Hostname: page-component-68945f75b7-z8dg2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-05T12:02:05.595Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Small Claims, Complex Disputes: A Review of the Small Claims Literature

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 July 2024

Barbara Yngvesson  and
Patricia Hennessey
Patricia Hennessey
Affiliation:
Hampshire College
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

We take it as a matter of course that a judge should be a mere umpire, to pass upon objections and hold counsel to the rules of the game, and that the parties should fight out their own game in their own way without judicial interference … The idea that procedure must of necessity be wholly contentious disfigures our administration of justice at every point.

Pound, 1906:404-5

The possibility that any given problem might be handled in more than one way does not constitute a liability. Rather, it is a form of competition among, for instance, means of settling a dispute …. Each method of dispute settlement constitutes a different product—of differing utility to different consumers—some clearly more suitable than others for certain situations. The Justice Industry has an obligation, not simply continuously to refine one product—but to deliver new and competing products to serve the varied needs of the consumer.

Cahn & Cahn, 1966:947-48

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 9 , Issue 2: Litigation and Dispute Processing: Part II , Winter 1975 , pp. 219 - 274
Copyright
Copyright © 1975 The Law and Society Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ALPER, Carl (1934) “The Practice in the Small Claims Court of the City of New York,” 9 St. John's Law Review 24.Google Scholar
AMERICAN POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW (1914) “Small Debtors Court,” 9 American Political Science Review 635.Google Scholar
AUBURT, Vilhelm (1963) “The Structure of Legal Thinking,” in Andenaes, J. (ed.), Legal Essays: Festshrift Til Frede Castberg. Oslo: Universitets Forlaget.Google Scholar
BLALOCK, Hubert M. (1970) Introduction to Social Research. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
BLUMENFELD, Norma (1972) The Small Claims Court and The Low Income Consumer. M.A. Thesis. Queens College, City University of New York.Google Scholar
BODEN, Robert F. (1963-64) “Wisconsin Small Claims Practice Under Ch. 299: A Discussion and Some Suggestions,” 47 Marquette Law Review 38.Google Scholar
BRADWAY, John S. (1940) “Benefits, Functions and Procedures of Small Claims Courts,” 50 Monthly Labor Review 16.Google Scholar
CAHN, Edgar and J.C., CAHN (1966) “What Price Justice? The Civilian Perspective Revisited,” 41 Notre Dame Lawyer 929.Google Scholar
CAHN, Edgar and J.C., CAHN (1971) “Power to the People or the Profession? The Public Interest in Public Interest Law,” 79 Yale Law Journal 1005.Google Scholar
CALIFORNIA LAW REVIEW (1923) “Jurisdiction of Small Claims Courts,” 11 California Law Review 276.Google Scholar
CAPLOVITZ, David (1971) “Debtors in Default,” in Bureau of Applied Social Research, Report. New York: Columbia University.Google Scholar
CAYTON, Nathan (1939) “Small Claims and Conciliation Courts,” 205 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 57.Google Scholar
COATS, Daniel, Charles, GANTZ and Bruce, HEATHCOTTE (1969) “Small Claims in Indiana,” 3 Indiana Legal Forum 517.Google Scholar
COLUMBIA JOURNAL OF LAW AND SOCIAL PROBLEMS (1969) “Small Claims Courts: Reform Revisited,” 5 Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems 47.Google Scholar
COLUMBIA LAW REVIEW (1934) “Small Claims Courts,” 34 Columbia Law Review 932.Google Scholar
COMMUNITY SERVICE SOCIETY OF NEW YORK (1974) Large Grievances About Small Causes. New York: Department of Public Affairs, Community Service Society of New York.Google Scholar
CONSUMER CLAIMS COURT ASSISTANCE ACT, S. 1602, 92d Cong., 1st Sess. (1971).Google Scholar
CONSUMER CONTROVERSIES RESOLUTION ACT, S. 2928, 93d Cong., 2d Sess. (1974).Google Scholar
CONSUMER COUNCIL (1970) Justice Out of Reach: A Case for Small Claims Courts. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.Google Scholar
CURRIE, F.A. (1956) “Small Claims Courts,” 9 University of Florida Law Review 33.Google Scholar
DELLINGER, Robert William (1972) An Observation Study of the Los Angeles Small Claims Court, M.A. Thesis, California State University at Los Angeles.Google Scholar
ECKHOFF, Torstein (1966) “The Mediator, the Judge and the Administrator in Conflict Resolution,” 10 Acta Sociologica 158.Google Scholar
EDHOLM, Charles Lawrence (1915) “The Small Debtors' Court,” 22 Case and Comment 29.Google Scholar
EOVALDI, Thomas L. and Joan E., GESTRIN (1971) “Justice for Consumers: The Mechanisms of Redress,” 66 Northwestern University Law Review 281.Google Scholar
FOWKS, Robert J. (1968) “Small Claims Court: Simplified Pleadings and Procedure,” 37 Journal of the Kansas Bar Association 220.Google Scholar
FOX, Harry J. (1971) “Small Claims Revisions—A Break for the Layman,” 20 DePaul Law Review 912.Google Scholar
FULLER, Lon (1963) “Collective Bargaining and the Arbitrator,” 3 Wisconsin Law Review 18.Google Scholar
FULLER, Lon (1971) “Mediation—Its Forms and Functions,” 44 Southern California Law Review 305.Google Scholar
GALANTER, Marc (1974) “Why the ‘Haves’ Come Out Ahead: Speculation on the Limits of Legal Change,” 9 Law & Society Review 95.Google Scholar
GLUCKMAN, Max (1955) The Judicial Process Among the Barotse of Northern Rhodesia. Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
GULLIVER, Philip H. (1969) “Introduction to Case Studies of Law in Non-Western Societies,” in Nader, L. (ed.), Law in Culture and Society. Chicago: Aldine Press.Google Scholar
GULLIVER, Philip H. (1973) “Negotiation as a Mode of Dispute Settlement: Towards a General Model,” 7 Law & Society Review 667.Google Scholar
HAEMMEL, William G. (1973) “The North Carolina Small Claims Court—An Empirical Study,” 9 Wake Forest Law Review 503.Google Scholar
HARLEY, Herbert (1915) “Ultimate Types of Inferior Courts and Judges,” 22 Case and Comment 4.Google Scholar
HARLEY, Herbert (1919) “Justice or Litigation?” 6 Virginia Law Review 143.Google Scholar
HARLEY, Herbert (1920) “Conciliation Is Succeeding: Problem of Rendering Real Justice, Swift and Cheap, in Small Claims Solved by Conciliation Procedure,” 4 Journal of the American Judicature Society 70.Google Scholar
HENNESSEY, Patricia (1973) An Observation of Small Claims Process. An unpublished paper presented in course, “Dispute Settlement,” Hampshire College, Amherst, Mass.Google Scholar
HOLLINGSWORTH, Earl, William B., FELDMAN and David C., CLARK (1973) “The Ohio Small Claims Court: An Empirical Study,” 42 Cincinnati Law Review 469.Google Scholar
HOSTETLER, Zona F. (1965) “Poverty and the Law,” in Seligman, B.B. (ed.) Poverty As A Public Issue. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
INSTITUTE OF JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATION (1955) “Small Claims Courts in the United States,” New York: Institute of Judicial Administration.Google Scholar
INSTITUTE OF JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATION (1959) “Small Claims Courts in the United States: 1959 Supplement,” New York: Institute of Judicial Administration.Google Scholar
ISON, Terence G. (1972) “Small Claims,” 35 Modern Law Review 18.Google Scholar
JONES, Mary G. and Harry, BOYER (1972) “Improving the Quality of Justice in the Marketplace,” 40 George Washington Law Review 357.Google Scholar
JONES, J.P. (1974) “Practical Results of Court Reforms: The Politics of Small Claims Court,” An unpublished paper on file with Law & Society Review.Google Scholar
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN JUDICATURE SOCIETY (1918) “Special Issue on Conciliation and Informal Procedure,” 2 Journal American Judicature Society.Google Scholar
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN JUDICATURE SOCIETY (1921) “Editorial,” 4 Journal American Judicature Society 163.Google Scholar
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN JUDICATURE SOCIETY (1924) “Report of Committee on Small Claims and Conciliation,” 8 Journal American Judicature Society 247.Google Scholar
JOURNAL OF THE INDIAN LAW INSTITUTE (1974) “Evolution of the Small Cause Courts in India—1753-1887 With Special Reference to the Presidency Court at Calcutta,” 16 Journal of The Indian Law Institute 98.Google Scholar
KLEIN, Robert J. (1971) “Buyer vs. Seller in Small Claims Courts,” 36 Consumer Reports 624 (October).Google Scholar
KRONHEIM, Milton S. (1951) “Does the Small Claims Branch of Our Municipal Court Measure Up to the Standards of the Community?” 18 Journal of the Bar Association of the District of Columbia 113.Google Scholar
LAUER, Edgar J. (1918) “Conciliation and Arbitration in the Municipal Court of the City of New York,” 1 Journal of the American Judicature Society 153.Google Scholar
LEVINE, Martin (1918) “Conciliation Court of Cleveland,” 2 Journal of the American Judicature Society 10.Google Scholar
MATZA, David (1956) “The Disreputable Poor,” in Bendix, R. and Lipset, S.M. (eds.), Class, Status and Power. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
McFADGEN, Terrence (1972) Dispute Resolution in the Small Claims Context: Adjudication, Arbitration or Conciliation? LL.M. Thesis, Harvard University.Google Scholar
MEYERS, Frank H. (1953) “Small Claims Court in the District of Columbia,” 287 Annals of American Academy of Political and Social Science 21.Google Scholar
MINTON, Michael and Joel, STEFFENSON (1972) “Small Claims Courts: A Survey and Analysis,” 55 Judicature 324.Google Scholar
MOLLER, Stephen (1970) Dispute Settlement in the Boston Municipal Court. M.A. Thesis, Harvard University.Google Scholar
MOULTON, Beatrice (1969) “The Persecution and Intimidation of the Low Income Litigant As Performed by the Small Claims Court of California,” 21 Stanford Law Review 1657.Google Scholar
MURPHY, [Hon.] Tim (1967) “D.C. Small Claims Court—The Forgotten Court,” 34 D.C. Bar Journal 14.Google Scholar
NADER, Laura (1965) “The Antropological Study of Law,” 67 American Anthropologist 3.Google Scholar
NADER, Laura (1969a) Law in Culture and Society. Chicago: Aldine Press.Google Scholar
NADER, Laura (1969b) “Styles of Court Procedure: To Make the Balance,” in Nader, L. (ed.), Law in Culture and Society. Chicago: Aldine Press.Google Scholar
NADER, Laura et al. (1974) “Forms of Dispute Settlement,” (In press), Journal of Social Issues, special issue on justice, M. Lerner, ed.Google Scholar
NADER, Laura and Barbara, YNGVESSON (1973) “On Studying the Ethnography of Law and Its Consequences,” in Honigman, J. (ed.) Handbook of Social and Cultural Anthropology. Chicago: Rand McNally.Google Scholar
NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR CONSUMER JUSTICE (1972) Staff Studies on Small Claims Courts. Boston: National Institute for Consumer Justice.Google Scholar
NEHEMKIS, Peter R. Jr. (1932-33) “The Boston Poor Debtors Court,” 42 Yale Law Journal 561.Google Scholar
NELSON, Douglas A. (1949) “The Small Claims Court,” 22 Bulletin of the State Bar Association of Wisconsin 237.Google Scholar
NEW LAW JOURNAL (1971) “Dilemmas of the Small Claim,” 121 New Law Journal 966.Google Scholar
NEW YORK LAW REVIEW (1925) “Do Litigants Want Law and Not Conciliation?” 3 New York Law Review 425.Google Scholar
OLSON (1910) “The Proper Organization and Procedure of a Municipal Court,” 7 Proceedings of the American Political Science Association 78 (1910).Google Scholar
PACKER, Herbert L. (1968) The Limits of the Criminal Sanction. Stanford: Stanford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
PAGTER, Carl R., McCLOSKEY, Robert and Mitchell, REINIS (1964) “The California Small Claims Court,” 52 California Law Review 876.Google Scholar
POUND, Roscoe (1906) “The Causes of Popular Dissatisfaction with the Administration of Justice,” 29 Reports of American Bar Association 395; Reprinted, 46 Journal of the American Judicature Society 55 (1962).Google Scholar
POUND, Roscoe (1913) “The Administration of Justice in the Modern City,” 26 Harvard Law Review 302.Google Scholar
POUND, Roscoe (1940) The Organization of Courts. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
ROBINSON, Cyril D. (1963) “A Small Claims Division for Chicago's New Circuit Court,” 44 Chicago Bar Record 421.Google Scholar
ROOT, Elihu (1916) “Address of the President: Public Service By the Bar,” 41 Reports of the American Bar Association 358.Google Scholar
SCOTT, Austin (1923) “Small Causes and Poor Litigants,” 9 American Bar Association Journal 457.Google Scholar
SIEGEL, Ellen Beth and Robert W., ATWOOD (1971) “An Evaluation of the Operations and Procedures of the Small Claims Courts in New York City.” Unpublished paper of the Department of Consumer Affairs of the City of New York.Google Scholar
SILVERSTEIN, Lee (1956) “Small Claims Courts vs. Justices of the Peace,” 58 West Virginia Law Review 241.Google Scholar
SMALL CLAIMS COURT BILL 99, House of Commons (Great Britain), introduced Feb., 1971.Google Scholar
SMALL CLAIMS COURT STUDY GROUP (1972) Little Injustices: Small Claims Courts and the American Consumer. Washington: The Center For Auto Safety.Google Scholar
SMALL CLAIMS COURT STUDY GROUP (1972b) “A Report on the Small Claims Courts of Boston and Roxbury, Massachusetts,” in National Institute for Consumer Justice, Staff Studies on Small Claims Courts. Boston: National Institute for Consumer Justice.Google Scholar
SMITH, Regan G. (1970) The Small Claims Court: A Sociological Interpretation. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign.Google Scholar
SMITH, Reginald H. (1919) Justice and the Poor. Chicago: American Judicature Society [Bulletin VII]; Reprinted, Chicago: National Legal Aid and Defenders Association, 1967.Google Scholar
SMITH, Reginald H. (1920) “Small Claims Courts for Massachusetts,” 4 Journal of American Judicature Society 51.Google Scholar
SMITH, Reginald H. (1924) “Small Claims Procedure is Succeeding,” 8 Journal of American Judicature Society 247.Google Scholar
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA LAW REVIEW (1969) “Small Claims Courts and the Poor,” 42 Southern California Law Review 493.Google Scholar
STANFORD LAW REVIEW (1952) “Small Claims Court As Collection Agencies,” 4 Stanford Law Review 237.Google Scholar
STARR, June and Barbara, YNGVESSON (1975) “Who Wins and Why: Zeroing-in On Compromise,” 2 American Ethnologist (in press).Google Scholar
STEADMAN, John M. and Richard S., ROSENSTEIN (1973) “‘Small Claims’ Consumer Plaintiffs in the Philadelphia Municipal Court: An Empirical Study,” 121 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1308.Google Scholar
STOLLER, Bernard M. (1968-69) “Small Claims Courts in Texas: Paradise Lost,” 47 Texas Law Review 448.Google Scholar
VANCE, W.R. (1918) “The Minneapolis Court of Conciliation in Operation,” 2 Minnesota Law Review 491.Google Scholar
YNGVESSON, Barbara (1965) “Hostility in Small Claims Court Disputes,” an unpublished paper presented at Annual Meeting of the Southwestern Anthropological Association, University of California at Irvine.Google Scholar
YNGVESSON, Barbara (1974) “Responses to Grievance Behavior: Extended Cases in a Fishing Community,” In Lowy, M. (ed.) Choice-Making in the Law (in press).Google Scholar