Please note, due to essential maintenance online transactions will not be possible between 02:30 and 04:00 BST, on Tuesday 17th September 2019 (22:30-00:00 EDT, 17 Sep, 2019). We apologise for any inconvenience.
Foreordained Failure: The Quest for a Constitutional Principle of Religious Freedom. By Steven D. Smith. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press1995. Pp. 174. (Out of print.) ISBN: 0-195-09075-6. Paper. $19.95. ISBN: 0-195-13248-3.
1.Fish, Stanley, Mission Impossible: Settling the Just Bounds Between Church and State, 97Colum. L. Rev.2255 (1997).
2.Id. at 2264.
3. Lawrence G. Sager and I have explored this point at greater length in a review essay devoted partly to Smith's book. Eisgruber, Christopher L. & Sager, Lawrence G., Unthinking Religious Freedom, 74Tex. L. Rev. 577, 595–600 (1996).
4. Lawrence Sager and I have elsewhere claimed that it cannot be. Eisgruber & Sager, supra n. 3, at 591-592. Stanley Fish also claims that Smith's conclusions and critique are inconsistent with one another. Fish, supra n. 1, at 2320-2324.
5. Sager and I elaborate this point at greater length in Eisgruber & Sager, supra n. 3, at 597600, 602-612.
6. I am not sure whether Fish would agree with this conclusion. There is some evidence to suggest that he would. For example, he says that the point of his article is not to critique theories which “proceed from a strong angle of conviction”; he is concerned with those theories that make it their “project … to proceed from no angle, or from an angle so wide that it takes in everyone, no matter what his or her religion, political affiliation, ethnic identification, etc.” Fish, supra n. 1 at 2257.
† Laurance S. Rockefeller Professor of Public Affairs and in the University Center for Human Values; Director of the Program in Law and Public Affairs, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey.
Recommend this journal
Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.