Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-txr5j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-06T20:02:28.616Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Flexibility and Authority: Resolving Labor Disputes in A County Government in Western China

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Xin He  and
Yang Su
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Existing literature regards flexibility and authority as key characteristics of informal justice. We further contend that the combination of the two is crucial for informal justice to be effective. We investigate the process of dispute resolution by a Chinese labor agency. Following the life cycles of a sample of 810 labor disputes, we find that this informal justice forum was efficient and effective, made possible by the combination of flexibility and authority. Flexibility means that the agency attracts certain types of cases that are usually screened out of the formal legal system and that agency officials use “informal,” hence flexible, techniques. Authority means that the administrative agency possesses additional powers over the disputants; hence, the disputants are under pressure to follow its suggestions and decisions. A comparative analysis of various cases of informal justice reinforces the importance of combining flexibility and authority. We further demonstrate that flexibility without authority is insufficient and that some informal justice forums are effective because they enjoy both.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 53 , Issue 4 , December 2019 , pp. 1341 - 1376
Copyright
© 2019 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

An earlier version of this paper was presented by Xin He at "Labor Rights in China Conference" Organized by NYU Law School and the Ford Foundation in Beijing, May 2015. We benefited from the comments of the audience. The editors and anonymous reviewers of the Review provided invaluable suggestions for improvement. Jing Wang provided indispensable research assistance. Lastly, we are grateful for the officials and migrant workers who kindly accepted our interviews.

References

Abel, Richard L. (1982a) “Introduction,” in Richard, Able, ed., The Politics of Informal Justice, Vol. I. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Abel, Richard L. (1982b) “The Contradictions of Informal Justice,” in Richard, Able, ed., The Politics of Informal Justice, Vol. I. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Albiston, Catherine R., Edelman, Lauren B., & Milligan, Joy (2014) “The DisputeTree and the Legal Forest,” 10 Annual Rev. of Law and Social Science 105–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cook, Royer F., Roehl, Janice A., & Sheppard, David I. (1980) Neighborhood Justice Centers: Field Test. U.S. Department of Justice National Institute of Justice Office of Program Evaluation.Google Scholar
Chen, Yongzhu (2015) “The Judge as Mediator in China and Its Alternatives: A Problem in Chinese Civil Justice,” X J. of Comparative Law 106–25.Google Scholar
Delgado, Richard (1988) “ADR and the Dispossessed: Recent Books about the Deformalization Movement,” 13 Law & Social Inquiry 145–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Di, Xiaohua & Wu, Yuning (2009) “The Developing Trend of the People's Mediation in China,” 42 Sociological Focus 228–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ding, Chunyan (2015) “A Dose to Cure ‘Medical Chaos': Medical Mediation in China,” X J. of Comparative Law 158–76.Google Scholar
Felstiner, William, Abel, Richard, & Sarat, Austin (1980-1981) “The Emergence and Transformation of Disputes: Naming, Blaming, Claiming…,” 15 Law & Society Rev. 631–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feng, Chen & Xu, Xin (2012) “Active Judiciary': Judicial Dismantling of Workers' Collective Action,” 67 The China Journal 87–108.Google Scholar
Fiss, Owen M. (1984) “Against settlement,” 93 Yale Law J. 1073–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fu, Hualing & Cullen, Richard (2011) “From Mediatory to Adjudicatory Justice: The Limits of Civil Justice Reform in China,” in Woo, M. & Gallagher, M., eds., Chinese Justice. Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Galanter, Marc (2004) “The Vanishing Trial: An Examination of Trials and Related Matters in Federal and State Courts,” 1 J. of Empirical Legal Studies 459–570.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallagher, Mary (2006) “Mobilizing the Law in China: ‘Informed Disenchantment' and the Development of Legal Consciousness,” 40 Law & Society Rev. 783–813.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halegua, Aaron (2008) “Getting Paid: Processing Labor Disputes of China's Migrant Workers,” 26 Berkeley J. of International Law 254–322.Google Scholar
Halegua, Aaron (2005) “Reforming the People's Mediation System in Urban China,” 35 Hong Kong Law J. 715–47.Google Scholar
Hand, Keith J. (2011) “Resolving Constitutional Disputes in Contemporary China,” 7 Univ of Pennsylvania East Asia Law Rev. 51–159.Google Scholar
Harrington, Christine (1982) “Delegalization Reform Movements: A Historical Analysis,” in Richard, Able, ed., The Politics of Informal Justice. New York, NY: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Harrington, Christine (1985) Shadow Justice: The Ideology and Institutionalization of Alternatives to Court. New York, NY: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
He, Xin (2017) ““No Malicious Incidents” : The Concern for Stability in China's Divorce Law Practice,” 26 Social & Legal Studies 467–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin, Wang, Lungang, & Su, Yang (2013) “Above the Roof, Beneath the Law: Perceived Justice among Migrant Wage Claimants in China,” 47 Law & Society Rev. 703–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin & Su, Yang (2013) “Do the ‘Haves’ Come out Ahead in Shanghai Courts?” 10 J. of Empirical Legal Studies 121–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henry, Stuart (1983) Private Justice. Boston, MA: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Hofrichter, Richard (1982) “Neighborhood Justice and the Social Control Problems of American Capitialism: A Perspective,” in Richard, Able, ed., The Politics of Informal Justice, Vol. I. New York, NY: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Hofrichter, Richard (1987) Neighborhood Justice in Capitalist Society: The Expansion of the Informal State. New York, NY: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Huang, Philip C. C. (2010) Chinese Civil Justice, Past and Present. New York, NY: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Inc.Google Scholar
Huang, Robin Hui (2015) “Securities Dispute Resolution in China,” X J. of Comparative Law 177–88.Google Scholar
Johnson, Earl, Kantor, Valerie, & Schwartz, Elizabeth (1977) Outside the Courts: A Survey of Diversion Alternatives in Civil Cases. Denver, CO: National Center for State Courts.Google Scholar
Kagan, Robert (2003) Adversarial Legalism. Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Labournet.com.cn. (2012) Laodong zhengyi chuli tongji shuju (Statistics for labor disputes settlement). Available at: http://www.labournet.com.cn/ldzy/ckzl/ckzl.asp (accessed 23 April 2017).Google Scholar
Lai, Yunglien, Cao, Liqun, & Zhao, Jihong Solomon (2010) “The Impact of Political Entity on Confidence in Legal Authorities: A Comparison between China and Taiwan,” 38 J. of Criminal Justice 934–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, Ching Kwan (2007) Against the Law: Labor Protests in China's Rustbelt and Sunbelt. Berkeley, CA: Univ. of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, Ching Kwan (2012) “Double Subordination: Chinese Labor Regime in a South Korea Lens,” in Walter, Andrew & Zhang, Xiaoke, eds., East Asian Capitalism: Diversity Continuity and Change. Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Li, Fei. (2008) Goujian hexie laodong guanxi – quanguo fayuan laodong zhengyi anjian qingkuang diaocha (Building Harmonious Labor Relations – National Survey on the Settlement of Labor Dis- Putes by Courts). Zhongguo Fayuan Bao. Available at: http://rmfyb.chinacourt.org/public/detail.php?id=118654 (accessed 23 April 2017).Google Scholar
Li, Ji (2013) “Dare You Sue the Tax Collector? An Empirical Study of Administrative Lawsuits Against Tax Agencies in China,” 23 Pacific Rim Law & Policy J. 84–112.Google Scholar
Li, Yedan, Kochen, Joris, & van Rooij, Benjamin (2018) “Understanding China's Court Mediation Surge: Insights from a Local Court,” 43 Law & Social Inquiry 58–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lubman, Stanley (1967) “Dispute Resolution in Communist China,” 55 California Law Rev. 1284–358.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lubman, Stanley (1999) Bird in a Cage. Stanford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Merry, Sally (1992) “Popular Justice and the Ideology of Social Transformation,” 1 Social & Legal Studies 161–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merry, Sally & Milner, Neal (1993) The Possibility of Popular Justice: A Case Study of Community Mediation in the United States. Ann Arbor, MI: Univ. of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michelson, Ethan (2006) “The Practice of Law as an Obstacle to Justice: Chinese Lawyers at Work,” 40 Law & Society Rev. 1–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michelson, Ethan (2007) “Climbing the Dispute Pagoda: Grievances and Appeals to the Official Justice System in Rural China,” 72 American Sociological Rev. 459–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ministry of Labor and Social Security (1996–2006) Zhongguo Laodong Tongji Nianjian (China Labor Statistics Yearbook). Beijing, China: China Statistics Press.Google Scholar
Minzner, Carl (2011) “China's Turn against Law,” 59 American J. of Comparative Law 935–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mnookin, Robert & Kornhauser, Lewis (1979) “Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: The Case of Divorce,” 88 Yale Law J. 950–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ng, Kwai Hang & He, Xin (2014) “Internal Contradictions in China's Judicial Mediation,” 39 Law & Social Inquiry 282–312.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ng, Kwai Hang & He, Xin (2017) Embedded Courts: Judicial Decision Making in China. New York, NY: Cambridge Univ Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pun, Ngai, Lu, Huilin, & Zhang, Huipeng (2010) On the Grand Construction Site [大工地上]. Hong Kong, China: Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Salas, Louis (1983) “The Emergence and Decline of the Cuban Popular Tribunals,” 17 Law & Society Rev. 587–613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sandefur, Rebecca (2008) “Access to Civil Justice and Race, Class, and Gender Inequality,” 34 Annual Rev. of Sociology 339–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shapiro, Martin (1981) Courts: A Comparative and Political Analysis. Chicago, IL: Univ. of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Silbey, Susan S. & Merry, Sally E. (1986) “Mediator Settlement Strategies,” 8 Law & Policy 7–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SPC (1998) The Reply on the Issues of the Enforcement of the LIB.Google Scholar
Steele, Eric (1975) “Fraud, Dispute, and the Consumer: Responding to Consumer Complaints,” 123 Univ. of Pennsylvania Law Rev. 1107–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Su, Yang & He, Xin (2010) “Street as Courtroom: State Accommodation of Labor Protests in South China,” 44 Law & Society Rev. 157–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thireau, Isabelle & Linshan, Hua (2008) “The Moral Universe of Aggrieved Chinese Workers: Workers' Appeal to Arbitration Committees and Letters and Visits Offices,” 50 The China J. 83–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tomasic, Roman & Feeley, Malcolm M. (1982) Neighborhood Justice. Addison-Wesley Educational Publishers Inc..Google Scholar
Wang, Lungang. (2009) The Struggle for Rights and Interests by Migrant Workers in the China's Legal Development [法制进程中当代中国农民工非正式的利益抗争]. Doctoral Dissertation. Southwestern University of Finance and Economics, China.Google Scholar
Wang, Yuhua & Minzner, Carl (2015) “Rise of the Chinese Security State,” 222 China Q. 339–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wu, Yuning (2014) “People's Mediation in China,” in Cao, L., Sun, I., & Hebenton, B., eds., The Routledge Handbook of Chinese Criminology. London, UK: Routledge.Google Scholar
Xian, Yifan (2015) “Grassroots Judges of China in the Resurgence from Adjudicatory to MediatoryJustice,” X J. of Comparative Law 126–41.Google Scholar
Xiong, Hao (2014) “The Feasibility of Court Mediation in the Grassroots Society of Southwest China: A Case Study from Yunnan,” 44 Hong Kong Law J. 277–302.Google Scholar
Zhang, Xianchu (2015) “Rethinking the Mediation Campaign,” X J. of Comparative Law 44–64.Google Scholar
Zhao, Yuhong (2015a) “Mediation of Environmental Disputes,” X J. of Comparative Law 237–53.Google Scholar
Zhao, Yun (2015b) “Mediation in Contemporary China: Thinking about Reform,” X J. of Comparative Law 65–83.Google Scholar
Zhuang, Wenjia & Chen, Feng (2015) “‘Mediation First': The Revival of Mediation in Labor Dispute Resolution in China,” 222 China Q. 380–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zou, Mimi, Pan, Xuanming, & Han, Sirui (2015) “Regulating Collective Labor Disputes in China: A Tale of Two Actors,” X J. of Comparative Law 276–90.Google Scholar
Zuckerman, A. A. S. (1996) “Lord Woolf's Access to Justice,” 59 Modern Law Rev. 773–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar