschen.” Cologne, 1967.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Erasmus of Rotterdam. Opera Omnia. 10 vols. Leiden, 1703–06.Google Scholar
Erasmus of Rotterdam. Opera Omnia Desiderii Erasmi Roterodami: Recognita et Adnotatione Critica Instructa Notisque Illustrata. Ed. P. F. Hovingh. 9 vols. Amsterdam, 1969–.Google Scholar
Erasmus of Rotterdam. The Essential Erasmus. Trans. John P. Dolan. New York, 1983.Google Scholar
Erasmus of Rotterdam. The Collected Works of Erasmus, Volume 49: Paraphrase on Mark. Trans. Erika Rummel. Toronto, 1988.Google Scholar
Erasmus of Rotterdam. “Sileni Alcibiadis.” In The Catholic Reformation: Savonarola to Ignatius of Loyola, ed. John C. Olin, 71–89. New York, 1992.Google Scholar
Erasmus of Rotterdam. Collected Works of Erasmus, Volume 11: Letters 1535 to 1657, January–December 1525. Trans. Alexander Dalzell. Toronto, 1994.Google Scholar
Eschmann, I. T. “St. Thomas Aquinas on the Two Powers.” Mediaeval Studies 20 (1958): 177–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Farinella, Vincenzo Alfonso I d’Este: Le immagini e il potere. Milan, 2014.Google Scholar
Ficino, Marsilio Opera. 2 vols. Basel, 1561.Google Scholar
Fiorenza, Giancarlo “Hebrew, Hieroglyphs, and the Secrets of Divine Wisdom in Ludovico Mazzolino’s Devotional Paintings.” In Visual Cultures of Secrecy in Early Modern Europe, ed. Timothy McCall, Sean Roberts, and Giancarlo Fiorenza, 126–48. Kirksville, 2013.Google Scholar
Flavio, Biondo Scritti inediti e rari di Flavio Biondo. Ed. Bartolomeo Nogara. Rome, 1927.Google Scholar
Fontana, Federica Missere Testimoni parlanti: Le monete antiche a Roma tra Cinquecento e Seicento. Rome, 2009.Google Scholar
Fulgentius, Fabius Planciades Opera Quae Sunt Publici Juris Omnia. Venice, 1742.Google Scholar
Fulvio, Andrea Illvstrivm Imagines: Imperatorum, et Illustrium Virorum, ac Mulierum Vultus ex Antiquis Numismatibus Expressi. Rome, 1517.Google Scholar
Gentili, Augusto Tiziano. Milan, 2012.Google Scholar
Giardino de oratione fructose. Venice, 1496.Google Scholar
Gilbert, Creighton E. “Some Findings on Early Works of Titian.” Art Bulletin 62.1 (1980): 36–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grande dizionario della lingua italiana. Salvatore Battaglia. 21 vols. Turin, 1975.Google Scholar
Gronau, Georg “Alfonso d’Este und Tizian.” Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien 2 (1928): 233–46.Google Scholar
Hadot, Pierre Philosophy as a Way of Life. Ed. Arnold I. Davideson. Trans. Michael Chase. Oxford, 1995.Google Scholar
Hamburger, Jeffrey F. St. John the Divine: The Deified Evangelist in Medieval Art and Theology. Berkeley, 2002.Google Scholar
Hampton, Timothy Writing from History: The Rhetoric of Exemplarity in Renaissance Literature. Ithaca, 1990.Google Scholar
Hankins, James Plato in the Italian Renaissance. Second Impression with Addenda and Corrigenda. 2 vols. Leiden, 1991.Google Scholar
Hart, H., SJ. “The Coin of ‘Render unto Caesar . . .’ (A Note on Some Aspects of Mark 12:13–17; Matt. 22: 15–22; Luke 20: 20–26).” In Jesus and the Politics of His Day (1984), 241–48.Google Scholar
Haskell, Francis History and Its Images: Art and the Interpretation of the Past. New Haven, 1993.Google Scholar
Helas, Philine “Lo ‘smeraldo’ smarrito, ossia il ‘vero profilo’ di Cristo.” In Il volto di Cristo, ed. Giovanni Morello and Gerhard Wolf, 215–26. Milan, 2000.Google Scholar
