Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-wbk2r Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-14T23:05:39.593Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Australia's Reactions to the Boer War—a Study in Colonial Imperialism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2014

Barbara R. Penny
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

“After God I dearly love the British Empire.” Imperialism is a belief as well as a political phenomenon, and one can often come closer to understanding it by exploring the emotions underlying significant events than by describing the events themselves.

Towards the end of the nineteenth century, for example, British imperialists were inspired with fervour and confidence. Nowhere was the inspiration stronger than amongst Australian colonists, who were beginning to thrill not only with the vicarious agony of exiles, but also with the virility of frontiersmen. Although the pull to the heart of the Empire was strong, the void beyond the red pale of civilization was beckoning too. In an increasingly hostile world it was encouraging to measure one's strength as part of the force of an Empire greater than Greece or Rome had known, and inspiring to feel that a colony's achievements were part of the historic mission of an imperialist power. It is not surprising, although it has been overlooked by European-centred historians of empire and by parochial historians of emerging nations, that the convinced and practising colonial imperialists were a significant force in shaping the ideals if not the strategy of European expansion, and in popularizing the creed, to the great comfort of the planners at “home” and the discomfort and bewilderment of local republicans.

The Boer War has become a symbolic episode in British imperial history and the spontaneous colonial participation a notable feature of it.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 7 , Issue 1 , November 1967 , pp. 97 - 130
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1967

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Stephenson, T. Alfred, The Peril of Empire (Melbourne, 1907), p. 3Google Scholar.

2. Abbreviation of “Absent-Minded Beggar”—the title of a poem written by Rudyard Kipling for the Patriotic Fund and set to music by Sir Arthur Sullivan.

3. See, e.g., Murray, J. in the Victorian Legislative Assembly, Oct. 10, 1899. Victorian Parliamentary Debates, XCII, 1788–1789Google Scholar; National Library of Australia, Canberra, P. McMahon Glynn, diary entry for Jan. 21 and Dec. 2, 1900, McMahon Glynn Papers, MS 558; N.L.A., Canberra, entries for Oct. 11 and 12, 1899, in E. T. Hubert, Behind the scenes in Parliamentary and official life, MS 506; Holman, Ada A., Memoirs of a Premier's Wife (Sydney, 1948), pp. 8–9, 11Google Scholar; Dr.Maloney, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCIII, 2875.Google Scholar

4. Haynes in the New South Wales Legislative Assembly, Oct. 19, 1899, New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, first series, C, 1808, 1505 (hereafter cited as N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C); Higgins, H. B., Commonwealth Parliamentary Debates, VII, 8761.Google Scholar

5. New South Wales Parliamentary Papers (1901), III, No. 559, 50–57.Google Scholar

6. The Governors of Queensland (July 10, 1899), Victoria (July 5 and 12), and New South Wales (July 19) informed the Colonial Office that men were volunteering for service in South Africa. Queensland Parliamentary Papers (1899), second session, I, No. 35, 843et seq.Google Scholar; PRO, CO 309/148 (for Victoria); PRO, CO 201/626 (for New South Wales).

7. N.L.A., Canberra, material relating to the South African war, C. F. Cox Papers, MS 37; Wilkinson, F., Australian Cavalry: The N.S.W. Lancer Regiment and the First Australian Horse (Sydney, 1901), pp. 13–21Google Scholar; Templeton, J. M., The Consolidation of the British Empire: The growth of citizen soldiership and the establishment of the Australian Commonwealth (Melbourne, 1901), pp. 10–11, 26Google Scholar.

8. Hales, A. G., Campaign Pictures of the War in South Africa (London, 1900), p. xiGoogle Scholar.

9. Wilkinson, , Australian Cavalry, p. 19Google Scholar.

10. N.S.W. Part. Papers (1901), III, No. 559, 55–57.Google Scholar The proposed colonial contributions were: N.S.W., 745 men; Victoria, 543; Queensland, 275; Tasmania and Western Australia, 160 each; South Australia, 140.

11. Ibid., III, No. 559, 43-44, Joseph Chamberlain to the governors of the Australian colonies, Oct. 4, 1899.

12. Ibid., III, No. 559, 45, French to the Principal Under Secretary, Sydney, Oct. 7, 1899; and see Fitzpatrick, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1536.Google Scholar

13. N.S.W. Parl. Papers (1901), III, No. 559, 42Google Scholar, J. Burns, officer commanding the N.S.W. Lancer Regiment, to the Chief Secretary, Oct. 3, 1899.

14. For the most accurate general account see Wilkinson, F., Australia at the Front: A Colonial View of the Boer War (London, 1901), p. 4Google Scholar. A hotly defensive version was given by Senator Cox (who commanded the Lancers, 1899-1900) in Oct. 1933, C'wealth Parl. Deb., CXLI, 3752–54Google Scholar. Contemporary material revealing the strenuous efforts to secure official approval and information about Harkus is in N.L.A., Canberra, material relating to the South African war, July-Oct. 1899 bundle, C. F. Cox Papers, MS 37; see also PRO, CO 201/626. Dates of arrival, departure, and Harkus's death appear in Murray, P. L., Official Records of the Australian Military Contingents to the War in South Africa (Melbourne, n.d.), pp. 5, 10Google Scholar; the disgruntled remark was noted in N.L.A., Canberra, letter by “An Australian Spectator,” Oct. 10, 1899, E. A. Petherick Papers, MS 760, Box 3.

15. Templeton, , Consolidation of the British Empire, pp. 8–11Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, diary of the N.S.W. Lancers' visit to the Jubilee, 1897, and J. G. Wilson to Captain Cox, May 17, 1899, C. F. Cox Papers, MS 37. ThompsonContrast, A. M. Contrast, A. M., Towards Conscription (London, 1898), p. 4Google Scholar, which calls the Jubilee “the gaudily stage-managed spectacular exhibition … of brutal strength in gorgeous apparel.”

16. Downard in the Vic. Leg. Assembly, Oct. 10, 1899, Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1744Google Scholar; Meagher in the N.S.W. Leg. Assembly, Oct. 19, 1899, N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1529Google Scholar; The South African Strike: A Voice from the Veldt, by a Boer, Back-Veldt (Sydney, 1914), p. 20Google Scholar. N.L.A., Canberra, lecture by J. S. Larke, Commissioner for Canada, on Christian patriotism, to the Sydney University Christian Union, July 12, 1900, Australian Student Christian Movement Papers, MS 980, Box 2, S.U.C.U. Memorabilia Book, 1896-1903, p. 51. Skirving, R. Scot, Our Army in South Africa (Sydney, 1901), p. 15Google Scholar.

17. Hales, , Campaign Pictures, p. xiGoogle Scholar.

18. Jan Smuts to Jan Hofmeyr, May 10, 1899, quoted in Hancock, W., Smuts: The Sanguine Years, 1870-1919 (London, 1962), p. 91Google Scholar.

19. A widespread fear reiterated in the most popular and widely read contemporary account, Doyle, A. Conan, The Great Boer War (London, 1903), pp. 63, 549, 550–51Google Scholar. See also Smuts, Jan, Memoirs of the Boer War, quoted in Hancock, Smuts, p. 123Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, “The British Fury,” bundle of letters and articles re the Boer War, E. A. Petherick Papers, MS 760, Box 3; New Zealand in the Next Great War (Nelson, 1894), pp. 9–10, 25Google Scholar.

20. Coghlan, T. A., A Statistical Account of the Seven Colonies of Australia, 1899-1900 (Sydney, 1900), pp. 144, 255, 258Google Scholar. With the approach of federation, a conference of all colonial statisticians met in Feb. 1900 to estimate (inter alia) the population of the whole continent, for electoral purposes. Vic. Parl. Papers (1900), II, No. 1.Google Scholar

21. Templeton, , Consolidation of the British Empire, p. 49Google Scholar; Abbott, J. H. M., Tommy Cornstalk: Being some account of the less notable features of the South African War from the point of view of the Australian ranks (London, 1902), p. 5Google Scholar.

22. Quoted in Bufton, J., Tasmanians in the Transvaal War (Launceston, 1905), p. 15Google Scholar. See Wisden's Cricketer's Almanac for 1899, p. 382Google Scholar, and for 1900, p. 256. The Prince of Wales and the German Emperor also noted that cricket tour. See Buckle, G. E. (ed.), Letters of Queen Victoria, third series (London, 1930–1932), III, 483–84Google Scholar.

23. Abbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, pp. 214–15Google Scholar.

24. Froude, J. A., Oceana (London, 1886), pp. 12–13, 332–33, 334Google Scholar; and see Templeton, , Consolidation of the British Empire, p. 22Google Scholar.

25. “Tasmania's Gift,” Oct. 1899, in Dawson, W. H., War Songs, 1899-1900 (Hobart, 1901), p. 2Google Scholar; Hales, , Campaign Pictures, p. 50Google Scholar; Glendale, M. A., British and Colonial Heroes of the South African British-Boer War (Sydney, 1901), p. 16Google Scholar.

26. Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, pp. 159–60Google Scholar; Reay, W. T., Australians in War (Melbourne, 1900)Google Scholar, Preface; The Queenslanders at Elands River, August 1900 (Hertford, n.d.).

27. N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1469Google Scholar.

28. Copeland, ibid., C, 1439.

29. E.g., Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, p. 253Google Scholar; O'Sullivan, E. W., Under the Southern Cross (Sydney, n.d.), p. 11Google Scholar; How Westralia's Sons Served the Empire (Melbourne, n.d.), p. 7Google Scholar.

30. “A Ballad of Ladysmith,” in Dawson, , War Songs, p. 13Google Scholar.

31. N.L.A., Canberra, General Hutton to his wife, July 21, 1900, Hutton Papers, MS 1215, III, letter No. 23. See also Dacey, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1573–74Google Scholar; Copeland, ibid., C, 1441; Macdonald, ibid., C, 1518; J. A. Mackay, ibid., C, 1474; C. G. Heydon, ibid., C, 1476.

32. Paterson, A. B., Happy Dispatches (Sydney, 1934), p. 1Google Scholar.

33. Abbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, pp. 233–36Google Scholar. Arthur Griffith in the N.S.W. Leg. Assembly, Oct. 19, 1899: “They were as dirty and unprogressive fifteen years ago when we gave them their freedom, as they are today, when we are going to take it from them.” N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1549Google Scholar. For indifference to sturdy piety see Macdonald, ibid., C, 1515, 1518; Skirving, , Our Army in South Africa, p. 6Google Scholar; Kipling, Rudyard, The Science of Rebellion: A Tract for the Times (London, 1901), p. 9Google Scholar.

34. Lord Milner's phrase, in popular contemporary use. See Milner's Credo, quoted in Hancock, , Smuts, p. 74Google Scholar; Green, J., The Story of the Bushmen (being notes of a chaplain) (Sydney, 1903), p. 1Google Scholar; Advance Australia, Apr. 1, 1897, p. 2Google Scholar; O'Sullivan, , Under the Southern Cross, p. 10Google Scholar; Jefferis, J., The Federation of the British People (Adelaide, 1901)Google Scholar.

35. Templeton, , Consolidation of the British Empire, p. 14Google Scholar; Holroyd, C., The Boer War, Its Causes and justification (Melbourne, 1900), pp. 41–42Google Scholar; Glendale, , British and Colonial Heroes, p. 10Google Scholar; Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, p. 64Google Scholar. Contrast an admirer of Gladstone's attitude, Haynes, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1512.Google Scholar

36. Pacifist attitudes were expressed by Haynes, ibid., C, 1505; by McDonald in the Commonwealth House of Representatives, Jan. 14, 1902, C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8774Google Scholar; by Ronald (a Quaker), ibid., VII, 9389; and in the Petition to the House of Representatives seeking peace and withdrawal of Australian troops, Jan. 21, 1902, Parliament House, Canberra, House of Representatives Records, 563/1901-02. A “Peace and Humanity Society” founded in Sydney in July 1900 had feeble support. On the point that few opponents of the war were pacifists, see Eddy, J., “Some Aspects of Imperial Opinion on the South African War, 1899-1902, with Particular Reference to Australia” (B.A. thesis, Melbourne University, 1958)Google Scholar; and Wood, G. A.'s own testimony in “Australia and Imperial Politics,” in Atkinson, M. (ed.), Australia: Economic and Political Studies (Melbourne, 1920)Google Scholar.

37. See speeches by Meagher, and Macdonald, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1516, 1529;Google Scholar by Shiels, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCIII, 2876–77Google Scholar; by Neild, , C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 9022Google Scholar; How Westralia's Sons Served the Empire, p. 6; O'Sullivan, , Under the Southern Cross, p. 32Google Scholar.

38. The International Convention for the Pacific Settlement of International Disputes was signed at The Hague, July 29, 1899- See Von Hagen, C., Peace, Liberty and Defence Versus the Imperialism of the Cecils (Newtown, n.d.), p. 2Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, H. B. Higgins, “The Duties of Patriotism,” Higgins Papers, MS 1057.

39. Shiels, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCIII, 2877.Google Scholar

40. E.g., Rawson, ibid., XCII, 1775; and Murray, ibid., XCII, 1729.

41. Maloney, ibid., XCIII, 2876; and see N.L.A., Canberra, draft letter to the Standard, “The side of the big battalions,” E. A. Petherick Papers, MS 760, Box 3.

42. N.L.A., Canberra, Boer War hymn, rendered into English from the Taal, ibid. See also N.L.A., Canberra, “A Call to Arms! An appeal to the burghers of Orange Free State, October 11, 1899,” Hutton Papers, MS 1215.

43. N.L.A., Canberra, “Australia to the Rescue,” in Morning Post, Feb. 20, 1901Google Scholar, Deakin Papers, MS 1540.

44. E.g., McGowen, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1553Google Scholar; R. Sleath, ibid., C, 1561; Macdonald, ibid., C, 1513. All were staunch labour men; McGowen led the N.S.W. Parliamentary Labour Party, 1894-1917.

45. E.g., N.S.W. Parl. Papers (1901), III, No. 559, 45Google Scholar, French to the Principal Under Secretary, Sydney, Oct. 7, 1899; Tremearne, A. J. N., Some Austral-African Notes and Anecdotes (London, 1913), p. 3Google Scholar.

46. Campbell, R. G., “Neutral Rights and Obligations in the Anglo-Boer War,” Johns Hopkins University Studies in Historical and Political Science, XXVI (April, May, June 1908), 47Google Scholar and passim; de Wet, C. R., Three Years War (Westminster, 1902), pp. 71–72Google Scholar; Buckle, , Letters of Queen Victoria, third series, III, 459;Google Scholar Reay, Australians in War, Preface; N.L.A., Canberra, Chamberlain to Sir Edmund Barton, Feb. 8, 1900, Barton Papers, MS 51, series 1, item 210.

47. Meagher, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1526Google Scholar; Barton, ibid., C, 1504. Barton became the first Prime Minister of Australia, 1901-03.

48. E.g., Copeland, ibid., C, 1444; Sawers, ibid., C, 1555, 1556; Smith, Bruce, C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8792.Google Scholar

49. E.g., Holman, W. A., N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1460et seq.Google Scholar; Von Hagen, Peace, Liberty and Defence, passim; N.L.A., Canberra, Higgins, “The Duties of Patriotism,” Higgins Papers, MS 1057; “T” (Hargrave, E.), An American View of the South African Situation (New York, 1901)Google Scholar; Griffith, Arthur (ed.), The Facts about the Transvaal (Sydney, 1902)Google Scholar.

50. N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1384, 1389Google Scholar; and see Macdonald, ibid., C, 1518.

51. E.g., Sleath, ibid., C, 1562-63; and contrast Ebden, ibid., C, 1567. Both were examiners. See also note on the Uitlanders' appeal, Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, p. 11Google Scholar; and the exchange between Turner, and Murray, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1728Google Scholar. Blainey, G., The Peaks of Lyell (Melbourne, 1959), pp. 90–92Google Scholar, gives an account of the impact of the war on a mining community in Tasmania. E. A. Petherick, who had then been away from Victoria for thirty years, saw a natural analogy between conditions on the Rand and those on the Victorian goldfields in the 1850s, but the comparison did not strike Australians in Australia. See N.L.A., Canberra, E. A. Petherick Papers, MS 760, Box 3. The Uitlanders' appeal is in N.S.W. Parl. Papers (1901), III, No. 559, 38.Google Scholar

52. Higgins was a Member of the Victorian Legislative Assemby, 1894-1900, a Member of the Commonwealth House of Representatives, 1901-06, became a Justice of the High Court of Australia in 1906, and presided over the Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration, 1906-22. Wood was the first Challis Professor of History at Sydney University, 1891-1928. Holman was a Member of the N.S.W. Legislative Assemby, 1898-1920, and became Premier of N.S.W., 1913-20. Hughes was a Member of the N.S.W. Legislative Assembly, 1894-1900, a Member of the Commonwealth House of Representatives, 1901-52, and became Prime Minister of Australia, 1915-23. A similar attitude to theirs appears in Hirst, Francis, Murray, Gilbert, and Hammond, J. L., Liberalism and the Empire (London, 1900), Preface and pp. 184et seq.Google Scholar

53. A Peace Society petition appealed to the Commonwealth to be “loyal to its own autonomy and to the moral ‘fair fame of England.’” Parliament House, Canberra, House of Representatives Records, 563/1901-02. Griffith appealed to “a self-governing people,” N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1539Google Scholar; as did Haynes, ibid., C, 1513; J. Ashton stressed that “the colony, as a colony, is in precisely the position of an individual as a volunteer,” ibid., C, 1452. For Wood's attitude see Crawford, R. M., “The Antipodean Pilgrimage of Arnold Wood,” Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society, XLVIII (1963)Google Scholar, Pt. 6.

54. Sleath, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1558.Google Scholar

55. Cook, ibid., C, 1457; Sawers, ibid., C, 1496; Barton, ibid., C, 1556; Murray-Smith, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1750.Google Scholar

56. Paterson, , Happy Dispatches, p. 23Google Scholar.

57. Quoted in Evatt, H. V., Australian Labour Leader (Sydney, 1942), p. 143Google Scholar; N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1462Google Scholar.

58. The point is discussed in Koebner, R. and Schmidt, J., Imperialism (Cambridge, 1964), pp. 226–28, 231, 235, 236, 246, 251–52Google Scholar. See, for an example, Burns, J., Stop the War! The Trail of the Financial Serpent (London, n.d.), p. 7Google Scholar; and Hobson, J. A., The War in South Africa, Its Causes and Effects (London, 1900), pp. 11, 189–97, 226Google Scholar.

59. Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, p. 6Google Scholar. Norton agreed, N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1472Google Scholar.

60. McDonald, , C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8768Google Scholar. Compare the later statement: “The blood-lust is being conjured up in defence of the money-lust, and with the designed purpose also of counteracting and sapping the strength of the working class movement in this country.” Anti-Militarism: An Appeal from the I.W.W. Clubs to the Australian Working Class (Sydney, 1910)Google Scholar.

61. Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, pp. 6, 20Google Scholar; Griffith, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1549.Google Scholar In 1904, when Chinese labour was introduced into the Transvaal, Alfred Deakin felt betrayed, and W. M. Hughes confirmed in his suspicions. See Atkinson, , Australia, pp. 381, 395Google Scholar.

62. Higgins, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1779.Google Scholar

63. N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1469Google Scholar. See also Griffith, ibid., C, 1549: “The Transvaal mines are worth £200,000,000 and there are only a few thousand Dutch farmers standing between them and the greed of the London stock-holders.” See also Higgins, , C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8758.Google Scholar

64. Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, p. 8Google Scholar.

65. Murray, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1730.Google Scholar

66. Ibid., XCII, 1734. Hon. N. Levi defended Jews in the Legislative Council, ibid., XCII, 1800. Tributes to Zox are in ibid., XCII, 2085-87.

67. Carter, ibid., XCII, 1765; N.L.A., Canberra, Arthur Macquarie, “A Fam'ly Matter,” in South Africa, an Album of press cuttings relating to Australian interest in the South African War, p. 71; Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, p. 64Google Scholar; McLeod, Gussie, For Empire, Home and Honour (Sydney, 1900)Google Scholar, which was sold for the benefit of the Patriotic Fund; Carter, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1764.Google Scholar

68. E.g., Bowser, ibid., XCII, 1773; McLeod, ibid., XCII, 1783; Glynn, McMahon, C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8797.Google Scholar

69. See inscriptions under statues of Queen Victoria, Bendigo, as cited; Ararat:

In commemoration of the late illustrious Queen Victoria:

Her court was pure, her life serene,

God gave her peace, her land reposed.

A thousand claims to reverence closed

In her as mother, wife and queen.

Also Templeton, , Consolidation of the British Empire, pp. 58–59Google Scholar.

70. See Buckle, , Letters of Queen Victoria, third series, IIIGoogle Scholar, passim. “Soldiers of the Queen” was a favourite contemporary march. The Transvaal War, Souvenir of the Queensland Contingent for Service in South Africa (Brisbane, 1899), p. 2Google Scholar. Most Boer War memorials are inscribed “For Queen and Empire” or “For Queen and Country,” e.g., Mt. Gambier (S.A.), Casterton (Vic.), Wagga Wagga (N.S. W.). News of the Queen's death was a painful shock to the fourth Victorian contingent. See Kemp, D., “The South African War, 1899-1902: Reminiscences of the Late James Cue Ryan, of the Maffra Spectator,” Victorian Historical Magazine, XXXVI (1965), 58Google Scholar.

71. Buckle, , Letters of Queen Victoria, third series, III, 457.Google Scholar

72. A Plea for Separation: or the Freedom and Independence of Australia (Melbourne, 1888), p. 29Google Scholar.

73. N.L.A., Canberra, “Diva Britannia and Zaphnath Paaneah,” E. A. Petherick Papers, MS 760, Box 3.

74. See the incident over the Fitzroy State School flag, which Higgins was invited to supply to prove his loyalty. N.L.A., Canberra, Higgins Papers, MS 1057, series 1, items 78, 79, 81. Hermes, VI (Aug. 14, 1900), 14,Google Scholar speaks of University men who “have given their lives for the Flag.”

75. Wilson, H. W., With the Flag to Pretoria (London, 1900), I, 247Google Scholar; “A Ballad of Ladysmith,” in Dawson, , War Songs, p. 13Google Scholar; Templeton, , Consolidation of the British Empire, p. 31Google Scholar; Macdonald, D., How We Kept the Flag Flying. The Story of the Siege of Ladysmith (London, 1900), esp. pp. 281, 285Google Scholar.

76. Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, p. 248Google Scholar; Blainey, , Peaks of Lyell, p. 91Google Scholar.

77. See the opening paragraph of the petition opposing the war, Parliament House, Canberra, House of Representatives Records, 563/1901-02. See also the entry for New Year's Eve, 1900-01, at Mafeking, , in Kemp, , “The South African War,” Vic. Hist. Mag., XXXVIGoogle Scholar. See also speeches by Sleath, and Davis, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1563, 1573;Google ScholarBennett, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 2787;Google Scholar Maloney, ibid., XCII, 1759; Carter, ibid., XCII, 1764; Bowser, ibid., XCII, 1773; Rawson, ibid., XCII, 1774; Sir H. Wrixon, ibid., XCII, 1794.

78. For a model young man, see speech by McBride, ibid., XCII, 1780. V. L. Hodgman, second federal contingent, was a “healthy-minded, clean-living country lad, who did what he conceived to be his duty.” Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, p. 483Google Scholar. For political caution overriding private opinion, see N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1567Google Scholar; Fitzhardinge, L. F., William Morris Hughes (Sydney, 1964), I, 98Google Scholar; Holman, Ada, Memoirs, p. 11Google Scholar; Evatt, , Australian Labour Leader, p. 144Google Scholar; Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, p. 24nGoogle Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, Glynn diary, pp. 519, 607, McMahon Glynn Papers, MS 558. For a record of the coincidence of the end of long political regimes, the retirement and death of prominent politicians in all colonies, see Coghlan, , Statistical Account, pp. 39, 60, 88, 109, 110, 137, 159Google Scholar. For the dullness of country life and lack of a cricket tour, see Murray, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1731;Google ScholarReay, , Australians in War, pp. 24–26Google Scholar. See Bulletin, Jan. 11, 1902, for a cartoon showing the Prime Minister christening the Commonwealth with the blood of the contingents.

79. The Bulletin misjudged public opinion, and through propagating a crude antiwar campaign, its circulation dropped considerably. See Jebb, R., Studies in Colonial Nationalism (London, 1905), p. 199Google Scholar.

80. Higgins was particularly incensed as his brother-in-law, Dr. G. E. Morrison, was erroneously reported murdered by the Boxers in Pekin—to Higgins, typical and deliberate distortion by the press. See Palmer, N., Henry Bournes Higgins: A Memoir (London, 1931), p. 164Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, Wood to Higgins, May 6, 1902, and Higgins, , “The Duties of Patriotism,” pp. 6, 13Google Scholar, Higgins Papers, MS 1057; Higgins, , C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8757Google Scholar, and Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1777Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, letter by “An Australian Spectator,” Oct. 10, 1899, E. A. Petherick Papers, MS 760, Box 3. Wilkinson, , Australia at the Front, pp. 244–45Google Scholar, lists some Australian war correspondents.

81. Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, pp. 6, 12Google Scholar; Holman, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1460–63Google Scholar; Norton, ibid., C, 1521; exchange between Willis and Griffith, ibid., C, 1540-41. See Holman, “I must confess I find it difficult to discover what honorable members who supported the motion did say. The majority have gone through a kind of process of obtaining what information they could while they were on their feet from the interjections of critical listeners.” Ibid., C, 1465. Cf. Glynn, “We do not always take the cold-blooded view taken by the hon. member, who tests the interior of every question with the axe of logic. Most of us are affected, to some extent, by prejudice, which means enthusiasm or passion.” C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8794Google Scholar. See Bennett, “no matter what speeches are made on this question there will be no difference in the voting when the division takes place.” Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1786Google Scholar.

82. Hobhouse, E., A Letter to the Committee of the South African Women and Children's Distress Fund (London, n.d.)Google Scholar; C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8762Google Scholar. For a contrary opinion see the Peace Society petition, Parliament House, Canberra, House of Representatives Records, 563/1901-02: “It is a question of the fair fame of England and of the reputation for manliness, to say nothing of chivalry, of our people.” Mungo MacCallum, a supporter of the war, took much the same view as Higgins. Wood, possibly alone, was stirred by the disclosure of “methods of barbarism” to re-enter public controversy on the war. See Crawford, , “The Antipodean Pilgrimage,” Jour. Roy. Aust. Hist. Soc., XLVIII, Pt. 6, 420–21Google Scholar.

83. Wynne, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1796;Google ScholarAbbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, p. 98Google Scholar.

84. Skirving, , Our Army in South Africa, p. 15Google Scholar; McLeod, , For Empire, Home and Honour, p. 6Google Scholar; Wilson, , With the flag to Pretoria, I, 101, 200, 270, 305, 343Google Scholar; Fuller, J. F. C., The Last of the Gentlemen's Wars (London, 1937)Google Scholar; Hall, D. O. W., The New Zealanders in South Africa, 1899-1902 (Wellington, 1949), p. 4Google Scholar; Abbott, J. H. M., “The Gentle War,” in Out of the Past (Sydney, 1943), pp. 71–72Google Scholar.

85. “I pray God that I may be equal to the emergencies and may be able to do full justice to the responsibility attaching to [my] command.” N.L.A., Canberra, Hutton to his wife, Apr. 7, 1900, Hutton Papers, MS 1215, I.

86. Address of the Cardinal Archbishop of Sydney to the Catholic Soldiers of the South African Contingent, at St. Mary's Cathedral, 14 January 1900 (Sydney, 1900)Google Scholar. For items about Catholic chaplains see N.L.A., Canberra, South Africa, an Album of press cuttings, pp. 59, 54; also Eddy, , “Some Aspects of Imperial Opinion,” p. 21Google Scholar. For the Irish-Australians' attitude, see N.L.A., Canberra, Deakin's article in the Morning Post, June 12, 1902, Deakin Papers, MS 1540.

87. N.L.A., Canberra, “A Call to Arms!” Hutton Papers, MS 1215.

88. Australian Christian World, Mar. 2, 1900.

89. N.L.A., Canberra, Hutton to his wife, July 22, 1900, Hutton Papers, MS 1215, III, letter No. 33; Holroyd, , Boer War, p. 42Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, lecture by Larke, Commissioner for Canada, July 12, 1900, Australian Student Christian Movement Papers, MS 980, Box 2, S.U.C.U. Memorabilia Book, 1896-1903, p. 51. For a discussion of the attitude of the churches in South Australia, see Haydon, A. P., “South Australia's First War,” Historical Studies, Australia and New Zealand, XI (1964), 222–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar. A bishop told a departing contingent that the streets of the city were consecrated by the tread of their feet. Griffith, , Facts about the Transvaal, p. 5Google Scholar.

90. McLeod, , For Empire, Home and Honour, p. 6Google Scholar. A few “advanced” women protested against the war, but they could be dismissed for having special motives for doing so: Vida Goldstein, the suffragette, for publicity; Ada Kidgell, secretary of the Anti-War League, married W. A. Holman in 1900; Eleanor Whitfield married her professor, G. A. Wood, in 1898.

91. Hermes, VI (May 22, 1900), 17Google Scholar, 15–16, 8–9. Ibid., VI (Aug. 14, 1900), 14; ibid., VI (Oct. 27, 1900), 3-4, 8, 10; ibid., VI (May 4, 1900), 6. The Boer War memorial at Gundagai, N.S.W., claims: “Sgt. Major G. A. Griffin, 1st Australian Horse, killed in action at Slingersfontein, Cape Colony, 16 January 1900. The first soldier from N.S.W. to fall in the war.”

92. Kemp, , “The South African War,” Vic. Hist. Mag., XXXVI, 59–60Google Scholar.

93. That is 4.6 per cent of all British troops; 3.6 per cent of the Australians. Compiled from Murray, Official Records, passim; Holt, E., The Boer War (London, 1958), pp. 163, 293–94Google Scholar.

94. Reay, , Australians in War, p. 27Google Scholar; and see Wigmore, L., They Dared Mightily (Canberra, 1963), pp. 13–26Google Scholar; Hayes, B., Hull Down (London, 1925), p. 117Google Scholar; Bufton, , Tasmanians in the Transvaal War, p. 253Google Scholar. See C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8741et seq.Google Scholar, re the accusation in Vossiche Zeitung, Dec. 1901, that “so long as it was thought in the colonies that military laurels could be cheaply won by a promenade to Johannesburg and Pretoria, there were young people forthcoming in Canada and Australia, bent upon adventures and military glory … But military ardour soon vanished when it became evident that the war against the Boers was po nursery game.”

95. Lewis, R. C., On the Veldt (Hobart, 1902), p. 1Google Scholar; Blackmore, E. G., The Story of the South Australian Bushmen's Corps 1900 (Adelaide, 1900), pp. 3–8Google Scholar; Evening News, Feb. 6, 1902; N.L.A., Canberra, French to the officer commanding Capetown, Mar. 13, 1901, Cox Papers, MS 37; Tremearne, , Some Austral-African Notes, p. 7Google Scholar; Reay, , Australians in War, p. 26Google Scholar. See Holroyd, , Boer War, p. 42Google Scholar:

They answered nobly to the call,

Sons of the Southern Sea,

If for the Empire men must fall

Let ours that glory be.

96. N.S.W. Parl. Papers (1901), III, No. 559, 48, 62;Google ScholarBlackmore, , Story of the S.A. Bushmen's Corps, p. 7Google Scholar; Vic. Parl. Deb., XCIII, 3924Google Scholar; C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8954Google Scholar.

97. Quotations, in order, from: Abbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, pp. 11–12Google Scholar; Wilkinson, , Australia at the Front, p. 286Google Scholar; Paterson, , Happy Dispatches, p. 12Google Scholar; N.L.A., Canberra, Cox Papers, MS 37.

98. Green, , Story of the Bushmen, pp. 2–4Google Scholar.

99. Wilson, , With the Flag to Pretoria, I, 226–28Google Scholar; Wisden, for 1901, p. 463Google Scholar; The Australian Bushmen's Contingent, second souvenir (Sydney, n.d.), final souvenir (Sydney, 1900)Google Scholar; Blackmore, Story of the S.A. Bushmen's Corps, passim; Lewis, On the Veldt, passim; How Westralia's Sons Served the Empire, passim.

100. The first such contingents (1,068 men) were paid for by public subscription; the remainder were “Imperial Bushmen,” paid by the Imperial Government. Murray, , Official Records, pp. 70, 207, 337, 392, 441, 542, 577Google Scholar. See typical examples in Dooner, M., The ‘Last Post’: being a roll of all officers (Naval, Military or colonial) who gave their lives for their Queen, King and Country, in the South African War, 1899-1902 (London, 1903)Google Scholar. See also In Memory of the gallant Officers and Men of Victoria who died in defence of our Empire in the Transvaal War, 1899-1900 (Melbourne, 1900)Google Scholar, and the scores of Boer War memorials scattered throughout Australian country towns — columns, fountains, plaques in churches and halls, memorial rolls in schools.

101. Abbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, pp. 264Google Scholar, 97-98; Tremearne, , Some Austral-African Notes, p. 1Google Scholar.

102. The rates of pay were raised in 1900 for the Imperial Bushmen's contingents, and confusion and delays in paying caused much resentment, Feb. 1901; offers of cheap land in Rhodesia were made to Australian, Canadian, and New Zealand volunteers, Aug. 1900. Colonial troops took a keen interest in the agricultural or pastoral possibilities of the land they fought over and spoke of prospecting after their term of service was up. See Kemp, , “The South African War,” Vic. Hist. Mag., XXXVI, 52, 53–55Google Scholar; Abbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, pp. 19–23Google Scholar; Wilkinson, , Australia at the Front, p. 286Google Scholar.

103. “The recruiting of colonial corps has been overdone, and the quality of the army in South Africa has suffered accordingly.” Times, May 28, 1901Google Scholar.

104. Telegraph (Sydney), Apr. 4 and 3, 1902Google Scholar.

105. News first appeared in the Sydney Morning Herald, Mar. 26, 1902; the official version from South Africa followed in the evening edition, ibid., Apr. 7, 1902. For an understanding account see Renar, F., Bushman and Buccaneer: Harry Morant. His 'Ventures and Verses (Sydney, 1902)Google Scholar; obituary for Morant, , Bulletin, Apr. 5, 1902Google Scholar; cartoon, “A glimpse of the real thing,” ibid., Apr. 12, 1902. For a partisan account see Witton, G. R., Scapegoats of Empire: The Story of the Bushveldt Carbineers (Melbourne, 1907)Google Scholar. For the official Australian reaction see C'wealth Parl. Deb., IX, 11250-51, 11380–81Google Scholar.

106. Voice from the Veldt, p. 21; Reay, , Australians in War, p. 118Google Scholar.

107. For the incident concerning the Victorians, see C'wealth Parl. Deb., IV, 5405–08Google Scholar; for stories see Hayes, , Hull Down, pp. 115 ff.Google Scholar; Abbott, , Tommy Cornstalk, p. 219Google Scholar; for the strain between colonial and imperial officers, see C'wealth Parl. Deb., IX, 11409Google Scholar.

108. Only five voted against an affirmation of “the readiness of Australia to give all requisite aid to the Mother Country, in order to bring the present war to an end,” Jan. 14, 1902. C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8738–8800Google Scholar. Subsequently proposals to send Commonwealth contingents were not debated but simply notified to the House; Jan. 21, 1902, ibid., VII, 8594; Mar. 20, 1902, ibid., VIII, 11099.

109. Coghlan, , Statistical Account, pp. 310–11Google Scholar; Vic. Parl. Deb., XCIV, 205, 381 ff.Google Scholar, 401-02; N.S.W. Parl. Deb., first series, CIV, 1267 ff., 1514Google Scholar.

110. N.L.A., Canberra, Morning Leader, Mar. 15, 1900, Deakin Papers, MS 1540. Deakin was a Member of the Victorian Legislative Assembly, 1880-1900, a Member of the Commonwealth House of Representatives, 1901-13, and became Prime Minister of Australia, 1903, 1905-08, and 1909. See Nauze, J. A. La, Alfred Deakin: A Biography (Melbourne, 1965), I, 196–97Google Scholar; II, 482-83.

111. Vic. Parl. Deb., XCIV, 381–82Google Scholar.

112. The first request arrived on Dec. 21, 1901, and the first Commonwealth contingent sailed from various Australian ports, Feb. 12-26, 1902; the second cabled request arrived Jan. 20, 1902, and the second contingent sailed Mar. 25 - Apr. 8, 1902. A third contingent sailed May 18 - June 2, 1902. See Murray, Official Records, passim; and C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8741, 8954Google Scholar.

113. Quick, ibid., VII, 8783; N.L.A., Canberra, Morning Post, Jan. 29 and Feb. 11, 1902, Deakin Papers, MS 1540.

114. C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8757, 8774, 9029Google Scholar. Concern about the “loss of able-bodied population” had been shown occasionally in the colonies before federation. E.g., Hamilton, , Vic. Parl. Deb., XCII, 1737–38Google Scholar; Sawers, , N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1555Google Scholar; Miller, ibid., C, 1576; N.S.W. Parl. Papers (1900), I, 87, 255, 459Google Scholar; ibid. (1901), I, 118. The considerable civilian emigration from Australia to South Africa from Jan. 1902 caused concern. See Sydney Morning Herald, Jan. 8, 1902.

115. Coghlan, , Statistical Account, p. 250Google Scholar. The population of the six Australian colonies at the end of 1899 was 3,726,480. See Watson, , C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8751Google Scholar, re injuries; for anxiety that the men be discharged in Australia, see ibid., VI, 7609. Altogether 1,246 men are known to have been discharged in South Africa. Murray, , Official Records, pp. 337, 441, 542, 577Google Scholar. No figures are available for N.S.W. or S.A.

116. Parliament House, Canberra, House of Representatives Records, 563/1901-02.

117. C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8954, 9105Google Scholar.

118. Sydney Morning Herald, Apr. 24, 26, 29, and May 29, 1902. N.L.A., Canberra, Wood to Higgins, May 6, 1902, Higgins Papers, MS 1057, series 1, item 85. N.L.A., Canberra, Morning Post, June 12, 1902, Deakin Papers, MS 1540. Crawford, , “The Antipodean Pilgrimage,” Jour. Roy. Aust. Hist. Soc., XLVIIIGoogle Scholar, Pt. 6, passim. Wood resigned as chairman of the Anti-War League, May 4, 1902. Sydney Morning Herald, May 20, 1902.

119. Ibid., Apr. 8, 12, 21, and 24, 1902. Nonetheless the League claimed to have collected over one thousand signatures by Apr. 23, including those of six senators and seven members of the House of Representatives. Ibid., Apr. 12 and 24, 1902.

120. O'Connor, , C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 9009Google Scholar. See also Neild, ibid., VII, 9023; Downer, ibid., VII, 9016; Barton, ibid., VII, 8798; McLean, ibid., VII, 8751. The contrary view was expressed by Higgins, ibid., VII, 8762; Watson, ibid., VII, 8750; McGregor, ibid., VII, 9009; Higgs, ibid., VII, 9636; and in de Wet, , Three Years War, pp. 289et seq.Google Scholar

121. C'wealth Parl. Deb., X, 12938Google Scholar. Watson contested Chamberlain's assertion that “Australia will be satisfied with nothing less in the way of a settlement than the complete subjugation of the Boer States,” but continued, “It is not for me, nor for the members of this House, to indicate the terms upon which the war should be concluded.” Ibid., VII, 8750-51.

122. Senator Pearce, ibid., VII, 9026; Senator McGregor, ibid., VII, 9009. See also the Presidential Address to the Imperial Federation League of Victoria, March 1900 (Melbourne, 1900)Google Scholar: “The colonies which have assisted the mother country in the prosecution of the war should be consulted on the settlement of the terms of peace. This would be a first step towards consulting them upon all questions of foreign policy which might involve the risk of war.”

123. C'wealth Parl. Deb., X, 13146et seq.Google Scholar For an account of the reception of the news of peace, see Sydney Morning Herald, June 3 and A, 1902. “Australia has had her first taste of war, not a very great or very important performance, but we have buried our dead, and that at least binds us more closely to the Motherland than ever before.” Hales, , Campaign Pictures, p. 6Google Scholar. “On the plains of South Africa, in common danger and in common privation, the blood brotherhood of the Empire was sealed.” Doyle, , Great Boer War, p. 551Google Scholar.

124. Holman, Ada, Memoirs, pp. 9–10, 11Google Scholar. According to Evatt, Holman himself at the 1916 Labour conference alluded to his earlier stand, in order to avert censure of his Government. See Evatt, , Australian Labour Leader, p. 386Google Scholar.

125. N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C. 1466, 1552–54, 1563, 1567Google Scholar; Fitzhardinge, , William Morris Hughes, I, 98.Google Scholar

126. McGregor, Senator, C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 9009.Google Scholar

127. Palmer, , Henry Bournes Higgins, pp. 161–65Google Scholar.

128. See C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8753, 8755Google Scholar. N.L.A., Canberra, Wood to Higgins, May 6, 1902, Griffith to Higgins, Dec. 11, 1902, and W. Newton to Higgins, Feb. 6, 1903, Higgins Papers, MS 1057, items 85, 91, 92, 93. Holman, Ada, Memoirs, pp. 129–30, 132Google Scholar.

129. C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8754Google Scholar.

130. E.g., N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1436, 1510Google Scholar; C'wealth Parl. Deb., VII, 8755Google Scholar. Higgins personally was in touch with Spencer and Stead.

131. N.L.A., Canberra, Morning Post, June 12, 1902, Deakin Papers, MS 1540.

132. Jebb, , Studies in Colonial Nationalism, p. 199Google Scholar.

133. Tasmanian Journal and Proceedings of Parliament (1900), XLIII, No. 71Google Scholar.

134. Wood, , “Australia and Imperial Politics” (written in Aug. 1917), in Atkinson, , Australia, pp. 394–95, 381Google Scholar.

135. Hughes, W. M., The Splendid Adventure (London, 1929), pp. 22–23Google Scholar.

136. N.S.W. Parl. Deb., C, 1574–75Google Scholar. It is interesting to remember that the Immigration Restriction Act (“White Australia Policy”) was being debated and passed by the Commonwealth Parliament from June to Dec. 1901.

137. Sydney Gazette, Feb. 1, 1817.