Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-5lx2p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-31T10:04:57.004Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Soviet Antarctic plans after the International Geophysical Year: changes in policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 September 2009

Irina Gan
Irina Gan*
Affiliation:
Institute of Antarctic and Southern Ocean Studies, University of Tasmania, Private Bag 77, Hobart, Tasmania 7001, Australia (igan@postoffice.utas.edu.au)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The final months of the International Geophysical Year of 1957–1958 were a period when the political and scientific future of the Antarctic was being shaped, with many of the participating countries reassessing their policies regarding the South Polar region. This paper explores the thinking of both political and scientific figures in the USSR that helped mould Soviet Antarctic policy during this time and demonstrates that the two perspectives did not necessarily coincide. The political perspective is exemplified by the deputy chairman of the USSR council of ministers and member of the central committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union Aleksei Kosygin, and the scientific perspective by the deputy director of the Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute, Mikhail Somov. The fact that there was interplay between both viewpoints when planning the Soviet post IGY Antarctic programmes shows that political considerations did not always prevail over the scientific, with national prestige being an area in which their interests overlapped. Ultimately, Somov was instrumental in reducing to some extent the effects of the Soviet government's attempts to curtail Soviet Antarctic research operations when it was reassessing its policy in the light of new international initiatives regarding future collaboration in the Antarctic.

Type
Research Article
Information
Polar Record , Volume 46 , Issue 3 , July 2010 , pp. 244 - 256
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Annals of the IGY. 1958. Annals of the IGY part II. London, N.Y., Paris: Pergamon PressGoogle Scholar
Afanasiev, A. 1958. Meropriyatiya po obespecheniyu zavershayushchih rabot, svyazannih s otpravkoi i pribitiem k mestu naznacheniya 4 kompleksnoi Antarkticheskoi expeditsii, 19 Noyabria 1958 [Measures taken to ensure the completion of work related to the departure and arrival at final destination of the fourth composite Antarctic expedition. 19 November 1958]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2595.Google Scholar
Afanasiev, A. 1962. V Ministerstvo Morskogo Flota. Savinovu, 8 Yanvarya 1962 [To the ministry of the merchant fleet]. Radiogram to Savinov. 8 January 1962. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2612.Google Scholar
Avsiuk, Y. 1979. Dvadtsat let otkritiyu Polusa otnositelnoi nedostupnosti Antarktidi [The 20th anniversary of the opening of the Antarctic pole of inaccessibility station] URL: http://www.aari.aq/default_en.htmlGoogle Scholar
Belov, M. 1969. Istoriya otkritiya i issledovaniya [History of discovery and exploration]. In: Tostikov, E. (editor). Atlas Antarktiki [Atlas of Antarctica] vol 2. Leningrad: Hydrometeoizdat [Hydro Meteorological Service Press]:35–97.Google Scholar
Berg, L. 1949. Russkiye otkritiya v Antarktike i sovremennii interes k nei [Russian discoveries in the Antarctic and Present-day interests]. Izvestiya Vsesoyuznogo geograficheskogo obshchestva 2: 137–148.Google Scholar
Bertram, G. 1957. Antarctica today and tomorrow. Dunedin: University of Otago.Google Scholar
Birch, R. 1961. To Dr. F. Jacka, Antarctic division, Department of External Affairs. Exchange with the USSR. 7 March 1961. Canberra: National Archives of Australia 1838, 1495/13/5.Google Scholar
Boczek, B. 1984. Soviet Union and the Antarctic Treaty. American Journal of International Law 78 (4): 834–858.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boiko, L. 2007. Ot vseya Rossii blagodarnost i vechnaya v svete slava [From the whole of Russia: gratitude and eternal glory]. Unpublished manuscript (copy in possession of author).Google Scholar
Bourchier, M.G.M. 1956. For the secretary, Department of External Affairs. Soviet Antarctic Policy, 23 July 1956. Canberra, Australia: National Archives of Australia A1838, 1495/1/9/4 part 4.Google Scholar
Buinitski, V. 1945. Osnovniye itogi i perspektivi nauchno-isledovatelskih rabot Arkticheskogo instituta [Main results and opportunities for scientific research of the Arctic institute]. Moscow and Leningrad: Glavsevmorput Press.Google Scholar
Burhanov, V., and Tolstikov, E.. 1956. V Tsentralny Komitet KPSS tov. Pegovu 29 Marta 1956. [To the central committee of the CPSU, 29 March 1956, attention comrade Pegov]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvennii Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2584.Google Scholar
Burhanov, V. 1958. I.O. Direktora AANII P.Gordienko 23 Avgusta 1958 [To the acting director of the AARI P. Gordienko, 23 August 1958]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2595.Google Scholar
Conquest, R. 1961. Power and policy in the USSR. The study of Soviet dynastics. London: MacMillan and Co Ltd.Google Scholar
Dralkin, A. 1962. Radiogramma Afanasievu 3 Fevralya 1962 [Radiogram to Afanasiev 3 February 1962]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2612.Google Scholar
Gan, I. in press a. The Soviet preparation for the IGY Antarctic program and the Australian response: politics and science. Santiago, Chile: Scientific Committee on Antarctic Research (SCAR) (paper prepared for the second SCAR workshop on the history of Antarctic research entitled ‘Multidimensional exploration of Antarctica around the 1950s’, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Chile, Santiago, Chile, 21–22 September 2006).Google Scholar
Gan, I., in press b. Towards the great unknown: The Soviets prepare for their thrust into the Antarctic interior. Columbus, OH: Scientific Committee on Antarctic Research (SCAR) (paper prepared for the third SCAR workshop on the history of Antarctic research entitled ‘National and transnational agendas in Antarctic research from the 1950s and beyond’, Byrd Polar Research Center, Columbus, Ohio, USA, 25–26 October 2007).Google Scholar
Gan, I. 2009. ‘Will the Russians abandon Mirny to the penguins after 1959. . .or will they stay’? Polar Record 45 (233): 167–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gordienko, P., and Burdikina, A.. 1958. Vipiska iz protokola no 10 Zasedaniaya Uchenogo Soveta Arkticheskogo insituta ot 24 Maya 1958 [Excerpt from protocol No. 10 of the Academic Council of the Arctic Research Institute, 24 May 1958]. Moscow, Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2595.Google Scholar
Hall, R. 1994. International regime formation and leadership: the origins of the Antarctic Treaty. Unpublished PhD dissertation. Hobart: University of Tasmania: School of Government.Google Scholar
Hanessian, J. 1962. A select bibliography of the Polar regions. Polar area series II (1): 21–24 (American field staff reports service).Google Scholar
Joyner, C. 1991. A comparison of Soviet Arctic and Antarctic politics. In: Brigham, L. (editor). The Soviet maritime Arctic. London: Belhaven Press: 284–299.Google Scholar
Klotz, F. 1990. America on the ice. Antarctic policy issues. Washington: National Defence University Press.Google Scholar
Khozikov, V. 2004. Raketnie bogi Kremlia [The Kremlin's rocket gods]. Moscow: Yauza Eksmo.Google Scholar
Kosygin, A. 1958. Ukazaniya tovarisha A.N. Kosygina [Comrade A.N. Kosygin's instructions]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvennii Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2595.Google Scholar
Law, P. 1959. To M.G.M. Bourchier, 13 May 1959. Canberra, Australia: National Archives of Australia A1838, 1495/1/9/4 part 2.Google Scholar
Lebedev, V. 1960. Spravka o podgotovke atlasa Antarktiki. 8 Avgusta 1960 [Memorandum regarding the preparation of an Antarctic atlas. 8 August 1960]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvennii Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2604.Google Scholar
Lukin, V., Kornilov, N., and Dmitriev, N.. 2006. Sovetskiye i rossiiskiye antarcticheskiye expeditsii v tsifrah i faktah (1955–2005) [Soviet and Russian Antarctic expeditions – facts and figures (1955–2005)]. St. Petersburg: AARI.Google Scholar
MacDonald, R. 2006. Challenges and accomplishments: a celebration of the Arctic Institute of North America. Arctic 59 (4): 440–451. URL: http://pubs.aina.ucalgary.ca/arctic/Arctic58–4-440.pdfGoogle Scholar
Maksimov, I. 1945. Dokladnaya zapiska zamestitelyu nachalnika Glavsevmorputi pri SNK SSSR V. Novikovu Sentyabr 1945 [Report to the deputy director of Glavsevmorput at the council of the people's commissars, V. Novikov, September 1945]. Moscow, Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv sotsialno politicheskoi istorii [Russian State Archives for Social and Political History] file 475, op 1, d 43: 196.Google Scholar
Mann, E. 1974. National security policy for the Antarctic. Alabama: Air University.Google Scholar
Mather, K. 1957. ANARE executive planning committee report on USSR Antarctic station at Mirny, September 1957. Kingston, Tasmania, Australia: Australian Antarctic Division Library special collection.Google Scholar
Polushkin, V and Ushakov, S.. 1956. 44 voprosa po Antarktide [44 questions about Antarctica]. Tekhnika Molodezhi 2 (March) 1956: 2–9.Google Scholar
Sakharov, A. 1990. Memoirs. (translator Lourie, R.). London: Hutchinson.Google Scholar
Savatyugin, L., and Preobrazhenskaya, M.. 1999. Rossiiskie issledovaniya v Antarktike Tom 1 [Russian research in the Antarctic vol 1]. St Petersburg: Hydrometeoizdat [Hydrometeorological Service Press].Google Scholar
Savatyugin, L. 2004. Rossiiskaya nauka v Antarktike [Russian science in Antarctica]. Moscow: Gorodets.Google Scholar
Savatyugin, L. 2007. Polus holoda [Pole of cold]. Unpublished manuscript (copy in possession of author).Google Scholar
Schapiro, L. 1963. The communist party of the Soviet Union. London: Methuen and Co Ltd.Google Scholar
Smith, P. 1969. Prospects for international cooperation on the moon: the Antarctic analogy. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 25 (7): 36–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Somov, M. 1959. Poyasnitelnaya zapiska k planu rabot 5 SAE 1959–1961, 5 Maya1959 [Explanatory note about plans for the fifth SAE 1959–1961, 5 May 1959]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 3759.Google Scholar
Timofeev, ? 1947. Doklad o reshenii kollegii Glavsevmorputi ot 26.09 [1947] o vipolnenii postanovleniya partsobraniya Arkticheskogo institute ot 1.08.1947 po delu professorov Kluevoi i Roskina [Report of the Glavsevmorput board decision of 26 September [1947] regarding the implementation of the party meeting resolution of ARI of 1 August 1947 concerning the case of professors Klyueva and Roskin]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv sotsialno politicheskoi istorii [Russian State Archives for Social and Political History] file 475, op 1, d 43: 13–27.Google Scholar
Tolstikov, E. 1960. Somovu, 28 Marta 1960 [To M. Somov, 28 March 1960]. Moscow, Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2704.Google Scholar
Tolstikov, E. 1980. Na polyusah Antarctidi [On the poles of Antarctica]. Leningrad: Hydrometeoizdat [Hydro meteorological Service Press].Google Scholar
Tryoshnikov, A. 1961a. Plan probnih poletov v Antarctiku na samolyotah IL 18 i AN 12 v sezon XII-1961–III-1962 [Plan of trial flights to Antarctica of IL 18 and AN 12 planes in the XII-1961–III-1962 season]. Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2609.Google Scholar
Tryoshnikov, A. 1961b. Plan Sovetskih issledovaniy v Antarktike 1961–1980. [Plan of Soviet Research in Antarctica in 1961–1980]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2609.Google Scholar
Tryoshnikov, A. 1963. Istoriya otkritiya i issledovaniya Antarktidi [History of the discovery and investigation of Antarctica]. Moscow: Geografizdat [Geographical Literature Press].Google Scholar
USSR. 1949. Resolution of 10 February 1949 concerning Antarctica adopted by the All-Union Geographical Society. In: Bush, W.M. (editor). 1982. Antarctica and international law: a collection of inter-state and national documents vol 3. London: Oceana: 207–208.Google Scholar
USSR. 1950. USSR memorandum of 7–8 June 1950 on the participation of the Soviet Union in any international settlement concerning Antarctica. In: Bush, W.M. (editor). 1982. Antarctica and international law: a collection of inter-state and national documents vol 3. London: Oceana: 208–209.Google Scholar
USSR. 1958a. USSR note of 2 June 1958 to the United States accepting the United States invitation to attend an international conference on Antarctica. In: Bush, W.M. (editor). 1982. Antarctica and international law: a collection of inter-state and national documents vol 3. London: Oceana: 212–214.Google Scholar
USSR. 1958b. Plan rabot chetvertoi SAE AANII GSMP MMF SSSR na 1959–1960. [Plan of the fourth SAE, Glavsevmorput, ministry of the merchant navy of the USSR, 1959–1960]. Moscow: Rossiiskiy Gosudarstvenniy Archiv Economiki [Russian State Economics Archives] file 9570, op 2, ed hr 2595.Google Scholar
USSR. 1963. Trudi SAE Tom 26. Chetvertaia continentalnaya expeditsiya 1958–1960 [Annals of the SAE vol. 26. The fourth continental expedition 1958–1960]. Leningrad: Morskoy transport.Google Scholar
United States. 1958. United States note of 2 May 1958 to eleven countries inviting them to participate in a conference on Antarctica. In: Bush, W.M. (editor). 1982. Antarctica and international law: a collection of inter-state and national documents vol 3. London: Oceana: 473–475.Google Scholar
Wolk, S. 1958. The basis of Soviet claims in the Antarctic. Bulletin of the Institute for the Study of the USSR 5: 43–48.Google Scholar