Skip to main content Accessibility help

Conservation payments in a social context: determinants of tolerance and behavioural intentions towards wild cats in northern Belize

  • Rebecca G. Harvey (a1), Venetia Briggs-Gonzalez (a1) and Frank J. Mazzotti (a1)


Carnivores are valued by conservationists globally but protecting them can impose direct costs on rural, livestock-dependent communities. Financial incentives are increasingly used with the goal of increasing people's tolerance of predators, but the definition of tolerance has been vague and inconsistent. Empirical correlations between attitudinal and behavioural measures of tolerance imply that attitudes may be a valid proxy for behaviours. However, theoretical differences between the concepts suggest that attitudinal tolerance and behavioural intention to kill cats would have different underlying determinants. We surveyed 112 residents within a forest–farm mosaic in northern Belize inhabited by jaguars Panthera onca and four other species of wild cats. A conservation payment programme pays local landowners when camera traps record cat presence on their land. Results indicated that tolerance was associated with gender and participation in the camera-trapping programme, whereas intention to kill cats was associated with cultural group (Mennonites vs Mestizos), presence of children in the home and, to a lesser extent, tolerance. Neither dependent variable was significantly related to depredation losses or economic factors. Results suggest that monetary payments alone are unlikely to affect attitudes and behaviours towards carnivores. Payment programmes may be enhanced by accentuating non-monetary incentives, leveraging social norms and targeting specific groups with information about risks and benefits associated with carnivores. By empirically separating two concepts commonly conflated as ‘tolerance’ we clarify understanding of how social forces interact with financial incentives to shape people's relationships with predators.


Corresponding author

(Corresponding author) E-mail


Hide All

Also at: Lamanai Field Research Center, Indian Church Village, Orange Walk, Belize



Hide All
Agarwala, M., Kumar, S., Treves, A. & Naughton-Treves, L. (2010) Paying for wolves in Solapur, India and Wisconsin, USA: comparing compensation rules and practice to understand the goals and politics of wolf conservation. Biological Conservation, 143, 29452955.
Ajzen, I. (1985) From intentions to actions: a theory of planned behavior. In Action Control: From Cognition to Behavior (eds Kuhl, J. & Beckmann, J.), pp. 1139. Springer, Heidelberg, Germany.
Bagchi, S. & Mishra, C. (2006) Living with large carnivores: predation on livestock by the snow leopard (Uncia uncia). Journal of Zoology, 268, 217224.
Bauer, H., Müller, L., Van Der Goes, D. & Sillero-Zubiri, C. (2015) Financial compensation for damage to livestock by lions Panthera leo on community rangelands in Kenya. Oryx,
Briggs-Gonzalez, V.S. & Mazzotti, F.J. (2014) Camera trapping wild cats with landowners in northern Belize. Caribbean Naturalist, 17, 113.
Bruskotter, J.T. & Fulton, D.C. (2012) Will hunters steward wolves? A comment on Treves and Martin. Society & Natural Resources, 25, 97102.
Bruskotter, J.T., Singh, A., Fulton, D.C. & Slagle, K. (2015) Assessing tolerance for wildlife: clarifying relations between concepts and measures. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 20, 255270.
Bruskotter, J.T. & Wilson, R.S. (2014) Determining where the wild things will be: using psychological theory to find tolerance for large carnivores. Conservation Letters, 7, 158165.
Bulte, E.H. & Rondeau, D. (2005) Why compensating wildlife damages may be bad for conservation. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 69, 1419.
Carpenter, L.H., Decker, D.J. & Lipscomb, J.F. (2000) Stakeholder acceptance capacity in wildlife management. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 5, 519.
Chen, X., Lupi, F., He, G. & Liu, J. (2009) Linking social norms to efficient conservation investment in payments for ecosystem services. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106, 1181211817.
Conforti, V.A. & De Azevedo, F.C.C. (2003) Local perceptions of jaguars (Panthera onca) and pumas (Puma concolor) in the Iguaçu National Park area, south Brazil. Biological Conservation, 111, 215221.
Curry, J.M. (2000) Community worldview and rural systems: a study of five communities in Iowa. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 90, 693712.
Delibes-Mateos, M. (2014) Negative attitudes towards predators do not necessarily result in their killing. Oryx, 48, 16.
Dickman, A.J., Macdonald, E.A. & Macdonald, D.W. (2011) A review of financial instruments to pay for predator conservation and encourage human–carnivore coexistence. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108, 1393713944.
Dillman, D.A., Smyth, J.D. & Christian, L.M. (2014) Internet, Phone, Mail, and Mixed-Mode Surveys: The Tailored Design Method, 4th edition. Wiley, Hoboken, USA.
Ferraro, P.J. & Kiss, A. (2002) Direct payments to conserve biodiversity. Science, 298, 17181719.
Figel, J.J., Durán, E. & Bray, D.B. (2011) Conservation of the jaguar Panthera onca in a community-dominated landscape in montane forests in Oaxaca, Mexico. Oryx, 45, 554560.
Fisher, M. (2016) Whose conflict is it anyway? Mobilizing research to save lives. Oryx, 50, 377378.
Fulton, D.C., Manfredo, M.J. & Lipscomb, J. (1996) Wildlife value orientations: a conceptual and measurement approach. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 1, 2447.
Genzinger, P.G. (1995) Mennonite representations of nature in the nineteenth century. MA thesis. University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Goldman, M.J., Roque De Pinho, J. & Perry, J. (2013) Beyond ritual and economics: Maasai lion hunting and conservation politics. Oryx, 47, 490500.
Gore, M.L. & Kahler, J.S. (2012) Gendered risk perceptions associated with human–wildlife conflict: implications for participatory conservation. PLoS ONE, 7(3), e32901.
Harvey, R.G., Perez, L. & Mazzotti, F.J. (2015) Not seeing is not believing: volunteer beliefs about Burmese pythons in Florida and implications for public participation in invasive species removal. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 59, 789807.
Hazzah, L., Dolrenry, S., Naughton-Treves, L., Edwards, C.T., Mwebi, O., Kearney, F. & Frank, L. (2014) Efficacy of two lion conservation programs in Maasailand, Kenya. Conservation Biology, 28, 851860.
Hazzah, L., Mulder, M.B. & Frank, L. (2009) Lions and warriors: social factors underlying declining African lion populations and the effect of incentive-based management in Kenya. Biological Conservation, 142, 24282437.
Heberlein, T.A. (2012) Navigating Environmental Attitudes. Oxford University Press, New York, USA.
Inskip, C. & Zimmermann, A. (2009) Human–felid conflict: a review of patterns and priorities worldwide. Oryx, 43, 1834.
IUCN (2014) The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species v. 2014.1. [accessed 28 July 2015].
Kaltenborn, B.P., Bjerke, T. & Nyahongo, J. (2006) Living with problem animals—self-reported fear of potentially dangerous species in the Serengeti Region, Tanzania. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 11, 397409.
Karanth, K.U. & Chellam, R. (2009) Carnivore conservation at the crossroads. Oryx, 43, 12.
Karlsson, J. & Sjostrom, M. (2011) Subsidized fencing of livestock as a means of increasing tolerance for wolves. Ecology & Society, 16, 16.
Koenker, R. (1981) A note on studentizing a test for heteroscedasticity. Journal of Econometrics, 17, 107112.
Lambert, J.D.H. & Arnason, J.T. (1978) Distribution of vegetation on Maya ruins and its relationship to ancient land use at Lamanai, Belize. Turrialba, 28, 3341.
Lindsey, P.A., Du Toit, J.T. & Mills, M.G.L. (2005) Attitudes of ranchers towards African wild dogs Lycaon pictus: conservation implications on private land. Biological Conservation, 125, 113121.
Lindsey, P.A., Havemann, C.P., Lines, R., Palazy, L., Price, A.E., Retief, T.A. et al. (2013) Determinants of persistence and tolerance of carnivores on Namibian ranches: implications for conservation on Southern African private lands. PLoS ONE, 8(1), e52458.
Lute, M.L., Bump, A. & Gore, M.L. (2014) Identity-driven differences in stakeholder concerns about hunting wolves. PLoS ONE, 9(12), e114460.
Marchini, S. & Macdonald, D.W. (2012) Predicting ranchers’ intention to kill jaguars: case studies in Amazonia and Pantanal. Biological Conservation, 147, 213221.
Naughton-Treves, L., Grossberg, R. & Treves, A. (2003) Paying for tolerance: rural citizens’ attitudes toward wolf depredation and compensation. Conservation Biology, 17, 15001511.
Nelson, F. (2009) Developing payments for ecosystem services approaches to carnivore conservation. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 14, 381392.
Noss, A.J. & Cuéllar, R.L. (2001) Community attitudes towards wildlife management in the Bolivian Chaco. Oryx, 35, 292300.
Ogra, M.V. (2008) Human–wildlife conflict and gender in protected area borderlands: a case study of costs, perceptions, and vulnerabilities from Uttarakhand (Uttaranchal), India. Geoforum, 39, 14081422.
Persson, J., Rauset, G.R. & Chapron, G. (2015) Paying for an endangered predator leads to population recovery. Conservation Letters, 8, 345350.
Redpath, S.M., Bhatia, S. & Young, J. (2015) Tilting at wildlife: reconsidering human–wildlife conflict. Oryx, 49, 222225.
Ripple, W.J., Estes, J.A., Beschta, R.L., Wilmers, C.C., Ritchie, E.G., Hebblewhite, M. et al. (2014) Status and ecological effects of the world's largest carnivores. Science, 343,
Roessingh, C. (2007) Mennonite communities in Belize. International Journal of Business and Globalisation, 1, 107124.
Romañach, S.S., Lindsey, P.A. & Woodroffe, R. (2007) Determinants of attitudes towards predators in central Kenya and suggestions for increasing tolerance in livestock dominated landscapes. Oryx, 41, 185195.
Slagle, K.M., Zajac, R.M., Bruskotter, J.T., Wilson, R.S. & Prange, S. (2013) Building tolerance for bears: a communications experiment. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 77, 863869.
Soto-Shoender, J.R. & Main, M.B. (2013) Differences in stakeholder perceptions of the jaguar Panthera onca and puma Puma concolor in the tropical lowlands of Guatemala. Oryx, 47, 109112.
Thorn, M., Green, M., Marnewick, K. & Scott, D.M. (2015) Determinants of attitudes to carnivores: implications for mitigating human–carnivore conflict on South African farmland. Oryx, 49, 270277.
Trapasso, L.M. (1994) Indigenous attitudes, ecotourism, and Mennonites: recent examples in rainforest destruction/preservation. GeoJournal, 33, 449452.
Treves, A. (2012) Tolerant attitudes reflect an intent to steward: a reply to Bruskotter and Fulton. Society & Natural Resources, 25, 103104.
Treves, A. & Bruskotter, J. (2014) Tolerance for predatory wildlife. Science, 344, 476477.
Zabel, A. & Holm-Müller, K. (2008) Conservation performance payments for carnivore conservation in Sweden. Conservation Biology, 22, 247251.
Zimmermann, A., Walpole, M.J. & Leader-Williams, N. (2005) Cattle ranchers’ attitudes to conflicts with jaguar Panthera onca in the Pantanal of Brazil. Oryx, 39, 406412.
Zinn, H.C. & Pierce, C.L. (2002) Values, gender, and concern about potentially dangerous wildlife. Environment and Behavior, 34, 239256.



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed