Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Potential Pitfalls of Pollen Dating

  • Thomas Neulieb (a1), Elisabeth Levac (a1) (a2), John Southon (a3), Michael Lewis (a4), I Florin Pendea (a5) and Gail L Chmura (a1)...

Abstract

Pollen extracted from ocean and wetland sediments cored from the eastern Canadian Margin, James Bay region, and Atlantic provinces of Canada have been radiocarbon dated and results are reported here. Pollen dates from ocean sediments were compared with marine carbonate (mollusk shells or foraminifera) dates from the same core levels, dates for which validity was assessed via correlations with other cores, and for which reworking has been excluded. Pollen samples from 3 tidal wetlands were taken from levels dated with 137Cs and 210Pb profiles. Pollen dates from 2 additional wetlands were compared with 14C dates of botanical macrofossils. Most pollen dates disagree with 14C dates based on macrofossils or carbonates, with age differences typically exceeding 250 yr and reaching 4000 yr in one instance. In some cores, pollen dates show age reversals. Significant proportions of reworked pollen grains in ocean and wetland samples are associated with pollen dates that are too old. Prolonged core storage could result in pollen 14C ages that are too young, possibly because of growth of fungi or other microbes, but more work is needed to verify this hypothesis. Despite the problems we encountered, some pollen dates are consistent with other 14C dates from the same core levels, suggesting this dating method can work, but at present, more work is needed to understand the conflicting results obtained.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Corresponding author. Email: elevac@ubishops.ca.

