Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-rvbq7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T13:34:33.608Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The “Production” of Corruption in China's Courts: Judicial Politics and Decision Making in a One-Party State

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Ling Li
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Despite its rampant presence, judicial corruption in China has often been regarded as the idiosyncratically deviant behavior of a few black sheep eluding prescribed judicial conduct. This entrenched assumption has both discouraged in-depth investigation of the phenomenon of judicial corruption and inhibited proper understanding of the functioning of China's courts. This article, based on an empirically grounded examination of the processing of court rulings tainted by corruption, showed that judicial corruption in China is an institutionalized activity systemically inherent in the particular decision-making mechanism guided by the Chinese Communist Party's instrumental rule-by-law ideal. In investigating what has contributed to the institutionalization of judicial corruption, the interplay between law and party politics in China's courts was also examined. The findings, therefore, also shed light on behind-the-courtroom judicial activities and on the enduring perplexity of the gap between the law in the book and the law in action.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 37 , Issue 4 , Fall 2012 , pp. 848 - 877
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2012 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

BFW. 2006. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/1/2005-09-09/172710966054.shtml (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
Bi, Yuqian, ed. 2002. Sifa Shenpan Dongtai Yu Yanjiu [Research on Judicial Development]. Beijing: Law Press.Google Scholar
Burenbatu. 2006. A Research on the Operational Mechanism of Judicial Independence in China. PhD diss., Chinese University of Political Science and Law.Google Scholar
Burns, J. P. 1994. “Strengthening Central CCP Control of Leadership Selection: The 1990 Nomenklatura. China Quarterly June:458–91.Google Scholar
Caijing. 2006. http://finance.sina.com.cn/g/20061127/18053113275 (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
Caing. 2010. http://policy.caing.com/2010-06-02/100149536.html (accessed July 1, 2011).Google Scholar
CCP Central Committee Office. 1985. Notification on Equipping Cadres in People's Courts and Procuratorates. Zhong Ban Fa[1985] No. 47.Google Scholar
CDSB. 2011. http://focus.scol.cn/zgsz/20091130/2009113065811.htm (accessed July 8, 2011).Google Scholar
Chen, Ruihua. 1998. Zhengyi De Wuqu [The Hold-Up of Justice]. Peking University Law Review 1 (2): 381–412.Google Scholar
Cheng, Wenhao. 2004. An Empirical Study of Corruption within China's State-Owned Enterprises. China Review 4 (2): 55–80.Google Scholar
Chinacourt.org. 2001. http://oldfyb.chinacourt.org/public/detail.php?id=18285 (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
China News. 2009. http://www.chinanews.com/gn/news/2009/05-06/1679465.shtml (accessed July 1, 2011).Google Scholar
China Youth Daily. 2006. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/l/2006-10-13/062711224922.shtml (accessed July 8, 2011).Google Scholar
CNHubei. 2001. http://www.cnhubei.com/200411/ca620229.htm (accessed July 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Cohen, Jerome A. 2011. Law Unto Itself—A Socialist Legal System with Chinese Characteristics. South China Morning Post (Hong Kong).Google Scholar
Courtpress. 2005. People's Court Case Report (Criminal Section). No. 47. People's Courts Press.Google Scholar
CTDSB. 2007. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/l/2007-07-20/072613488841.shtml (accessed July 5, 2011).Google Scholar
Edin, Maria. 2003. State Capacity and Local Agent Control in China: CCP Cadre Management from a Township Perspective. China Quarterly 173:35–52.Google Scholar
Fuller, Lon L. 1978. Forms and Limits of Adjudication. Harvard Law Review 92:353–409.Google Scholar
FZYXW. 2004. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2004-03-12/13423016437.shtml (accessed July 8, 2011).Google Scholar
Gaotai County Court Regulation (Gansu Province). 2004. http://www.gtxfyw.com/Article/ShowArticle.asp?ArticleID=46 (accessed August 10, 2011).Google Scholar
Gong, Ting. 2004. Dependent Judiciary and Unaccountable Judges: Judicial Corruption in Contemporary China. China Review 4 (2): 33–54.Google Scholar
Gu, Sharron. 2009. Law and Politics in Modern China: Under the Law, the Law, and Above the Law. Amherst, NY: Cambria Press.Google Scholar
Guo, Yong. 2008. Corruption in Transitional China: An Empirical Analysis. China Quarterly 194:349–64.Google Scholar
GZDSB. 2009. http://news.sohu.com/20090211/n262174423.shtml (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
GZSB. 2006. http://www.xinhuanet.com/chinanews/2006-06/07/content_7196104.htm (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
Han, Han. 2011. Other People's Lives. Han Han's Blog. http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_4701280b01017hr5.html?tj=1 (accessed November 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Han, Ling. 2007. On the Reforming and Improving for the Domestic System of Judicial Committee. JD diss., Jilin University.Google Scholar
Han, Longfu. 1997. Gudai Diwang Quanshu Daguan [An Overview of the Power Manipulation of Chinese Ancient Emperors]. Changsha, PRC: YueluShushe.Google Scholar
He, Xin. 2009. Court Finance and Court Responses to Judicial Reforms: A Tale of Two Chinese Courts. Law & Policy 31 (4): 463–86.Google Scholar
Helan County Court. 2007. Rules on Monitoring and Assessment of Case Quality. http://www.nxhlfy.gov.cn/23/2008-12-8/7843001@378.htm (accessed August 10, 2011).Google Scholar
Henderson, Keith. 2007. The Rule of Law and Judicial Corruption in China: Half-Way over the Great Wall. In Global Corruption Report 2007: Corruption in Judicial Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, T. International.Google Scholar
Hiniker, Paul J. 1969. Chinese Reactions to Forced Compliance: Dissonance Reduction or National Character. Journal of Social Psychology 77:157–76.Google Scholar
Hu, Xiabing et al. 2002. Sifa Gongzheng Yu Woguo Faguan Zhidu Gaige [Judicial Justice and the Reform of the Judiciary of China]. In Sifa Gaige Lunping [Judicial Reform Review], ed. Zhang, W., 3. Beijing: China Fazhi Press.Google Scholar
Huang, Jianliang, and Chen, Qiuhua. 2005. Faguan Tanwu, Huilu Fanzui Fenxi [A Criminological Analysis of Embezzlement and Bribery Committed by Judges]. Fazhi Pinglun Zhoukan[Rule of Law Review Weekly].Google Scholar
Jiang, Zongfu. 2010. Wo De Guanyang Nianhua [My Years in the Officialdom]. Guangzhou Daily .Google Scholar
Jiating Magazine. 2007. http://xia.cnfamily.com/200710/ca34133.htm (accessed July 5, 201).Google Scholar
Kunming Intermediate Court Regulation (Yunnan Province). 2001. http://china.findlaw.cn/fagui/gj/22/13495.html (accessed June 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Li, Dongwen. 2005. Heibai Zhijian De Shenzhen Dongmen Dashijie [Shenzhen Da Shijie in Both the Black and White Worlds]. Nanfang Dushi Bao[Southern Metropolis Newspaper].Google Scholar
Li, Ling. 2010a. Corruption in China's Courts. In Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion, ed. Peerenboom, R., 196–220. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Li, Ling. 2010b. Legality, Discretion and Informal Practices in China's Courts: A Socio-Legal Investigation of Private Transactions in the Course of Litigation. PhD diss., Leiden University.Google Scholar
Li, Ling. 2011. “Performing” Bribery in China—Guanxi-Practice: Corruption with a Human Face. Journal of Contemporary China 68:1–20.Google Scholar
Li, Xiaobo. 2001. Dangqian Zhiding Caipan Wenshu Zhong Fang'ai Shixian Sifa Gongzheng De Zhuyao Wenti Yu Gaige Silu [Thoughts for Reform to Remove Current Problems Obstructing Justice in the Composition of Court Judgments]. Sifa Shenpan Dongtai Yu Yanjiu [Research on Judicial Development] 1 (1): 224–28.Google Scholar
Li, Yuwen. 2002. Court Reform in China: Problems, Progress & Prospects. In Implementation of Law in the People's Republic of China, ed. Jianfu, C. et al., 55–84. The Hague, The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International.Google Scholar
Liebman, Benjamin L. 2007. China's Courts: Restricted Reform. China Quarterly 191:620–43.Google Scholar
Liu, Alan P. L. 1983. The Politics of Corruption in the People's Republic of China. American Political Science Review 77:602–23.Google Scholar
Liu, Nanping. 2008. Trick or Treat: Legal Reasoning in the Shadow of Corruption in PRC. North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulation 34:179–262.Google Scholar
Liu, Tianming. 1997. ZhanzaiBeigaoren Xi Shang de Faguan [The Judge Standing in the Defendant's Dock]. Zhengfufazhi[Government and Rule by Law] 6:18–19.Google Scholar
Liu, Zheng. 2008. Lun Woguo Shenpan Weiyuanhui Zhidu De Xianshi Kunjing Ji Qi Gaijin Silu [The Significant Dilemma of the Adjudicative Committee and Considerations on Reform Measures]. Xingshi Sifa Luntan [Criminal Justice Forum] 1:33–46.Google Scholar
Lui, Francis T. 1986. A Dynamic Model of Corruption Deterrence. Journal of Public Economics 31:215–36.Google Scholar
Luo, Changping. 2007. Jilin Gaofa Chuan'an [Collusion among Judges in Jilin Province]. Caijing Magazine 14. http://www.chinavalue.net/media/article.aspx?articleid=9149 (accessed November 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Luo, Shuping. 2001. Caipan Wenshushang De Zhuyao Wenti Yu Gaijin Jianyi [Main Problems and Suggestion about the Composition of Court Judgments]. Sifa Shenpan Dongtai Yu Yanjiu [Research on Judicial Development] 1 (1): 229–35.Google Scholar
Luo, Shuping. 2002. Shenpan Weiyuanhui “Shenpi Anjian” Zhidu Ying Yu Quxiao [The Practice of Adjudication by Seeking Approval from the Adjudicative Committee Should Be Abandoned]. Sifa Gaige Lunping [Judicial Reform Review] 3:51–74.Google Scholar
Manion, M. 1985. The Cadre Management System, Post-Mao China: The Appointment, Promotion, Transfer and Removal of Party and State Leaders. China Quarterly 102:203–33.Google Scholar
MRXB. 2004. http://past.tianjindaily.com.cn/docroot/200402/10/xb01/10171301.htm (accessed July 5, 2011).Google Scholar
Peerenboom, Randall. 2008. Are China's Legal Reforms Stalled? SSRN ELibrary. La Trobe Law School Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2008/13. http://ssrn.com/abtract=1283203 (accessed November 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Peerenboom, Randall. 2010. Judicial Independence in China. In Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion, ed. Peerenboom, R. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
PeopleNet. 2003. http://www.people.com.cn/gb/shehui/44/20030120/911470.html (accessed July 7, 2011).Google Scholar
Ramseyer, J. Mark, and Rasmusen, Eric B. 1997. Judicial Independence in a Civil Law Regime: The Evidence from Japan. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 13 (2): 259–86.Google Scholar
Ren, Jianxin. 1998. Annual Report of the Supreme People's Court. Supreme People's Court. http://www.court.gov.cn/qwfb/gzbg (accessed November 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Sapio, F. 2008. Shuanggui and Extralegal Detention in China. China Information 22 (1): 7–37.Google Scholar
Shouguang People's Court. 2001. “Dali'an” Jizhi De Yunxing Moshi Yu Chengxiao [The Operational Model and Effect of the “Grand Case-Registering” Mechanism]. Sifa Shenpan Dongtai Yu Yanjiu [Research on Judicial Development] 1 (1): 95–100.Google Scholar
SHRB. 2006. http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2006-11-07/031810429732s.shtml (accessed July 9. 2011).Google Scholar
Sina. 2004. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2004-03-12/13423016437.shtml (accessed July 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Sina. 2007. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/1/2007-07-20/072613488841.shtml (accessed July 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Sina. 2009. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2009-03-19/111217439571_2.shtml (accessed August 11, 2011).Google Scholar
Southern Daily. 2007. http://news.qq.com/a/20071108/001636.htm (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
Southern Daily. 2010. http://news.xinhuanet.com/legal/2010-06/03/c_12174933.htm (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
Southern People Weekly. 2005. http://nf.nfdaily.cn/rwzk/20050105/sz/200501190076.asp (accessed July 8, 2011).Google Scholar
Tan, Shigui. 2000. Zhongguo Sifa Gaige Yanjiu [A Study on Judicial Reform of China]. Beijing: Law Press China.Google Scholar
Tan, Shigui. 2003. Sifa Fubai Fangzhi Lun [Preventing Judicial Corruption]. Beijing: Law Press.Google Scholar
Tanzi, Vito. 1998. Corruption around the World: Causes, Consequences, Scope, and Cures. IMF Staff Papers 45 (4): 559–94.Google Scholar
Upham, Frank K. 2005. Political Lackeys or Faithful Public Servants? Two Views of the Japanese Judiciary. Law & Social Inquiry 30:421–55.Google Scholar
Wang, Guanglong. 2003. Reflection on the Rules of Approval for the Issuance of Court Rulings. Forefront of Reform 19 (151): 61–62.Google Scholar
Wang, Heyan. 2010. Details regarding the Case of Huang Songyou. New Century Magazine (5). http://www.chinaelections.org/newsinfo.asp?newsid=167562(accessed February 15, 2012).Google Scholar
Wang, Jian. 2006. The Thought on Court Non-Administrative Mode. Masters thesis, Jilin University.Google Scholar
Wang, Weicheng. 2004. A Few Points Regarding the Socialist Legal System with Chinese Characteristics—The 8th Legal Lecture by the Standing Committee of the NPC. http://www.nm.yfw.com.cn/printnews.asp?id=32339 (accessed July 6, 2011).Google Scholar
Wang, Yuewen. 1999. Guohua [Chinese Painting]. Beijing: Renmin Wenxue.Google Scholar
Wenshan Intermediate People's Court Regulation (Yunnan Province). 2008. http://www.wszjfy.gov.cn (accessed June 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Winston, Kenneth. 2005. The Internal Morality of Chinese Legalism. Singapore Journal of Legal Studies 313–347. http://ssrn.com/abstract=952630 .Google Scholar
XinhuaNet. 2007. http://news.shangdu.com/category/10003/2007/11/30/2007-11-30_840426_10003.shtml (accessed July 3, 2011).Google Scholar
XinhuaNet. 2010a. http://news.163.com/10/0119/09/5tco43o00001124j.html (accessed July 3, 2011).Google Scholar
XinhuaNet. 2010b. http://news.xinhuanet.com/lianzheng/2010-05/31/c_12162362.htm (accessed July 9, 2011).Google Scholar
XinhuaNet. 2011. http://news.xinhuanet.com/legal/2011-01/26/c_121027565.htm (accessed July 8, 2011).Google Scholar
Xuan, Yi. 2006. Woguo Faguan Duli Shenpan Linian Xianzhuang Ji Duice Tanxi[On the Concept, Present Conditions and Countermeasures of the Judge's Independent Trial in Our County]. Masters thesis, East University of Political Science and Law.Google Scholar
Yin, Hongwei. 2011. http://www.5186law.com/chongqingyinxiang/1518.html (accessed July 8, 2011).Google Scholar
Yu, Huaqing. 1990. Quanshu Lun: Zhongguo Gudai Zhengzhi Quanshu Pipan [A Critique of Political Power Manipulation in Ancient China]. Xi'an, PRC: Shaanxi People's Publishing House.Google Scholar
Yuan, Ling. 2008. DongchengAnTuokua Huang Songyou Deng SifaGaoguan [Dongechng Case Dragged Down Huant Soungyou and Other High Judicial Officials]. Liaowang Dongfang Zhoukan[Oriental Outlook Weekly] November 10. http://www.360doc.com/content/08/1110/23/142_1901023.shtml (accessed November 15, 2011).Google Scholar
Zhang, Weiping. 2000. Debureaucratizing People's Courts of China—One Approach of Court Reform. Review of Law and Commerce 3:3–11.Google Scholar
Zhao, Ziyang. 2009. Gaige Licheng [Prisoner of the State—The Secret Journal of Premier Zhao Ziyang]. Hong Kong: New Century.Google Scholar
Zhi, Min. 2003. Liangming Laoren Gaodao Liu Ming Dafaguan [Two Elderlies Won a Case Against Six Judges]. Fazhi Yu Shehui [Rule by Law and the Society] 3:15–18.Google Scholar
Zhu, Dinglong. 2007. Guansi [Lawsuit]. Beijing: Law Press.Google Scholar
Zhu, Jingwen, ed. 2007. Zhongguo Falü Fazhan Baogao (1979–2004) [China Legal Development Report (1979–2004)]. Beijing: People's University.Google Scholar
Zhu, Suli. 2010. The Party and the Courts. In Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion, ed. Peerenboom, R., 52–68. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Zou, Keyuan. 2000. Judicial Reform versus Judicial Corruption: Recent Developments in China. Criminal Law Forum 11:321–51.Google Scholar
21CBN. 2004. http://www.21cbh.com/html/2004-2-12/14016.html (access July 1, 2011).Google Scholar
163NET. 2009. http://news.163.com/09/0507/14/58netdjb0001124j.html (accessed July 1, 2011).Google Scholar

Cases Cited

Beijing City No. 1 Procuratorate v. Mai Chongkai, Criminal Division, Beijing No. 1 Intermediate Court (2003).Google Scholar
Chongqing No. 5 People's Procuratorate v. Zheng Wei, Criminal Division, Chongqing No. 5 Intermediate Court No. 195 (2007).Google Scholar
Dalian City Procuratorate v. Mu Suixin, Criminal Division, Dalian Intermediate Court, No. 153 (2007).Google Scholar
Loudi City Procuratorate v. Li Xiaohua, Criminal Division, Lianyuan City Court (2006).Google Scholar
Wanbolin District Procuratorate v. Sun Jinxi, Criminal Division, Wanboli District Court (2006).Google Scholar

Statutes Cited

CCP Charter (1927).Google Scholar
CCP Charter (1945).Google Scholar
CCP Charter (1956).Google Scholar
CCP Charter (2007).Google Scholar
CCP Central Committee Office, “Notification on Equipping Cadres in People's Courts and Procuratorates,” Zhong Ban Fa [1985] No. 47 (1985).Google Scholar
CCP Directive for the Selection and Appointment of Party Cadres (2002).Google Scholar
Chinese Civil Procedural Law (1991).Google Scholar
Chinese Criminal Procedural Law (2005).Google Scholar
Organizational Law Governing People's Courts (1983).Google Scholar
Regulation on the Selection of Panel-Leader in People's Court (provisional) (2000).Google Scholar
Rules on the Working Procedure of Collegial Panels (2000).Google Scholar
SPC Notice on Rules Governing the Processing of Official Documents in People's Courts, Fa Fa 1996(9) (1996).Google Scholar
SPC Notice to Qinghai High Court on Issues Related to the Signature of Court Judgments of Criminal Cases (1956).Google Scholar
SPC Notification on Enhancing Court Leaders and Divisional Leaders' Participation in Collegial Panel and Attendance in Court Trials. No. 14 (2007).Google Scholar
SPC Opinions on Formalizing the Adjudicative Working Relationship between the Higher and Lower Courts (2010).Google Scholar
SPC Reply to Beijing High Court on Whether Court Presidents Shall Sign Off Court Judgments (1963).Google Scholar
SPC Reply to Tai'an Intermediate Court on Who Should Sign off Court Judgments of Cases Deliberated by the Court Adjudicative Committee (1957).Google Scholar
SPC Working Rules on the Guiding-Case System, Fa Fa 2010(51) (2010).Google Scholar