Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-2xdlg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-19T04:41:24.308Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

National and International Approaches to Human Germ-Line Gene Therapy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2016

Andrea L. Bonnicksen
Andrea L. Bonnicksen*
Affiliation:
Northern Illinois University, USA
Get access

Abstract

Germ-line gene therapy, in which genetic flaws are corrected in the DNA of externally fertilized human embryos, lies in the distant yet foreseeable future. Worries about germ-line therapy have prompted international bodies to craft guidelines that are unusual for their anticipatory nature. Motivating these guidelines is the idea that a “transnational harmonization” of principles should be reached before national policies are developed. This article reviews selected national policies and international recommendations, and it concludes that national policies should be precedents for, rather than descendants of, international normative codes. The inclination to develop morally-based codes, which is implicit in transnational harmonization, will be more useful if grounded in empirically-based medical technologies and politically-tested policies rather than on abstract principles developed well in advance of technological feasibility.

Type
Germ-Line Gene Therapy
Information
Politics and the Life Sciences , Volume 13 , Issue 1 , February 1994 , pp. 39 - 49
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Anderson, W.F. (1992). “Editorial: Uses and Abuses of Human Gene Transfer.” Human Gene Therapy 3:1–2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beier, H.M. and Beckman, J.O. (1991). “Implications and Consequences of the German Embryo Protection Act.” Human Reproduction 6(4):607–8.Google Scholar
Bering-Jensen, H. (1990). “German Angst Bears Embryo Law,” Insight 6(49):52–53(December 3).Google Scholar
“Bioethics Law to be Reviewed” (1993). Biotechnology Business News (March 13, 1992). Westlaw 1993 Predicasts.Google Scholar
Bonnicksen, A.L. (1992). “Genetic Diagnosis of Human Embryos: Making Decisions and Placing Responsibility.” Paper presented at Third International Conference on Health Law and Ethics, Toronto.Google Scholar
Boulyjenkov, V. (1992). “IInd International Meeting of the Milazzo Group on the ‘Genetic Revolution’,” Milazzo, Italy, July 1991. Reprinted inInternational Digest of Health Legislation 43(2):397–98.Google Scholar
Brumby, M. and Kasimba, P. (1987). “When is Cloning Lawful?” Journal of In Vitro Fertilization and Embryo Transfer 4:198–204.Google Scholar
Carmen, I.H. (1992). “Debates, Divisions, and Decisions: Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee (RAC) Authorization of the First Human Gene Transfer Experiments.” American Journal of Human Genetics 50:245–60.Google Scholar
Carmen, I.H. (1993). “Human Gene Therapy: A Biopolitical Overview and Analysis.” Human Gene Therapy 4:187–93.Google Scholar
Cook-Deegan, R.M. (1990). “Human Gene Therapy and Congress.” Human Gene Therapy 1:163–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
“Council of Europe Publishes Principles in the Field of Human Artificial Procreation” (1989). International Digest of Health Legislation 40(4):907–12.Google Scholar
“Document from the French National Ethics Committee” (1991). Human Gene Therapy 2:329.Google Scholar
“Document from the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, 1982, Thirty-Third Ordinary Session Recommendation 934 (1982) on Genetic Engineering” (1991). Human Gene Therapy 2:327–28.Google Scholar
Dokras, A., Sargent, I.L., Ross, C., Gardner, R.L., and Barlow, D.H. (1990). “Trophectoderm Biopsy in Human Blastocytes.” Human Reproduction 5:821–25.Google Scholar
Federal Register (1975). 40 (August 8):33527; 45 C.F.R. s.46.204(d).Google Scholar
Federal Register (1990). 55(March 1):7438–48.Google Scholar
First, N.L. (1991). “Manipulation Techniques with Potential Use in Animal Agriculture.” In Verlinsky, Y. and Kuliev, A. (eds.), Preimplantation Genetics. New York: Plenum.Google Scholar
Fletcher, J.C. and Anderson, W.F. (1992). “Germ-Line Gene Therapy: A New Stage of Debate.” Law, Medicine and Health Care 20:26–39.Google Scholar
“France's Three New Bioethics Bills” (1993). Biotechnology Business News (March 13, 1992). Westlaw 1993 Predicasts.Google Scholar
Fujiki, N. and Macer, D. (1992). “Second International Bioethics Seminar on Ethical, Legal and Social Issues Raised by Human Genome Research,” Fukui, Japan, March 1992. Reprinted inInternational Digest of Health Legislation 43(3):660–62.Google Scholar
“German Embryo Protection Act (October 24th, 1990): Gesetz zum Schutz von Embryonen” (1991). Human Reproduction 6(4):605–6.Google Scholar
Glover, J. et al.(1989). Ethics of New Reproductive Technologies: The Glover Report to the European Commission. DeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press.Google Scholar
Gordon, J. (1991). “Strategies for Human Germ Line Gene Therapy.” In Verlinsky, Y. and Kuliev, A. (eds.), Preimplantation Genetics. New York: Plenum.Google Scholar
Gordts, S., Camp, R., Vercruysse, M., Roziers, P., Swinnen, K., Wu, R., Decorte, R., Van Leuven, F., and Cassiman, J.J. (1992). “Biopsy of Polar Bodies and Pre-Implantation Embryos for Genetic Analysis.” Abstracts of the International Symposium on Preimplantation Genetics and Assisted Fertilization, Brussels.Google Scholar
Grifo, J.A., Boyle, A., Fischer, E., Lavy, G., DeCherney, A.H., Ward, D.C., and Sanyal, M.K. (1990). “Preembryo Biopsy and Analysis of Blastomeres by in situ Hybridization,” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 163:2013–19.Google Scholar
Handyside, A.H., Kontogianni, E.H., Hardy, K., and Winston, R.M.L. (1990). “Pregnancies from Biopsied Human Preimplantation Embryos Sexed by Y-Specific DNA Amplification.” Nature 344:768–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Handyside, A.H., Lesko, J.G., Tarin, J.J., Winston, R.M.L., and Hughes, M.R. (1992). “Birth of a Normal Girl after In Vitro Fertilization and Preimplantation Diagnostic Testing for Cystic Fibrosis.” New England Journal of Medicine 327(13):905–9.Google Scholar
Hotchkiss, R.D. (1965). “Portents for a Genetic Engineering,” Journal of Heredity 56:197–202.Google Scholar
“Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990” (1991). International Digest of Health Legislation 42(1):69–85.Google Scholar
“II Workshop on International Cooperation for the Human Genome Project: Ethics Adopts Valencia Declaration on Ethics and the Human Genome Project” (1991). Valencia, Spain, November 14, 1990. Reprinted inInternational Digest of Health Legislation 42(2):338–39.Google Scholar
Juengst, E.T. (1991). “Germ-Line Gene Therapy: Back to Basics.” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16(6):587–92.Google Scholar
Kirk, D. (1989). “Germany to Ban Embryo Use,” Science 245:464.Google Scholar
Knoppers, B.M. and LeBris, S. (1991). “Recent Advances in Medically Assisted Conception: Legal, Ethical and Social Issues.” American Journal of Law and Medicine 27(4):329–61.Google Scholar
Kolberg, R. (1993). “Human Embryo Cloning Reported,” Science 262:652–53.Google Scholar
Lappe, M. (1991). “Ethical Issues in Manipulating the Human Germ Line.” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16(6):621–39.Google Scholar
“Law No. 35/1988 of 22 November 1988 on Assisted Reproduction Procedures. Boletin Oficial del Estado, 24 November 1988, No. 282, pp. 33373-33378” (1989). Reprinted inInternational Digest of Health Legislation 38(4):782–85.Google Scholar
Mauron, A. and Thevoz, J-M. (1991). “Germ-Line Engineering: A Few European Voices.” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16(6):649–66.Google Scholar
Morgan, D. and Nielsen, L. (1993). “Prisoners of Progress or Hostages to Fortune?” Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 21:30–42.Google Scholar
Munson, R. and Davis, L.H. (1992), “Germ-Line Gene Therapy and the Medical Imperative.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 9(2): 137–58.Google Scholar
Navidi, W. and Arnheim, N. (1991). “Using PCR in Preimplantation Genetic Disease Diagnosis.” Human Reproduction 6:836–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
NIH Revitalization Act (1993). P.L. 103-43, 107 Stat. 133.Google Scholar
“Notification of the NIH Human Embryo Research Panel Meeting February 2-3, 1994 in Bethesda, Maryland” (1994). Science Policy Studies Center, Division of Science Policy Analysis and Development, National Institutes of Health, January 18.Google Scholar
Parliamentary Assembly, Council of Europe (1982). “Official Report of Debates.” Thirty-Third Ordinary Session (Third Part). Vol. III, Sittings 20 to 27, January 25-29.Google Scholar
Parliamentary Assembly, Council of Europe (1989). “Official Report of Debates.” Fortieth Ordinary Session (Third and Fourth Parts). Vol. III, Sittings 18 to 26, January 30-February 3.Google Scholar
“Parliamentary Assembly of Council of Europe Adopts Recommendation on Use of Human Embryos and Foetuses for Research Purposes” (1989). International Digest of Health Legislation 40(2):485–91.Google Scholar
Pergament, E. (1992). “Preimplantation Diagnosis: Patient Perspectives.” Prenatal Diagnosis 11:493–500.Google Scholar
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research (1982). Splicing Life: A Report on the Social and Ethical Issues of Genetic Engineering with Human Beings. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Robertson, J.A. (1992). “Ethical and Legal Issues in Preimplantation Genetic Screening.” Fertility and Sterility 57:1–11.Google Scholar
Trounson, A.L. (1992). “Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis—Counting Chickens before They Hatch?” Human Reproduction 7(5):583–84.Google Scholar
Verlinsky, Y., Ginsberg, N., Lifchez, A., Valle, J., Moise, J., and Strom, C.M. (1990). “Analysis of the First Polar Body: Preconception Genetic Diagnosis.” Human Reproduction 5(7):826–29.Google Scholar
Vogel, D. (1993). “Genetics and Physiology of Human Oocytes.” RFA:HD-94004. NIH Guide 22(17), April 30.Google Scholar
Walters, L. (1991). “Human Gene Therapy: Ethics and Public Policy.” Human Gene Therapy 2:115–22.Google Scholar
Warnock, M. (1991). “Reflections on the New United Kingdom Legislation on Human Fertilization and Embryology.” International Digest of Health Legislation 42(2):346–50.Google Scholar
Winston, R.M.L. and Handyside, A.H. (1993). “New Challenges in Human In Vitro Fertilization.” Science 260:932–36.Google Scholar
Wivel, N.A. and Walters, L. (1993). “Germ-Line Gene Modification and Disease Prevention: Some Medical and Ethical Perspectives.” Science 262:533–38.Google Scholar
“World Medical Association Adopts Declarations and Statements on Bioethical and Other Matters” (1988). International Digest of Health Legislation 39(1):267–74.Google Scholar
Zell, R. (1991). “Germany Moves to Outlaw Embryo Research.” New Scientist 123(1675):19(July 29).Google Scholar
Zimmerman, B.K. (1991). “Human Germ-Line Therapy: The Case for Its Development and Use.” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16:593–612.Google Scholar