Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-45l2p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T15:01:54.069Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Blind Man and the Elephant in the Room: Robert Lieberman and the Israel Lobby

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 May 2009

John J. Mearsheimer  and
Stephen M. Walt
John J. Mearsheimer
Affiliation:
University of Chicago. E-mail: j-mearsheimer@uchicago.edu
Stephen M. Walt
Affiliation:
John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University. E-mail: Stephen_Walt@harvard.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Robert Lieberman's critique of our work on the Israel lobby is at odds with an abundance of evidence and prior scholarship describing the powerful influence that pro-Israel groups exert on U.S. Middle East policy. In addition to mischaracterizing our arguments, Lieberman claims that our methodology and research design are flawed and that our work contradicts the scholarly literature on American politics. Neither claim is true. Contrary to what he says, we did consider alternative hypotheses, and our analysis contains significant variation on both the independent and dependent variables. Given the methodological challenges involved in assessing the causal influence of any interest group, we also relied heavily on “process-tracing.” Lieberman recognizes this is an appropriate method for assessing causal impact and he concedes that this evidence supports our central argument. Moreover, we went to some lengths to avoid selection bias. Similarly, our arguments are consistent with the existing literature on interest groups, and with much of the scholarly literature on congressional decision-making, campaign financing, electoral politics, and the role of think tanks and the media. Surprisingly, after leveling a variety of false charges, Lieberman offers an “alternative” explanation for the Israel lobby's influence that is virtually identical to our own.

Type
Exchange
Information
Perspectives on Politics , Volume 7 , Issue 2 , June 2009 , pp. 259 - 273
Copyright
Copyright © American Political Science Association 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ahrari, M.E., ed. 1987. Ethnic Groups and U.S. Foreign Policy. Westport: Greenwood.Google Scholar
Almanac of Federal PACs. 2006. Washington, DC: CQ Press.Google Scholar
Ansolabehere, Stephen, de Figueiredo, John M., and Snyder, James M. Jr. 2003. Why is there so little money in U.S. politics? Journal of Economic Perspectives 17 (1): 105–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ball, George W., and Ball, Douglas L.. 1992. The Passionate Attachment: America's Involvement with Israel from 1947 to the Present. New York: W. W. Norton.Google Scholar
Bard, Mitchell. 1991. The Water's Edge and Beyond: Defining the Limits to Domestic Influence on U.S. Middle East Policy. New York: Transaction Books.Google Scholar
Baumgartner, Frank R., and Leech, Beth L.. 1998. Basic Interests: The Importance of Groups in Politics and in Political Science. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Ben David, Calev. 2008. “Analyze This: Ninja Turtle Mogul Saban Rallies around Obama.” Jerusalem Post (online). August 31.Google Scholar
Berger, Matthew E. 2006. “U.S. Vote May Alter Stance on Middle East.” Jerusalem Post (online), November 7.Google Scholar
Besser, James. D. 2008. “Obama ‘Baffled’ by Jews' Resistance.” Jewish Week. July 23.Google Scholar
Biersack, Robert, Herrnson, Paul S., and Wilcox, Clyde, eds. 1994. Risky Business: PAC Decisionmaking in Congressional Elections. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.Google Scholar
Brown, Clifford W., Powell, Lynda W., and Wilcox, Clyde, eds. 1995. Serious Money: Fundraising and Contributing in Presidential Campaigns. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruck, Connie. 2008. “The Brass Ring: A Multimillionaire's Relentless Quest for Global Influence.” New Yorker, June 30.Google Scholar
Cigler, Allan J., and Loomis, Burdett A., eds. 2006. Interest Group Politics. Washington, DC: CQ Press.Google Scholar
Currinder, Marian. 2009. Money in the House: Campaign Funds and Congressional Party Politics. Boulder, CO: Westview.Google Scholar
Dekmejian, R. Hrair, and Themelis, Angelos. 1997. “Ethnic Lobbies in U.S. Foreign Policy: A Comparative Analysis of the Jewish, Greek Armenian and Turkish Lobbies.” Occasional Research Paper 13. Institute of International Relations, Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences. Athens.Google Scholar
Findley, Paul M. 1985. They Dare to Speak Out: People and Institutions Confront Israel's Lobby. Westport, CT: Lawrence Hill.Google Scholar
Fiorina, Morris, Peterson, Paul, Johnson, Bertram, and Mayer, William G.. 2006. The New American Democracy. 5th ed.New York: Longman.Google Scholar
Fox, Justin. 2006. “Electoral Donations and Interest Group Influence.” Unpublished paper available at http://pantheon.yale.edu/%7Ejf398/electoral.pdfGoogle Scholar
George, Alexander L., and Bennett, Andrew. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Goldberg, J. J. 1996. Jewish Power: Inside the American Jewish Establishment. New York: Perseus Books.Google Scholar
Goldwater, Barry M., Casserly, with Jack. 1988. Goldwater. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Guttman, Nathan. 2008. “New Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Draws Praise From All Sides.” Forward (online). April 24.Google Scholar
Hall, Richard, and Deardorff, Alan V.. 2006. Lobbying as legislative subsidy. American Political Science Review 100 (1): 69–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Richard, and Wayman, Frank W.. 1990. Buying time: Moneyed interest and the mobilization of bias in Congressional committees. American Political Science Review 84 (2): 797–820.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haney, Patrick, and Vanderbush, Walt. 1999. The role of ethnic interest groups in U.S. foreign policy: The case of the Cuban-American National Foundation. International Studies Quarterly 43 (1): 341–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hansen, John Mark. 1991. Gaining Access: Congress and the Farm Lobby, 1919–1981. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Herrnson, Paul S., and Wilcox, Clyde. 1994. Not so Risky Business: PAC Activity in 1992. In Risky Business: PAC Decisionmaking in Congressional Elections, ed. Biersack, Robert, Herrnson, Paul S., and Wilcox, Clyde. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.Google Scholar
Jacobson, Gary. 2004. The Politics of Congressional Elections. New York: Pearson Longman.Google Scholar
King, David, and Pomper, Miles. 2004. The U.S. Congress and the contingent influence of diaspora lobbies: Lessons from U.S. foreign policy toward Azerbaijan and Armenia. Journal of Armenian Studies 8 (1): 72–98.Google Scholar
Kollman, Ken. 1998. Outside Strategies: Public Opinion and Interest Groups. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kronholz, June, and Audi, Tamara. 2008. “Vegas Tycoon Bankrolls Republicans.” Wall Street Journal, July 15.Google Scholar
Levitt, Steven D. 1998. Are PACs trying to influence politicians or voters? Economics and Politics 10 (1): 19–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lieberman, Brett, and Guttman, Nathan. 2008. “Jimmy Carter Conspicuously Absent from Podium.” Forward (online). August 28.Google Scholar
Lieberman, Robert. 2009. The “Israel lobby” and American politics. Perspectives on Politics 7 (2): 235–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lind, Michael. 2002. “The Israel Lobby.” Prospect, April 1.Google Scholar
Massing, Michael. 2002a. “The Israel Lobby.” Nation, June 10.Google Scholar
Massing, Michael. 2002b. “Deal Breakers.” American Prospect, March 11.Google Scholar
Mathias, Charles McC. 1981. Ethnic groups and foreign policy. Foreign Affairs 59 (5): 975–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mearsheimer, John J., and Walt, Stephen M.. 2007. The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy. New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux.Google Scholar
Miller, Aaron David. 2008. The Much Too Promised Land: America's Elusive Search for Arab-Israeli Peace. New York: Bantam.Google Scholar
Peretz, Martin. 2008. “Biden Is More than Just a ‘Friend of Israel.’” Jerusalem Post, September 4.Google Scholar
Rubenzer, Trevor. 2008. Ethnic minority interest group attributes and U.S. foreign policy influence: A qualitative comparative analysis. Foreign Policy Analysis 4 (2): 169–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Said, A.A. 1981. Ethnicity and U.S. Foreign Policy. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
Shain, Yossi. 1994–95. Ethnic diasporas and U.S. foreign policy. Political Science Quarterly 109 (4): 811–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sheffer, Gabriel. 2003. Diaspora Politics: At Home Abroad. New York: Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Tony. 2000. Foreign Attachments: The Power of Ethnic Groups in the Making of American Foreign Policy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Snyder, James M. Jr. 1992. Long-term investing in politicians; or, Give early, give often. Journal of Law & Economics 35 (1): 15–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sorkin, Andrew Craig. 2004. “Schlepping toward Moguldom.” New York Times Magazine, September 5.Google Scholar
Stratmann, Thomas. 1992. Are contributors rational? Untangling strategies of political action committees. Journal of Political Economy 100 (3): 647–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stratmann, Thomas. 2002. Can special interests buy Congressional votes?: Evidence from financial services legislation. Journal of Law & Economics 45 (2): 345–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stratmann, Thomas. 2005. Some talk: Money in politics—A (partial) review of the literature. Public Choice 124 (1–2): 135–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tivnan, Edward. 1987. The Lobby: Jewish Political Power and American Foreign Policy. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
Trice, Robert H. 1976. Interest groups and the foreign policy process: U.S. policy in the Middle East. Sage Professional Papers in International Studies. Beverly Hills: Sage.Google Scholar
Uslaner, Eric M. 2006. American interests in the balance? Do ethnic groups dominate foreign policy making? In Interest Group Politics, ed. Cigler, Allan J. and Loomis, Burdett A.. Washington, DC: CQ Press.Google Scholar
Van Evera, Stephen. 1997. Guide to Methods for Students of Political Science. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Van Natta, Don. 2007. “Big Coffers and a Rising Voice Lift a New Conservative Group.” New York Times, September 30.Google Scholar
Wallace, Amy. 2008. “Haim Saban: Power Ranger.” Conde Nast Portfolio (online). September.Google Scholar
Watanabe, Paul. 1984. Ethnic Groups, Congress, and American Foreign Policy: The Politics of the Turkish Arms Embargo. Westport: Greenwood.Google Scholar