Helas, Philine “Il Redentore di Tiziano e l’invenzione di un ritratto storico del Salvatore.” In L’immagine di Cristo dall’acheropita alla mano d’artista: Dal tardo medioevo all’eta barocca, ed. Christoph L. Frommel and Gerhard Wolf, 341–73. Vatican City, 2006.Google Scholar
Holmes, Megan “The Carmelites of Santa Maria del Carmine and the Currency of Miracles.” In The Brancacci Chapel: Form, Function, and Setting, ed. Nicholas A. Eckstein, 157–75. Florence, 2007.Google Scholar
Homiliarius Doctorum in Evangelia Dominicalia de Tempore et de Sanctis per Anni Cursum. Basel, 1506.Google Scholar
Hood, William, and Hope, Charles. “Titian’s Vatican Altarpiece and the Pictures Underneath.” Art Bulletin 59.4 (Dec. 1977): 534–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hope, Charles, and Jaffe, David, eds. Titian. London, 2003.Google Scholar
Horbury, W. “The Temple Tax.” In Jesus and the Politics of His Day (1984), 265–86.Google Scholar
Humfrey, Peter Titian: The Complete Paintings. New York, 2007.Google Scholar
The Image of the Individual: Portraits in the Renaissance. Ed. Nicholas Mann and Luke Syson. London, 1998.Google Scholar
Jardine, Lisa Goods: A New History of the Renaissance. London, 1997.Google Scholar
Jerome. Opera Omnia. Vols. 22–30 of Patrologia Latina. Ed. J. P. Migne. Paris, 1845.Google Scholar
Jesus and the Politics of His Day. Ed. Ernst Bammel and C. F. D. Moule. Cambridge, 1984.Google Scholar
Joannides, Paul Masaccio and Masolino: A Complete Catalogue. New York, 1993.Google Scholar
Joannides, Paul Titian to 1518: The Assumption of Genius. New Haven, 2001.Google Scholar
Josephus. The Jewish Wars. Trans. H. St. J. Thackeray. 9 vols. Cambridge, MA, 1961.Google Scholar
Martyr, Justin. Justin, Philosopher and Martyr: Apologies. Ed. and trans. Denis Minns and Paul Parvis. Oxford, 2009.Google Scholar
Kantorowicz, Ernst H. The Kings Two Bodies: A Study in Mediaeval Political Theology. Princeton, 1957.Google Scholar
Ladner, Gerhart B. The Idea of Reform: Its Impact on Christian Thought and Action in the Age of the Fathers. New York, 1967.Google Scholar
Lemburg-Ruppelt, Edith. “Der systematische Ausbau der Numismatik in Werk Enea Vicos (1523–1567).” In Wissenschaftsgeschichte der Numismatik. Beiträg zum XVII Deutschen Numismatikertag 3–5 märz 1995 in Hannover, ed. Albert Rainer, 45–70. Speyer, 1995.Google Scholar
Lettere storiche di Luigi da Porto dall’anno 1509 al 1528. Ed. Bartolommeo Bressan. Florence, 1857.Google Scholar
Lexikon der christlichen Ikonographie. Ed. Engelbert Kirschbaum (vols. 1–4) and Wolfgang Braunfels (vols. 5–8). 8 vols. Rome, 1968–76.Google Scholar
Ludolphus de Saxonia. Vita Jesu Christi ex Evangelio et Approbatis ab Ecclesia Catholica Doctoribus Sedule Collecta. Ed. L. M. Rigollot. 3 vols. Paris, 1878.Google Scholar
Luther, Martin “Concerning Governmental Authority.” In The Protestant Reformation, ed. Hans J. Hillerbrand, 73–92. New York, 2009.Google Scholar
Luz, Ulrich Matthew: A Commentary (Hermeneia: A Critical and Historical Commentary on the Bible). Trans. James E. Crouch. 3 vols. Minneapolis, 2005.Google Scholar
Lyons, John D. Exemplum: The Rhetoric of Example in Early Modern France and Italy. Princeton, 1990.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mann, Nicholas “Petrarch and Portraits.” In The Image of the Individual (1998), 15–20.Google Scholar
Marsilius of Padua. The Defender of Peace: The Defensor Pacis. Trans. Alan Gewirth. New York, 1967.Google Scholar
Matter, E. Ann. “The Church Fathers and the Glossa ordinaria.” In The Reception of the Church Fathers in the West (1997), 83–111.Google Scholar
Meller, Peter “Cappella Brancacci, problemi ritrattistici e iconografici.” Acropoli 1 (1961): 273–312.Google Scholar
Merback, Mitchell B. “The Man of Sorrows in Northern Europe: Ritual Metaphor and Therapeutic Exchange.” In New Perspectives on the Man of Sorrows, ed. Catherine Pulglisi and William L. Barcham, 77–116. Kalamazoo, 2013.Google Scholar
Mohlo, Anthony “The Brancacci Chapel: Studies in Its Iconography and History.” Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 40 (1977): 50–98.Google Scholar
Nagel, Alexander, and Wood, Christopher. Anachronic Renaissance. New York, 2010.Google Scholar
The New Catholic Encyclopedia. Ed. Thomas Carson and Joann Cerrito. 15 vols. Detroit, 2003.Google Scholar
Nygren, Christopher J. “Stylizing Eros: Narrative Ambiguity and the Discourse of Desire in Titian’s So-Called Salome.” In Renaissance Love: Eros, Passion, and Friendship in Italian Art around 1500, ed. Jeanette Kohl, Marianne Koos, and Adrian Randolph, 23–44. Berlin, 2014.Google Scholar
Origen. Homilies on Luke and Fragments on Luke. Trans. Joseph T. Lienhard. Washington, DC, 1996.Google Scholar
Ozment, Steven The Age of Reform, 1250–1550: An Intellectual and Religious History of Late Medieval and Reformation Europe. New Haven, 1980.Google Scholar
Paleotti, Gabriele Discourse on Sacred and Profane Images. Trans. William McCuaig. Los Angeles, 2012.Google Scholar
Petrarca, Francesco Le Familiari. Edizione critica. Ed. Vittorio Rossi. 4 vols. Florence, 1937.Google Scholar
Petrarca, Francesco Letters on Familiar Matters. Rerum Familiarum Libri. Trans. Aldo S. Bernardo. 3 vols. Baltimore, 1985.Google Scholar
Pfisterer, Ulrich Lysippus und seine Freunde: Liebesgaben und Gedächtnis im Rom der Renaissance oder: Das erste Jahrhundert der Medaille. Berlin, 2008.Google Scholar
Pietro Bembo e l’invenzione del Rinascimento. Ed. Guido Beltramini, Davide Gasparotto, and Adolfo Tura. Venice, 2013.Google Scholar
Pollard, J. Graham. “Il medagliere mediceo.” In Gli Uffizi: Quattro secoli di una galleria; atti del Convegno internazionale di studi (Firenze 20–24 settembre 1982), ed. Paola Barocchi and Giovanna Ragionieri, 271–86. Florence, 1983.Google Scholar
Pollard, J. Graham. “The Italian Renaissance Medal: Collecting and Connoisseurship.” In Italian Medals: Studies in the History of Art, Volume 21 (Center For Advanced Study in The Visual Arts), ed. J. Graham Pollard, 161–70. Hanover, 1987.Google Scholar
Preimesberger, Rudolf “‘[…] und es sahe der achtsame Mann, das Angesicht des Gottes genau’: Ein Augenzeuge namens Lentulus in van Dycks ‘Zinsgroschen.’” In Geschichte und Ästhetik: Festschrift für Werner Busch zum 60. Geburtstag, ed. Margit Kern, Thomas Kirchner, and Hubertus Kohle, 68–88. Munich, 2004.Google Scholar
Raccolta di cataloghi ed inventarii inediti di quadri, statue, disegni, bronzi, dorerie, smalti, medaglie, avorii, ecc. dal secolo XV al secolo XIX. Ed. Giuseppe Campori. Modena, 1870.Google Scholar
The Reception of the Church Fathers in the West: From the Carolingians to the Maurists. Ed. Irena Backus. Leiden, 1997.Google Scholar
Rice, Eugene F Jr. “The Renaissance Idea of Christian Antiquity: Humanist Patristic Scholarship.” In Renaissance Humanism: Foundations, Forms and Legacy, ed. Albert Rabil Jr., 17–28. Philadelphia, 1988.Google Scholar
Robichaud, Denis J.-J. “Marsilio Ficino’s De vita Platonis, Apologia de moribus Platonis. Against the Poetasters and Cynics: Aristippus, Lucian, Cerberus, and Other Dogs.” Accademia. Revue de la Societe Marsile Ficin 8 (2006): 23–59.Google Scholar
Rosati, Franco Pavini “Le collezioni numismatiche.” In Museo perché. Museo come. Saggi sul museo, ed. Pietro Romanelli, 119–30. Rome, 1980.Google Scholar
Rosenberg, 1998 Rosenberg, Charles M. “Money Talks: Numismatic Propaganda under Alfonso I d’Este.” In L’età di Alfonoso I e la pittura del Dosso. Atti del convegno internazionale di Studi, Ferrara, Palazzina di Marfisa d’Este, 9–12 December 1998, ed. Angela Ghinato, 145–64. Modena, 2004.Google Scholar
Roskill, Mark Dolce’s Aretino and Venetian Art Theory of the Cinquecento. Toronto, 2000.Google Scholar
Salort-Pons, Salvador. “Titian’s The Tribute Money and Las Descalzas Reales.” In L’arte del dono: Scambi artistic e diplomazia tra Italia e Spagna, 1550–1650, ed. Marieke Von Bernstorff and Susanne Kubersky-Piredda, 151–59. Milan, 2013.Google Scholar
Schmitter, Monika “The Display of Distinction: Art Collecting and Social Status in Early Sixteenth-Century Venice.” PhD diss., University of Michigan. Ann Arbor, 1997.Google Scholar
Shepherd, Rupert “A Letter Concerning Coins in Sixteenth-Century Ferrara.” Apollo 149 (1999): 40–43.Google Scholar
Shuger, Debora Kuller The Renaissance Bible: Scholarship, Sacrifice, and Subjectivity. Berkeley, 1994.Google Scholar
Spike, John T. Masaccio. Milan, 1995.Google Scholar
Syson, Luke, and Thornton, Dora. Objects of Virtue: Art in Renaissance Italy. London, 2001.Google Scholar
Tellbe, Mikael “The Temple Tax as a Pre-70 CE Identity Marker.” In The Formation of the Early Church, ed. Jostein Adna, 19–44. Tübingen, 2005.Google Scholar
Tertullian. Opera Omnia. Vols. 1–2 of Patrologia Latina. Ed. J. P. Migne. Paris, 1844.Google Scholar
Tertullian. The Five Books of Quintus Sept. Flor. Tertullianus Against Marcion. Trans. Peter Holmes. Edinburgh, 1868.Google Scholar
Thornton, Dora The Scholar in His Study: Ownership and Experience in Renaissance Italy. New Haven, 1997.Google Scholar
Thornton, Peter The Italian Renaissance Interior, 1400–1600. New York, 1991.Google Scholar
Tierny, Brian The Crisis of Church and State, 1050–1300. Toronto, 1988.Google Scholar
Tracy, James “Liberation through the Philosophia Christi: Erasmus as a Reformer of Doctrina, 1514–1521.” Lutherjahrbuch 62 (1995): 28–47.Google Scholar
Una silloge numismatica del secolo XVI: Celio Calcagnini e la Raccolta Estense. Ed. Gianluigi Missere and Federica Missere Fontana. Modena, 1993.Google Scholar
Valla, Lorenzo De Voluptate. On Pleasure. Trans. A. Kent Hieatt and Maristella Lorch. New York, 1977.Google Scholar
Vasari, Giorgio Le opere di Giorgio Vasari con nuove annotazioni e commenti di Gaetano Milanesi. 9 vols. Florence, 1906.Google Scholar
Venerable Bede. Opera Omnia. Vols. 90–95 of Patrologia Latina. Ed. J. P. Migne. Paris, 1850–51.Google Scholar
Vico, Enea Discorsi di M. Enea Vico Parmigiano sopra le medaglie de gli antichi divisi in due libri. Ove si dimostrano notabili errori di Scrittori antichi, e moderni, intorno alle Historie Romane. Con due tavole, l’una de’Capitoli, l’altra delle cose piu notabili. Venice, 1558.Google Scholar
Weiss, Roberto The Renaissance Discovery of Classical Antiquity. Oxford, 1969.Google Scholar
Wethey, Harold The Paintings of Titian. 3 vols. London, 1969–75.Google Scholar
Wolf, Gerhard Schleier und Spiegel: Traditionen des Christusbildes und die Bildkonzepte der Renaissance. Munich, 2002.Google Scholar
Wood, Christopher S. Forgery, Replica, Fiction: Temporalities of German Renaissance Art. Chicago, 2008.Google Scholar