Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-xq9c7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-18T18:59:46.420Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Through a Green Lens: The Construction of Customary Environmental Law and Community in Indonesia's Maluku Islands

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 April 2024

Charles Zerner
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the Maluku Islands of Eastern Indonesia, a center of global diversity in coral reef systems and the historic center of trade in cloves and other spices, tenure practices known as sasi have flourished for at least a century. This article analyzes changes in the ways Dutch colonial officials, Indonesian government officials, and environmental NGOs have interpreted Moluccan customary law and local institutions. Dutch colonial accounts of sasi, a generic name for a historic family of institutions, laws, and ritual practices that regulated access to fields, reefs, and rivers, suggest that sasi was a synthetic, highly variable body of practices linked to religious beliefs and local cultural ideas of nature. During the past two decades, as international and national conservation discourses have proliferated and a movement has developed to support indigenous Indonesian cultural communities, Indonesian NGOs and the Ministry of the Environment have promoted, and largely created, images of sasi as an environmental institution and body of customary law promoting sustainable development, conservation, and social equity. This article focuses on how sasi has been continuously reinterpreted by a variety of actors, following the trajectory of changing institutional interests and images.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 28 , Issue 5: Symposium: Community and Identity in Sociolegal Studies , 1994 , pp. 1079 - 1122
Copyright
Copyright © 1994 by The Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This essay is based on fieldwork conducted in the Moluccas during July 1994, as well as two months' field research there during 1991, sponsored by the Fisheries Research and Development Project of the Central Fisheries Research Institute and supported by the United States Agency for International Development. Archival research was conducted during my tenure at the Woodrow Wilson Center (1991-92) and the Rainforest Alliance. Support for preparation of this manuscript was provided by the Rockefeller Brothers Foundation (1994), the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars (Asia Program 1991-92), the Liz Claiborne and Art Ortenberg Foundation, and The Rainforest Alliance. Many people and organizations contributed to my understanding of sasi. I acknowledge the assistance of Carla Sapsford and Henry Heuveling van Beek in translating several Dutch language texts; Hasmi Bandjar, my colleague during field research; Francis Gouda's scholarly insights on the Dutch colonial law enterprise; and James Collins's linguistic assistance. I also acknowledge productive discussions with Iwan Tjitradjaja (University of Indonesia), Cliff Marlessy, Meentze Simatauw, and Kalvein Khuouw (HUALOPU), Sandra Moniaga and Suraya Affif (Indonesian Environmental Forum), Martha Belcher, and the Environmental Studies Center of the University of Pattimura and the Institute for Fisheries Research. The fishermen, local government leaders, and kewang of Saparua, Halmahera, Hatta, Ai, and Ran islands made this intellectual journey possible. Peter Riggs offered enthusiasm and material support for my recent research. Special thanks to Toby Alice Volkman, whose insights and careful comments inform this work. All the usual disclaimers apply. An earlier version was presented at a panel on "Comparing State Policy and Local Resource Tenure across Asia" at the Association of Asian Studies meeting, 25--27 March 1994, Boston.

References

REFERENCES

Abrahamsz, James (1991) “Nasib Lola dan Lembaga Sasi di Kepulauan Kei, Maluku Tenggara (Fate of the Trochus and Sasi Institutions in the Kei Archipelago, Southeast Maluku),” 9 (No. 48) KabarDari Kampung (News from the Village) 52 (Irian Jaya, Indonesia).Google Scholar
Acciaioli, Gregory (1985) “Culture as Art: From Practice to Spectacle in Indonesia,” 8 (nos. 1 & 2) Canberra Anthropology 148.Google Scholar
Andaya, Leonard Y. (1993) The World of Maluku: Eastern Indonesia in the Early Modern Period. Honolulu: Univ. of Hawaii Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Appadurai, Arjun (1990) “Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Culture Economy,” 2 (2) Public Culture 1.Google Scholar
Apponno, John, trans. (1977) “Peraturan Kewan Negeri Porto Tahun 1870” (Kewan Regulations of Porto Village Year 1870). Ambon: Center for Information Documentation HUALOPU.Google Scholar
Bailey, Connor, & Zerner, C. (1992) “Community-based Management of Fisheries Resources in indonesia,” Maritime Anthropological Studies 5(1).Google Scholar
Baker, Russ W. (1994) “The Deforesting of Irian Jaya,” Nation, 1 Feb., 162.Google Scholar
Barber, Charles Victor (1990) “The Legal and Regulatory Framework for Forest Production in Indonesia,” in Zerner 1990.Google Scholar
Bartels, Dieter (1977) “Guarding the Invisible Mountain: Intervillage Alliance, Religious Syncretism and Ethnic Identity among Amonese Christians and Moslems in the Moluccas.” Ph.D. diss., Cornell Univ.Google Scholar
Berwick, Nora (1989) “Background Paper on Indonesia's Coastal Resources Sector.” Washington, DC: Office of Forestry, Environment, & Natural Resources, U.S. Agency for International Development.Google Scholar
Bowen, John R. (1989) “Narrative Form and Political Incorporation: Changing Uses of History in Aceh, Indonesia,” 31 Comparative Studies in Society & History 671.Google Scholar
Breckenridge, Lee P. (1993) “Protection of Biological and Cultural Diversity: Emerging Recognition of Local Community Rights in Ecosystems under International Environmental Law,” 59 Tennessee Law Rev. 735.Google Scholar
Chauvel, Richard (1990) Nationalists, Soldiers and Separatists: The Ambonese Islands from Colonialism to Revolt, 1880-1950. Leiden: KITLV Press.Google Scholar
Cohn, Bernard S. (1983) “Representing Authority in Victorian India,” in Hobsbawm & Ranger 1983.Google Scholar
Colchester, Marcus (1990) “A Future on the Land? Logging and the Status of Native Customary Land in Sarawak,” 19 Ilmu Masyarakat 36.Google Scholar
Cole, David (1986) “Agon at Agora: Creative Misreadings in the First Amendment Tradition,” 95 Yale Law J. 857.Google Scholar
Dove, Michael R. (1983) “Theories of Swidden Agriculture, and the Political Economy of Ignorance,” 1 Agroforestry Systems 85.Google Scholar
Down to Earth (1992) “Forest Reserves Opposed for Logging,” Down to Earth, 17 June (published in London, Eng. by Survival International).Google Scholar
Ellen, Roy F. (1979) “Sago Subsistence and the Trade in Spices: A Provisional Model of Ecological Succession and Imbalance in Moluccan History,” in Burnham, P. C. & Ellen, R. F., eds., Social and Ecological Systems. New York: Academic Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, Jefferson, ed. (1993) “Legal Frameworks for Forest Management in Asia: Case Studies of Community/State Relations.” East-West Center Program on Environment, Occasional Paper No. 16. Honolulu: East-West Center.Google Scholar
Fried, Stephanie (1994) “Writing for Their Lives: Bentian Dyak Authors and Indonesian Development Discourses.” Manuscript, Rural Sociology Program, Cornell Univ.Google Scholar
Gouda, Frances (1994) “A Cunning David amidst the Goliaths of Empire: Dutch Colonial Practice in the Indonesian Archipelago.” Presented at Annual Meeting of the Social Science & History Association, Baltimore (7 Nov.).Google Scholar
Grove, Richard (1992) “Origins of Western Environmentalism,” 267 Scientific American 42 (July).Google Scholar
Gupta, Anil & Ferguson, Jame (1992) “Beyond ‘Culture’: Space, Identity, and the Politics of Difference,” 7 (1) Cultural Anthropology 63.Google Scholar
Hanna, Willard A. (1991) Indonesian Banda: Colonialism and Its Aftermath in the Nutmeg Islands. Banda Naira: Banda Naira Heritage & Culture Institute.Google Scholar
Hobsbawm, Eric, & Ranger, Terence, eds. (1983) The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Holleman, F. D. (1923) Het adat-grondenrecht van Ambon en de Oelaisers. Delft: Meinema.Google Scholar
Post, Jakarta (1992) “Forest Concession in Yamdena Stands Despite Bloody Clash,” Jakarta Post, 24 Sept.Google Scholar
Khouow, Kalvein, & Simatauw, M. (1991) “Hasil Survei Sosial Ekonomi Masyarakat Pulau Pulau Aru, Maluku Tenggara” (Results of a Socio-economic Survey of Aru Archipelago Communities). Ambon: Yayasan HUALOPU.Google Scholar
Korps Kewang Negeri Ihamahu (Kewang Corps Ihamahu Village) (1987) “Korps Kewang Ihamahu dan Lingkungan Hidup” (Kewang Corps of Ihamahu and the Living Environment). Speech presented by the Kewang Corps of Ihamahu at Nature Conservation Education Society meetings, Ambon (2–9July).Google Scholar
Lokollo, J. E. (1988) “Hukum Sasi di Maluku: Satu Portet Binamulia Lingkungan Pedesaan Yang Dicari Oleh Pemerintah” (Sasi Law in the Maluku: A Noble Portrait of the Village Environment Sought by the Government). Presented on 25th Anniversary of Univ. of Pattimura, Ambon.Google Scholar
Lynch, Owen (1992) “Securing Community-based Tenurial Rights in the Tropical Forests of Asia: An Overview of Current and Prospective Strategies.” World Resource Institute, Center for International Development & Environment, Issues in Development #1. Washington, DC: the Institute.Google Scholar
Malikki, Lisa (1992) “The Rooting of Peoples and the Territorialization of National Identity among Scholars and Refugees,” 7 (1) Culture Anthropobgy 24.Google Scholar
Matatula, A. (1990) “Sejarah Bia Lola (Trochus Niloticus) Di Desa Nolloth (Kecematan Saparua)” (History of the Lola (Trochus Niloticus) in Nolloth Village (District of Saparua). On file with Matatula, Village Head, Nolloth, Saparua Island, Central Maluku Province.Google Scholar
Moniaga, Sandra (1993) “Toward Community-based Forestry and Recognition of Adat Property Rights in the Outer Islands of indonesia,” in Fox 1993.Google Scholar
Peletz, Michael G. (1993) “Sacred Texts and Dangerous Words: The Politics of Law and Cultural Rationalization in Malaysia,” 35 Comparative Studies in Society & History 66.Google Scholar
Peluso, Daniela (1993) “Conservation and Indigenismo,” Hemisphere, p. 6 (Winter/Spring).Google Scholar
Poffenberger, Mark, & McGean, Betsy (1993a) “Communities and Forest Management in East Kalimantan: Pathway to Environmental Stability.” Center for Southeast Asia Studies, Southeast Asia Sustainable Forest Management Research Network Report #3. Berkeley: Center for Southeast Asia Studies, University of California.Google Scholar
Poffenberger, Mark (1993b) “Upland Philippine Communities: Guardians of the Final Forest Frontiers.” Center for Southeast Asia Studies, Southeast Asia Sustainable Forest Management Research Network Report #4. Berkeley: Center for Southeast Asia Studies, University of California.Google Scholar
Poole, Peter, ed. (1995) “Geomatics: Special Issue on Mapping, Territory, and Indigenous Peoples,” 18 (4) Cultural Survival Q. 1.Google Scholar
Rahail, J. P. (1993) Larwul Ngabal: Hukum Adat Kei Bertahan Menghadapi Arus Perubahan“ (Larwul Ngabal: Kei Customary Law Survives Changing Currents). Seri Pustaka Khasana Buddya Lokal [Library Series on Special Local Cultures] #1. Larwul Ngabal: Hukum Adat Kei Bertahan Menghadapi Arus Perubahan“ (Larwul Ngabal: Kei Customary Law Survives Changing Currents). Seri Pustaka Khasana Buddya Lokal [Library Series on Special Local Cultures] #1: Yayasan Sejati Institute: Yayasan Sejati Institute.Google Scholar
Reid, Anthony (1992) “Indonesian Fishermen Detained in Broome: A Report on the Social and Economic Background,” in Illegal Entry. Center for Southeast Asian Studies and Northern Territory University Occasional Paper Series, No. 1. Canberra: the Center.Google Scholar
Ririmasse, B. (1985) “Peraturan Sasi Desa Haruku” (Sasi Regulations of Haruku Village). Unpub. typescript, pp. 1–7. Ambon: Information Documentation Center of HUALOPU.Google Scholar
Rouse, Roger (1991) “Mexican Migration and the Social Space of Postmodernism,” 1 (1) Diaspora 8.Google Scholar
Sekritariat Kerjasama Pelestrian Hutan Indonesia (SKEPHI) (1992) To Sink the Island: Logging Problem in Yamdena Island. Jakarta: SKEPHI.Google Scholar
Talbott, Kirk, & Lynch, O.J. (forthcoming) “Securing the Balance: Community-based Forest Management and National Law in Asia and the Pacific.” Washington, DC: World Resources Institute.Google Scholar
Tsing, Anna (1993) “Crafting Customary Claims: Environmentalists Colonial Paradoxes in Post-Colonial Indonesia.” Presented at Anthropology Colloquium, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA (Dec).Google Scholar
Ukru, Yunus, Ubro, Soeleman, Teniwut, Robby, Elmas, Pieter, Saza, Minggus Umbu, Widodo, Dudit, Panjaitan, Erwin, and Topatimasang, Roem (1993) Portret Orang Orang Kalah: Kumpulan Kasus Penyingkiran Orang-Orang Asli Kepulauan Maluku (Portrait of People Who Have Lost: Cases of Marginalization of the Indigenous Inhabitants of the Maluku Archipelago). Jakarta: Yayasan Sejati Institute.Google Scholar
Vandergeest, Peter, & Peluso, Nancy Lee (in press) “Territorialization and State Power in Thailand,” Theory & Society.Google Scholar
Volker, T. (1925) “Het Recht Van Sasi in De Molukken” (The Law of Sasi in the Moluccas), 24 Adatrechtbundels 293. The Hague: Martinus Nijoff.Google Scholar
Volkman, Toby Alice (1984) “Great Performances: Toraja Cultural Identity in the 1970s,” 11 American Ethnologist 153.Google Scholar
Volkman, Toby Alice, (1990) “Visions and Revisions: Toraja Culture and the Tourist Gaze,” 17 American Ethnologist 91.Google Scholar
von Benda-Beckmann, Franz von, Benda-Beckmann, Keebet von, & Brouwer, Arie (1992) “Changing ‘Indigenous Environmental Law’ in the Central Moluccas: Communal Regulation and Privatization of Sasi.” Presented to Congress of the Commission on Folk Law & Legal Pluralism, Victoria University, Wellington, NZ.Google Scholar
World Resources Institute (WRI), World Conservation Union (IUCN), and United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) (1992) Global Biodiversity Strategy. Washington, D.C.: World Resources Institute.Google Scholar
Yayasan HUALOPU, Fakultas Hukum, Pusat Studi Maluku UNPATTI (HUALOPU Institute, Law Faculty and the Environmental Studies Center of the University of Pattimura) (1991) “Laporan Penelitian Hak Adat Kelautan Di Maluku.” Research Report on Marine Customary Law in Maluku, Ambon. Ambon: HUALOPU Institute.Google Scholar
Zerner, Charles (1990) Legal Options for the Indonesian Forestry Sector. Jakarta: Ministry of Forestry & U.N. Food & Agriculture Organization.Google Scholar
Zerner, Charles (1992) “Indigenous Forest-dwelling Peoples of Indonesia's Outer Islands: Livelihood, Rights, and Resource Management Institutions in the Era of Industrial Forest Exploitation.” Report prepared for World Bank in preparation for Indonesia Forestry Sector Loan (Dec).Google Scholar