Skip to main content Accessibility help

A Multi-Period Analysis of Two Common Livestock Management Strategies Given Fluctuating Precipitation and Variable Prices

  • John P. Ritten (a1), W. Marshall Frasier (a2), Christopher T. Bastian (a1), Steven I. Paisley (a3), Michael A. Smith (a4) and Siân Mooney (a5)...


Many areas of the US recently endured a severe drought and management strategies to cope with the lack of forage production varied. A multi-period mathematical model is presented that estimates the outcomes of two common producer responses to changes in precipitation, partial liquidation and purchasing hay, given fluctuating cattle prices over a long term planning horizon. Results were further summarized with regression analysis and selected elasticities were calculated to reflect the sensitivity of outcomes to variability in precipitation and livestock prices. Although little impact was seen from utilizing additional hay as a strategy during drought, producers who follow this strategy are in a position to market more animals immediately post drought in general, resulting in better long run financial outcomes. Elasticity estimates suggest that profitability is more sensitive to variability in prices but that optimal choices of management strategies are more sensitive to variability in precipitation.



Hide All
Bastian, C.T., Mooney, S., Nagler, A.M., Hewlett, J.P., Paisley, S.I., Smith, M.A., Frasier, W.M., and Umberger, W.J.Cattle Ranchers Diverse in Their Drought Management Strategies.Western Economics Forum 5(2006):18.
Bastian, C.T., Ponnamanneni, P., Mooney, S., Ritten, J.P., Frasier, W.M., Paisley, S.I., Smith, M.A., and Umberger, W.J.Range Livestock Strategies Given Extended Drought and Different Price CyclesJournal of the American Society of Farm Managers and Rural Appraisers 72,1(2009):153–63.
Carande, V.G., Bartlett, E.T., and Gutierrez, P.H.Optimization of Rangeland Management Strategies under Rainfall and Price Risks.Journal of Range Management 48(1995):6872.
Cattle-Fax Inc. Unpublished data. Centennial, CO. Internet site: (Accessed August 21, 2007).
Garoian, L., Mjelde, J.W., and Conner, J.R.Optimal Strategies for Marketing Calves and Yearlings from Rangeland.American Journal of Agricultural Economics 72,2(1990):604–13.
Hart, C.R., and Carpenter, B.B.Stocking Rate and Grazing Management.” Texas Agricultural Extension Service Publication E-64, 2005.
Holecheck, J.L.Financial Returns from Grazing Different Management Systems in New Mexico.Rangelands 16(1994):237–40.
May, G.J., Van, L.W. Tassell, Smith, M.A., and Waggoner, J.W.Optimal Feed Cost Strategies Associated with Early and Late Calving Seasons.” Paper presented at the conference of the American Agricultural Economics Association annual meetings, Salt Lake City, UT, August 2- 5, 1998.
Murugan, S.Profit Maximizing Livestock Production and Marketing Strategies to Manage Climate Variability.” M.S. thesis. New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM, 2007.
Nagler, A., Bastian, C., Hewlett, J.P., Mooney, S., Paisley, S.I., Smith, M.A., Frasier, M., Umberger, W., and Ponnameneni, P.Multiple Impacts, Multiple Strategies: How Wyoming Cattle Producers are Surviving in Prolonged Drought. Laramie: University of Wyoming, Cooperative Extension Service, 2007.
Nagler, A., Mooney, S., Bastian, C., Hewlett, J.P., Aldridge, B., Sarchet, B.A., Umberger, W., Frasier, M., Paisley, S.I., Smith, M.A., Ponnameneni, P., Taylor, D.T., and Foulke, T.Wyoming Beef Cattle Producers Survey – Final Report. Laramie: Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of Wyoming, June 2006. Internet site: (Accessed April 24, 2008).
National Climatic Data Center (NCDC). National Oceanic and Atmospheric administration (NOAA). Internet site: (Accessed June 6, 2007).
Parseti, L.D., Popp, M.P., and Loewer, O.J.Stocking Rate Risk for Pasture-Fed Steers Under Weather Uncertainty.Journal of Range Management 50(1997):541–49.
Ramsey, R., Doye, D., Ward, C., McGrann, J., Falconer, L., and Bevers, S.Factors Affecting Beef Cow-Herd Costs, Production, and Profits.Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 37,1(2005):851–63.
Robb, J.Personal Communication. Livestock Marketing Information Center (LMIC), Lake-wood, CO, June 2007.
Smith, M.A.Drought Prediction Model Development and Dissemination in Wyoming. Report for 2002WY7B, 2005. Internet site: (Accessed April 24, 2008).
Stockton, M.C., and Wilson, R.K.Simulated Analysis of Drought's Impact on Different Cow-Calf Production Systems.” Paper presented at the Southern Agricultural Economics Association meetings, Mobile, AL, February 4-7, 2007.
Taylor, D., Coupai, R., and Foulke, T.The Economic Importance of Livestock Grazing on BLM Land in Fremont County, Wyoming.” Project Report. Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, College of Agriculture, University of Wyoming, October 2004. Internet site: (Accessed June 17, 2009).
Torell, L.A., Tanaka, J.A., Rimbey, N., Darden, T., Van Tassell, L., and Harp, A.Ranch-Level Impacts of Changing Grazing Policies on BLM Land to Protect the Greater Sage-Grouse: Evidence from Idaho, Nevada and Oregon. PACWPL Policy Paper SG-01-02. Caldwell, Idaho: Policy Analysis Center for Western Public Lands, 2001.
Ward, CE., Vestal, M.K., Doye, D.G., and Lalman, D.L.Factors Affecting Adoption of Cow-Calf Production Practices in Oklahoma.Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 40,3(2008):851–63.
Wyoming Agricultural Statistics Service (WASS). Internet site: (Accessed May 30, 2007).


A Multi-Period Analysis of Two Common Livestock Management Strategies Given Fluctuating Precipitation and Variable Prices

  • John P. Ritten (a1), W. Marshall Frasier (a2), Christopher T. Bastian (a1), Steven I. Paisley (a3), Michael A. Smith (a4) and Siân Mooney (a5)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed