Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Burn Disasters—An Audit of the Literature

  • Carsten L. Broeze (a1), Sian Falder (a1), Suzanne Rea (a1) and Fiona Wood (a1)

Abstract

All events that result in disasters are unique, and it is impossible to become fully prepared. However, through thorough planning and preparedness, it is possible to gain a better understanding of the typical injury patterns and problems that arise from a variety of hazards. Such events have the potential to claim many lives and overwhelm local medical resources. Burn disasters vary in scope of injury and procedures required, and are much more labor and resource intensive than non-burn disasters.

This review of the literature should help determine whether, despite each event having its own unique features, there still are common problems disaster responders face in the prehospital and hospital phases, what recommendations were made from these disasters, and whether these recommendations have been implemented into practice and the current disaster planning processes.

The objective of this review was to assess: (1) prehospital and hospital responses used during past burn disasters; (2) problems faced during those disaster responses; (3) recommendations made following those disasters; (4) whether these recommendations were integrated into practice; and (5) the key characteristics of burn disasters and how they differ from other disasters. This review is important to determine why, despite having disaster plans, things still go wrong.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Telstra Burns Unit, South Block, Level 11, Royal Perth Hospital Wellington Street, Perth, Western Australia 6000, E-mail: carsten.broeze@gmail.com

References

Hide All
1.Bradt, DA, Abraham, K, Franks, R: A strategic plan for disaster medicine in Australasia. Emerg Med (Fremantle) 2003;15(3):271282.
2.Ahuja, RB, Bhattacharya, S: Burns in the developing world and burn disasters. BMJ 2004;329(7463):447449.
3.Gunn SWA: The Scientific Basis of Disaster Medicine. In: Masellis, M, Gunn, SWA, (eds): The Management of Mass Burn Casualties and Fire Disasters: Proceedings of the First International Conference on Burns and Fire Disasters. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic, 1992: pp 1318.
4.Quenemoen, LE, Davis, YM, Malilay, J, Sinks, T, Noji, EK, Klitzman, S: The World Trade Center bombing: Injury prevention strategies for high-rise building fires. Disasters 1996;20(2):125132.
5.Forgione, T, Owens, PJ, Lopes, Briggs SM: New horizons for OR nurses— Lessons learned from the World Trade Center attack. AORN J 2003;78(2):240245.
6.Suner, S: On-site medical care during the September 11th WTC terrorist attack rescue and recovery effort and the National Disaster Medical System (NDMS). Med Health R I 2003;86(11):354356.
7.Gutman, D, Biffl, WL, Suner, S, Cioffi, WG: The station nightclub fire and disaster preparedness in Rhode Island. Med Health R I 2003;86(11):344346.
8.Tarnow, PF, Gewalli, F, Cassuto, J: Fire disaster in Gothenburg 1998— Surgical treatment of burns. Burns 2003;29(5):417421.
9.Tucker, K, Lettin, A: The Tower of London bomb explosion. Br Med J 1975;3(5978):287290.
10.Brismar, B, Bergenwald, L: The terrorist bomb explosion in Bologna, Italy, 1980: An analysis of the effects and injuries sustained. J Trauma 1982;22(3):216220.
11.Gomez Morell, PA, Escudero Naif, F, Palao Domenech, R, Sospedra Carol, E, Bañuelos Roda, JA: Burns caused by the terrorist bombing of the department store Hipercor in Barcelona. Part I. Burns 1990;16(6):423425.
12.Teague, DC: Mass casualties in the Oklahoma City bombing. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2004;(422):7781.
13.Anteau, CM, Williams, LA: What we learned from the Oklahoma City bombing. Nursing 1998;28(3):5255.
14.Dellinger, AM, Waxweiler, RJ, Mallonee, S: Injuries to rescue workers following the Oklahoma City bombing. Am J Ind Med 1997;31(6):727732.
15.Tucker, P, Pfefferbaum, B, Vincent, R, Boehler, SD, Nixon, SJ: Oklahoma City: Disaster challenges mental health and medical administrators. J Behav Health Serv Res 1998;25(1):9399.
16.McLain SR: The Oklahoma City Bombing: Lessons Learned by Hospitals, online article. American Hospital Association.
17.Ray, S: Coping with terrorism: Lessons of Oklahoma City. Health Trends 2001;14(2):912.
18.Glass, RT: The Oklahoma City bombing: The roles of the dental teams… and the lessons learned. J Okla Dent Assoc 1998;89(2):2021,25-32,34-36.
19.Hollander, D: Nairobi bomb blast—Trauma and recovery. Trop Doct 2000;30(1):4748.
20.Carter, GE: The Omagh bombing—A medical perspective. JR Army Med Corps 2000;146:1821.
21.Miller, IS, McGahey, D, Law, K: The otologic consequences of the Omagh bomb disaster. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2002;126(2):127128.
22.Kennedy, PJ, Haertsch, PA, Maitz, PK: The Bali burn disaster: Implications and lessons learned. J Burn Care Rehabil 2005;26(2):125131.
23.Hampson, GV, Cook, SP, Frederiksen, SR: Operation Bali assist. Med J Aust 2002;177(11-12):620623.
24.Lain, RC, Griffiths, C, Hilton, JM: Forensic dental and medical response to the Bali bombing. A personal perspective. Med J Aust 2003;179(7):362365.
25.Read, D, Ashford, B: Surgical aspects of Operation Bali Assist: Initial wound surgery on the tarmac and in flight. ANZ J Surg 2004;74(11):986991.
26.Southwick, GJ, Pethick, AJ, Thalayasingam, P, Vijayasekaran, VS, Higg, JJ: Australian doctors in Bali: The initial medical response to the Bali bombing. Med J Aust 2002;177(11-12):624626.
27.Stephens, DP, De Keulenaer, BL, Collins, S, Harbison, PW, Weidmann, G, Potter, AW: Operation Bali assist—The Royal Darwin Hospital Intensive Care Unit. Anaesth Intensive Care 2003;31(3):300305.
28.Spain, BT, Blum, PG, Hams, SC: The role of anaesthetists in the Darwin response to the Bali bombing. Anaesth Intensive Care 2003;31(3):306308.
29.Palmer, DJ, Stephens, D, Fisher, DA, Spain, B, Read, DJ, Notaras, L: The Bali bombing: The Royal Darwin Hospital response. Med J Aust 2003;179(7):358361.
30.Fisher, D, Burrow, J: The Bali bombings of 12 October, 2002: Lessons in disaster management for physicians. Intern Med J 2003;33(3):125126.
31.Taylor, RM, O'Connor, B, St. Leone, M, Halpern, JS: The voice of experience: Australian nurses caring for victims of Bali bombing. Disaster Manag Response 2003;1(1):27.
32.Heath, C, Orrell, T, Lee, R, et al: A review of the Royal Perth Hospital Bali experience: An infection control perspective. Aust Inf Control 2003;8(2):4354.
33.McCullough, C, Christiansen, K, Coombs, G, et al: Bali Bugs. Australian Society for Antimicrobials Newsletter 2003;No 13.
34.Silla, RC, Fong, J, Wright, J, Wood, F: Infection in acute burn wounds following the Bali bombings: A comparative prospective audit. Burns 2006;32(2):139144.
35.Tran, MD, Garner, AA, Morrison, I, Sharley, PH, Griggs, WM, Xavier, C: The Bali bombing: Civilian aeromedical evacuation. Med J Aust 2003;179(7):353356.
36.Edgar, D, Wood, F, Goodwin-Walters, A: Maintaining physical therapy standards in an emergency situation: Solutions after the Bali bombing disaster. Burns 2005;31(5):555557.
37.McGuire, D: Terror in paradise. Emerg Med Serv 2003;32(3):5559.
38.Watts, J: Bali bombing offers lessons for disaster relief. Lancet 2002;360(9343):1401.
39.Bosch, X: Horror as Madrid death toll climbs to over 200. Lancet 2004;363(9413):955.
40.Gutierrez de Ceballos, JP, Turégano Fuentes, F, Perez Diaz, D, Sanz Sanchez, M, Martin Llorente, C, Guerrero Sans, JE: Casualties treated at the closest hospital in the Madrid, March 11, terrorist bombings. Crit Care Med 2005;33(1):s107112.
41.de Ceballos, JP, Turégano-Fuentes, F, Perez-Diaz, D, Sanz-Sanchez, M, Martin-Llorente, C, Guerrero-Sanz, JE: 11 March 2004: The terrorist bomb explosions in Madrid, Spain—An analysis of the logistics, injuries sustained and clinical management of casualties treated at the closest hospital. Crit Care 2005;9(1):104111.
42.Frykberg, ER: Terrorist bombings in Madrid. Crit Care 2005;9(1):2022.
43.Dolan, B: London 2005, bruised but not broken. Disaster Manag Response 2005;3(4):9495.
44.Arnold, JL: The 2005 London bombings and the Haddon matrix. Prehospital Disast Med 2005;20(5):278281.
45.Hines, S, Payne, A, Edmondson, J, Heightman, AJ: Bombs under London. The EMS response plan that worked. JEMS 2005;30(8):5860,62,64-67.
46.Redhead, J, Ward, P, Batrick, N: The London attacks—Response: Prehospital and hospital care. N Engl J Med 2005;353(6):546547.
47.Wong, JM, Marsh, D, Abu-Sitta, G, Lau, S, Mann, HA, Nawabi, DH, Patel, H: Biological foreign body implantation in victims of the London July 7th suicide bombings. J Trauma 2006;60(2):402404.
48.Parish, C: The London bombings: How EDs and nurses responded to the terrorist attacks of July 7. Am J Nurs 2005;105(9):102103.
49.Harding, ML: Comms failure hampered London bombing response. Health Serv J 2006;116(6009):9.
50.Lockey, DJ, Mackenzie, R, Redhead, J, Wise, D, Harris, T, Weaver, A, Hines, K, Davies, GE: London bombings July 2005: The immediate pre-hospital medical response. Resuscitation 2005;66(2):ix–xii.
51.Ryan, J, Montgomery, H: The London attacks—Preparedness: Terrorism and the medical response. N Engl J Med 2005;353(6):543545.
52.Saffle, JR: The 1942 fire at Boston's Cocoanut Grove nightclub. Am J Surg 1993;166(6):581591.
53.Finland, M, Davidson, CS, Levenson, SM: Clinical and therapeutic aspects of the conflagration injuries to the respiratory Tract sustained by victims of the Cocoanut Grove Disaster. Medicine 1946;25(3):215283.
54.Davidson, CS: The Cocoanut Grove disaster. J Infect Dis 1972;125:s58–s59.
55.Hart, RJ, Lee, JO, Boyles, DJ, Batey, NR: The Summerland disaster. Br Med J 1975;1(5952):256259.
56.Eisentrout, TH: Story of the Beverly Hills fire: Minister's role in a major disaster. Bull Am Protestant Hosp Assoc 1978;42(2):105108.
57.Birky, M, Malek, D, Paabo, M: Study of biological samples obtained from victims of MGM Grand Hotel fire. J Anal Toxicol 1983;7(6):265271.
58.Buerk, CA, Batdorf, JW, Cammack, KV, et al: The MGM Grand Hotel fire:: essons learned from a major disaster. Arch Surg 1982;117(5):641644.
59.Woolley, WD, Smith, PG, Fardell, PJ, et al: The Stardust Disco fire, Dublin 1981: Studies of combustion products during simulation experiments. Fire Safety Journal 1984;7:267–83.
60.Duignan, JP, McEntee, GP, Scully, B, Corrigan, TP: Report of a fire disaster— Management of burns and complications. Ir Med J 1984;77(1):810.
61.Sadler, C: Accident and emergency: The St Valentine's day disaster. Nurs Mirror 1982;154(20):1416.
62.Tarnow, P, Gewalli, F, Cassuto, J: Fire disaster in Gothenburg 1998—Surgical treatment of burns. Burns 2003;29(5):417421.
63.Gewalli, F, Fogdestam, I: Triage and initial treatment of burns in the Gothenburg fire disaster 1998. On-call plastic surgeons' experiences and lessons learned. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg Hand Surg 2003;37(3):134139.
64.Brandsjo, KA, Hedelin, A, Lundin, T, Lundälv, J, Swedish Disaster Medicine Study Organization: KAMEDO Report No. 75: Fire catastrophe in Gothenburg 29-30 October 1998. Prehosp Disaster Med 2005;20(4):258261.
65.Cassuto, J, Tarnow, P: The discotheque fire in Gothenburg 1998. A tragedy among teenagers. Burns 2003;29(5):405416.
66.Dyregrov, A, Frykholm, AM, Lilled, L, Broberg, AG, Holmberg, I: The Goteborg discotheque fire, 1998. Scand J Psychol 2003;44(5):449457.
67.Pirson, J, Degrave, E: Aeromedical transfer to Belgium of severely burned patients during the initial days following the Volendam fire. Mil Med 2003;168(5):360363.
68.Welling, L, van Harten, SM, Patka, P, Bierens, JJ, Boers, M, Luitse, JS, Mackie, DP, Trouwborst, A, Gouma, DJ, Kreis, RW: The cafe fire on New Year's Eve in Volendam, the Netherlands: Description of events. Burns 2005;31(5):548554.
69.Welling, L, Perez, RS, van Harten, SM, Patka, P, Mackie, DP, Kreis, RW, Bierens, JJ: Analysis of the pre-incident education and subsequent performance of emergency medical responders to the Volendam cafe fire. Eur J Emerg Med 2005;12(6):265269.
70.van Harten, S, Welling, ML, Perez, RS, Patka, P, Kreis, RW: Management of multiple burn casualties from the Volendam disaster in the emergency departments of general hospitals. Eur J Emerg Med 2005;12(6):270274.
71.Mahoney, EJ, Harrington, DT, Biffl, WL, et al: Lessons learned from a nightclub fire: Institutional disaster preparedness. J Trauma 2005;58(3):487491.
72.Dunbar, JA: The Rhode Island nightclub fire: The story from the perspective of an on-duty ED nurse. J Emerg Nurs 2004;30(5):464466.
73.Gutman, D, Biffl, WL, Suner, S, Cioffi, WG: The station nightclub fire and disaster preparedness in Rhode Island. Med Health R I 2003;86(11):344346.
74.Biffl, WL, Cioffi, WG: Medical disasters: are we really prepared? An analysis of the station fire. Med Health R I 2003;86(11):342343.
75.Dacey, MJ: Tragedy and response—The Rhode Island nightclub fire. N Engl J Med 2003;349(21):19901992.
76.Blocker, V, Blocker, TG: The Texas City disaster; A survey of 3,000 casualties. Am J Surg 1949;78(5):756771.
77.Ishida, T, Ohta, M, Sugimoto, T: The breakdown of an emergency system following a gas explosion in Osaka and the subsequent resolution of problems. J Emerg Med 1985;2(3):183189.
78.Aburel, V, Visa, L, Grigorescu, D: The 1979 fire disaster (93 casualties) in Brasov (Romania)—The importance of rapid transport and unitary treatment in a hospital. Ann Medit Burns Club 1994;VII(1).
79.Allister, C, Hamilton, GM: Cardowan coal mine explosion: Experience of a mass burns incident. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 1983;287(6389):403405.
80.Arturson, G: The tragedy of San Juanico—The most severe LPG disaster in history. Burns Incl Therm Inj 1987;13(2): 87102.
81.Olley, D: Piper alpha—A personal experience. J R Soc Health 1991;111(5):193195.
82.Clark, DH: Dental identification in the Piper Alpha oil rig disaster. J Forensic Odontostomatol 1991;9(2):3746.
83.Alexander, DA: Psychiatric intervention after the Piper Alpha disaster. J R Soc Med 1991;84(1):811.
84.Fraser, DE: Occupational health management of police officers involved in the Piper Alpha disaster. J Soc Occup Med 1991;41(4):174175.
85.Kulyapin, AV, Sakhautdinov, VG, Temerbulatov, VM, Becker, WK, Waymack, JP: Bashkiria train-gas pipeline disaster: A history of the joint USSR/USA collaboration. Burns 1990;16(5):339342.
86.Masellis, M: Thermal Agent Disaster and Fire Disaster; Definition, Damage, Assessment, and Relief Operations, Chapter 1. In: Masellis, M, Gunn, SWA, (eds.): The Management of Mass Burn Casualties and Fire Disasters: Proceedings of the First International Conference on Burns and Fire Disasters. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic, 1992, pp 712.
87.Cairns, BA, Stiffler, A, Price, F, Peck, MD, Meyer, AA: Managing a combined burn trauma disaster in the post-9/11 world: Lessons learned from the 2003 West Pharmaceutical plant explosion. J Burn Care Rehabil 2005;26(2):144150.
88.Polk, HC Jr, Tessler, R: The Yarmouth Castle disaster. Further experience in the treatment of large human burns with aqueous silver nitrate (0.5 per cent). J Fla Med Assoc 1966;53(11):10591062.
89.Carswell, JW, Rambo, WA: A fire at Nakivubo, Kampala: A case report. Burns 1976;2:178183.
90.Baux, S, Saizy, R, Porte, A, Zumer, L, Mayer, G, Mole, B, Monsaingeon, I: [The Los Alfaques disaster]. Ann Chir Plast 1981;26(2):185187. (in French).
91.Brough, MD: The King's Cross fire. Part 1: The physical injuries. Burns 1991;17(1):69.
92.Sturgeon, D, Rosser, R, Shoenberg, P: The King's Cross fire. Part 2: The psychological injuries. Burns 1991;17(1):1013.
93.Deahl, MP, Bisson, JI: Dealing with disasters: Does psychological debriefing work? J Accid Emerg Med 1995;12(4):255258.
94.Masellis, M, Laia, A, Sperrazza, G, et al: Fire disaster in a motorway tunnel. Annals of Burns and Fire Disasters 1997;X(4).
95.O'Hickey, SP, Pickering, CA, Jones, PE, Evans, JD: Manchester air disaster. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 1987;294(6588):16631667.
96.Samuels, A: The Manchester airport disaster. Med Sci Law 1987;27(2):118120.
97.Kossmann, T, Wittling, I, Buhren, V, et al: Transferred triage to a level I trauma center in a mass catastrophe of patients; many of them with burns. Acta Chir Plast 1991;33(3):145150.
98.Martin, TE: The Ramstein airshow disaster. J R Army Med Corps 1990;136(1):1926.
99.Seletz, JM: Flugtag-88 (Ramstein Air Show Disaster): An Army response to a MASCAL. Mil Med 1990;155(4):152155.
100.Lee, WH, Chiu, TF, et al: Emergency medical preparedness and response to a Singapore airliner crash. Acad Emerg Med 2002;9(3):194198.
101.Cyganik, KA: Disaster preparedness in Virginia Hospital Center—Arlington after Sept 11, 2001. Disaster Manag Response 2003;1(3):8086.
102.Waage, A, Hamberger, B, Lundin, T, Suserud, BO, Riddez, L, Swedish Disaster Medicine Study Organization: KAMEDO report no. 84: Terrorist attacks against the World Trade Center, 11 September 2001. Prehosp Disaster Med 2006;21(2):129131.
103.Havlak, R, Gorman, SE, Adams, SA: Challenges associated with creating a pharmaceutical stockpile to respond to a terrorist event. Clin Microbiol Infect 2002;8(8):529533.
104.Gottlieb, S: The casualties that never arrived. BMJ 2001;323(7314):654.
105.Ward, MJ: Attack on the Pentagon. The initial fire & EMS response. JEMS 2002;27(4):2230,32,34.
106.Jordan, MH, Hollowed, KA, Turner, DG, Wang, DS, Jeng, JC: The Pentagon attack of September 11, 2001: A burn center's experience. J Burn Care Rehabil 2005;26(2):109116.
107.Banauch, GI, Dhala, A, Prezant, DJ: Pulmonary disease in rescue workers at the World Trade Center site. Curr Opin Pulm Med 2005;11(2):160168.
108.Nemery, B: Reactive fallout of World Trade Center dust. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2003;168(1):23.
109.Pesola, GR, Dujar, A, Wilson, S: Emergency preparedness: The World Trade Center and Singapore airline disasters. Acad Emerg Med 2002;9(3):220222.
110.Roche, M: Eyewitness to terror: EMS responds to the attack on the Pentagon. Air Med J 2001;20(6):45.
111.Wang, D, Sava, J, Sample, G, Jordan, M: The Pentagon and 9/11. Crit Care Med 2005;33(1 Suppl):s42-s7.
112.Das RAP: 1981 Circus fire disaster in Bangalore, India: Causes, management of burn patients and possible presentation. Burns 1982;10:1729.
113.Sharpe, DT: Management of burns in major disasters. Natnews 1989;26(12): 910.
114.Sivaloganathan, S, Green, MA: The Bradford Fire Disaster. Part 1. The initial investigations: Who died, where and how? Med Sci Law 1989;29(4):279283.
115.Sivaloganathan, S, Green, MA: The Bradford Fire Disaster. Part 2. Accident reconstruction: Who died, when and why. Med Sci Law 1989;29(4):284–6.
116.Al-Hoqail, R: A fire disaster at a wedding in a village in the eastern province, Saudi Arabia. Annals of Burns and Fire Disasters 2004;XVII(3).

Keywords

Burn Disasters—An Audit of the Literature

  • Carsten L. Broeze (a1), Sian Falder (a1), Suzanne Rea (a1) and Fiona Wood (a1)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed