Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-nmvwc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-05T17:58:12.317Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Bastard Children of Tyranny”: The Ancient Constitution and Fulke Grevilles A Dedication to Sir Philip Sidney*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Peter C. Herman
Peter C. Herman*
Affiliation:
San Diego State University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This essay proposes that Fulke Greville structured A Dedication to Sir Philip Sidney according to the principles of the Ancient Constitution. Greville departs from the standard view of Sidney in the early seventeenth century as a primarily literary figures by constructing his late friend as an avatar of the Ancient Constitution, and views Elizabeth and Essex in the same light. Greville’s redefinition of all three as exemplars of English constitutionalism directly results from the controversies surrounding James’ increasing absolutism. However, the question remains as to why in 1652 a Royalist would publish such a text, and the answer lies in how shifting political circumstances alters the interpretation of texts.

Type
Studies
Information
Renaissance Quarterly , Volume 55 , Issue 3 , Autumn 2002 , pp. 969 - 1004
Copyright
Copyright © Renaissance Society of America 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to Cynthia Bowers, Roger Kuin, Sandra Sherman, Paul J. Voss and Germaine Warkentin for their essential help in writing this essay. I also happily acknowledge my debt to Constance Jordan for gently urging me some years ago to read Pocock's The Ancient Constitution and the Fuedal Law. Her suggestion changed everything.

References

Ashton, Robert. 1982. “From Cavalier to Roundhead Tyranny, 1642-49.” In Reactions to the English Civil War, 1642- 49, ed. John, Morrill. 185–247. London.Google Scholar
Academiae Cantabrigiensis Lachrymae Tumulo Noblilissimi Equitis, D. Philippi Sidneii Sacratae. 1980. In Elegies for Sir Philip Sidney (J587). Ed. Colaianne, A.J. and Godshalk, W L.. Delmar, NY. [No pagination].Google Scholar
Baker-Smith, Dominic. 1986. “'Great Expectations: Sidney's Death and the Poets.” In Sir Philip Sidney, 83-103.Google Scholar
Buchanan, George. 1680. De Jure Regni apud Scotos. Or, A Dialogue, Concerning the due Priviledge of Government in the Kingdom of Scotland. Trans. Philelethes, . London.Google Scholar
Burgess, Glenn. 1992. The Politics of the Ancient Constitution: An Introduction to English Political Thought, 1603- 1642. University Park, PA.10.1007/978-1-349-22263-6Google Scholar
Buxton, John. 1989. “The Mourning for Sidney.” Renaissance Studies 3.1:46–56.10.1111/j.1477-4658.1989.tb00168.xGoogle Scholar
Candido, Joseph. 1985. “Fulke Greville's Biography of Sir Philip Sidney and the Architectonic’ Tudor.” South Central Review 2.1:3–12.10.2307/3189406Google Scholar
“The Great Case of Impositions [Bates' Case].” 1809. In Cobbett's Complete Collection of State Trials, 2:371-82.Google Scholar
“The Case of Proclamations.” 1809. In Cobbett's Complete Collection of State Trials, 2:723-27.Google Scholar
Cartwright, Julia. 1926. Sacharissa: Some Account of Dorothy Sidney, Countess of Sunderland. New York.Google Scholar
Charles, I. 1659. Bibliotheca Regia, or, The Royal Library, Containing a Collection of such of the Papers of His Late Majesty King Charles, the Second Monarch of Great Britain, as Have Escaped the Wrack and Ruines of These Times. London.Google Scholar
Charles, I. 1983. “A Proclamation Prohibiting the Payment and Receipt of Tonnage and Poundage, and Other Impositions Upon Merchandises, under the Colour of the Late Pretended Ordinance of Both Houses of Parliament.“ In Stuart Royal Proclamations. Ed. James F., Larkin, 2:831-33. Oxford.Google Scholar
Cobbett's Complete Collection of State Trials. 1811-26. Ed. Howell, T. B.. London. 22 vols.Google Scholar
Coke, Edward. 1602. Le Second Part des Reportes del Edward Coke. London.Google Scholar
Coke, Edward. 1602. Le Tierce Part des Reportes Del Edward Coke. London.Google Scholar
Coke, Edward. 1604. Le Quart Part des Reportes Del Edward Coke. London.Google Scholar
Coke, Edward. 1605. The Fift part of the Reports of Sr. Edward Coke. London.Google Scholar
Coke, Edward. 1607. La Size Part des Reports. London.Google Scholar
Colclough, David. 1999. “Parrhesia: The Rhetoric of Free Speech in Early Modern England.” Rhetorica 17.2:177– 212.10.1525/rh.1999.17.2.177Google Scholar
A Collection of Scarce and Valuable Tracts…. Selected from … Public, As Well As Private Libraries; Particularly that of the late Lord Somers [Somers Tracts]. 1809-15. Ed. Walter, Scott. 2nd. ed. 13 vols. London.Google Scholar
Collins, Arthur. 1973. Letters and Memorials of State. 2 vols. 1746. Reprint, New York.Google Scholar
Eccleshall, Robert. 1978. Order and Reason in Politics: Theories of Absolute and Limited Monarchy in Early Modern England. Oxford.Google Scholar
Fink, Z. S. 1945. The Classical Republicans: An Essay on the Recovery of a Pattern of Thought in Seventeenth-Century England. Evanston.Google Scholar
Fortescue, Sir John. 1997. In Praise of the Laws of England. In On the Laws and Governance of England. Ed. Lockwood, S., 1–80. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Fryde, E. B. and Edward, Miller. 1970. Historical Studies of the English Parliament. 2 vols. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Gadamer, Hans-George. 1975. Truth and Method. New York.Google Scholar
Gardiner, Samuel R. 1894-96. History of England from the Accession of James I to the Outbreak of the Civil War, 1603- 1642. 10 vols. London.Google Scholar
Greenberg, Janelle. 2001. The Radical Face of the Ancient Constitution: St. Edward's “Laws “ in Early Modern Political Thought. Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511521393Google Scholar
Greville, Fulke. 1652. The Life of Sir Philip Sidney. London.Google Scholar
Greville, Fulke. 1965. The Remains, Being Poems of Monarch and Religion. Ed. Wiles, G. A.. Oxford Google Scholar
Greville, Fulke. 1986. A Dedication to Sir Philip Sidney. In The Prose Works of Fulke Greville, Lord Brooke. Ed. John, Gouws, 3–136. Oxford.Google Scholar
Guy, John. 1992. “'Imperial Crown’ and the Liberty of the Subject: The English Constitution from Magna Carta to the Bill of Rights.” In Court, Country and Culture: Essays on Early Modern British History in Honor of Perez Zagorin. ed. Bonnelyn Y., Kunze and Dwight D., Brautigan, 65–87. Rochester.Google Scholar
Guy, John. 1993. “The Henrician Age.” In The Varieties of British Political Thought, 1500-1800, ed. Pocock, J. G. A., 13–46. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Hamilton, Donna B. 1983. “The State of Law in Richard II.” Shakespeare Quarterly 34:5–17'.10.2307/2870216Google Scholar
Hanson, Donald W. 1970. From Kingdom to Commonwealth: The Development of Civic Consciousness in English Political Thought. Cambridge, MA.10.4159/harvard.9780674182745Google Scholar
Hassall, W.O., ed. 1950. A Catalogue of the Library of Sir Edward Coke. New Haven.Google Scholar
The Historical Renaissance: New Essays on Tudor and Stuart Literature and Culture. 1988. Eds. Heather Dubrow, and Richard, Strier. Chicago.Google Scholar
Helgerson, Richard. 1992. Forms of Nationhood: The Elizabethan Writing of England. Chicago.Google Scholar
Herman, Peter C. 1996. Squitter-wits and Muse-haters: Sidney, Spenser, Milton and Renaissance Antipoetic Sentiment. Detroit Google Scholar
Herman, Peter C. 2000. “Rastell s Pastyme of People: Monarchy and the Law in Early Modern Historiography.” Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 30.2:275–308.10.1215/10829636-30-2-275Google Scholar
Herman, Peter C. 2001. “Authorship and the Royal T: King James VI/I and the Politics of Monarchic Verse.” Renaissance Quarterly 54:1–37.Google Scholar
Herman, Peter C. 2002. “'Best of Poets, Best of Kings': King James VI/I and the Scene of Monarchical Verse.” In Royal Subjects: Essays on the Writings of James VII I, ed. Daniel, Fischlin and Mark, Fortier. 61–103. Detroit.Google Scholar
Hill, Christopher. 1968. Puritanism and Revolution. 1958. Pbk. reprint, New York.Google Scholar
Ho, Elaine Y. L. 1995. “Author and Reader in Renaissance Texts: Fulke Greville, Sidney, and Prince Henry.” Connotations 5.1:34–48.Google Scholar
Howard, Jean E. and Phyllis, Rackin. 1997. Engendering a Nation: A Feminist Account of Shakespeare's English Histories. New York.Google Scholar
Howell, James. 1647. A Letter to the Earle of Pembrooke. London.Google Scholar
James, VI/I. 1918. The True Law of Free Monarchies. In The Political Works of James I. Ed. Charles, McIIwain. Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
James, VI/I. 1986. “A Speech to the Lords and Commons of the Parliament at White- Hall.” In Divine Right and Democracy: An Anthology of Political Writing in Stuart England. Ed. David, Wootton, 107-09. Harmondsworth.Google Scholar
Jenkins, David. 1809. Remonstrance to the Lords and Commons of the Two Houses of Parliament. In Somers Tracts. Vol. 5, 95–108. London.Google Scholar
Jordan, Constance. 1997. Shakespeare's Monarchies; Ruler and Subject in the Romances. Ithaca.Google Scholar
Judson, Margaret A. 1988. The Crisis of the Constitution. 1949. Pbk. reprint, New Brunswick, NJ.Google Scholar
Larson, Charles. 1980. Fulke Greville. Boston.Google Scholar
Laud, William. 1977. “A Paper Concerning the Subsidies given in Divers Parliaments.“ In The Works. Ed. James, Bliss, 627-28. New York.Google Scholar
MacLean, Hugh N. 1952-53. “Fulke Greville: Kingship and Sovereignty.“ Huntington Library Quarterly 16.3:237-71.10.2307/3816145Google Scholar
Maitland, F. W. 1926. The Constitutional History of England. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Marotti, Arthur F. 1995. Manuscript, Print, and The English Renaissance Lyric. Ithaca.Google Scholar
Martin, Christopher. 1986. “Between Duty and Selfness: Greville s Life of Sidney.“ Mid-Hudson Language Studies 9:19- 29.Google Scholar
Matz, Robert. 2000. Defending Literature in Early Modern England: Renaissance Literary Theory in Social Context. Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511483776Google Scholar
McCrea, Adriana. 1995. “Whose Life is It, Anyway?: Subject and Subjection in Fulke Greville's Life of Sidney.” In The Rhetorics of Life-Writing in Early Modern Europe: Forms of Biography from Cassandra Fedele to Louis IV, ed. Thomas F., Mayer and Woolf, D. R., 199– 220. Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
McDonald, Russ. 1996. The Bedford Companion to Shakespeare. New York.10.1007/978-1-349-13753-4Google Scholar
Mcllwain, Charles H. 1940. Constitutionalism Ancient and Modern. Ithaca.Google Scholar
Neale, J. E. 1970a. “The Commons’ Privilege of Free Speech in Parliament.” In Fryde and Miller, 2.147-76.Google Scholar
Neale, J. E. 1970b. “Peter Wentworth.” In Fryde and Miller, 2.246-95.Google Scholar
Pask, Kevin. 1996. The Emergence of the English Author: Scripting the Life of the Poet in Early Modern England. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Patterson, Annabel. 1994. Reading “Holinshed's Chronicles. “ Chicago.Google Scholar
Peltonen, Marku. 1995. Classical Humanism and Republicanism in English Political Thought 1570-1640. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Pocock, J. G. A. 1957. The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law: English Historical Thought in the Seventeenth Century. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Pollard, A.W. and Redgrave, G.R., comps., eds. 1976-91. A Short-Title Catalogue of Books Printed in England, Scotland, and Ireland and of English Books Printed Abroad, 1475-1640. 2nd ed., revised and corrected. 3 vols. London.Google Scholar
Prescott, Anne Lake. 1989. “King David as a ‘Right Poet': Sidney and the Psalmist.“ English Literary Renaissance 19:131-51.10.1111/j.1475-6757.1989.tb00973.xGoogle Scholar
