Mr. Shen Yuting, in this Journal, vol. 18, no. 2 (June, 1953), stated a new paradox of intuitive set-theory. This paradox involves what Mr. Yuting calls the class of all grounded classes, that is, the family of all classes a for which there is no infinite sequence b such that … ϵ bn ϵ … ϵ b2ϵb1 ϵ a.

Now it is possible to state this paradox without employing any complex set-theoretical notions (like those of a natural number or an infinite sequence). For let a class x be called regular if and only if (k)(x ϵ k ⊃ (∃y)(y ϵ k · ~(∃z)(z ϵ k · z ϵ y))). Let Reg be the class of all regular classes. I shall show that Reg is neither regular nor non-regular.

Suppose, on the one hand, that Reg is regular. Then Reg ϵ Reg. Now Reg ϵ ẑ(z = Reg). Therefore, since Reg is regular, there is a y such that y ϵ ẑ(z = Reg) · ~(∃z)(z ϵ z(z = Reg) · z ϵ y). Hence ~(∃z)(z ϵ ẑ(z = Reg) · z ϵ Reg). But there is a z (namely Reg) such that z ϵ ẑ(z = Reg) · z ϵ Reg.

On the other hand, suppose that Reg is not regular. Then, for some k, Reg ϵ k · [1] (y)(y ϵ k ⊃ (∃z)(z ϵ k · z ϵ y)). It follows that, for some z, z ϵ k · z ϵ Reg. But this implies that (ϵy)(y ϵ k · ~(ϵw)(w ϵ k · w ϵ y)), which contradicts [1].

It can easily be shown, with the aid of the axiom of choice, that the regular classes are just Mr. Yuting's grounded classes.