Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-ckgrl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-18T11:09:03.308Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Arab Unity Schemes Revisited: Interest, Identity, and Policy in Syria and Egypt

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 April 2009

Eberhard Kienle
Eberhard Kienle
Affiliation:
Associate Professor in the Department of Politics, School of Oriental and African Studies, Thornhaugh Street, Russel Square, London WC1H OXG, U.K.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

From the day in April 1946 when the last French soldiers left and Syrians were finally able to run their own affairs, their policies toward other Arabs have differed significantly, although decreasingly over the years, from the policies pursued by Egyptians. Within their country, Syrian legislators used to privilege Arab over non-Arab foreigners in various respects, including the investment of capital as well as the acquisition of citizenship and political rights, while fewer, if any, advantages of this sort were granted in Egypt Such differences in the treatment of noncitizen Arabs at home have been paralleled by different policies toward other Arab states. Unity schemes, a prominent feature in inter-Arab relations generally, are one key area where approaches diverged quantitatively as well as qualitatively and where favorable attitudes in Syria often contrasted with considerable reluctance on the Egyptian side.

Type
Articles
Information
International Journal of Middle East Studies , Volume 27 , Issue 1 , February 1995 , pp. 53 - 71
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

1 Cf. Kienle, Eberhard, “Imagined Communities Legislated: Nationalisms and Law of Nationality in Syria and Egypt” (Unpublished paper presented to the workshop “Rethinking Nationalism in the Arab World,” Boulder, Colo., 09 1994Google Scholar).

2 For instance, Ethnicity: Theory and Experience, ed. Glazer, Nathan and Moynihan, Daniel P. (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1975);Google ScholarHorowitz, Donald L., Ethnic Groups in Conflict (Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 1985);Google ScholarHobsbawm, Eric J., Nations and Nationalism since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990).Google Scholar

3 For Qudsi's plan, cf. Khūrī, Yūsuf, ed., al-Mashāriʿal-waḥdawiyya al-ʿarabiyya, 1913–1987 (Beirut: Markaz Dirāsāt al-Wahda al-ʿarabiyya, 1988), 257 ff.;Google Scholar forʿAzm's proposal, ibid., 294 f.; for the 1956 project, ibid., 336 ff.

4 Cf. Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 402 f.Google Scholar

5 Cf. ibid., 403 ff.

6 Cf. Kerr, Malcolm H., The Arab Cold War: Garmal, ʿAbd al-Nasir and His Rivals 1958–1970 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1971), 37 f.Google Scholar

7 Text of agreement in Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 405 ff.Google Scholar

8 For details, cf. Patrick Seale, The Struggle for Syria.

9 Cf. Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ 432 ff., 439 ff.Google Scholar

10 See Kienle, Eberhard, Baʿlh v. Baʿth: The Conflict between Syria and Iraq 1968–1989 (London: I. B. Tauris, 1990), chap. 4, 176 ff.,Google Scholar for text of Charter of Joint National Action; original text of Mīthāq al-ʿamal al-qawmī al-mushtarak in Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 479.Google Scholar

11 Cf. Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 498.Google Scholar

12 Ibid., 467

13 Cf. al-Wathāʾiq al-ʿarabiyya, ed. American University of Beirut (Beirut: AUB, 1964), 2:270 f.Google Scholar

14 Ibid., 2:519.

15 Cf. Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ 464 f.Google Scholar

16 For details, cf. Seale, Struggle for Syria, chap. 22; al-Sayyid, Mustafa Kamal, “The Rise and Fall of the United Arab Republic” (Paper presented to the 17th conference of the Center of Arab Studies, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C., 04 1992);Google ScholarʿAsasa, Sami, Asrār al-infiṣāl: Miṣr…wa Sūriya (Cairo: Dār al-Shaʿb, s.d.);Google ScholarRathmell, Andrew, “The Role of Covert Action and International Terrorism in Middle East Politics: Syria 1949–1961” (Unpubl. Ph.D. diss., University of London, 1994), chap. 6Google Scholar.

17 For Nasser's reservations, see also Riyad, Mahmud, Mudhakkirāt Mahmūd Riyad (Cairo: Dār al-Mustaqbal al-ʿarabī, 1986), 2:chaps. 8–10Google Scholar.

18 Cf. Kerr, , Arab Cold War, 33Google Scholar.

19 Kienle, Baʿth v. Baʿth, chap. 4.

20 al-Barada, Jarīdat, ed., Yawm al-qawmī al-ʿarīsa: Jalāʿ al-juyūsh al-ajnabiyyaʿ an Sūriya (Damascus, 1946), 1–13Google Scholar.

21 Anonymous, Resolution from April 1947 in al-Aḥzāb al-siyāsiyya fī Sūriya (Damascus: Dār al-Ruwwād, 1954), 192–205Google Scholar; Khalil, Muhammad, The Arab States and the Arab League: A Documentary Record (Beirut: Khayats, 1962), 1:670 ffGoogle Scholar.

22 Statement of 15 August 1948 in Khalil, , The Arab States, 1:677 ff.Google Scholar; Anonymous, al-Aḥzāb, 157–70Google Scholar.

23 Constitution of the Baʿth, Arab party (Dustūr al-Ḥizb), 17 04 1947,Google Scholar as printed in various party publications, English translation in Arab Nationalism: An Anthology, ed. Haim, Sylvia G. (Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 1976), 233–42Google Scholar

24 Seale, Struggle for Syria, chap. 8; Yamak, Labib Z., The Syrian Socialist Nationalist Party: An Ideological Analysis (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1966)Google Scholar.

25 E.g., Dusen, M. H. van, “Political Integration and Regionalism in Syria,” Middle East Journal 26, 2 (1972): 123–36Google Scholar.

26 Minutes of this session in Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 115 ffGoogle Scholar.

27 al-Barada, , ed., Yawm al-qawmī, 1–13Google Scholar.

28 al-Quwatli, Shukri, Shukrī al-Quwatli yukhāṭib ummatahu (Beirut: Markaz al-wathāʿiq al-muʿāṣira, 1970), 171–84Google Scholar.

29 Cf. minutes in Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 115 ffGoogle Scholar.

30 Zaʿim's first public address after his coup on 3 April 1949 in ʿAwf, B., al-lnqilāb al-sūrī (Damascus: Maktabat al-Nuri, 1949), 133 ff.Google Scholar; Hinnawi's Proclamation No. 1 in al-Qabas (Damascus), 15 08 1949Google Scholar.

31 As to the discrepancy between policies and rhetorics, cf. Seale, Struggle for Syria, 147Google Scholar.

32 Davis, H. M., Constitutions, Electoral Laws, and Treaties of States in the Near and Middle East (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 1953), 402–33Google Scholar.

33 As quoted in Seale, Struggle for Syria, 130, referring to al-Barada (Damascus), 25 October 1953.

34 As to this relationship between “people” and “nation,” cf. also resolution passed by the Syrian Chamber of Deputies on 5 July 1956 in support of the federal union with Egypt, as quoted by Seale, Struggle for Syria, 258 fGoogle Scholar.

35 For the minutes, cf. Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 336 ffGoogle Scholar.

36 Ibid., 337.

37 Ibid., 342.

38 The following paragraph draws heavily on the detailed study by Freitag, Ulrike, Geschichtsschreibung in Syrien 1920–1990 zwischen Wissenschaft und Ideologic (Hamburg: Deutsches Orient-Institut, 1991), 183–202,Google Scholar who refers to al-sūriyya, al-Jumhūriyya, al-maʿārif, Wizārat, Minhāj al-dirāsa al-thanawiyya (Damascus, 1947)Google Scholar and Manāhij al-dirāsa al-thanawiyya li-al-ḥalqatayn al-mutawaṣṣita wa al-iʿdādiyya (Damascus, 1952)Google Scholar.

39 Freitag, , Ceschichlsschreibung, 193 ffGoogle Scholar.

40 Ibid., 196 ff., referring to al-Jumhūriyya al-sūriyya, al-maʿārif, Wizārat, Minhāj al-taʿlīm fī almadāris al-thanawiyya (Damascus, 1957)Google Scholar.

41 “Proclamation No. 1, 28 September 1961 in Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 371Google Scholar.

42 Cf. al-Wathāʾiq al-ʿarabiyya, ed. American University of Beirut (Beirut: AUB, 1963), 1:45Google Scholar.

43 E.g., Foreign Minister Salah al-Bitar, 11 March 1963, in ibid., 1:51.

44 Cf. ibid., 1964, 2:179 ff.

45 E.g., communiqué of 23 February 1966, in ibid., 1966, 4:117 ff.

46 E.g., al-Baʿth, 9 02 1967Google Scholar; President Nur al-Din al-Atasi on 22 February 1967, in al-Baʿth, 23 February 1967.

47 Freitag, , Geschichtsschreibung, 288 ff.,Google Scholar referring to al-sūriyya, al-Jumhūriyya al-ʿarabiyya, al-tarbiya, Wizārat, Manāhij al-marḥala al-iʿdādiyya and Manāhij al-marḥala al-thanawiyya for 1971–1972 (Damascus, 1971),Google Scholar which repeat formulations from 1967.

48 For details, cf. Kienle, , Baʿth v. Baʿth, chap. 2–5Google Scholar; for concrete illustrations, e.g., al-Baʿth, Tishrīn, 22–30 04 1976Google Scholar.

49 E.g., in a speech to officers on 29 April 1980 in British Broadcasting Corporation. Summary of World Broadcasts: The Middle East (BBC/SWB), 31 03 1980Google Scholar; or in his major speech on 8 March 1987, in Tishrīn, 9 March 1987.

50 E.g., in a speech in Damascus, 17 March 1980, in BBC/SWB, 19 03 1980Google Scholar.

51 Asad on 8 March 1987, in BBC/SWB, 10 03 1987Google Scholar.

52 Al-Baʿth, 12 03 1992Google Scholar.

53 Al-Ahrām, 16 11 1951Google Scholar.

54 E.g., policy statement by Prime Minister Nuqrashi in the Chamber of Deputies (Majlis al-nuwwāb), 15 December 1947, in al-Ahrām, 16 12 1947Google Scholar; policy statement Prime Minister Sirri in the chamber, 1 August 1949, in al-Ahrām, 2 08 1949Google Scholar.

55 Session of 21 January 1950, in al-nuwwāb, Majlis, Majmūʿa al-maḍābiṭ, 21 01 1950Google Scholar; also in al-Ahrām, 22 01 1950Google Scholar.

56 E.g., speech by al-ʿUrabi, ʿAli Z., in al-shuyūkh, Majlis, Majmūʿa al-maḍābiṭ, Session 1947–48, 8 12 1947Google Scholar.

57 E.g., question time in the Egyptian Senate (Majlis al-shuyūkh), 12 March 1945, in al-Ahrām, 13 03 1945Google Scholar.

58 In Bilādī, 18 05 1945Google Scholar.

59 Farouq, King, Speech from the Throne (Khiṭāb al-ʿarsh), 16 January 1950, in al-Ahrām, 17 01 1950Google Scholar. The Chamber of Deputies on 21 January 1950 passed a resolution in support of this declaration, which is phrased identically.

60 E.g., Farouq, King in his Speech from the Throne on 18 January 1945 in al-Ahrām, 19 01 1945Google Scholar; also Speech from the Throne of 16 January 1950, in al-Ahrām, 17 01 1950Google Scholar.

61 E.g., Farouq, King, Speech from the Throne, November 1951, in al-Ahrām, 16 11 1951Google Scholar.

62 E.g., statement by Prime Minister Nuqrashi, 3 March 1947, in The Times (London), 4 03 1947Google Scholar; also Farouq's, King Speech from the Throne, November 1951, in al-Ahrām, 16 11 1951Google Scholar.

63 E.g., Farouq, King as quoted in al-Ahrām, 16 11 1951Google Scholar.

64 Farouq, King, Speech from the Throne, November 1951, in al-Ahrām, 16 11 1951Google Scholar.

65 E.g., policy statement by Prime Minister Nuqrashi in the Chamber of Deputies, 15 December 1946, in al-Ahrām, 16 12 1946Google Scholar.

66 Wizārat al-maʿārif alʿumūmiyya (Ministry of Public Education), Manāhij al-taʿlīm al-thanawī 1948 (Ṭarīkh), 83Google Scholar.

67 Cf., e.g., Egyptian memorandum on Sudanese self-determination of 2 November 1952, in Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ, 263 fGoogle Scholar.; agreement between Egypt and the advocates of independence in Sudan, ibid., 261 f.; charter of Egyptian Liberation Organization, in Khalil, The Arab States, 1:688Google Scholar; original in al-Ahrām, 22 01 1953Google Scholar.

68 Khalil, , The Arab States, 1:688 fGoogle Scholar.

69 al-ʿumūmiyya, Wizārat al-maʿārif, al-thāniyya, Al-majmūʿa, Manāhij mawādd al-dirāsat li-lmarḥala al-iʿdādiyya 1953–54 (Cairo, 1954), 53 ffGoogle Scholar.

70 Nasr, Marlin, al-Taṣawwur al-qawmī al-ʿarabi fī fikr Gamāl ʿAbd al-Nāsir, 1952–1970, 4th ed. (Beirut: Markaz Dirāsāt al-Waḥda al-ʿArabiyya, 1990)Google Scholar.

71 Cf. Dawisha, Adeed I., Egypt in the Arab World: The Elements of Foreign Policy (London: Macmillan, 1976), chap. 2Google Scholar.

72 al-Nasir, Gamal ʿAbd, Falsafat al-Thawra (Cairo: Wizārat al-l-ʿlām, 1953)Google Scholar.

73 Nasr, , al-Taṣawwur, 107, 125Google Scholar.

74 First published in al-Ahrām, 17 01 1956Google Scholar; passed by referendum on 26 july 1956.

75 Cf. Nasr, , al-Taṣawwur, 386 fGoogle Scholar.

76 Cf. in particular Nasser's nationalization speech, al-Ahrām, 27 07 1956Google Scholar; trans, in Khalil, , The Arab States, 742–71Google Scholar.

77 Riyad, , Mudhakkirāt, 2:141Google Scholar.

78 al-Ahrām, 27 07 1956Google Scholar.

79 al-Ḥayāt, 7 07 1956Google Scholar; Majmūʿat khuṭub wa-taṣrīḥāt wa-bayānāt al-raʿīs Gamāl ʿAbd al-Nāsir, ed. al-ʿarabiyya, Jumhūriyyat Miṣr, al-istiʿlāmāt, Maslaḥāt (Cairo, s.d.), 1:541 fGoogle Scholar.

80 al-taʿlīm, Wizārat al-tarbiya wa, Majmūʿ at manāhij al-taʿ līm bi-l-marḥala al-i-ʿdādiyya al-ʿāmma 1957 (Cairo, 1957), 52 ffGoogle Scholar.

81 Al-Manāhij al-mushtaraka bayna al-bilād al-ʿarabiyya: Miṣr, Sūriyā, al-Urdun, li-mawādd aldirāsat bi al-madāris al-thanawiyya 1957–1958, ed. alʿarabiyya, al-Maktab al-dāʿim li-l-waḥda al-thaqāfiyya (Cairo: Dār al-maʿārif bi-Maṣr, s.d.)Google Scholar.

82 al-muttaḥida, Al-Jumhūriyya al-ʿarabiyya, wa-l-taʿlīm, Wizārat al-tarbiya, Al-Manāhij al-muwaḥ-ḥada li-l-marḥala al-iʿdādiyya al-ʿāmma li-l-ʿām al-dirāsī 1963–1964 (Cairo, 1963), 150Google Scholar.

83 Gamal ʾAbd al-Nasser's Speeches and Press Interviews During the Year 1958 (Cairo, n.d.), 4 fGoogle Scholar.

84 Nasr, , al-Taṣawwur, 386 fGoogle Scholar.

85 E.g., Nasser, , 22 July 1963, in al-Ahrām, 23 07 1963Google Scholar; ʿAmr, Marshall, 7 12 1963, in al-Ahrām, 8 11 1963Google Scholar; for a statistical analysis throughout Nasser's rule, cf. Nasr, , al-Taṣawwur, 396 f., confirming that not Egyptian identity as such but only I'identité de cette identité has been subject of debateGoogle Scholar; cf. Roussillon, Alain, “Egyptianité, Arabité, Islamité: La recomposition des référents identitaires”, Egypte/Monde arabe 11, 3 (1992): 77CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86 E.g., Nasser, in Algiers on 4 May 1963, in al-Ahrām, 5 05 1963Google Scholar.

87 Nasr, , al-Taṣawwur, 383 fGoogle Scholar.

88 See also Dawisha, , Egypt in the Arab World, 143 ffGoogle Scholar.

89 According to the minutes released by Egypt, in al-Wathāʾiq al-ʿarabiyya, 1963, 1:63Google Scholar.

90 Ibid., 1:114.

91 al-Ahrām, 31 03 1968Google Scholar.

92 Sadat to the National Assembly, 7 October 1970, in Speeches by President Anwar al-Sadat, September 1970-March 1971, ed. United Arab Republic, Ministry of Information, State Information Service (Cairo, s.d.), 5 ffGoogle Scholar.; similarly, explicit references to Egypt are omitted in his “Address to the Nation,” on radio and television on 18 10 1970Google Scholar; ibid., 15 ff.

93 Speeches by President Anwar al-Sadat, 1 ff.

94 Speech by President Sadat on 4 02 1971, in Speeches by President Anwar al-Sadat, 233–58Google Scholar.

95 President Sadat in his public statement on 14 05 1971, in Speeches by President Anwar al-Sadat, 114Google Scholar.

96 al-ʿarabiyya, Jumhūriyyat Maṣr, al-taʿlīm, Wizārat al-tarbiya wa, Al-Manāhij al-muṭawwara li-lmarḥala al-iʿdādiyya 1979–80 (Cairo, 1979), 159Google Scholar

97 On the 40th anniversary of the revolution, al-Ahrām, 23 07 1992Google Scholar.

98 Ibid., 26 April 1992.

99 Seale, Struggle for Syria and Kerr, Arab Cold War remain the most comprehensive sources to date.

100 Cf. Khuri, , al-Mashāriʿ 339 fGoogle Scholar.

101 Mufti, Malek, “Pan-Arabism and State Formation in Syria and Iraq, 1920–1992” (Unpublished Ph.D. diss., Harvard University, 05 1993)Google Scholar.

102 Kienle, Baʿth v. Baʿth, Introduction.