Skip to main content Accessibility help

Nutritional depletion of total mixed rations by red-winged blackbirds and projected impacts on dairy cow performance

  • James C. Carlson (a1), Randal S. Stahl (a1), John J. Wagner (a2), Terry E. Engle (a2), Shelagh T. DeLiberto (a1), Dustin A. Reid (a1) and Scott J. Werner (a1)...


This Research Communication describes an investigation of the nutritional depletion of total mixed rations (TMR) by pest birds. We hypothesized that species-specific bird depredation of TMR can alter the nutritional composition of the ration and that these changes can negatively impact the performance of dairy cows. Blackbirds selected the high energy fraction of the TMR (i.e., flaked corn) and reduced starch, crude fat and total digestible nutrients during controlled feeding experiments. For Holsteins producing 37·1 kg of milk/d, dairy production modeling illustrated that total required net energy intake (NEI) was 35·8 Mcal/d. For the reference TMR unexposed to blackbirds and the blackbird-consumed TMR, NEI supplied was 41·2 and 37·8 Mcal/d, and the resulting energy balance was 5·4 and 2·0 Mcal/d, respectively. Thus, Holsteins fed the reference and blackbird-consumed TMR were estimated to gain one body condition score in 96 and 254 d, and experience daily weight change due to reserves of 1·1 and 0·4 kg/d, respectively. We discuss these results in context of an integrated pest management program for mitigating the depredation caused by pest birds at commercial dairies.


Corresponding author

*For correspondence; e-mail:


Hide All
Benjamini, Y & Hochberg, Y 1995 Controlling for false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 57 289300
Besser, JF, DeGrazio, JW & Guarino, JL 1968 Costs of wintering starlings and red-winged blackbirds at feedlots. Journal of Wildlife Management 32 179180
Carlson, JC, Stahl, RS, DeLiberto, ST, Wagner, JJ, Engle, TE, Engeman, RM, Olson, CS, Ellis, JW & Werner, SJ 2018 Nutritional depletion of total mixed rations by European starlings: projected effects on dairy cow performance and potential intervention strategies to mitigate damage. Journal of Dairy Science 101 17771784
Depenbusch, BE, Drouillard, JS & Lee, CD 2011 Feed depredation by European starlings in a Kansas feedlot. Human-Wildlife Interactions 5 5865
Dolbeer, RA, Wornecki, PA, Strickley, JR & White, SB 1978 Agricultural impact of a winter population of blackbirds and starlings. Wilson Bulletin 90 3144
Glahn, JF, Twedt, DJ & Otis, DL 1983 Estimating feed loss from starling use of livestock feed troughs. Wildlife Society Bulletin 11 366372
National Research Council (NRC) 2001 Nutrient Requirement of Dairy Cattle, Seventh edition. National Research Council, National Academy Press, Washington, DC
Shwiff, SA, Carlson, JC, Glass, H, Suckow, J, Lowney, MS, Moxcey, KM, Larson, B & Linz, GM 2012 Producer survey of bird livestock interactions in commercial dairies. Journal of Dairy Science 95 68206829
Twedt, DJ & Glahn, JF 1982 Reducing starling depredation at livestock feeding operations through changes in management practices. Proceedings of the Vertebrate Pest Conference 10 159163
White, SB, Dolbeer, RA & Bookhout, TA 1985 Ecology, bioenergetics, and agricultural impacts of a winter-roosting population of blackbirds and starlings. Wildlife Monographs 93 142



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed