Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-sh8wx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-19T15:19:38.280Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Origins of the Scottish Plantations in Ulster to 1625: A Reinterpretation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

J. Michael Hill
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

There is no question that the plantation of Ulster during the reign of James I had a profound effect on the course of British history. However, the nature of that plantation has been either misrepresented or misunderstood. In order to overcome this problem, we must address two provocative questions: (1) Were the Scots-Irish, the largest group of settlers, predominantly Celtic or non-Celtic ethnically and culturally? and (2) If they were mainly Celtic, why were they better able than non-Celts to establish viable settlements in Ulster, a predominantly Celtic area? A reexamination of the origins of the pre-1625 Scottish settlers and their methods of settlement indeed casts the problem of the Ulster Plantation in a new light.

For the last two decades, historians have begun to question the portrayal of the Scots-Irish, or Ulster Scots, as frugal, hardworking, anglicized Presbyterian Lowlanders who brought the light of civilization to a benighted Celtic backwater. For example, Nicholas Canny correctly dismisses the “myth” of Ulster's material transformation by pointing out that the province, unlike Leinster and Munster, was settled by British planters from less economically advanced areas of the archipelago. But, again, he does not adequately examine the cultural and ethnic background of the dominant Scots-Irish. Traditionally, they have been classed as “Lowland,” non-Celts rather than as “Highland,” Celtic Scots. These designations are misleading because they oversimplify Scotland's historical and cultural divisions that had been in place as early as the Norman invasion.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 32 , Issue 1 , January 1993 , pp. 24 - 43
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1993

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For works that contribute to our misunderstanding of the Scots-Irish, see the Scotch-Irish Society of America, The Scotch-Irish in America, 10 vols. (Cincinnati, 1889; Nashville, 1891–1901)Google Scholar; and Hanna, C. A., The Scotch-Irish in America, 2 vols. (New York, 1902)Google Scholar. Recent works that have renewed interest in the cultural origins of British settlers in North America are McWhiney, Grady, Cracker Culture: Celtic Ways in the Old South (Tuscaloosa, Ala., 1988)Google Scholar; Bailyn, Bernard, Voyagers to the West: A Passage in the Peopling of America on the Eve of the Revolution (New York, 1986)Google Scholar; and Fischer, David Hackett, Albion's Seed: Four British Folkways in America (Oxford, 1989)Google Scholar. Important studies in early modern Irish history over the past two decades include Perceval-Maxwell, Michael, The Scottish Migration to Ulster in the Reign of James I (London, 1973)Google Scholar; Canny, Nicholas, From Reformation to Restoration: Ireland, 1534–1660 (Dublin, 1987)Google Scholar, and Kingdom and Colony: Ireland in the Atlantic World, 1560–1800 (Baltimore and London, 1988)Google Scholar; Brady, Ciaran and Gillespie, Raymond, eds., Natives and Newcomers: Essays on the Making of Irish Colonial Society, 1534–1641 (Dublin, 1986)Google Scholar; Gillespie, Raymond, Colonial Ulster: The Settlement of East Ulster, 1600–1641 (Cork, 1985)Google Scholar; and Robinson, Philip S., The Plantation of Ulster: British Settlement in an Irish Landscape, 1600–1670 (Dublin and New York, 1984)Google Scholar.

2 Canny, Nicholas, “A Reply [to Raymond Gillespie],” Irish Economic and Social History 13 (1986): 96–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 1–18, 233–51, 323–57, passim.

4 Smyth, Alfred P., Warlords and Holymen: Scotland, A.D. 80–1000 (London, 1984), pp. 3–4Google Scholar; Barrow, G. W. S., Kingship and Unity: Scotland, 1000–1306 (Toronto, 1981), p. 135Google Scholar; Grant, Alexander, “Scotland's ‘Celtic Fringe’ in the Late Middle Ages: The MacDonald Lords of the Isles and the Kingdom of Scotland,” in The British Isles, 1100–1500: Comparisons, Contrasts and Connections, ed. Davies, R. R. (Edinburgh, 1988), p. 135Google Scholar; and Dunlop, A. I., The Life and Times of James Kennedy, Bishop of St. Andrews (Edinburgh, 1950), p. 372Google Scholar. That the counties of the Borders-Southwest differed considerably from the actual Lowland counties should come as no surprise to anyone familiar with Great Britain (see Calendar of Border Papers, 1560–1603, 2 vols., ed. Bain, Joseph [London, 1894–1896])Google Scholar or with the numerous local studies on the southwestern counties.

5 Smyth, p. 26; Rev. Hill, George, An Historical Account of the MacDonnells of Antrim (Belfast, 1877), pp. 21–23Google Scholar.

6 Jackson, K. H., “The Britons in Southern Scotland,” Antiquity 29 (1955): 77–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 O'Rahilly, T. F., Irish Dialects Past and Present (Dublin, 1932), pp. 164, 260–61Google Scholar.

8 Smyth, p. 81.

9 Brown, P. Hume, A Short History of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1904), p. 94Google Scholar; Dunlop, p. 372.

10 Barrow, pp. 10–12, 107; Smyth, 220–21, 227–28, 231.

11 Barrow, p. 56.

12 For the importance of the MacDonnells in northeastern Ireland from the fifteenth through the seventeenth centuries, see Hill, G., MacDonnells of Antrim, pp. 21–351 passimGoogle Scholar; and Hill, J. Michael, Sorley Boy MacDonnell and Clan Ian Mor in the Sixteenth Century (London, 1993), in pressGoogle Scholar.

13 Gailey, Alan, “The Scots Element in North Irish Popular Culture,” Ethnologia Europaea 8 (1975): 13Google Scholar; Adams, G. B., ed., Ulster Dialects (Cultra, 1964), p. 1Google Scholar; Braidwood, J., “Ulster and Elizabethan English,” in Adams, , ed., p. 9Google Scholar.

14 Gailey, p. 13; Gregg, R. J., “Scotch-Irish Urban Speech in Ulster,” in Adams, , ed., p. 190Google Scholar; Homer, Nils M., On Some Relics of the Irish Dialect Spoken in the Glens of Antrim (Uppsala, 1940), p. 6Google Scholar.

15 Gailey, pp. 13–14; Gregg, , “Scotch-Irish Urban Speech,” p. 190Google Scholar; Braidwood, p. 19; Gregg, R. J., “Notes on the Phonology of a County Antrim Scotch/Irish Dialect,” Orbis 8 (1959): 402Google Scholar, and “The Scotch-Irish Dialect Boundaries in Ulster,” in Patterns in the Folk Speech of the British Isles, ed. Wakelin, M. F. (London and New York, 1972), p. 111Google Scholar.

16 Indenture between Lord Deputy Perrot and Sorley Boy MacDonnell, June 18, 1586, Public Record Office (PRO), London, State Papers (SP) 63/124/83, Ireland, Elizabeth (hereafter cited as SP 63); Sorley Boy MacDonnell's patent of denization, June 18, 1586, Bodleian Library (Bodl.), Oxford, MS Laud Misc. 613, Ms. 302–5; Hill, G., MacDonnells of Antrim, pp. 194–215Google Scholar; Perceval-Maxwell (n. 1 above), p. 67; Canny, , Reformation to Restoration (n. 1 above), p. 170Google Scholar; Montgomery, W., The Montgomery Manuscripts, ed. Rev. Hill, George (Belfast, 1869), pp. 51–52Google Scholar; SirHamilton, James, The Hamilton Manuscripts, ed. Lowry, T. K. (Belfast, 1867), pp. 18–27Google Scholar; Gillespie, , Colonial Ulster (n. 1 above), p. 50Google Scholar.

17 British Library (BL), London, Additional MSS (Add.) 4770, fols. 147–78, 204–69 (hereafter cited as BL, Add. MSS); Gillespie, , Colonial Ulster, p. 33Google Scholar; Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 68, 233–34, 250–51.

18 Rev. Hill, George, An Historical Account of the Plantation in Ulster, 1608–1620 (Belfast, 1877), pp. ii, iv–vGoogle Scholar.

19 Lambeth Palace Library, London, Carew MSS, vol. 630, fols. 99, 103–4; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fol. 103; T. W. Moody, ed., “Ulster Plantation Papers, 1608–13,” in Irish Manuscripts Commission, (IMC), Analecta Hibernica (Dublin, 1938), 8:229–30Google Scholar; Historical Manuscripts Commission, Hastings MSS (London, 1947), 4:166Google Scholar.

20 Perceval-Maxwell, p. 327.

21 Hastings MSS, 4:166, 170; Carew MSS, vol. 630, fols. 98–99; Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 323–24, 327, 333, 351–52.

22 Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 323–24, 327, 333–36, 341–45, 349, 351–54, 357; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fols. 103, 107, 110; Carew MSS, vol. 630, fols. 99, 102–3; Hastings MSS, 4:166, 177Google Scholar; Moody, ed., pp. 229–30; Great Britain, Calendar of Stale Papers Relating to Ireland, 1509–1670, 24 vols. (London, 1860–1911), vol. 16, 1615–25, p. 468Google Scholar (hereafter cited as CSP Ire.).

23 Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 324–25, 332, 336, 340, 345–50, 354; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fols. 103, 107, 109–10, 112; Carew MSS, vol. 630, fols. 99, 101–3; Undertakers' certificates, 1622, MS 8014; Sir John Drummond's certificate, 1622, Sir George Hamilton's certificate, n.d., Sir Robert Hepburn's certificate, n.d., Mrs. Lindsay's certificate, n.d., Andrew Stewart's certificate, n.d., National Library of Ireland (NLI), Dublin, MS 8014/8–9 (hereafter cited as NLI, 8014); Moody, ed., p. 204; CSP Ire., vol. 16, 1615–1625, p. 468Google Scholar; R. D. Edwards, ed., “Letter-Book of Sir Arthur Chichester, 1612–14,” in IMC, 8:30; Hastings MSS, 4:177–78Google Scholar.

24 CSP Ire., vol. 16, 1615–25, p. 468Google Scholar, vol. 17, 1625–32, pp. 512–13; Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 325–30, 332–34, 336–43, 346–48, 350–56; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fols. 100, 104, 107–8, 110, 112, 114–15, 117–18; Carew MSS, vol. 630, fols. 96–97.

25 CSP Ire., vol. 16, 1615–25, p. 468Google Scholar, vol. 17, 1625–32, pp. 512–13; Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 325–26, 328–30, 332–33, 337–39, 341, 343, 346–48, 350–51, 353–56; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fols. 100, 104, 107–8, 110, 112, 114, 117–18; Carew MSS, vol. 630, fols. 96–98.

26 Perceval-Maxwell (n. 1 above), 327–30, 333–34, 336, 340–42, 351–53; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fols. 100, 110, 114–15.

27 Robinson, , Plantation of Ulster (n. 1 above), p. 1Google Scholar; Canny, N. P., “Migration and Opportunity: Britain, Ireland and the New World,” Irish Economic and Social History 12 (1985): 8CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gillespie, , Colonial Ulster (n. 1 above), p. 222Google Scholar; Robinson, Philip S., “British Settlement in County Tyrone, 1610–66,” Irish Economic and Social History 5 (1978): 7, 19CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

28 Rev. Andrew Stuart, quoted in Hanna (n. 1 above), 1:549; Cullen, L. M., “Population Trends in Seventeenth-Century Ireland,” Economic and Social Review 6 (1975): 153–54Google Scholar; CSP Ire., vol. 14, 1608–1610, pp. 17, 85Google Scholar; Robinson, , Plantation of Ulster, p. 150Google Scholar; Perceval-Maxwell, p. 87; Chichester to Salisbury, November 1610, in Rev. Hill, George, ed., Plantation Papers, 2 vols. (Belfast, 1888–1889), 2:21Google Scholar; MacNevin, Thomas, The Confiscation of Ulster (Dublin, 1846), p. 166Google Scholar.

29 Cullen, L. M., The Emergence of Modern Ireland, 1600–1900 (New York, 1981), pp. 62, 65–66, 68Google Scholar; Hunter, R. J., “Towns in the Ulster Plantation,” Stadia Hibernica 9 (1971): 43, 52–55, 77Google Scholar; PRO, Northern Ireland, Belfast, R. C. 3/4, fols. 88–93; Simington, R. C., ed., The Civil Survey (Dublin, 1937), 3:23Google Scholar; Canny, , “Migration and Opportunity,” p. 23Google Scholar; SirBrereton, William, Travels in Holland, The United Provinces, England, Scotland, and Ireland, 1634–1635, ed. Hawkins, Edward (London, 1844), pp. 126, 132Google Scholar; Robinson, Philip S., “Vernacular Housing in Ulster in the Seventeenth Century,” Ulster Folklife 25 (1979): 1, 6–8, 13–14, 20–21Google Scholar; Hastings MSS, 4:170Google Scholar; SirPetty, William, “The Anatomy of Ireland, 1672,” in A Collection of Tracts and Treatises, 2 vols. (Dublin, 1861), 2:77Google Scholar.

30 Canny, , “Migration and Opportunity,” 17–18, 19, 27, 29Google Scholar; Robinson, Philip S., “The Spread of Hedged Enclosure in Ulster,” Ulster Folklife 23 (1977): 57–58Google Scholar. For livestock raising and herding practices, see O'Donovan, John, The Economic History of Livestock in Ireland (Cork, 1940)Google Scholar.

31 Hill, G., ed., Plantation in Ulster, pp. ii, iv–vGoogle Scholar; Robinson, , “County Tyrone,” p. 11Google Scholar; Gillespie, , Colonial Ulster, p. 39Google Scholar; Canny, , “Reply,” p. 96Google Scholar; CSP Ire., vol. 17, 1625–1632, 512–13Google Scholar; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fol. 112; Canny, , “Migration and Opportunity,” 9–10, 20, 22Google Scholar; McCarthy-Murrogh, Michael, The Munster Plantation: English Migration to Southern Ireland, 1583–1641 (Oxford and New York, 1986), pp. 1–45, 223–84 passimGoogle Scholar; Robinson, , Plantation of Ulster, pp. xviii–xixGoogle Scholar; BL, London, Harleian MSS (Harl.) 4706, fol. 8.

32 Pocock, J. G. A., “British History: A Plea for a New Subject,” Journal of Modern History 67 (1975): 601–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 Stewart, A. T. Q., The Narrow Ground: Patterns of Ulster History (London, 1977), p. 24Google Scholar.

34 Reid, James Seaton, History of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, 3 vols. (Belfast, 1867), 1:96Google Scholar.

35 Brooke, Peter, Ulster Presbyterianism: The Historical Perspective, 1610–1970 (Dublin, 1987), p. 17Google Scholar.

36 Ibid., 19, 21–22, 26–27, 29, 41, 49, 51.

37 Braidwood (n. 13 above), p. 26; Gailey (n. 13 above), pp. 4, 9; Perceval-Maxwell (n. 1 above), p. 273.

38 CSP Ire., vol. 17, 1625–1632, pp. 512–13Google Scholar; Perceval-Maxwell, pp. 272, 325–26; Carew MSS, vol. 630, fol. 100; Hastings MSS, 4:181Google Scholar; BL, Add. MSS 4756, fol. 110; Simington, ed., 3; 170, 180.

39 Hill, J. Michael, “Shane O'Neill's Campaign against the MacDonnells of Antrim, 1564–65,” Irish Sword 18, no. 71 (Summer 1991): 129–38Google Scholar.

40 Simms, Katherine, “Warfare in the Medieval Gaelic Lordships,” Irish Sword 12 (1975–1976): 98–108Google Scholar; Hill, J. Michael, “The Distinctiveness of Gaelic Warfare, 1400–1750,” European History Quarterly 22 (July 1992): 323–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 Canny, , Reformation to Restoration (n. 1 above), pp. 206–7Google Scholar; Gillespie, Raymond, “An Army sent from God: Scots at War in Ireland, 1642–49,” in Scotland and War, A.D. 79–1918, ed. MacDougall, Norman (Edinburgh, 1991), pp. 113–32Google Scholar.

42 Quoted in Hill, G., ed., Plantation in Ulster (n. 28 above), p. 91nGoogle Scholar; “Discourse on the settlement of natives in Ulster, c. 1613,” Bodl., Oxford, Carte MS 30, fol. 54.

43 Robinson, , Plantation of Ulster (n. 1 above), p. 194Google Scholar.

44 I am presently working on a study of the Celtic Scots' settlements in Ulster from 1625 to 1720 in which this issue will be presented.