Skip to main content Accessibility help

Effect of changes in milking routine on milking related behaviour and milk removal in Tunisian dairy dromedary camels

  • Moufida Atigui (a1) (a2) (a3) (a4), Pierre-Guy Marnet (a2) (a3), Naziha Ayeb (a1), Touhami Khorchani (a1) and Mohamed Hammadi (a1)...


We studied the effects of changes in the milking routine (lack or presence of 30-s prestimulation, 0 or 1, 2 or 4-min delay between preparation and cluster attachment) and environmental perturbation (unusual loud sounds capable of frightening animals just after stall entry or during the course of milking) on milk removal and milking-related behaviour in dairy dromedary camels. A 30-s prestimulation decreased incidence of bimodal milk flow curves and increased occurrence of the best milk ejection patterns with higher milk flow but had limited effect on milk production in our well-trained animals within a good machine milking setting. However, unusual sounds heard from the beginning of milking or even after milk ejection caused inhibition or disruption of milk removal and modification of camels’ behaviour. Milk ejection was significantly delayed (1·58±0·17 min), residual milk increased over 40% of total milk yield and average and peak milk flow rates were significantly lowered when unusual noises were heard from the beginning of milking. These environmental perturbations increased signs of vigilance and the number of attempts to escape the milking parlour. Delaying cluster attachment for over 1 min after the end of udder preparation caused serious milk losses. Up to 62% of total milk was withheld in the udder when the delay reached 4 min. Average and peak milk flow rates also decreased significantly with delayed milking. Signs of vigilance and attempts to escape from the milking parlour appeared when camels waited for over 2 min. After a 4-min delay, camels showed signs of acute stress. Defaecation prior to milk ejection (solid faeces) and rumination during milking can be used to assess camels’ milk ejection during milking. Animal welfare and milking efficiency can be ensured when camels are pre-stimulated, milked in calm conditions and with cluster attachment within a maximum of a 1-min delay after stimulation


Corresponding author

* For correspondence; e-mail:


Hide All
Ambord, S, Stoffel, HM & Bruckmaier, MR 2010 Teat anatomy affects requirements for udder preparation in Mediterranean buffaloes. Journal of Dairy Research 77 468473
Atigui, M, Hammadi, M, Barmat, A, Khorchani, T & Marnet, PG 2011 Effects of vacuum level and pulsation rate on milk flow traits in Tunisian Maghrebi camels (Camelus dromedarius). In Book of Abstracts of the 62nd Annual Meeting of EAAP, Stavanger, Norway, vol. 17, p. 298
Atigui, M, Hammadi, M, Barmat, A, Farhat, M, Khorchani, T & Marnet, PG 2014 First description of milk flow traits in Tunisian dairy dromedary camels under intensive farming system. Journal of Dairy Research 81 173182
Bernabé, J & Ricordel, MJ 1985 Effects of adrenalin and phenylephrine on milk extraction during machine milking of cows. Reproduction, Nutrition and Development 25 379388
Billon, P, Gaudin, V & Huneau, T 2006 Influence of waiting between udder stimulation and milk clusters attachment on milking and milk quality. Compte Rendu 1410631016 Institut de l'Elevage, France. 35 p
Bobic, T, Mijić, P, Kneževič, I, Šperanda, M, Antunovič, B, Baban, M, Sakač, M, Frizon, E & Koturič, T 2011 The impact of environmental factors on the milk ejection and stress of dairy cows. Biotechnology in Animal Husbandry 27 919927
Borghese, A, Rasmussen, M & Thomas, CS 2007 Milking management of dairy buffalo. Italian Journal of Animal Science 6 3950
Bruckmaier, RM & Blum, JW 1996 Simultaneous recording of oxytocin release, milk ejection and milk flow during milking of dairy cows with and without pre-stimulation. Journal of Dairy Research 63 201208
Bruckmaier, RM & Hilger, M 2001 Milk ejection in dairy cows at different degrees of udder filling. Journal of Dairy Research 68 369–337
Bruckmaier, RM, Mayer, H & Schams, D 1991 Effects of á- and â-adrenergic agonists on intramammary pressure and milk flow in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Research 58 411419
Bruckmaier, RM, Schams, D & Blum, JW 1993 Milk removal in familiar and unfamiliar surroundings: concentration of oxytocin, prolactin, cortisol and â-endorphin. Journal of Dairy Research 60 449456
Bruckmaier, RM, Schams, D & Blum, JW 1994 Continuously elevated concentrations of oxytocin during milking are necessary for complete milk removal in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Research 61 323334
Caja, G, Ayadi, M & Knight, CH 2004 Changes in cisternal compartment based on stage of lactation and time since milk ejection in the udder of dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 87 24092415
Caja, G, Salama, OA, Fathy, A, El-Sayed, H & Salama, AAK 2011 Milk partitioning and accumulation in the camel udder according to time elapsed after milking. In Book of Abstracts of the 62nd Annual Meeting of EAAP, Stavanger, Norway, vol. 17, p. 363
Cavallina, R, Roncoroni, C, Campagna, MC, Minero, M & Canali, E 2008 Buffalo behavioural response to machine milking in early lactation. Italian Journal of Animal Science 7 287295
De Passillé, AM, Marnet, PG, Lapierre, H & Rushen, J 2008 Effects of twice-a-day nursing a calf on milk ejection and milk yield during nursing and milking in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 91 14161422
Dzidic, A, Macuhova, J & Bruckmaier, RM 2004 Effects of cleaning duration and water temperature on oxytocin release and milk removal in an automatic milking system. Journal of Dairy Science 87 41634169
Eisa, MO, Abu-Nikhaila, AM, Abd El Majid, AM & Abdel Moniem, MAE 2012 Study on milk stimulation interval in camels using the nomadic traditional method. Algerian Journal of Arid Environment 2 4249
Gorewit, RC & Aromando, MC 1985 Mechanisms involved in the adrenalin induced blockade of milk ejection in dairy cattle. In Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine, vol. 180, pp. 340347
Gorewit, RC & Gasman, KB 1985 Effect of duration of udder stimulation on milking dynamics and oxytocin release. Journal of Dairy Science 68 18131818
Hammadi, M, Atigui, M, Ayadi, M, Barmat, A, Belgacem, A, Khaldi, G & Khorchani, T 2010 Training period and short time effects of machine milking on milk yield and milk composition in Tunisian Maghrebi camels (Camelus dromedarius). Journal of Camel Practice and Research 17 17
Hammon, HM, Bruckmaier, RM, Honegger, UE & Blum, JW 1994 Distribution and density of α- and β-adrenergic binding sites in the bovine mammary gland. Journal of Dairy Research 61 4757
Hemsworth, PH, Barnett, JL & Coleman, GJ 1993 The human-animal relationship in agriculture and its consequences for the animal. Animal Welfare 2 3351
Jacobs, JA & Siegford, JM 2012 Lactating dairy cows adapt quickly to being milked by an automatic milking system. Journal of Dairy Sciences 95 15751584
Juhasz, J & Nagy, P 2008 Challenges in the development of a large-scale milking system for dromedary camels. In Proceedings of the WBC/ICAR 2008 Satellite Meeting on Camelid Reproduction, pp. 8487 (Eds Nagy, P, Huszenicza, G & Juhasz, J) Budapest, Hungary
Kaskous, S & Bruckmaier, RM 2011 Best combination of pre-stimulation and latency period duration before cluster attachment for efficient oxytocin release and milk ejection in cows with low to high udder-filling levels. Journal of Dairy Research 78 97104
Labussière, J 1999 The physiology of milk ejection: consequences on milking techniques. In Biology of Lactation, pp. 307343 (Eds Martinet, J, Houdebine, LM & Head, HH). Paris: INRA.
Macuhova, J, Tancin, V, Kraetzl, WD, Meyer, HHD & Bruckmaier, RM 2002 Inhibition of oxytocin release during repeated milking in unfamiliar surroundings: the importance of opioids and adrenal cortex sensitivity. Journal of Dairy Research 69 6367
Macuhova, J, Tancin, V & Bruckmaier, RM 2004 Oxytocin release and milk removal after delayed or long-lasting teat cup attachment during automatic milking. Livestock Production Science 87 237244
Marnet, PG & Negrao, JA 2000 The effect of a mixed-management system on the release of oxytocin, prolactin, and cortisol in ewes during suckling and machine milking. Reproduction Nutrition and Development 40 271281
Martin, P & Bateson, P 1993 Measuring Behaviour – An Introductory Guide, 2nd edn, p. 222. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Neijenhuis, F & Hillerton, JE 2003 Effects of milking interval on teat condition and milking performance with whole-udder take off. Report of EU project: Implications of the introduction of automatic milking on dairy farms. Available in February 04 2014
Rasmussen, MD, Frimer, ES, Galton, DM & Petersson, LG 1992 The influence of premilking teat preparation and attachment delay on milk yield and milking performance. Journal of Dairy Science 75 21312141
Reinemann, DJ, Mein, GA & Ruegg, PL 2001 Evaluating milking machine performance. In VII International Congress on Bovine Medicine, Oviedo, Asturias, Spain, June 29–July 1, 2001
Rushen, J, de Passille, AMB & Munksgaard, L 1999. Fear of people by cows and effects on milk yield, behaviour, and heart rate at milking. Journal of Dairy Sciences 82 720727
Rushen, J, Munksgaard, L, Marnet, PG & DePassille, AM 2001 Human contact and the effect of acute stress on cows at milking. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 73 114
Salamon, D, Matokovic, I, Batinic, V & Dzidic, A 2011 The effect of pre-stimulation on milking characteristics in Simmental, Holstein-Friesian and Brown Swiss cow breed. Agriculturae Conspectus Scientificus 76 317320
Schmidt, GH 1971 Biology of Lactation, p. 151. San Francisco, CA, USA: WH Freeman and Company
Seifu, E 2009 Analysis on the contributions of and constraints to camel production in Shinile and Jijiga zones, eastern Ethiopia. Journal of Agriculture and Environment for International Development 103 213224
Squines, SL 2003 Applied Animal Endocrinology, p. 234. Cambridge, MA, USA: CABI Publishing
Stefanowska, J, Plavsic, M, Ipema, AH & Hendriks, MMWB 2000 The effect of omitted milking on the behaviour of cows in the context of cluster attachment failure during automatic milking. Applied Animal Behaviour Sciences 67 277291
Welp, T, Rushen, J, Kramer, DL, Festa-Bianchet, M & De Passillé, AMB 2004 Vigilance as measure of fear in dairy cattle. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 87 113
Weiss, D, Dzidic, A & Bruckmaier, RM 2003. Effect of stimulation intensity on oxytocin release before, during and after machine milking. Journal of Dairy Research 70 349354
Wellnitz, O, Bruckmaier, RM & Blum, JW 1997 Naloxone and adrenergic blocking agents fail to abolish central inhibition of milk ejection in cows. Journal of Dairy research 64 627663
Wenzel, C, Schönreiter-Fischer, S & Unshelm, J 2012 Studies on step–kick behavior and stress of cows during milking in an automatic milking system. Livestock Production Science 83 237246
Yagil, R, Van Creveld, C, Abu-R'Kaik, G & Merin, U 1999 Milk “Let-down” in camels. Journal of Camel practice and Research 6 2729


Effect of changes in milking routine on milking related behaviour and milk removal in Tunisian dairy dromedary camels

  • Moufida Atigui (a1) (a2) (a3) (a4), Pierre-Guy Marnet (a2) (a3), Naziha Ayeb (a1), Touhami Khorchani (a1) and Mohamed Hammadi (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed