Skip to main content Accessibility help

A comparison of management practices, farmer-perceived disease incidence and winter housing on organic and non-organic dairy farms in the UK

  • Fritha M Langford (a1), Kenneth MD Rutherford (a1), Mhairi C Jack (a1), Lorna Sherwood (a1), Alistair B Lawrence (a1) and Marie J Haskell (a1)...


There have been increases in the number of organic dairy farms in the UK in recent years. However, there is little information on the impact of organic regulations on cow welfare. As part of a larger study, we aimed to investigate differences between organic and non-organic farms in management practices and winter housing quality. Forty organic and 40 non-organic farms throughout the UK were visited. Organic and non-organic farms were paired for housing type, and as far as possible for herd size, genetic merit and location. A detailed questionnaire covering key aspects of dairy management was carried out with each farmer. On a subset of twenty pairs, an assessment of the quality of the winter housing for both lactating and dry cows was undertaken, covering the parlour, bedding, loafing and feeding areas. Management practices and building conditions varied greatly within farm types and there was considerable overlap between organic and non-organic farms. Milk yield, level and composition of concentrate feed, management of heifers and calving, and use of ‘alternative treatments’ to prevent and treat mastitis differed between organic and non-organic farms. In all other respects there were no differences between farm types. Building dimensions per cow did not differ, even though organic recommendations advise greater space per cow than recommended for non-organic farms. The similarity between organic and non-organic farms in most respects indicates that cow housing and health, based on both the described management regimes and the farmers' perceptions of disease incidence, on organic dairy farms is neither compromised by the regulations, nor considerably better than on non-organic farms.


Corresponding author

*For correspondence; e-mail;


Hide All
Biggs, A 1999 Mastitis therapy. Cattle Practice 7 1518
CEC [Commission of the European Communities] 2004 Consolidated text (01/05/04) of Council Regulation No 2092/91 on organic production. Official Journal of the European Communities L198 115
DEFRA [Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs] 2003 Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Cattle p. 19
Green, MJ, Bradley, AJ, Medley, GF & Browne, WJ 2007 Cow, farm, and management factors during the dry period that determine the rate of clinical mastitis after calving. Journal of Dairy Science 90 37643776
Livestock Production Standards 2006 Organic Inspection and Certification Control Manual, Section 8, pp. 159. Shrewsbury, UK: Organic Farmers & Growers Ltd.
Hardeng, F & Edge, VL 2001 Mastitis, ketosis and milk fever in 31 organic and 93 conventional Norwegian dairy herds. Journal of Dairy Science 84 26732679
Haskell, MJ, Rennie, LJ, Bowell, VA, Bell, MJ & Lawrence, AB 2006 Housing system, milk production, and zero-grazing effects on lameness and leg injury in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 89 42594266
Hektoen, L, Larsen, S, Ødegaard, SA & Løken, T 2004 Comparison of homeopathy, placebo and antibiotic treatment of clinical mastitis in dairy cows – methodological issues and results from a randomized-clinical trial. Journal of the Veterinary Medicine Series A 51 439446
Hovi, M & Roderick, S 2000 Mastitis and mastitis control strategies in organic milk production. Cattle Practice 8 259264
Hovi, M, Sundrum, A & Thamsborg, SM 2003 Animal health and welfare in organic livestock production in Europe: current state and future challenges. Livestock Production Science 80 4153
Huang, CL 1996 Consumer preferences and attitudes towards organically grown produce. European Review of Agricultural Economics 23 331342
Kondo, S, Sekine, J, Okubo, M & Asahida, Y 1989 The effect of group size and space allowance on the agonistic and spacing behaviour of cattle. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 24 127135
Løken, T 2001 Alternative therapy of animals – homeopathy and other alternative methods of therapy. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica Supplement 95 4750
Lund, V 2006 Natural living – a precondition for animal welfare in organic farming. Livestock Science 100 7183
Nederhof, AJ 1985 Methods of coping with social desirability bias: A review. European Journal of Social Psychology 15 263280
O'Mahony, MC, Healy, AM, O'Farrell, KJ & Doherty, ML 2006 Animal health and disease therapy on organic dairy farms in the Republic of Ireland. Veterinary Record 159 680682
Roche, JF 2006 The effect of nutritional management of the dairy cow on reproductive efficiency. Animal Reproduction Science 96 282296
Rozzi, P, Miglior, F & Hand, KJ 2007 A total merit selection index for Ontario organic dairy farmers. Journal of Dairy Science 90 15841593
Rutherford, KMD, Langford, FM, Jack, MJ, Sherwood, L, Lawrence, AB & Haskell, MJ 2008 Lameness prevalence and risk factors in organic and non-organic dairy herds in the United Kingdom. Veterinary Journal doi:10.1016/j.tvjl.2008.03.015
Sato, K, Bartlett, PC, Erskine, RJ & Kaneene, JB 2005 A comparison of production and management between Wisconsin organic and conventional herds. Livestock Production Science 93 105115
Sehested, J, Kristensen, T & Søegaard, K 2003 Effect of concentrate supplementation level on production, health and efficiency in an organic dairy herd. Livestock Production Science 80 153165
Sundrum, A 2001 Organic livestock farming, a critical review. Livestock Production Science 67 207215
Swali, A & Wathes, DC 2006 Influence of the dam and sire on size at birth and subsequent growth, milk production and fertility in dairy heifers. Theriogenology 66 11731184
Vaast, M, Thamsborg, SM, Bennedsgaard, TW, Houe, H, Enevoldsen, C, Aarestrup, FM & de Snoo, A 2003 Organic dairy farmers' decision making in the first 2 years after conversion in relation to mastitis treatments. Livestock Production Science 80 109120
Vaast, M, Bennedsgaard, TW, Klaas, I, Nissen, TB, Thamsborg, SM & Østergaard, S 2006 Development and daily management of an explicit strategy of nonuse of antimicrobial drugs in twelve Danish organic dairy herds. Journal of Dairy Science 89 18421853
Von Borell, E & Sørensen, JT 2004 Organic livestock production in Europe: aims, rules and trends with special emphasis on animal health and welfare. Livestock Production Science 90 39



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed