Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-m42fx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T06:12:29.890Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The seventeenth-century transformation of the hysteric affection, and Sydenham's Baconian medicine

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 July 2009

Jeffrey M. N. Boss
Jeffrey M. N. Boss*
Affiliation:
Wellcome Unit for the History of Medicine, Banbury Road, Oxford
*
1Address for correspondence: Dr Jeffrey M. N. Boss, Department of Physiology, Medical School, University Walk, Bristol BS8 1TD.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Synopsis

Before 1600 the ‘hysteric affection’ was a paroxysmal ailment of women explained as primarily due to the condition or malposition of the womb. During the seventeenth century attention shifted from the womb to the brain. Then Thomas Sydenham's clinical method yielded a view of hysteria which comprehended a wide range of illness with a mental component, and which was related to the whole person. In the course of this paper the relation of the hysteric affection to witchcraft, demonic possession, St Vitus' dance (chorca), hypochondria and melancholy is also noted.

Type
Research Article
Information
Psychological Medicine , Volume 9 , Issue 2 , May 1979 , pp. 221 - 234
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abricossoff, G. (1897). L'hystérie aux 17e et 18e siècles. Steinheil: Paris.Google Scholar
Ady, T. (1661). A Perfect Discovery of Witches, etc. Brome: London.Google Scholar
Aldi, Filii (1547). Medici antiqui omnes, etc. Venetiis (apud Aldi Filios); fos. 71ff, Curandarum aegritudinem muliebrum, etc.Google Scholar
Avicenna, ([11th cent.] 1479). Canon. Padua. Book 3, Fen 21; Tractate 3, Capp. 25–28, and Tractate 4, Capp. 16–19.Google Scholar
Avicenna, (1608). Canon medicinae, etc. (2 vols.). Venetiis (apud luntas). Book 3, Fen 21; Tractate 3, Capp. 25–28 and Tractate 4, Capp. 16–19.Google Scholar
Baas, J. H. ([1889] 1971). Outlines of the History of Medicine and the Medical Profession (2 vols.) (transl. Handerson, H. E.), Vol. 2, p. 485. Krieger: Huntington, N.Y. (Offset reproduction.)Google Scholar
Bacon, F. ([1605] 1873). Advancenent of Learning (2nd edn.) (ed. Aldis Wright, W.). Clarendon: Oxford. [Triple numbers in refs. are of book, chapter and section.]Google Scholar
Bacon, F. ([1620] 1889). Novum Orgonurn, (ed. Fowler, T.). Oxford University Press: Oxford. [Double numbers in refs. are of Book and aphorism.]Google Scholar
Bacon, F. ([1653] 1964). Cogitaea et visa, transl. in Farrington, B., The Philosophy of Francis Bacon, Cap. 18. Liverpool University Press.Google Scholar
Bacon, F. ([1627] 1969). New Atlantis pp. 296–298. Oxford University Press: Oxford. (Reprint of 1906 edn.)Google Scholar
Bontekoe, C. (1698). Nouveaux Elements de Médecine, etc. Vol. 1, 25, 105. Paris. Fide Keele, K. D. (1957). Anatomies of Pain, p. 88. Blackwell: Oxford.Google Scholar
Borelli, J. A. (1681). De motu animalium. Bernabo: Rome.Google Scholar
Boss, J. (1977). William Butler (1535–1618): further evidence on a physician between two ages. Medical History 21, 434–445.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boss, J. (1978). Dr Butler revisited: appreciation and comments. Medical History 22, 426–429.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Boyle, R. (1688). A Disquisition about the Final Causes of Natural Things, etc. John Taylor: London.Google Scholar
Bradwell, S. (1603). Marie Glover's Late Woefull Case, etc. with A defence of the public sentence etc. Brit. Lib. MS Sloane 831.Google Scholar
Brady, S. (1702). De renum & vesicae calculo. M.D. dissertation. Corollaria I and II. Utrecht.Google Scholar
Bright, T. (1613). A Treatise of Melancholie, ‘3rd’ (actually 2nd) edn. Stansby: London.Google Scholar
Burton, R. ([1621] 1827). The Anatomy of Melancholy. Longman: London. [Quadruple numbers in refs. are of partition, Section, member and subsection.]Google Scholar
Cesbron, H. (1909). Histoire critique de l'hystérie. Asselin & Houzeau: Paris.Google Scholar
Charcot, J.-M. & Richer, P. (1887). Les démoniaques dans l'art. Delahaye & Lecrosnier: Paris.Google Scholar
Charcot, J.-M. & Richer, P. (1889). Les difforines et les malades dans l'art. Lecrosnier & Babé: Paris.Google Scholar
Cotta, J. (1616). The Triall of Witchcraft. Rand: London.Google Scholar
Cotta, J. (1617). A True Discovery of the Empericke. Edmund Weaver: London. [I.e. 2nd edn of A Short Discovery of the Unobserved Dangers, etc. James & Boyle: London. 1612.]Google Scholar
Cotta, J. (1619). A Short Discovery of Severall Sorts of Ignorant and Unconsiderate Practisers of Physicke in England, etc. Book I. Barnes: London.Google Scholar
Cotta, J. (1624). The Triall of Witchcraft (2nd edn). Higginbotham: London.Google Scholar
Cumston, C. G. (n.d.). A note on Charles Lepois's writings on hysteria, pp. 426–430. [Journal, vol. and year unknown.] [In offprint collection of the Welicome Historical Medical Library, London.]Google Scholar
Descartes, R. ([1637] 1965). Discourse on the Method of, etc. (transl. Veith, J.), pp. 11 (Pt.11), 37–42. (Pt. v), and 49–51 (Pt. VI). Dent: London. (Reprint of 1912 edn.)Google Scholar
Dewhurst, K. (1958). Locke and Sydenham on the teaching of anatomy. Medical History 2, 1–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ewen, C. L'E. (1933). Witchcraft and Demonism. Heath Cranton: London.Google Scholar
Galen, ([2nd cent.] 1538). Galênou apanta. [Complete Galen.] Basileae (apud A. Cratandrum).Google Scholar
Galen, (1824 a). Peri tôn peponthoton topôn. [De locis aftectis.] Book VI. In Claudii Galeni Opera omnia (22 vols.)(ed Kühn, C. G.), vol. VIII pp. 377–452. Knobloch: Lipsiae. 1821–1823.Google Scholar
Galen, (1824 b). Peri tôn sphygmôn tois eisagomenois. [De pulsibus libellus ad tirones.] In Galen (1824 a), vol. VIII, p. 489.Google Scholar
Galen, (1825 a). Peri tôn en tois sphygmôn aitiôn. [De causis pulsuam.] Book IV. In Galen (1824 a), vol. IX, p. 197.Google Scholar
Galen, (1825 b). Therapeutiké methods. [De methodo medendi.] Book II. In Galen (1824 a), vol. x, p. 78.Google Scholar
Galen, (1826). Peri tês tôn haplôn pharmakôn kraseôs kai dynameôs. [De simplicium medicamentorum temperamentis ac facultatibus.] Book IX. In Galen (1824a), vol. XII, p. 348.Google Scholar
Galen, (1827). Peri syntheseós pharmakôn tôn kata topous. [De compositione medicanientorum secundum locos.] Books VII, VIII and IX. In Galen (1824 a), vol. XII, pp. 1–361.Google Scholar
Galen, (1828). Hippokratous peri diaitês oxeôn nosématon bibliôn kai Galênou hypomnêma. [Hippocratis de acutorum morborum victu liber et Galeni commentarius.] Book IV. In Galen (1824 a), vol. XV pp. 916–917. [Not in Galen (1538); confirms Hippocrates (1840).]Google Scholar
Galen, (1829 a). Galênou tôn eis to peri chymôn Hippokratous hypomnêmata. [Galeni commentarii in Hippocratem de humoribus.] In Galen (1824 a), vol. XVI, pp. 1–488. [Not in Galen (1538), but pp. 179–180 argue as Galen (1824 a), pp. 423–425, and p.339 as Galen (1827), pp. 319–320; other refs. to the work are not essential to argument of this paper.]Google Scholar
Galen, (1829 b). Galênou eis to Hippokratous prorrhêtikôn biblion prôton hypomnêma. [Galeni commentarius in Hippocratis praedictionum Lib.1.] Book III. In Galen (1824 a), vol. XVI, pp. 772–774.Google Scholar
Galen, (1829 c). Hippocratis aphorismoi kai Galénou eis autous hypomnémata. [Hippocratis aphorismi et Galeni in eos conmentarii.] Book V, aph. 35. In Galen (1824a), Vol. XVIII B, pp. 823–824. [And cf. the note on this aphorism in Jones, W. H. S. (transl. and ed.) (1959). Hippocrates (Loeb Classics), Vol. 4, p. 167. Heinemann: London.]Google Scholar
Giffard, G. (1593). A Dialogue Concerning Witches and Witchcraftes. John Windet, for Cooke and Hart: London.Google Scholar
G(lanvill), J. (1667). Some Philosophical Considerations. etc. Collins: London.Google Scholar
Glisson, F. (1662). Doctrina de circulatione sanguinis haud immutat antiquam medendi methodum. Brit. Lib. MS Sloane 3309, fos. 341–343.Google Scholar
Greenhill, W. A. (1844). In Sydenham, T., Opera omnia (ed. Greenhill, W. A.), pp. xvii–xxvii, Historia literaria. Sydenham Society: London.Google Scholar
Harvey, G. (1666). Morbus anglicus, or the Anatomy of Consumptions. Brook: London.Google Scholar
Harvey, G. (1689). The Art of Curing Diseases by Expectation, etc. Ch. XXII. Partridge: London.Google Scholar
Highmore, N. (1660). Exercitationes duae quarum prior de passione hystenica: altera de affectione hypochondriaca. Davis: Oxford.Google Scholar
Highmore, N. (1670). De hysterica & hypochondriaca passione, responsio epistolaris ad Doctorem Willis medicum Londin-iensem celeberrimum. Clavel: London.Google Scholar
Hippocrates, ([5th cent. B.C.] 1588). Hippocrates coi opera quae extant. Venetiis (apud luntas).Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1840). Peri diaités oxeôn notha. [On acute diseases: appendix.] In Oeuvres complètes d'Hippocrate (10 vols.) vol. II, p. 522. Baillière: Paris. (1839–1861.) (Greek and French.)Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1844). Aphorismoi. [Aphorisms.] In Hippocrates (1840), Vol. IV, p. 544.Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1959). Peri hierês nosou. [On the sacred disease.[ Cc. 17 and 18. In Hippocrates. (Loeb Classics), (transl. and ed. Jones, W. H. S.), vol. 2, pp. 174–177. Heinemann:London.Google Scholar
Hippocrates, ([1846] 1962 a). Epidémiôn to hebdomon. [Seventh book of the Epidemics.] In Hippocrates (1840), vol. V, pp. 364–469. Hakkert: Amsterdam. (Offset.)Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1962 b). Prorrhetikos. [Prognosis.] Book I. In Hippocrates (1962a), vol. v, p. 550.Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1962 c). Kôakai prognôies. [The Coan prognostics.] In Hippocrates (1962 a), vol. v, pp. 588–733.Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1962 d). Peri topôn tôn kata anthrôpon. [Parts of the human body.] In Hippocrates (1962 a), vol. VI, pp. 344–348. [Resembles but is not identical with the false letter of Democritus to Hippocrates cited by Sydenham (1844e), P. 370].Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1962 e). Peri gynaikeiês physios. [On feminine nature] In Hippocrates (1962 a), vol. VII, pp. 312–431.Google Scholar
Hippocrates, (1962 f). Gynaikeión prôton: gynaikeió to deuteron. [Feminine matters, Books I and II] In Hippocrates (1962 a), vol. VIII, pp. 10–407.Google Scholar
Hunter, R. & Macalpine, I. (1963). Three Hundred Years of Psychiatry 1535–1860. Oxford University Press: London.Google Scholar
[James, VI (& I)] (1597). Daemonologie, etc. Waldegrave: Edinburgh. [Anon. but preface is signed ‘James R’.]Google Scholar
James, VI & I (1605). Letter of 10. x.1605 to the Earl of Salisbury about Anne Gunter, in Hunter & Macalpine (1963), pp. 76–77.Google Scholar
Jorden, E. (1603). A briefe discourse of a disease called the suffocation of the mother. Written upon occasion which hath been of late taken thereby, to suspect possession of an evill spirit, or some such like supernaturall power. Wherein is declared that divers strange actions and passions of the body of man, which in the common opinion, are imputed to the Divell, have their true natural causes, and do accompany this disease. John Windet: London.Google Scholar
Leibbrand, A. & Leibbrand, W. (1975). Die ‘kopernikanische Wendung’ des Hysteriebegriffes bei Paracelsus. In Paracelsus Werk und Wirkung, etc. (ed. Domadl, S.), pp. 125–132. WGO: Vienna.Google Scholar
Leidecker, K. F. (ed. and transl.) (1949). Volumen medicinae paramirum of Theophrastus von Hohenheim called Paracelsus, Bulletin of the History of Medicine Suppl. 11.Google Scholar
Mondino, d'Luzzi ([1493] 1974). In A Source Book in Medieval Science (ed. Grant, E.), p. 734. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
M(onfort), S. ([1693] 1844). Foreword to Sydenham, T., Processus integri (Sydenham, 1844 i, p. 532).Google Scholar
Muggleton, L. (1669). A True interpretation of the Witch of Endor. London. (No pubr. or printer stated.)Google Scholar
Nutton, V. (1978). Dr Butler revisited. Medical History 22, 417–426, 429–430.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Paré, A. ([1579] 1641). Livre traictant de la generation de l'homme, recueilly des anciens et modernes, i.e. Book 24 of Les oeuvres d' Ambroise Paré, Cc. 52–57, pp. 626–629. Claude Prost: Lyon.Google Scholar
Paulus, Aegineta ([7th cent.] 1844). In The Seven Books of Paulus Aegineta (3 vols.) (transl. and ed. Adams, F.), vol. 1, pp. 633–634 (Book 3, c. 71). Sydenham Society: London.Google Scholar
Petty, W. ([1676] 1927). Anatotny Lecture, Dublin, 1676. In The Petty Papers (2 vols.) (ed. Lansdowne, Marquis of), vol. 2, pp. 171–179. Constable: London.Google Scholar
Petty, W. ([1653] 1971). Letter to Robert Boyle, cited by Frank, R. G. Jr. Oxford and the Harveian tradition in the seventeenth century, p. 277. Ph.D. thesis, Harvard University, 1971.Google Scholar
Piso, C. & Lepois, C.] (1618). Selectiorum observationum… liber, pp. 101–161. Mercator: Ponte ad Monticulum.Google Scholar
Sennert(us), D. (1624). Duo tractatus de dignotione et curatione scorbuti et reliquorum ab eo dependentium affectum hypochondriacorum: I. De scorbuto & hypochondriacis affectibus. Beithmann, for Birckner: Ienae.Google Scholar
Sennert(us), D. (1656). The institutions…of…Physick and Chirurgery. Lodowick Lloyd: London.Google Scholar
Shaw, P. (1726). A New Practice of Physick, etc. Osborn & Longman: London. Title-page: quotation from Bacon's De Augmentis (unlocated but certainly genuine).Google Scholar
Spach, I. (1597). Gynaeciorum sive de mulierum…affectibus & morbis libri, etc., pp. 42ff: Erotis medici liberti Juliae quem aliqui Trotulam inepte nominant, etc. C. IV, De suffocatione matricis. Lazar Zetzner: Argentinae.Google Scholar
Stubbe, H. (1662). The indian Nectar, etc., pp. 129ff. Crook: London.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1675] 1844 a). Epistola dedicatoria editionis tertiae Observationum medicarum (to John Mapletoft). In Sydenham, T., Opera omnia (ed. Greenhill, W. A.), p. 4. Sydenham Society: London.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1685] 1844 b). Praefatio editionis tertiae Observationum medicarum. In Sydenham (1844 a), pp. 9–22.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1685] 1844 c). Observationes medicae circa morborum acutorum historiam et curationem (4th edn). In Sydenham (1844a), pp. 26–270.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1685] 1844 d). Epistolae responsoriae duae: prima, de morbis epidemicis, etc. (2nd edn). In Sydenham (1844a), pp. 275–303.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1685] 1844 e). Dissertatio episiolaris…de observationibus nuperis circa durationem variolarun confluentium; nec-non de affectione hysterica (2nd edn). In Sydenham (1844 a), pp. 331–404.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1685] 1844 f). Tractatus de podagra (2nd edn). In Sydenham (1844 a), p. 439.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1685] 1844 g). Tractatus de hydrope (2nd edn). In Sydenham (1844 a), pp. 455–478.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1688] 1844 h). Schedula monitoria de novae febris ingressu (2nd edn). In Sydenham (1844a), pp. 495–498.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([1695] 1844 i). Processus integri in morbis ferè omnibus curandis, etc. (1st edn). In Sydenham (1844 a), pp. 568–569.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([n.d.] 1966 a). Theologia rationalis, Brit. Lib. MS Sloane 3828, fos. 162–171. In Dr Thomas Sydenham (1624–1689) (K. Dewhurst), p. 151. Wellcome Historical Medical Library: London.Google Scholar
Sydenham, T. ([n.d.] 1966 b). Of the four constitutions. Bod. Lib. MS Locke c. 19, fos. 170–176. In Sydenham (1966 a), pp. 140–144.Google Scholar
Thomas, K. (1971). Religion and the Decline of Magic. Weidenfeld & Nicolson: London.Google Scholar
Trotula, ([13th cent.] 1940). In The diseases of women by Trotula of Salerno, a translation of Passionibus mulierum curando (transl. Mason-Hohl, E.). Ward Ritchie Press. [From text of Aldi filii (1547).]Google Scholar
Veith, I. (1965). Hysteria: the History of a Disease. Chicago University Press.Google Scholar
Willis, T. (1676). Opera omnia (2 vols.). Vol. I, Pt. III: Pathologia cerebri. Vol. I, Pt. IV: Affectionum quae dicuntur hystericae & hypochondiracae patholiga spasmodica vindicata, etc. De Tournes: Geneva.Google Scholar
Willis, T. (1685). ‘Eugenius Philiatros’ (ed. and transl.). In The London Practice of Physick. Basset & Crooke: London.Google Scholar
Willis, T. ([1683] 1971). Two Discourses Concerning the Soul of Brutes, etc. (transl. Pordage, S.). Dring, Harper and Leigh: London. In facsimile, with intro, by Diamond, S., Scholars Facsimiles and Reprints: Gainesville, Fa.Google Scholar
Wolfe, D. E. (1961). Sydenham and Locke on the limits of anatomy. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 35, 193–220.Google ScholarPubMed