Proceedings in Parliament 1610. 1966. Ed. Elizabeth Read, Foster. 2 vols. New Haven.Google Scholar
Proceedings in the Parliaments of Elizabeth I: 1558-1581. 1981. Ed. Hartley, T. E.. 2 vols. Wilmington, DE.Google Scholar
Prynne, William. 1649. A Brief Memento To the Present Unparliamentary Juncto. London.Google Scholar
Prynne, William. 1809. The Case of the Old Secured, Secluded and Now Excluded Mem bers, briefly and truly Stated (1660). In Somers Tracts, 6:544-50. London.Google Scholar
Quilligan, Maureen. 1988. “Sidney and His Queen.” In Historical Renaissance, 171-96.Google Scholar
Rebholz, Ronald A. 1971. TheLifeofFulke Greville, First Lord Brooke. Oxford.Google Scholar
Rees, Joan. 1971. Fulke Greville, Lord Brooke, 1554-1628: A Critical Biography. Berkeley.Google Scholar
Salmon, J. H. M. 1991. “Catholic Resistance Theory, Ultramontainism, and the Royalist Response, 1580-1620.“ In The Cambridge History of Political Thought: 1450-1700, ed. Burns, J. H. with the assistance of Mark, Goldie, 219-53. Cambridge.10.1017/CHOL9780521247160.010Google Scholar
Scott, Jonathan. 1988. Algernon Sidney and the English Republic, 1623-1677. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Shuger, Debora. 1998. “Castigating Livy: The Rape of Lucretia and the Old Arcadia.“ Renaissance Quarterly 51.2:526-48.10.2307/2901576Google Scholar
Sidney, Sir Philip. 1973. Miscellaneous Prose of Sir Philip Sidney. Ed. Katherine, Duncan-Jones and Jan van, Dorsten. Oxford.10.1093/actrade/9780198118800.book.1Google Scholar
Sidney: The Critical Heritage. 1996. Ed. Martin, Garrett. New York.Google Scholar
Sir Philip Sidney: 1586 and the Creation of a Legend. 1986. Eds. Jan Van, Dorsten, et al. Leiden.Google Scholar
Skretkowicz, Victor. 1986. “Building Sidney's Reputation: Texts and Editors of the Arcadia.” In Sir Philip Sidney, 111-24.Google Scholar
Somers Tracts: See Collection. Google Scholar
Sommerville, Johann. 1986. Politics and Ideology in England, 1603-1640. London.Google Scholar
Sommerville, Johann. 1989. “Ideology, Property and the Constitution.” In Conflict in Early Stuart England: Studies in Religion and Politics 1603-1649, ed. Richard, Cust and Ann, Hughes. London, 47–71.Google Scholar
State Trials: see Cobbett's Complete Collection. Google Scholar
Strier, Richard. 1988. “Faithful Servants: Shakespeare's Praise of Disobedience.“ In Historical Renaissance, 104-32.Google Scholar
Thompson, Christopher. 1997. “The Reaction of the House of Commons in November and December 1621 to the Confinement of Sir Edwin Sandys.“ The Historical Journal 403:779-86.10.1017/S0018246X97007413Google Scholar
Vindiciae Contra Tyrannos. 1969. In Constitutionalism and Resistance in the Sixteenth Century. Trans, and ed. Julian, H. Franklin, , 142-99. Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Walker, Clement. 1648. Relations and Observations Historical and Politick, Upon the Parliament, begun Anno Dom. 1640. Dividing into II. Bookes: 1. The Mystery of the Two Juntoʼs … . London.Google Scholar
Warkentin, Germaine. 1998. “The World and the Book at Penshurst: The Second Earl of Leicester (1595-1677) and his Library.” The Library 20.4:325-46.10.1093/library/20.4.325Google Scholar
Whetstone, George. 1587. The Life, Death, and Vertues of Sir Phillip Sidney Knight. London.Google Scholar
Willson, David. H. 1956. King James VI and I. London.Google Scholar
Wing, Donald. 1982-98. Short-Title Catalogue of Books Printed in England, Scotland, Ireland, Wales, and British America, and of English books Printed in Other Countries, 1641-1700. 4 vols. New York.Google Scholar
Wooden, Warren H. 1983. “The Rhetorical Design of Fulke Greville's Life of Sidney.” Proceedings of the PMR Conference 8:109-18.Google Scholar
Wbrden, Blair. 1996. The Sound of Virtue: Philip Sidney's “Arcadia” and Elizabethan Politics. New Haven.Google Scholar
Woudhuysen, H. R. 1996. Sir Philip Sidney and the Circulation of Manuscripts 1558-1640. Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198129660.001.0001Google Scholar