Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-m9pkr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T20:25:46.251Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Sentencing Decisions of Black and White Judges: Expected and Unexpected Similarities

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 July 2024

Cassia Spohn
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Those who champion the representation of blacks on the bench argue that black judges may make a difference. Indeed, some suggest that increasing the proportion of black judges might result in more equitable treatment of black and white defendants. In this study we test these expectations. Using data on defendants charged with violent felonies, we compare the sentencing decisions of black and white judges in Detroit. We find remarkable similarities and conclude that judicial race has relatively little predictive power. More important, we find that both black and white judge sentence black offenders more severely than white offenders. Our results raise questions about the appropriate interpretation of racial disparity in incarceration rates and suggest that the harsher treatment of black offenders cannot be attributed to the racism of white judges.

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 24 , Issue 5 , 1990 , pp. 1197 - 1216
Copyright
Copyright © 1990 The Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This research was supported by a Summer Research Fellowship from the National Institute of Justice. The data, made available by the Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research, were originally collected by Colin Loftin and Milton Heumann for their study of “Firearms Violence and the Michigan Felony Firearm Law: Detroit, 1976–1978.” Neither they nor the Consortium bear any responsibility for the analyses or interpretations presented here.

References

ALDBRICH, John H., and Forrest D., NELSON (1984) Linear Probability, Logit, and Probit Models. Beverly Hills, CA.: Sage Publications.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BALBUS, Isaac D. (1973) The Dialectics of Legal Representation: Black Rebels Before the American Criminal Courts. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
BALDUS, David C., Charles, PULASKI, and George, WOODWORTH (1983) “Comparative Review of Death Sentences: An Empirical Study of the Georgia Experience,” 74 Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 661.Google Scholar
BERK, Richard A. (1983) “An Introduction to Sample Selection Bias in Sociological Data,” 48 American Sociological Review 386.Google Scholar
BERK, Richard A., and Subhash C., RAY (1982) “Selection Biases in Sociological Data,” 11 Social Science Research 352.Google Scholar
BOWERS, William J., and Glenn L., PIERCE (1980) “Arbitrariness and Discrimination Under Post-Furman Capital Statutes,” 26 Crime & Delinquency 563.Google Scholar
CROCKETT, George W. (1984) “The Role of the Black Judge,” in D. Georges-Abeyie (ed.), The Criminal Justice System and Blacks. New York: Clark Boardman.Google Scholar
ENGLE, Charles Donald (1971) “Criminal Justice in the City: A Study of Sentence Severity and Variation in the Philadelphia Court System.” Ph.D. dissertation, Temple University.Google Scholar
FRAZIER, Charles E., and E. Wilbur, BOCK (1982) “Effects of Court Officials on Sentence Severity: Do Judges Make a Difference?” 20 Criminology 257.Google Scholar
FYFE, James (1981) “Who Shoots? A Look at Officer Race and Police Shooting,” 9 Journal of Police Science and Administration 367.Google Scholar
GIBSON, James (1978) “Judges' Role Orientations, Attitudes, and Decisions: An Interactive Model,” 72 American Political Science Review 911.Google Scholar
GIBSON, James (1980) “Environmental Constraints on the Behavior of Judges: A Representational Model of Judicial Decision-Making,” 14 Law & Society Review 343.Google Scholar
GIBSON, James (1983) “From Simplicity to Complexity: The Development of Theory in the Study of Judicial Behavior,” 5 Political Behavior 7.Google Scholar
GLICK, Henry Robert, and Kenneth N., VINES (1973) State Court Systems. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
GOLDMAN, Sheldon (1979) “Should There Be Affirmative Action for the Judiciary?” 62 Judicature 488.Google Scholar
GOTTSCHALL, Jon (1983) “Carter's Judicial Appointments: The Influence of Affirmative Action and Merit Selection on Voting on the U.S. Courts of Appeals,” 67 Judicature 164.Google Scholar
HAGAN, John, and Kristin, BUMILLER (1983) “Making Sense of Sentencing: A Review and Critique of Sentencing Research.” Presented at National Academy of Sciences Panel on Sentencing Research.Google Scholar
HECKMAN, James J. (1974) “Shadow Prices, Market Wages, and Labor Supply,” 42 Econometrics 679.Google Scholar
HEUMANN, Milton, and Colin, LOFTIN (1979) “Mandatory Sentencing and the Abolition of Plea Bargaining: The Michigan Felony Firearm Statute,” 13 Law & Society Review 393.Google Scholar
KLECK, Gary (1981) “Racial Discrimination in Criminal Sentencing,” 46 American Sociological Review 783.Google Scholar
LaFREE, Gary D. (1981) “Official Reactions to Social Problems: Police Decisions in Sexual Assault Cases,” 28 Social Problems 582.Google Scholar
LaFREE, Gary D. (1989) Rape and Criminal Justice: The Social Construction of Sexual Assault. Belmont, CA.: Wadsworth.Google Scholar
LEVIN, Martin A. (1972) “Urban Politics and Policy Outcomes: The Criminal Courts,” in Cole, G. F. (ed.), Criminal Justice: Law and Politics. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.Google Scholar
LOFTIN, Colin, Milton, HEUMANN, and McDOWALL, David (1983) “Mandatory Sentencing and Firearms Violence: Evaluating an Alternative to Gun Control,” 17 Law & Society Review 287.Google Scholar
MYERS, Martha (1988) “Social Background and the Sentencing Behavior of Judges,” 26 Criminology 649.Google Scholar
MYERS, Martha, and LaFREE, Gary (1982) “Sexual Assault and Its Prosecution: A Comparison with Other Crimes,” 73 Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 1282.Google Scholar
MYERS, Martha, and Susette M., TALARICO (1987) The Social Contexts of Criminal Sentencing. New York: Springer-Verlag.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL, COMMITTEE ON THE STATUS OF BLACK AMERICANS (1989) A Common Destiny: Blacks and American Society. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.Google Scholar
PITKIN, Hanna F. (1972) The Concept of Representation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
POOLE, Eric D., and Robert M., REGOLI (1980) “Race, Institutional Rule Breaking, and Disciplinary Response: A Study of Discretionary Decision Making in Prison,” 14 Law & Society Review 931.Google Scholar
SMITH, Michael David (1983) Race Versus the Robe: The Dilemma of Black Judges. New York: National University Publications.Google Scholar
SMITH, Douglas A., and J. R., KLEIN (1983) “Police Agency Characteristics and Arrest Decisions,” in G. P. Whitaker and C. D. Phillips (eds.), Evaluating Performance in Criminal Justice Agencies. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
SPOHN, Cassia (1990) “Decision Making in Sexual Assault Cases: Do Black and Female Judges Make a Difference?” 2 Women & Criminal Justice 83.Google Scholar
SPOHN, Cassia, John, GRUHL, and Susan, WELCH (1981–82) “The Effect of Race on Sentencing: A Re-examination of an Unsettled Question,” 16 Law & Society Review 72.Google Scholar
SUTTON, L. Paul (1978) Variations in Federal Criminal Sentences: A Statistical Assessment at the National Level. Albany, NY: Criminal Justice Research Center.Google Scholar
SWIGERT, Victoria L., and Ronald A., FARRELL (1977) “Normal Homicides and the Law,” 42 American Sociological Review 16.Google Scholar
UHLMAN, Thomas M. (1978) “Black Elite Decision Making: The Case of Trial Judges,” 22 American Journal of Political Science 884.Google Scholar
WALKER, Thomas G., and Deborah J., BARROW (1985) “The Diversification of the Federal Bench: Policy and Process Ramifications,” 47 Journal of Politics 596.Google Scholar
WELCH, Susan, Michael, COMBS, and John, GRUHL (1988) “Do Black Judges Make A Difference?” 32 American Journal of Political Science 126.Google Scholar
WRIGHT, Bruce McM. (1973) “A Black Broods on Black Judges,” 57 Judicature 22.Google Scholar
ZATZ, Marjorie S. (1987) “The Changing Forms of Racial/Ethnic Biases in Sentencing,” 24 Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 69.Google Scholar