Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-c9gpj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-12T11:23:03.391Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Mercantile Monasteries”: Shops, Shop Assistants, and Shop Life in Late-Victorian and Edwardian Britain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

Christopher P. Hosgood
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

It is now over twenty years since Geoffrey Crossick first urged historians to investigate the English lower middle class. On that occasion he suggested that small business interests and white-collar employees be designated the two wings of a residual lower middle class. Historians speculated that the members of this class were bound together by their marginality to the social, cultural, and economic world of the middle class and by their pathetic attempts to ape the gentility of their superiors. Such an analysis confirmed the unheroic nature of the lower-middle-class mentalité and explains Crossick's conclusion that this group “claimed no vital social role.” Crossick's more recent work, in collaboration with Heinz-Gerhard Haupt, offers a reevaluation of this earlier position and concludes that white-collar and small business interests should not be considered to occupy the same social station. Crossick and Haupt's work is significant because both authors make it clear that they now credit the petite bourgeoisie of small business families in Europe with a greater spirit of independence than they had earlier acknowledged. They argue convincingly that the petite bourgeoisie created their own social and cultural world, centered on the interrelationship between enterprise and family life, which enabled them to react more purposefully to outside social forces and agencies.

By hiving off these small business interests from the old lower middle class, we are left with a rump of white-collar workers who collectively formed a lower middle class that shared many common experiences and hence is attractive to historians as a potentially more cohesive social body.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 38 , Issue 3: Masculinity and the Lower Middle Class , July 1999 , pp. 322 - 352
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Crossick, Geoffrey, ed., The Lower Middle Class in Britain: 1870-1914 (London, 1977), p. 12Google Scholar. See also the recent appraisals of the period by Thompson, F. M. L., The Rise of Respectable Society: A Social History of Victorian Britain, 1830-1900 (London, 1988)Google Scholar; and Harrison, J. F. C., Late Victorian Britain, 1875-1901 (London, 1990)Google Scholar.

2 Crossick, Geoffrey, “Shopkeepers and the State in Britain, 1870-1914,” in Shopkeepers and Master Artisans in Nineteenth-Century Europe, ed. Crossick, Geoffrey and Haupt, Heinz-Gerhard (London, 1984), p. 247Google Scholar. I contend this point in Hosgood, Christopher P., “The ‘Pigmies of Commerce’ and the Working-Class Community: Small Shopkeepers in England, 1870-1914,” Journal of Social History 22 (1989): 439–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar, “‘A Brave and Daring Folk’: Shopkeepers and Trade Associational Life in Victorian and Edwardian England,” Journal of Social History 26 (1992): 285–308CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and “The ‘Knights of the Road’: Commercial Travellers and the Culture of the Commercial Room in Late-Victorian and Edwardian England,” Victorian Studies 37 (1994): 519–47Google Scholar.

3 Crossick, Geoffrey and Haupt, Heinz-Gerhard, eds., The Petite Bourgeoisie in Europe, 1780-1914 (New York, 1995)Google Scholar.

4 Wells, H. G., Wheels of Chance (London, 1896), p. 168Google Scholar.

5 Wells, H. G., Experiment in Autobiography: Discoveries and Conclusions of a Very Ordinary Brain (Since 1866) (New York, 1934), pp. 115, 122Google Scholar.

6 Wells, , Wheels of Chance, p. 7Google Scholar.

7 Warren, Samuel, Ten Thousand a Year (Edinburgh, 1841), pp. 9–13Google Scholar.

8 Lockwood, David, The Blackcoated Worker (London, 1958), p. 22Google Scholar.

9 Anderson, Gregory, Victorian Clerks (Manchester, 1976), p. 30Google Scholar.

10 Ibid., p. 108; Lockwood, , The Blackcoated Worker, pp. 141–42Google Scholar.

11 Lancaster, Bill, The Department Store: A Social History (Leicester, 1995), pp. 125–58Google Scholar.

12 Report and Special Report from the Select Committee on the Shop Hours Bill, Parliamentary Papers, 1892 (287), vol. 17 (hereafter 1892 S. C), question 3943, p. 169Google Scholar; question 3967, p. 170.

13 Behind the Counter: Sketches by a Shop Assistant (Aberdare, 1888), p. 4Google Scholar.

14 See Holcombe, Lee, Victorian Ladies at Work (Newton Abbot, 1973), pp. 103–40Google Scholar.

15 Report from the Select Committee on Shop Hours Regulation Bill, Parliamentary Papers, 1886 (155), vol. 12 (hereafter 1886 S. C), question 746, p. 43Google Scholar.

16 Holcombe, , Victorian Ladies at Work, p. 136Google Scholar.

17 1886 S. C, question 219, p. 12.

18 1892 S. C, appendix 10, p. 245.

19 1886 S. C, p. 95.

20 Malone, Caroline, “Gendered Discourses and the Making of Protective Labor Legislation in England, 1830-1914,” Journal of British Studies 37 (1998): 167CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Report from the Select Committee on Shops (Early Closing) Bill, Parliamentary Papers, 1895 (273), vol. 12 (hereafter 1895 S. C), questions 5379, 5389, p. 219Google Scholar.

22 1892 S. C, question 752, p. 28.

23 1892 S. C. question 1223, p. 52.

24 1886 S. C. question 215, p. 12.

25 1892 S. C. appendix 10, p. 247.

26 Anderson, Will, The Servitude of the Shop and Its Abolition (London, 1907), p. 4Google Scholar.

27 1886 S. C. question 212, pp. 11-12.

28 1886 S. C. question 853, p. 50.

29 Early Closing Association, 1880-81 Annual Report (London, 1881), pp. 37-38, 46–47Google Scholar.

30 Pioneer (21 May 1910).

31 Shop Assistant (February 1901).

32 Shop Assistant (8 March 1902).

33 1886 S. C, question 642, p. 38.

34 Royal Commission on Labour, “The Employment of Women,” Report by Miss Clare E. Collett on the Condition of Work in London, C. 6894, Parliamentary Papers, 1893–1894, vol. 37, pt. 1Google Scholar (hereafter 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Women), p. 91.

35 1892 S. C, questions 2386-96, p. 96; questions 1976-85, p. 82.

36 Ross, Ellen, Love and Toil: Motherhood in Outcast London, 1870-1914 (Oxford, 1993), pp. 44–45Google Scholar.

37 1895 S. C, questions 784-86, p. 34.

38 1892 S. C, question 4077, p. 175.

39 1892 S. C, p. 246.

40 Ross, Frederick, Edward Charlton; or, Life behind the Counter (London, 1860), p. 112Google Scholar.

41 Guild, Curtis, Over the Ocean; or, Sights and Scenes in Foreign Lands (Boston, 1871), p. 162Google Scholar. “The English shop boy,” explained one exasperated visitor, “tells you a lie with lofty unconcern. … He lies unflinchingly” (Malabari, Behramji, The Indian Eye on English Life, or Rambles of a Pilgrim Reformer [Westminster, 1893], p. 163)Google Scholar.

42 Shop Assistant (February 1898).

43 Rappaport, Erika, “‘The Halls of Temptation’: Gender, Politics, and the Construction of the Department Store in Late Victorian London,” Journal of British Studies 35 (1996): 66CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Lancaster, , The Department Store, p. 69Google Scholar.

44 Hallsworth, Joseph and Davies, Rhys J., The Working Life of Shop Assistants: A Study of Conditions of Labour in the Distributive Trades (Manchester, 1910), p. 121Google Scholar.

45 Goffman, Erving, “On the Character of Total Institutions,” in Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates (Chicago, 1961), p. xiiiGoogle Scholar.

46 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Women, p. 3.

47 Booth, Charles, Life and Labour in London, 2d ser., vol. 3, Industry (1902-1904) (New York, 1970), p. 84Google Scholar. Lee Holcombe suggests that living in was widespread in England and Wales. It was less prevalent in the north, common in the midlands and general in the south. Bill Lancaster's work on Newcastle and Sunderland, and my own work on Leicester, would tend to confirm this tentative conclusion. Holcombe, , Victorian Ladies at Work, p. 112Google Scholar; Lancaster, , The Department Store, p. 128Google Scholar.

48 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Women, pp. 8-9.

49 1892 S. C, question 1938, p. 81; questions 2085-97, pp. 85-86.

50 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Women, p. 4.

51 Report of the Truck Committee, C. 4442, Parliamentary Papers, 1908, vol. 59 (hereafter 1908 Truck Committee), question 13553, p. 139Google Scholar.

52 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Women, p. 4; p. 88.

53 Hoffman, P. C., They Also Serve (London, 1949), p. 24Google Scholar.

54 1892 S. C, questions 3960-61, p. 170.

55 Royal Commission on Labour, Minutes of Evidence before Group C of the Royal Commission, vol. 3, C. 6894, Parliamentary Papers, 1893–1894, vol. 34 (hereafter 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes), appendix 85, question 30783, p. 421Google Scholar.

56 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 30809, p. 423.

57 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Women, p. 5.

58 1892 S. C, appendix 10, p. 246.

59 1886 S. C, question 535, p. 32.

60 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 30776, p. 420.

61 Booth, , Life and Labour in London, 3:75Google Scholar.

62 Cited in Whitaker, Wilfrid, Victorian and Edwardian Shopworkers: The Struggle to Obtain Better Conditions and a Half-Holiday (Newton Abbot, 1973), pp. 19–20Google Scholar.

63 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, questions 30862-65, p. 426.

64 Booth, , Life and Labour in London, 3:75Google Scholar.

65 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 30864, p. 426.

66 Holcombe, , Victorian Ladies at Work, pp. 205–9Google Scholar.

67 Shop Assistant (January and April, 1901).

68 Roper, Michael and Tosh, John, “Introduction: Historians and the Politics of Masculinity,” in Manful Assertions: Masculinities in Britain since 1800, ed. Roper, Michael and Tosh, John (London, 1991), p. 8Google Scholar.

69 Warehouseman and Drapers’ Journal (11 October 1879).

70 Shop Assistant (November 1899).

71 Behind the Counter, p. 11.

72 Commercial Service Gazette (7 February 1874).

73 Shop Life Reform (18 February 1891).

74 George Sandford; or, The Draper's Assistant: By One Who Has Stood behind the Counter (Edinburgh, 1853), p. 33Google Scholar.

75 Tit-Bits (8 December 1906).

76 Tit-Bits (15 December 1906).

77 1908 Truck Committee, question 13553, p. 139.

78 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 31077, p. 440.

79 Bondfield, Margaret, “Socialism for Shop Assistants,” in Clarion Press Pass on Pamphlets (London, 1910), p. 5Google Scholar.

80 Hallsworth, and Davies, , The Working Life of Shop Assistants, pp. 58, 127Google Scholar.

81 Payne, William, Shop Slavery and Emancipation (London, 1912), p. 42Google Scholar.

82 Shop Assistant (11 March 1911).

83 Shop Assistant (August 1897).

84 For middle-class domesticity, see Rose, Sonya, Limited Livelihoods: Gender and Class in Nineteenth-Century England (Berkeley, 1992), pp. 141 ffGoogle Scholar.

85 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 30809, p. 423.

86 Shop Assistant (July 1897).

87 Bondfield, Margaret, A Life's Work (London, 1949), p. 36Google Scholar.

88 The Commercial Service Gazette (7 March 1874).

89 Young Woman (1892), p. 129.

90 Shop Assistant (4 February 1911).

91 Shop Assistant (February 1897).

92 Shop Assistant (March 1897).

93 Shop Assistant (8 March 1902).

94 Shop Assistant (15 March 1902).

95 Shop Assistant (22 March 1902).

96 Wright, D. G., Democracy and Reform (Harlow, 1970), p. 105Google Scholar.

97 Anderson, W., “Servitude of the Shop and Its Abolition,” p. 10Google Scholar.

98 1908 Truck Committee, p. 71.

99 Anderson, W., “Servitude of the Shop and Its Abolition,” pp. 6, 10Google Scholar.

100 Ibid., p. 7.

101 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 30783, p. 421; 1892 S. C, question 1269, p. 55.

102 1908 Truck Committee, p. 75.

103 1893-94 R. C. on Labour, Minutes, question 30878, p. 427.

104 Ibid.

105 Lancaster, , The Department Store, p. 142Google Scholar.

106 Young Man (November 1892), p. 391.

107 Shop Assistant (27 May 1911).

108 See, e.g., Philp, Robert, The Shopkeeper's Guide (London, 1853)Google Scholar; or Platt, James, Business (London, 1875)Google Scholar.

109 The ideal of a “golden age” of shop life is common in shop histories. W. O. Copeman, of Copemans & Sons, a large grocery firm in Norwich, recalled: “The relationship between principals and staff had still something of the family atmosphere. … At five o'clock the staff assembled in the private office upstairs for tea. Mr. Henry Copeman sat at the head of the table and poured out the tea—quite a family gathering” (Copeman, W. O., Copemans of Norwich, 1786-1946 [Norwich, 1946], p. 28)Google Scholar.

110 Winstanley, Michael, The Shopkeeper's World, 1830-1914 (Manchester, 1983), p. 120Google Scholar.

111 Shop Assistant (4 February 1911).

112 Young Woman (1892), p. 130.

113 Young Man (September 1892), p. 322.

114 Young Man (November 1892), p. 390.

115 Young Man (December 1892), p. 425.

116 1892 S. C, questions 3894, 3991, pp. 171-72.

117 1892 S. C, question 4350, p. 188.

118 1892 S. C, question 4606, p. 198.

119 Applin, Arthur, Shop Girls (London, 1914), p. 233Google Scholar.

120 Shop Assistant (August 1897).

121 Shop Assistant (July 1901).

122 Early Closing Association, 1879-80 Annual Report (London, 1880)Google Scholar.

123 Draper (26 November 1875, 1 February 1878, 8 February 1878).

124 Draper (1 February 1878).

125 Pall Mall Gazette (10 August 1887).

126 Ibid.

127 Pall Mall Gazette (16 August 1887).

128 Ibid.

129 Pall Mall Gazette (30 August 1887).

130 Draper (6 September 1878).

131 Shop Assistant (29 April 1911).

132 Hunt, E. H., British Labour History, 1815-1914 (Atlantic Highlands, N.J., 1981), p. 295Google Scholar.

133 Shop Assistant (30 August 1902).

134 Jones, Gareth Stedman, Outcast London: A Study in the Relationship between Classes in Victorian Society (Harmondsworth, 1976), p. 316Google Scholar.

135 1892 S. C, question 1264, p. 55.

136 Bondfield, , A Life's Work, p. 51Google Scholar.

137 Leicester Early Closing Association, “Early Closing: Two Essays,” pamphlet, Leicester Record Office, Leicester, 1855.

138 Booth, , Life and Labour in London, 3:82Google Scholar.

139 Chapman, Sydney J., Work and Wages, Part III: Social Betterment (London, 1914), p. 332Google Scholar.

140 1895 S. C, questions 3121-22, p. 128.

141 1892 S. C, question 4204, pp. 181-82.

142 1892 S. C, question 3950, p. 169.

143 Anderson, W., “Servitude of the Shop and Its Abolition,” p. 3Google Scholar.

144 Pioneer (21 January 1911).

145 Shaw, G. B., cited in Crossick, , “The Emergence of the Lower Middle Class,” p. 24Google Scholar.

146 Shop Assistant (July 1896).

147 Shop Assistant (November 1898).

148 Shop Assistant (August 1896).

149 Leicester Mercury (16 February 1891).

150 Leicester Mercury (22 February 1891).

151 Leicester Mercury (25 February 1891).

152 Leicester Mercury (12 March 1891).

153 Leicester Mercury (12 January 1900).

154 Hoffman, , They Also Serve, p. 72Google Scholar.

155 Shop Assistant (9 September 1911).

156 Shop Assistant (21 January 1911).

157 Quoted in Hallsworth, and Davies, , The Working Life of Shop Assistants, p. 114Google Scholar.

158 Joyce, Patrick, Work, Society and Politics: The Culture of the Factory in Later Victorian England (London, 1980), p. 112Google Scholar.

159 Miller, Michael B., The Bon Marché: Bourgeois Culture and the Department Store, 1869-1920 (London, 1981), p. 152Google Scholar.

160 Fish, W. F., The Autobiography of a Counter-Jumper: In Two Parts, England and South Africa (London, 1929), p. 42Google Scholar.