Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-jbqgn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-26T05:35:23.916Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

King Henry I's “Old Men”

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2014

Barbara MacDonald Walker
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

King Henry I “created men,” the novi homines of the chronicles. He also sustained, supported, and rewarded the “old men,” those men, or their descendants, who had held substantial estates in Normandy or in England prior to 1100. The “old men” who remained prominent in the reign of Henry I, however, were those willing to accept his authority, to lay down anarchical broadswords and seek peace through their loyalty to a nascent idea of the Crown, an Anglo-Norman regnum personified in the King. Loyalty was the stern arbiter, and Henry's feudal justice could be deaf to the entreaties of both family members and friends. While military organization was essential to peace and lawful order in Anglo-Norman society, the Conquest was past and soldierly virtue alone was not sufficient; Henry's kingly task was to mold the energies of his barons into administrative and judicial talents, and to cast those talents into a coherent framework of government. The paternal inheritance, as he viewed it, was an Anglo-Norman polity, its ruling class a nobility with cross-channel relationships in estates and blood ties. Whether or not the link with Normandy was deleterious, it was real to the King and his contemporaries, at the heart of the problems of the reign.

Henry drew upon his nobility for the work of governing, but “new men” also rose to prominence. The degree of attention given to the “new men” has created a congregate conception for assessments of the reign.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 8 , Issue 1 , November 1968 , pp. 1 - 21
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1968

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Southern, R. W., “The Place of Henry I in English History,” Proc. Br. Acad., XLVII (1962), 132Google Scholar.

2. The fates of Henry I's brother, Robert Curthose, his cousin William of Mortain, and the two daughters of his natural daughter Juliana, wife of Eustace of Breteuil, are often cited as examples of the King's stern justice. After Tinchebrai Duke Robert and Count William were sentenced to lifelong confinement; the punishment of the Count may have included being blinded, and it is possible that the Duke also suffered this fate. Juliana's daughters also may have been blinded, plus having the tips of their noses cut off, as a result of the perfidy of Count Eustace. For the latter story see Vitalis, Ordericus, Historiae Ecclesiasticae, ed. le Prevost, August (Paris, 1838–1855), IV, 336–39Google Scholar. These tales, however, may be seriously doubted. It is unlikely that the punishment of persons in the first rank of the Norman nobility would have included mutilation. See Davis, R. H. C., King Stephen (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1967), p. 6Google Scholar.

3. Hollister, C. Warren, The Military Organization of Norman England (Oxford, 1965), p. 3Google Scholaret passim.

4. Poole, Austin Lane, From Domesday Book to Magna Carta (2nd ed.; Oxford, 1955), p. 99Google Scholar.

5. Southern, , “The Place of Henry I,” Proc. Br. Acad., XLVII, 152, 155, 156Google Scholar.

6. Arnold, Thomas (ed.), Henrici Archidiaconi Huntendunensis Historia Anglorum [Rolls Series, No. 74] (London, 1879) (hereafter, Henry of Huntingdon), pp. 255–56Google Scholar.

7. “Hic inter prospera et adversa sibi divinirus commissum, prudenter et commode moderatus est, ac inter praecipuos totius Christianitatis principes, obtentu pacis et justitiae fulgens, insignis habitus est.” Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 91–92Google Scholar.

8. “ut parcat subjectis, et debellet superbos. Justitiae rigore inflexibilis … optimatibus venerabilis, provincialibus amabilis habebatur …. Quapropter sapientia nulli unquam modernorum regum secundus, et pene dicam omnium antecessorum in Anglia facile primus, libentius bellabat consilio quam gladio.” Stubbs, William (ed.), Willelmi Malmesbiriensis Monachi De Gestis Regum Anglorum [Rolls Series, No. 90] (London, 1887–1889) (hereafter, William of Malmesbury), II, 487–88Google Scholar.

9. Suger, Abbot, Vie de Louis VI le Gros, ed. and tr. Waquet, Henri (Paris, 1964), p. 14Google Scholar.

10. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 304–06Google Scholar.

11. Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 483Google Scholar.

12. Ibid.

13. “Robertus consul de Mellend in rebus saecularibus sapientissimus omnium hinc usque in Jerusalem degentium.” Arnold, , Henry of Huntingdon, p. 306Google Scholar.

14. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 112–13Google Scholar.

15. Ibid., III, 426.

16. Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 483Google Scholar.

17. Ordericus, , Historiae, II, 148Google Scholar.

18. Ibid., IV, 51.

19. Ibid., IV, 95.

20. Ibid., IV, 225, 229.

21. See esp. Davis, H. W. C., Johnson, C., and Cronne, H. A. (eds.), Regesta Regum Anglo-Normannorum (Oxford, 1913- ), IIGoogle Scholar.

22. “Unde in concilio nuper habito ex communi fratrum et coepiscoporum sententia delibertatum est regis consiliaros, qui ad investiturae flagitium ilium impellunt, et eos qui ab eo investiti sunt, ab ecclesiae liminibus repellendos, quia de libera facere conantur ancillam. Quam nimirum sententiam nos sancti spiritus iudicio in comitem de Mellento et eius complices promulgavimus, et eandem ipsam in eos qui sunt investiti a rege, eiusdem Spiritus sancti iudicio confirmamus.” Schmitt, F. S. (ed.), S. Anselmi Opera Omnia (Edinburgh, 1946–1961), II, Ep. 353, 11–16Google Scholar; see Cantor, N. F., Church, Kingship, and Lay Investiture in England (Princeton, 1958), pp. 218–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23. Hugh of Grandmesnil's properties also included substantial estates in counties Hertford, Warwick, and Northampton, and by far the largest “quarter” of the town of Leicester.

24. For Henry I's punishment of the most powerful barons of the 1101 revolt, Robert Malet, Ivo of Grandmesnil, Robert of Lacy, and Robert of Bellême, see Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 161 ff.Google Scholar

25. Ibid., IV, 167-68.

26. Ibid., IV, 169.

27. Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 844.

28. Ibid., II, No. 843.

29. Ibid., II, No. 1214.

30. SirStenton, Frank, The First Century of English Feudalism (2nd ed.; Oxford, 1961), pp. 228–29Google Scholar, n. 2.

31. The descent of the Grandmesnil properties in Leicestershire to the son of Robert of Meulan has been studied in the Leicestershire Survey. See Round, John Horace, Feudal England (London, 1895), pp. 196–214Google Scholar; Slade, C. F., The Leicestershire Survey c. AD. 1130 [Department of English Local History Occasional Papers, No. 7] (Leicester, 1956)Google Scholar.

32. “H. rex Anglie etc. Salutem. Sciatis mo concessisse Roberto filio Roberti comitis de Mell', totam terram et omnes tenuras et quicquid tenebat predictus comes in Anglia in secundo ano quod ego Normanniam prelio mihi subjugavi, ita bene et honorifice sicut unquam pater suus melius tenuit, preter Esturminster manerium sicut constiturum est ad reddendum vii (xx), li, per annum, quod pater ejus dedit Walrano filio suo concessu meo, et tali divisione ut quicquid ipse comes inde pro anima sua dare voluerit vel hominibus suis meo concessu, propter hoc hereditamentum vel consensum non dimittetur quin faciat.” Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 843. It is interesting to note here that the editors of the Regesta have translated Henry's word subjugavi (which has the same root as jus and justice) as “conquest” instead of “subjugation,” but the translation conquest requires the verb conquaerere, which denotes a different concept from Henry's word subjugavi. William I conquered England; Henry subjugated Normandy, that is, he put it under the yoke of law and justice.

33. Whitelock, Dorothy (ed.), Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (London, 1961), sub anno 1118, p. 186Google Scholar.

34. Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 844n.

35. See ibid., II, where 125 royal writs and charters include Count Robert of Meulan.

36. BM, Cotton MSS, Vesp. E, XVI, fol. 9.

37. Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 1233.

38. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 418Google Scholar.

39. Whitelock, , Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, sub anno 1124, pp. 190–92Google Scholar.

40. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 167Google Scholar.

41. Davis, et al., Regesta, II;Google Scholar for the years 1119-22, see Nos. 1214, 1240a, 1301, 1303, 1319, 1320; for the years 1129-35, see Nos. 1607, 1688, 1689, 1690, 1693, 1699, 1702, 1711, 1918. Cf. Whitelock, , Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, sub anno 1129, p. 195Google Scholar.

42. Ordericus, , Historiae, V, 50Google Scholar.

43. For William II's creation of the earldom of Warwick, see Stenton, , The First Century, p. 228Google Scholar.

44. Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 483Google Scholar.

45. Ordericus, , Historiae, III, 428Google Scholar.

46. See Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 1672n.

47. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 328Google Scholar, n. 2.

48. Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 1908.

49. Southern, , “The Place of Henry I,” Proc. Br. Acad., XLVII, 142Google Scholar.

50. See n. 2 above; cf. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 234Google Scholar; Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 475Google Scholar; Arnold, , Henry of Huntingdon, p. 236Google Scholar; Thorpe, Benjamin (ed.), Florentii Wigorniensis Monachi Chronicon ex Chronicis [Eng. Hist. Soc.] (London, 1848–1849) (hereafter, Florence of Worcester), II, 55Google Scholar; Whitelock, , Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, sub anno 1106, p. 180Google Scholar.

51. Southern, , “The Place of Henry I,” Proc. Br. Acad., XLVII, 142Google Scholar; cf. Davis, , King Stephen, pp. 7–10Google Scholar.

52. See Post, Gaines, Studies in Medieval Legal Thought (Princeton, 1964), p. 280CrossRefGoogle Scholar; cf. Cam, Helen M., “The Evolution of the Medieval English Franchise,” Speculum, XXXII (1957), 427–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53. Southern, R. W., Saint Anselm and His Biographer (Cambridge, 1963), p. 168Google Scholar.

54. Stenton, , The First Century, p. 228Google Scholar.

55. Ordericus, , Historiae, III, 273Google Scholar.

56. Ibid., III, 318.

57. Ibid., IV, 161-62.

58. Ibid., V, 52.

59. Ibid., IV, 180.

60. Round, Feudal England, pp. 468–79Google Scholar. Gilbert and Roger of Clare were members of the King's hunting party. Abbot Suger wrote of what he believed to be Tirel's innocence in his chronicle, Vie de Louis, p. 13.

61. Stenton, , The First Century, p. 228Google Scholar.

62. Southern, , Saint Anselm and His Biographer, p. 168Google Scholar.

63. Arnold, , Henry of Huntingdon, p. 310Google Scholar; cf. Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 475–76Google Scholar; Thorpe, , Florence of Worcester, II, 50–51Google Scholar; Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 169–83Google Scholaret passim.

64. Ibid., IV, 177.

65. Whitelock, , Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, sub anno 1104, p. 179Google Scholar.

66. Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 304–05Google Scholar.

67. Wightman, W. E., The Lacy Family in England and Normandy, 1066-1194 (Oxford, 1966)Google Scholar.

68. Ibid., p. 68.

69. Southern, , “The Place of Henry I,” Proc. Br. Acad., XLVII, 147Google Scholar.

70. Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 482Google Scholar.

71. Knowles, David, The Evolution of Medieval Thought (New York, 1962), p. 185Google Scholar.

72. Vinogradoff, Paul, Roman Law in Medieval History (London, 1909), pp. 39–42Google Scholar.

73. Poole, , From Domesday, p. 118Google Scholar.

74. “Tali ergo victoria usus. total terrain gratulabundus obtinuit, idque per epistolam Anselmo gaudenter et gratiosus mox intimavit. Omnes vero haec gesta tunc temporis audiere ea meritis concordiae quam rex cum Anselmo fecerat ascripsere.” Eadmer, , The Life of St. Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury, ed. Southern, R. W. (London, 1962), p. 138Google Scholar.

75. Trad., IX, 283 f.Google Scholar, quoted in Post, , Studies in Medieval Legal Thought, p. 264Google Scholar.

76. “Hanc igitur virtutem quam appeto, quam ex Sanctarum auctoritate Scripturarum, et generale approbatione publicae commoditatis, summopere laudo, toto nisu inquiere, et in tota Dei Ecclesia, ipso juvante, diffundere vivaciter elaborabo. Treviam Dei, sicus earn sanctae memoriae Urbanus Papa in concilio Clarimontis tenendam constituit, praecipio, et reliqua decreta, quae ibi a Sanctis Patribus sancita sunt, ex auctoritate Dei, et Sancti Petri, Apostoli, omniumque Sanctorum Dei confirmo.” Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 381Google Scholar.

77. Ibid., IV, 376-78, 398-99.

78. Davis, et al., Regesta, IIGoogle Scholar, No. 795.

79. “Sic hereditatem patris mei, totamque dominium ejus recuperavi, paternasque leges observare secundum voluntatem Dei ad quietem populi ejus elaboravi.” Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 402Google Scholar.

80. “Et ut nihil cumulatae pompae deesset, adolescentulos clarissimi generis, filios commitis de Mellento, ut contra cardinales de dialectica disputarent, subornavit: quorum tortilibus sophismatibus cum vivacitate rationum obsisti nequiret, non puduit cardinales confiteri, majori occiduas plagas florere literarum peritia quam ipsi audissent vel putassent in patria. Itaque haec collocutio hunc finem emeruit, ut pronunciaret apostolicus nihil Anglorum regis causa justius, prudentia eminentius, facundia uberius.” Stubbs, , William of Malmesbury, II, 482Google Scholar.

81. Stubbs, William, The Constitutional History of England (6th ed.; Oxford, 1897), I, 338Google Scholar.

82. Freeman, E. A., The History of the Norman Conquest of England (Oxford, 1867–1879), V, 158Google Scholar.

83. Round, , Feudal England, p. 197Google Scholar.

84. Stenton, , The First Century, p. 86Google Scholar.

85. Poole, , From Domesday, p. 388Google Scholar.

86. Sayles, G. O., The Medieval Foundations of England (Philadelphia, 1950), p. 306CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

87. Southern, , “The Place of Henry I,” Proc. Br. Acad., XLVIIGoogle Scholar.

88. Hollister, C. Warren, The Making of England (Boston, 1966), p. 144Google Scholar.

89. “Unde plerosque illustres pro temeritate sua de sublimi potestatis culmine praecipitavit, et hereditario jure irrecuperabiliter spoljatos condemnavit. Alios e contra, favorabiliter illi obsequentes, de ignobili stirpe illustravit, de pulvere, ut ita dicam, extulit, dataque multiplied facilitate, super consules et illustres oppidamos exaltavit.” Ordericus, , Historiae, IV, 164Google Scholar.

90. “Rex Guillemus dejectis, ut diximus, Merciorum maximis consulibus: Eduino scilicet interfecto, et Morcaro in vinculis constricto, adjutoribus suis inclytas Angliae regiones distribuit, et ex infinis Normannorum clientibus tribunos et centuriones ditissimos erexit.” “Nonnulli etiam eccliastici viri, qui sapientes et religiosi videbantur, regali curiae pro dignitatibus cupitis obnixe famulabantur, et diversis assentationum modis non sine dedecore religiosae opinionis adulabantur …. Clerici et monachi nunc terreno principi pro talibus stipendiis inhaerebant, et pro temporali commodo multiplex servitium, quod divino cultui non competit, indecenter impendebant.” Ibid., II, 218, 225.

91. “Militibus et exteris largus erat; sed pauperes incolas regni sui nimis opprimebat, et illis violenter auferebat quae prodigus advenis tribuebat. Multi sub ipso patris sui proceres obierunt, qui proavis suis extraneum jus bellicose vendicaverunt; pro quibus nonnullos degeneres in locis magnatorum restituit, et amplis, pro adulationis merito datis, honoribus sublimavit.” Ibid., IV, 9.

92. “Nec in vanum illi omnes regis amicitiam acquisiverunt. Nam, qui desideraverunt postestatam terrenam augere, invenerunt; qui pecuniam, pecuniam; qui familiaritatem, familiaritatem; qui utramque, utramque …. Nam sequentis temporis successu ex improviso dedit mihi Exanceastre, cum omni parochia, quae ad se pertinebat, in Saxonia et Cornubia, exceptis cotidianus donis innumerabilibus in omni genere terrestris divitiae.” Stevenson, William Henry (ed.), Asset's Life of King Alfred (Oxford, 1959), pp. 67–68Google Scholar.

93. Anselm, , Proslogion, 7Google Scholar, quoted in Southern, , Saint Anselm and His Biographer, pp. 98–99Google Scholar.