Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-gvh9x Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-20T02:27:03.208Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Writing the Arab-Israeli Conflict: Historical Bias and the Use of History in Political Science

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 March 2005

Jonathan B. Isacoff
Jonathan B. Isacoff
Affiliation:
Gonzaga University (isacoff@gonzaga.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

When doing political science research, how do we know that one story is not just as good as the next? Every historical school of thought purports to provide a “true” account of its subject matter. But contradictory schools of thought can not all be given equal weight. While much has been written on the epistemological question of objectivity in history, remarkably little work has been done regarding the practical problem encountered by political scientists faced with multiple narratives and historical bias. This essay develops a pragmatic method, which aims to evaluate historical narratives according to their utility in solving analytic and political problems. I illustrate the approach through the case of the Arab-Israeli conflict, where multiple, conflicting accounts of the “story” are vivid and copious. I conclude that while historical objectivity is elusive, some narratives are better than others at adjudicating both political science debates and “real-world” political problems.Jonathan B. Isacoff is assistant professor of political science at Gonzaga University (isacoff@gonzaga.edu). The author thanks Jennifer Hochschild, Bob Vitalis, Ian Lustick, and four anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments on earlier drafts.

Type
Research Article
Information
Perspectives on Politics , Volume 3 , Issue 1 , March 2005 , pp. 71 - 88
Copyright
© 2005 American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Allon, Yigal. 1970. Shield of David. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
Azure: Ideas for the Jewish Nation. 2004. What is Azure? http://www.shalem.org.il/azure/about.html.
Ben-Eliezer, Uri. 1998. The making of Israeli militarism. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Ben-Gurion, David. 1963. Israel: Years of challenge. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Ben-Gurion, David. 1971. Israel: A personal history. New York: Funk and Wagnalls.
Berkhofer, Robert F., Jr. 1995. Beyond the great story: History as text and discourse. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press.
Brecher, Michael. 1972. The foreign policy system of Israel: Setting, images, process. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Brecher, Michael. 1975. Decisions in Israel's foreign policy. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Bronner, Ethan. 1999a. Israel's history textbooks replace myths with facts. New York Times, August 14.
Bronner, Ethan. 1999b. Israel: The revised edition. Review of The iron wall: Israel and the Arab world, by Avi Shlaim, and Righteous Victims: A history of the Zionist-Arab conflict, 1881–1999, by Benny Morris. New York Times, November 14.
Carr, E. H. 1961. What is history? New York: Vintage Books.
Collingwood, R. G. 1963. The idea of history. New York: Galaxy. (Orig. pub. 1946.)
Dayan, Moshe. 1966. Diary of the Sinai campaign. Jerusalem: Steimatzky's Agency.
Dayan, Moshe. 1976. Moshe Dayan: Story of my life. New York: Morrow.
Dewey, John. 1938. Logic: The theory of inquiry. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Diner, Dan. 1995. Cumulative contingency: Historicizing legitimacy in Israeli discourse. In Israeli historiography revisited. Special issue, History and Memory 7 (1): 147–70.Google Scholar
Eban, Abba. 1968. My people: The story of the Jews. New York: Random House.
Eban, Abba. 1972. My country: The story of modern Israel. New York: Random House.
Eytan, Walter. 1958. The first ten years. London: Weidengeld and Nicolson.
Golani, Motti. 1998. Israel in search of a war: The Sinai campaign 1955–1956. Portland, OR: Sussex.
Handel, Michael I. 1973. Israel's political-military doctrine. Cambridge: Center for International Affairs, Harvard University.
Harkabi, Yehoshafat. 1983. The Bar Kokhba syndrome: Risk and realism in international politics. Chappaqua. NY: Rossel Books.
Haykal, Muhammad Hasanayn. 1998. Al-Urush wa'l-juyush: kadhalik infajara al-sira'a fi filastin [Thrones and armies: Thus erupted the struggle in Palestine], vol. 1. Cairo.
Herzog, Chaim. 1982. The Arab-Israeli wars: War and peace in the Middle East. New York: Random House.
Heydemann, Steven. 1991. Revisionism and the reconstruction of Israeli history. In Critical essays on Israeli society, politics, and culture, ed. Ian Lustick and Barry Rubin, 3–26. Albany, NY: SUNY.
Iggers, Georg. G. 1997. Historiography in the twentieth century: From scientific objectivity to the postmodern challenge. Hanover, NH: Wesleyan University Press.
Isacoff, Jonathan B. 2002. On the historical imagination of international relations: The case for a “Deweyan reconstruction.” Millennium: Journal of International Studies 31 (3): 603–26.Google Scholar
Isacoff, Jonathan B., and Wesley W. Widmaier. 2003. Constructing the Six-Day War: Strategic interpretation and the transformation of Israeli national interests. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association (ISA).
Israel Office of Information. 1960. Israel's struggle for peace. New York: Israel Office of Information.
Jenkins, Keith. 1997. The postmodern history reader. London: Routledge.
Jenkins, Keith. 1999. Why history? Ethics and postmodernity. New York: Routledge.
Khalidi, Walid. 1998. Al-Sihyunniyya fi mi ’at ‘am, 1897–1997 [A century of Zionism]. Beirut: Dar al-Nahar.
Khalidi, Walid. 1992. All that remains: The Palestinian villages occupied and depopulated by Israel in 1948. Washington, DC: Institute for Palestine Studies.
Khalidi, Walid, ed. 1987. From haven to conquest: Readings in Zionism and the Palestine problem until 1948. Washington, DC: Institute for Palestine Studies.
Khalidi, Walid, and Jill Khadduri, eds. 1974. Palestine and the Arab-Israeli conflict: An annotated bibliography. Beirut: Institute for Palestine Studies.
Kimmerling, Baruch. 1995. Academic history caught in the cross-fire: The case of Israeli-Jewish historiography. In Israeli historiography revisited. Special issue, History and Memory 7 (1): 41–65.Google Scholar
Khouri, Fred J. 1985. The Arab Israeli dilemma, 3rd ed. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press.
King, Gary, Robert Keohane, and Sidney Verba. 1994. Designing social inquiry: Scientific inference in qualitative research. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Kurtzer, Daniel C. 2002. American Jews and Israel. Address to North American Leaders, King David Hotel, Jerusalem, March 1. http://www.usembassy-israel.org.il/publish/mission/amb/030102.html.
Lakatos, Imre. 1970. Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. In Criticism and the growth of knowledge, ed. Imre Lakatos and Alan Musgrave, 91–196. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Levy, Daniel. 1999. The future of the past: Historiographical disputes and competing memories in Germany and Israel. History and Theory 38 (1): 51–66.Google Scholar
Levy, Yagil. 1997. Trial and error: Israel's route from war to de-escalation. Albany, NY: SUNY.
Lustick, Ian S. 1996. History, historiography, and political science: Multiple records and the problem of selection bias. American Political Science Review 90 (3): 605–18.Google Scholar
Lynfield, Ben. 1999. A boost for Palestinian statehood. Jerusalem Post, January 3.
Matar, Gamil, and al-Din Hilal. 1983. Ali, al-niazm al-iqlimi al-arabi [The Arab regional order]. Beirut: Dar al-Mustaqbal al-Arabi.
Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI). 2001. The Arabs are responsible. Post-Zionist historian Benny Morris clarifies his thesis. Special Dispatch Series, No. 310, December 9. http://memri.org/bin/articles.cgi?Page=archives&Area=sd&ID=SP31001.
Morris, Benny. 1993. Israel's border wars 1949–1956: Arab infiltration, Israeli retaliation, and the countdown to the Suez War. New York: Oxford University Press.
Morris, Benny. 1999. Righteous victims: A history of the Zionist-Arab conflict, 1881–1999. New York: Knopf.
Morris, Benny. 2002a. Camp David and after: An exchange (An interview with Ehud Barak). New York Review of Books 49 (10): 42–46.Google Scholar
Morris, Benny. 2002b. Peace? No chance. Guardian, February 21. http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/comment/0,10551,653594,00.html.
Morris, Benny. 2004. Birth of the Palestinian refugee problem revisited. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Netanyahu, Benjamin. 2000. A durable peace: Israel and its place among the nations. New York: Warner Books.
Novick, Peter. 1988. That noble dream: The “objectivity question” and the American historical profession. New York: Cambridge University Press.
O'Ballance, Edgar. 1957. The Arab-Israeli War, 1948. New York: Praeger.
Oren, Michael B. 1992. Origins of the second Arab-Israeli war: Egypt, Israel, and the great powers, 1952–56. London: Frank Cass.
Oren, Michael B. 2002. Six days of war: June 1967 and the making of the modern Middle East. New York: Oxford University Press.
Pappé, Ilan. 1995. Critique and agenda: The post-Zionist scholars in Israel. In Israeli historiography revisited. Special issue, History and Memory 7 (1): 66–90.Google Scholar
Pappé, Ilan. 1997. Post-Zionist critique on Israel and the Palestinians. Journal of Palestine Studies 26 (2): 29–41.Google Scholar
Pappé, Ilan, ed. 1999. The Israel/Palestine question. London: Routledge.
Patomaki, Heikki, and Colin Wight. 2000. After postpositivism? The promises of critical realism. International Studies Quarterly 44 (2): 213–37.Google Scholar
Peleg, Ilan. 1987. Begin's foreign policy, 1977–1983: Israel's move to the right. New York: Greenwood Press.
Penslar, Derek Jonathan. 1995. Innovation and revisionism in Israeli historiography. In Israeli historiography revisited. Special issue, History and Memory 7 (1): 125–46.Google Scholar
Peres, Shimon. 1993. The new Middle East. New York: Henry Holt.
Polisar, Daniel. 2000. Making history. Azure 1 (1): 14–22.Google Scholar
Ram, Uri. 1995. Zionist historiography and the invention of modern Jewish nationhood: The Case of Ben Zion Dinur. In Israeli historiography revisited. Special issue, History and Memory 7 (1): 91–124.Google Scholar
Roberts, Samuel J. 1973. Survival or hegemony? The foundations of Israeli foreign policy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Rorty, Richard. 1979. Philosophy and the mirror of nature. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Rorty, Richard. 1991. Objectivity, relativism, and truth. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Rothenberg, Gunther E. 1979. The anatomy of the Israeli army. London: B. T. Batsford.
Sachar, Howard. 1979. A history of Israel: From the rise of Zionism to our time. New York: Knopf.
Safran, Nadav. 1969. From war to war: The Arab-Israeli confrontation, 1948–1967. New York: Pegasus.
Safire, William. 2002. A chat with Sharon. New York Times, October 21.
Said, Edward. 1995. The politics of dispossession: The struggle for Palestinian self-determination, 1969–1994. New York: Vintage.
Said, Edward. 1996. Peace and its discontents: Essays on Palestine in the Middle East peace process. New York: Vintage.
Schweller, Randall. 1992. Domestic structure and preventive war: Are democracies more pacific? World Politics 44 (2): 235–69.Google Scholar
Sela, Avraham. 1998. The decline of the Arab-Israeli conflict: Middle East politics and the quest for regional order. Ithaca, NY: SUNY Press.
Shapira, Anita. 1995. Politics and collective memory: The debate over the “new historians” in Israel. In Israeli historiography revisited. Special issue, History and Memory 7 (1): 9–40.Google Scholar
Sharett, Moshe. 1980. Personal diary excerpts. In Livia Rokach, Israel's sacred terrorism: A study based on Moshe Sharett's personal diary. Belmont, MA: Association of Arab-American University Graduates.
Shavit, Ari. 2004. Survival of the Fittest. Interview with Benny Morris. http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=380986&sw=Beni%20Morris.
Sheffer, Gabriel. 1996. Moshe Sharett: Biography of a political moderate. New York: Oxford University Press.
Shlaim, Avi. 1999. His royal shyness: King Hussein and Israel. Interview with King Hussein. New York Review of Books, July 15.
Shlaim, Avi. 2000. The iron wall: Israel and the Arab world. New York: W. W. Norton.
Shook, John R. 2000. Dewey's empirical theory of knowledge and reality. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press.
Slater, Jerome. 1994. The significance of Israeli historical revisionism. In Critical essays on Israeli social issues and scholarship, ed. Walter P. Zenner and Russell A. Stone, 179–200. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Tilly, Charles. 1985. War making and state making as organized crime. In Bringing the state back in, ed. Peter B. Evans, Dietrich Rueschemeyer, and Theda Skocpol, 169–91. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tilly, Charles. 1992. Coercion, capital, and European states, AD 990–1990. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
von Ranke, Leopold. 1973. The theory and practice of history. ed. Georg G. Iggers and Konrad von Moltke. New York: Irvington Publishers.
Walt, Stephen M. 1987. The origins of alliances. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
White, Hayden. 1980. The value of narrativity in the representation of reality. Critical Inquiry 7 (1): 5–27.Google Scholar