References

Hide All
Alldredge, AL, Silver, MW. 1988. Characteristics, dynamics and significance of marine snow. Progress in Oceanography 20(1):4182.
Anderson, DM. 2001. Attenuation of millennial-scale events by bioturbation in marine sediments. Paleoceanography 16(4):352–7.
Anderson, TW, Levac, E, Lewis, CFM. 2007. Cooling in the Gulf of St. Lawrence and estuary region at 9.7 to 7.2 14C ka (11.2–8.0 cal ka): palynological response to the PBO and 8.2 cal ka cold events, Laurentide Ice Sheet air-mass circulation and enhanced freshwater runoff. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 246(1):75100.
Anderson, TW, Lewis, CFM. 1992. Climatic influences of deglacial drainage changes in southern Canada at 10 to 8 ka suggested by pollen evidence. Géographie Physique et Quaternaire 46(3):255–72.
Bard, E. 1988. Correction of accelerator mass spectrometry 14C ages measured in planktonic foraminifera: paleoceanographic implications. Palaeogeography 3(6):635–5.
Bard, E. 2001. Paleoceanographic implications of the difference in deep sea sediment mixing between large and fine particles. Palaeogeography 16(3):235–9.
Bard, E, Arnold, M, Mangerud, J, Paterne, M, Labeyrie, L, Duprat, J, Melieres, MA, Sonstegaard, E, Duplessy, JC. 1994. The North Atlantic atmosphere-sea surface 14C gradient during the Younger Dryas climatic event. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 126(4):275–87.
Beecher, CB, Chmura, GL. 2004. Pollen-vegetation relationships in Bay of Fundy salt marshes. Canadian Journal of Botany 82(5):663–70.
Birks, HJ, Birks, HH. 1980. Quaternary Paleoecology. Baltimore: University Park Press.
Blaauw, M, van der Plicht, J, van Geel, B. 2004. Radiocarbon dating of bulk peat samples from raised bogs: non-existence of a previously reported ‘reservoir effect’? Quaternary Science Reviews 23(14–15):1537–42.
Bourgeois, JC, Koerner, RM, Alt, BT. 1985. Airborne pollen: a unique air mass tracer, its influx to the Canadian High Arctic. Annals of Glaciology 7:109–16.
Bowman, S. 1990. Radiocarbon Dating (Interpreting the Past. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Brown, TA, Nelson, DE, Mathewes, RW, Vogel, JS, Southon, JR. 1989. Radiocarbon dating of pollen by accelerator mass spectrometry. Quaternary Research 32(2):205–12.
Brown, TA, Farwell, GW, Grootes, PM, Schmidt, FH. 1992. Radiocarbon dating of pollen extracted from peat samples. Radiocarbon 34(3):550–6.
Chmura, GL. 2001. The fate of salt marshes in Atlantic Canada. Climate Change Action Fund, Natural Resources Canada. 18 p.
Chmura, GL, Eisma, D. 1995. A palynological study of surface and suspended sediments on a tidal flat: implications for pollen transport and deposition in coastal waters. Marine Geology 128(3–4):183200.
Chmura, GL, Hung, GA. 2004. Controls on salt marsh accretion: a test in salt marshes of Eastern Canada. Estuaries 27:7081.
Dale, CT, Haworth, RT. 1979. High resolution seismology studies on late Quaternary sediments of the northeast Newfoundland continental shelf. Current Research, Part B, Geological Survey of Canada, Paper 79-1B. p 357–64.
Dyer, AK. 1986. A palynological investigation of the late Quaternary vegetational history of the Baie Verte Peninsula, northcentral Newfoundland [Master's thesis]. Department of Geography, Memorial University of Newfoundland. 182 pages.
Grimm, EC, Maher, LJ, Nelson, DM. 2009. The magnitude of error in conventional bulk-sediment radiocarbon dates from central North America. Quaternary Research 72:301–8.
Higham, T. 2006. C14 dating: corrections [online]. Available: www.c14dating.com/corr.html [accessed September 6, 2012].
Hinga, KR, Sieburth, J, Heath, GR. 1979. The supply and use of organic matter at the deep-sea floor. Journal of Marine Research 37:357579.
Hodder, TJ. 2009. Sediment analysis of three piston cores from the Labrador Inner Marginal Trough. Coop report to Geological Survey of Canada Atlantic/Natural Resources Canada/Bedford Institute of Oceanography.
Hua, Q, Barbetti, M. 2004. Review of tropospheric bomb 14C data for carbon cycle modeling and age calibration purposes. Radiocarbon 46(3):1273–98.
Josenhans, HW, Fader, GBJ. 1989. A comparison of models of glacial sedimentation along the Eastern Canadian Margin. Marine Geology 84(2–4):273300.
Josenhans, H, Zevenhuizen, J, Klassen, RA. 1986. The Quaternary geology of the Labrador Shelf. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 23:1190–213.
Kilian, MR, van der Plicht, J, van Geel, B, Goslar, T. 2002. Problematic 14C-AMS dates of pollen concentrates from Lake Gościąż (Poland). Quaternary International 88:21–6.
Levac, E. 2002. High resolution palynological records from Atlantic Canada: regional Holocene paleoceanographic and paleoclimatic history [PhD dissertation]. Department of Earth Sciences, Dalhousie University, Halifax. 465 pages.
Levac, E. 2003. Palynological records from Bay of Islands, Newfoundland: direct correlation Holocene paleoceanographic and climatic changes. Palynology 27:135–54.
Levac, E. 2012. Eolian pollen transport towards Sable Island, Nova Scotia, Canada. IPC/IOPC 2012 Conference, August 23–30, Tokyo, Japan. Japanese Journal of Palynology 58:125.
Levac, E, Lewis, CFM, Miller, AAL. 2011. The impact of the final Lake Agassiz flood recorded in northeast Newfoundland and northern Scotian shelves based on century-scale palynological data. In: Rashid, H, Polyak, L, Mosley-Thompson, E, editors. Abrupt Climate Change: Mechanisms, Patterns, and Impacts. Geophysical Monograph Series 193. Washington, DC: American Geological Union. p 139–59.
Lewis, CFM, Miller, AAL, Levac, E, Piper, DJW, Sonnichsen, GV. 2012. Lake Agassiz outburst age and routing by Labrador Current and the 8.2 cal ka cold event. Quaternary International 260:8397.
Long, A, Davis, OK, DeLanois, J. 1992. Separation and 14C dating of pure pollen from lake sediments: nannofossil AMS dating. Radiocarbon 34(3):557–60.
McNeely, R, Dyke, AS, Southon, JR. 2006. Canadian marine reservoir ages, preliminary data assessment: Open file 5049. Geological Survey of Canada. 3 p.
Mensing, SA, Southon, JR. 1999. A simple method to separate pollen for AMS radiocarbon dating and its application to lacustrine and marine sediments. Radiocarbon 41(1):18.
Mudie, PJ. 1982. Pollen distribution in recent marine sediment, eastern Canada. Canadian Journal of Earth Science 19:729–47.
Mudie, PJ, McCarthy, FMG 1994. Late Quaternary pollen transport processes, western North Atlantic: data from box models cross-margin and N-S transects. Marine Geology 118(1–2):79105.
Pendea, IF. 2011. Mid to late Holocene coastal landscape change in Eastern James Bay [PhD dissertation]. Department of Geography, McGill University, Montreal 154 p.
Pendea, IF, Chmura, GL. 2012. High resolution record of carbon accumulation rates during boreal peatland initiation. Biogeosciences 9:2711–7.
Pendea, IF, Costopoulos, A, Nielsen, C, Chmura, GL. 2010. A new shoreline displacement model for the last 7 ka from eastern James Bay, Canada. Quaternary Research 73(3):474–84.
Regnell, J, Everitt, E. 1996. Preparative centrifugation: a new method for preparing concentrates suitable for radiocarbon dating by AMS. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany 5:201–5.
Reimer, PJ, Reimer, R. 2005. CALIBomb Radiocarbon Calibration [online]. Available: http://calib.qub.ac.uk/CALIBomb/. Accessed 23 February 2013.
Reimer, PJ, Brown, TA, Reimer, RW. 2004. Discussion: reporting and calibration of post-bomb 14C data. Radiocarbon 46(3):1299–304.
Reimer, PJ, Baillie, MGL, Bard, E, Bayliss, A, Beck, JW, Blackwell, PG, Bronk Ramsey, C, Buck, CE, Burr, GS, Edwards, RL, Friedrich, M, Grootes, PM, Guilderson, TP, Hajdas, I, Heaton, T, Hogg, AG, Hughen, KA, Kaiser, KF, Kromer, B, McCormac, FG, Manning, SW, Reimer, RW, Richards, DA, Southon, JR, Talamo, S, Turney, CSM, van der Plicht, J, Weyhenmeyer, CE. 2009. IntCal09 and Marine09 radiocarbon age calibration curves, 0–50,000 years cal BP. Radiocarbon 51(4):1111–50.
Richardson, F, Hall, VA. 1994. Pollen concentrate preparation from highly organic Holocene peat and lake deposits for AMS dating. Radiocarbon 36(3):407–12.
Roe, HM, van de Plassche, O. 2005. Modern pollen distribution in a Connecticut saltmarsh: implications for studies of sea-level change. Quaternary Science Reviews 24(18–19):2030–49.
Sandercombe, S. 2011. The marine record of abrupt climate change at Bay of Islands, Newfoundland [MSc thesis]. Department of Geography, McGill University, Montreal. 65 p.
Santos, GM, Southon, JR, Griffin, S, Beaupré, SR, Druffel, ERM. 2007. Ultra small-mass AMS 14C sample preparation and analyses at KCCAMS/UCI Facility. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research B 259(1):293302.
Shotyk, W. 1996. Peat bog archives of atmospheric metal deposition: Geochemical evaluation of peat profiles, natural variations in metal concentrations, and metal enrichment factors. Environmental Reviews 4:149–83.
Southon, J, Santos, G Druffel-Rodriguez, K, Druffel, E, Trumbore, S, Xu, XM, Griffin, S, Ali, S, Mazon, M. 2004. The Keck Carbon Cycle AMS laboratory, University of California, Irvine: initial operation and a background surprise. Radiocarbon 46(1):41–9.
Stuiver, M, Polach, HA. 1977. Discussion: reporting of 14C data. Radiocarbon 19(3):355–63.
Stuiver, M, Reimer, P, Reimer, R. 2005. CALIB Manual [online]. Available: http://calib.qub.ac.uk/calib/manual/. Accessed 15 January 2013.
Stuiver, M, Reimer, PJ, Reimer, R. 2012. Marine Reservoir Correction Database [online]. Available: http://calib.qub.ac.uk/marine/. Accessed 15 January 2013.
Vasil'chuk, AK. 2004. Radiocarbon dating of pollen and spores from ice wedges of the Yamal and Kolyma regions. Biology Bulletin 31:182–92.
Vasil'chuk, AC, Kim, JC, Vasil'chuk, YK. 2004. The AMS dating of pollen from syngenetic ice-wedge ice. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research B 223–224:645–9.
Wohlfarth, B, Skog, G, Possnert, G, Holmquist, B. 1998. Pitfalls in the AMS radiocarbon-dating of terrestrial macrofossils. Journal of Quaternary Science 13(2): 137–45.
Zhou, W, Zhou, J, Xiao, JDD, Jull, AJT. 1999. Preliminary study on radiocarbon AMS dating of pollen. Science in China Series D 42:524–30.

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed