Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-wxhwt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T13:36:47.684Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Relative Resilience of Property: First Possession and Order Without Law in East Timor

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Daniel Fitzpatrick  and
Susana Barnes
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Much of the recent literature on customary property relations in sub-Saharan Africa has highlighted underlying characteristics of negotiability and indeterminacy. Custom is prone to reinvention as resource claimants manipulate customary references across multiple forums for property legitimation and authority. This article focuses on the resilience of customary property relations in East Timor. Based on a study of customary authority in the village of Babulo, we conclude that traditional Timorese narratives of first possession, where land authority is claimed by groups that trace descent to a mythic first settler, have acted as adaptive and resilient focal points for the reproduction of customary property relations in historical circumstances of war, colonization, and occupation. While a finding of customary resilience is not new to postcolonial contexts, the relative novelty of our study lies in its structured explanation for resilience in circumstances of war and displacement, based on the social ordering capacity of first possession principles themselves. This explanation, which derives from focal point theories for cooperative property relations, also takes into account a number of limits on the ordering capacity of first possession principles, which support a conclusion of relative or constrained resilience, particularly in terms of contested interpretations of possessory authority in contemporary East Timor.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 44 , Issue 2 , June 2010 , pp. 205 - 238
Copyright
© 2010 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The authors wish to thank Carol Rose, Andrew McWilliam, and two anonymous reviewers for their insights and comments. The authors owe a considerable debt of gratitude to the people of Babulo, and the members of East Timor's Land and Property Unit, for their hospitality and generosity. Research for this article was funded by a grant from the Australian Research Council (Discovery Project DP0556531, with Andrew McWilliam).

References

References

Alston, Lee J., et al. (1999) Titles, Conflict, and Land Use: The Development of Property Rights and Land Reform on the Brazilian Amazon Frontier. Ann Arbor: Univ. of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bellwood, Peter (1995) “Hierarchy, Founder Ideology and Austronesian Expansion,” in Fox, J. J. & Sather, C., eds., Origins, Ancestry and Alliance: Explorations in Austronesian Ethnography. Canberra: The Australian National University.Google Scholar
Benda-Beckmann, Franz von (1979) Property in Social Continuity, Continuity and Change in the Maintenance of Property Relationships in Minangkabau, West Sumatra. The Hague: Nijhoff.Google Scholar
Benda-Beckmann, Franz von (1992). “Changing Legal Pluralism in Indonesia,” Yuridika, No. 4 Tahun VII, 1.Google Scholar
Benda-Beckmann, Franz Von, & Benda-Beckmann, Keebet von (1994) “Property, Politics, and Conflict: Ambon and Minangkabau Compared,” 28 Law & Society Rev. 589.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Benda-Beckmann, Keebet von (1984) The Broken Stairways to Consensus: Village Justice and State Courts in Minangkabau. Dordrechtand Leiden, The Netherlands, and Cinnaminson, NJ: Foris Publications, KITLV Press.Google Scholar
Berry, Sara (1993) No Condition Is Permanent: The Social Dynamics of Agrarian Change in Sub-Saharan Africa. Madison: Univ. of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Berry, Sara (1997) “Tomatoes, Land and Hearsay, Property and History in Asante in the Time of Structural Adjustment,” 25 World Development 1225–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bourdieu, Pierre (1990) The Logic of Practice. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Central Intelligence Agency (2010). “World Factbook: Timor Leste,” https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/tt.html (accessed 15 April 2010).Google Scholar
Commission for Reception, Truth and Reconciliation in East Timor (CAVR) (2005) Chega! The Report of the Commission for Reception, Truth and Reconciliation in East Timor. Dili: Government of Timor Leste.Google Scholar
Clamagirand, Brigitte (1980) “The Social Organization of the Ema of Timor,” in Fox, J. J., ed., The Flow of Life: Essays on Eastern Indonesia. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Clay, Karen, & Wright, Gavin (2005) “Order without Law? Property Rights during the Californian Gold Rush,” 42 Explorations in Economic History 155.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De Sardan, Olivier (1999) “A Moral Economy of Corruption in Africa?,” 37 J. of Modern African Studies 25–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ellickson, Robert (1989) “A Hypothesis of Wealth-Maximizing Norms: Evidence from the Whaling Industry,” 5 J. of Law, Economics and Organization 83.Google Scholar
Ellickson, Robert (1991) Order without Law: How Neighbors Settle Disputes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fitzpatrick, Daniel (2002a) Land Claims in East Timor. Canberra: Asia Pacific Press.Google Scholar
Fitzpatrick, Daniel (2002b) “Restitution and Dispossession: International Property Norms in East Timor's New Constitution.” Proceedings of the Australian New Zealand Society of International Law Annual Conference, 16 September.Google Scholar
Fitzpatrick, Daniel (2006) “Evolution and Chaos in Property Systems: The Third World Tragedy of Contested Access,” 115 Yale Law J. 996–1048.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fitzpatrick, Daniel (2008). “Mediating Land Conflict in East Timor,” in Making Land Work: Reconciling Customary Land and Development in the South Pacific. Canberra: Australian Government, http://www.ausaid.gov.au (accessed 15 Nov. 2009).Google Scholar
Forman, Shephard (1980) “Descent, Alliance and Exchange Ideology among the Makassae of East Timor,” in Fox, J. J., ed., The Flow of Life: Essays on Eastern Indonesia. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Fox, James J. (1993) “Comparative Perspectives on Austronesian Houses: An Introductory Essay,” in Fox, J. J., ed., Inside Austronesian Houses: Perspectives on Domestic Designs for Living. Canberra: Department of Anthropology, Comparative Austronesian Project, Research School of Pacific Studies. The Australian National University.Google Scholar
Fox, James J. (1995). “Installing the Outsider Inside: The Exploration of an Epistemic Austronesian Cultural Theme and Its Social Significance.” Presented at Local Transformations and Common Heritage in Southeast Asia, the first Conference of the European Association for Southeast Asian Studies, Leiden University, June 29–July 1. Revised draft.Google Scholar
Fox, James J. (1996) “The Transformation of Progenitor Lines of Origin: Patterns of Precedence in Eastern Indonesia,” in Fox, J. J. & Sather, C., eds., Origins, Ancestry and Alliance: Explorations in Austronesian Ethnography. Canberra: Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, The Australian National University.Google Scholar
Gunn, Geoffrey C. (1999) Timor Loro Sae: 500 Years. Macau: Livros do Oriente.Google Scholar
Gunter, Janet (2007) “Communal Conflict in Viqueque and the ‘Charged’ History of '59,” in Fox, J. J. & McWilliam, A. eds., “Traditional Justice in Timor,” Special issue, 8 The Asia Pacific J. of Anthropology 27–42.Google Scholar
Gusmão, Xanana (2000) To Resist Is to Win! The Autobiography of Xanana Gusmão. Richmond, Victoria, British Columbia: Aurora Books with David Lovell Publishing.Google Scholar
Harrington, Andrew (2007). “Ethnicity, Violence, and Land and Property Disputes in Timor Leste,” 2 East Timor Law J., http://www.eastimorlawjournal.org/ARTICLES/2007/ethnicity_violence_land_property_disputes_timor_leste_harrington.html (accessed 15 April 2010).Google Scholar
Hicks, David (1976) Tetum Ghosts and Kin: Fieldwork in an Indonesian Community. Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield.Google Scholar
International Finance Corporation and World Bank (2007) Timor Leste: Economic and Social Development Brief, http://www.adb.org/Documents/Books/ESDB-Timor-Leste/ESDB-Timor-Leste.pdf (accessed 15 Oct. 2009).Google Scholar
Juul, Kristine (2002) “Post-Drought Migration and the Quest for Recognition: Asserting and Securing Claims among Falani Pastoralists in Northern Senegal,” in Juul, K. & Lund, C., eds., Negotiating Property in Africa. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.Google Scholar
Lewis, Daniel (2004) “Challenges to Sustainable Peace: Land Disputes Following Conflict.” Paper presented at Symposium on Land Administration in Post Conflict Areas, jointly organized by the Federation of International Surveyors, the Kosovo Cadastral Agency, and UN-HABITAT, Geneva, 29–30 April.Google Scholar
Luek, Dean (2005) “The Rule of First Possession and the Design of the Law,” 38 J. of Law and Economics 393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lund, Christian (2002) “Negotiating Property Institutions: On the Symbiosis of Property and Authority in Africa,” in Juul, K. & Lund, C., eds., Negotiating Property in Africa. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.Google Scholar
Lund, Christian (2008) Local Politics and the Dynamics of Property in Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McAdams, Richard (2000) “A Focal Point Theory of Expressive Law,” 96 Virginia Law Rev. 1649.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McDowell, Andrea (2002) “From Commons to Claims: Property Rights in the California Gold Rush,” 14 Yale J. of Law & the Humanities 1.Google Scholar
McDowell, Andrea (2004) “Real Property, Spontaneous Order, and Norms in the Gold Mines,” 29 Law & Social Inquiry 771.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McWilliam, Andrew R. (2002) Paths of Origin, Gates of Life: A Study of Place and Precedence in Southwest Timor. Leiden: KITLV Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McWilliam, Andrew R. (2005) “Houses of Resistance in East Timor: Structuring Sociality in the New Nation,” 15 Anthropological Forum 27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McWilliam, Andrew R. (2007) “Customary Claims and the Public Interest: On Fataluku Resource Entitlements in Lautem,” in Kingsbury, D. & Leach, M., eds., East Timor: Beyond Independence. Melbourne: Monash Asia Institute Press.Google Scholar
McWilliam, Andrew R. (2008) “Trunk and Tip in West Timor: Precedence in a Botanical Idiom,” in Vischer, M. P., ed., Precedence: Processes of Social Differentiation in the Austronesian World. Canberra: Australian University E-Press.Google Scholar
Moore, Sally F. (1978) Law as Process. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Moore, Sally F. (1986) Social Facts and Fabrications: “Customary” Law on Kilimanjaro 1880-1980. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Moore, Sally F. (1998) “Changing African Land Tenure: Reflections on the Incapacities of the State,” 10 European J. of Development Research 33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morriss, Andrew P. (2005) “Hayek & Cowboys: Customary Law in the American West,” 1 NYU J. of Law & Liberty 35.Google Scholar
National Statistics Directorate (2006) Census Atlas: Timor-Leste Census of Population and Housing 2004. Dili, Timor-Leste: National Statistics Directorate.Google Scholar
Peters, Pauline (2002) “The Limits of Negotiability: Security, Equity and Class Formation in Africa's Land Systems,” in Juul, K. & Lund, C. (eds.), Negotiating Property in Africa. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.Google Scholar
Pons-Vignon, Nicolas, & Lecomte, Henri-Bernard Solignac (2004) “Land, Violent Conflict and Development,” OECD Development Centre Working Paper No. 233, Paris.Google Scholar
Rose, Carol (1985) “Possession as the Origin of Property,” 52 University of Chicago Law Rev. 73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shipton, Parker (1994) How Private Property Emerges in Africa – Directed and Undirected Land Tenure Reforms in Densely Settled Areas South of the Sahara. Boston: Harvard University (Harvard Institute for International Development & Department of Anthropology).Google Scholar
Sugden, Robert (1986) The Economics of Rights, Cooperation, and Welfare. New York and Oxford: Basil Blackwell.Google Scholar
Sugden, Robert (1989) “Spontaneous Order,” 3 J. of Economic Perspectives 85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Traube, Elizabeth G. (1986) Cosmology and Social Life: Ritual Exchange among the Mambai of East Timor. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Traube, Elizabeth G. (1995) “Mambai Perspective on Colonialism and Decolonization,” in Carey, P. & Carter Bentley, G., eds., East Timor at the Crossroads: The Forging of a Nation. Honolulu: Univ. of Hawai'i.Google Scholar
United Nations (1960) Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples, G.A. Res. 1514, UN GAOR, 15th Sess., Supp. No. 16, at 66, UN Doc A/4684 (14 Dec.).Google Scholar
United Nations Security Council (1999) Security Council Resolution 1272, UN Doc S/Res/1272 (25 Oct).Google Scholar
Wiley, Liz (2002) Land Rights in Crisis. Kabul: Afghan Research and Evaluation Unit.Google Scholar
Zerbe, Richard O., & Anderson, C. Leigh (2001) “Culture and Fairness in the Development of Institutions in the California Gold Fields,” 61 J. of Economic History 114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Statutes Cited

Basic Agrarian Law, Act No. 5 of 1960 (Undang-Undang Pokok Agraria - UUPA).Google Scholar
RDTL (Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste) Constitution, 20 May 2002, http://www.gov.east-timor.org/constitution/constitution.htm (accessed 21 April 2010).Google Scholar

Case Cited

Pierson v. Post, 3 Cai. R. 175 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1805).Google Scholar