Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-9pm4c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-27T03:45:37.826Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

History and Legitimacy: Aspects of the Use of the Past in Precolonial Dahomey*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 May 2014

Robin Law
Robin Law*
Affiliation:
University of Stirling
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The kingdom of Dahomey (or Fon) was probably founded during the first half of the seventheenth century, but emerged clearly as a major power only in the early eighteenth century when its king Agaja (ca. 1716–40) conquered its southern neighbours Allada (1724) and Whydah (1727), thereby establishing direct contact with the European slave-traders at the coast. Dahomey then remained the dominant power in the area until it was itself conquered by the French in the 1892–94. The kingdom ceased to exist as a political entity when its last king was deposed by the French in 1900, but a degree of institutional continuity has been maintained through the performance of rituals at the royal palace (now a museum) in the capital city Abomey. The history of Dahomey from the 1720s onwards is relatively well documented from contemporary European sources, enjoying in particular the unique distinction of being made the subject already in the eighteenth century of a published book—Archibald Dalzel's History of Dahomy (1793). There is also a rich and coherent corpus of narrative traditions relating to the kingdom's history, best known in the classic recension published in 1911 by the French colonial official Le Herissé, which is in fact merely a translation (and in some measure an abridgement, omitting some detailed material) of the account given to him by a single Dahomian informant, Agbidinukun, the chef de canton of the cercle of Abomey under French colonial rule and a brother of the last independent king of Dahomey, Behanzin (1889–94).

Type
Papers from the Conference “Memoires, Histoires, Identites: Experiences Des Societes Francophones”
Information
History in Africa , Volume 15 , 1988 , pp. 431 - 456
Copyright
Copyright © African Studies Association 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

An earlier version of this paper was presented at the conference on “Mémoires, histoires, identités: expériences des sociétés francophones,” Université Laval, Québec, in October 1987. My thanks are due to those who contributed to discussion of the paper on that occasion, and also to the Nuffield Foundation, the British Academy, the Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland, and the University of Stirling, for their financial support of the research on which it is based.

References

Notes

1. Dalzel, Archibald, The History of Dahomy (London, 1793; reprinted 1967).Google Scholar

2. Le Herissé, A., L'ancien royaume du Dahomey (Paris, 1911), 274–352Google Scholar; for Agbidinukun and Le Hrissé's treatment of his material see ibid., 3, 273.

3. Law, Robin, “Dahomey and the Slave Trade: Reflections on the Historiography of the Rise of Dahomey,” JAH, 27(1986), 237–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem., “Ideologies of Royal Power: The Dissolution and Reconstruction of Political Authority on the ‘Slave Coast,’ 1680-1750,” Africa, 57(1987), 321–44.

4. Norris, Robert, Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, King of Dahomy (London, 1789Google Scholar; reprinted 1968), xiv-xv (copied by Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 1–2Google Scholar); Vicente Ferreira Pires, Viagem de Africa em o Reino de Dahomé, ed. de Lessa, Clado Ribeiro (São Paulo, 1957), 37–39Google Scholar; Brue, A. de, “Voyage fait en 1843, dans le Royaume de Dahomey,” Revue Coloniale, 7(1845), 58Google Scholar; Burton, Richard, A Mission to Gelele, King of Dahome (memorial ed., 2 vols.: London, 1893), 1:104–06Google Scholar; Foà, Edouard, Le Dahomey (Paris, 1895), 3–6.Google Scholar

5. E.g. Foà, , Dahomey, 288Google Scholar; Mercier, P., “The Fon of Dahomey” in African Worlds, ed. Forde, Daryll (London, 1954), 213.Google Scholar

6. Herskovits, Melville J., Dahomey, An Ancient West African Kingdom (2 vols.: New York, 1938), 2:208n2Google Scholar; cf. Herskovits, Melville J. and Herskovits, Frances S., Dahomean Narrative (Evanston, 1958), 16, 20.Google Scholar

7. Forbes, Frederick E., Dahomey and the Dahomans (2 vols.: London, 1851; reprinted 1966), 2:187.Google Scholar

8. Despatches from Commodore Wilmot Respecting His Visit to the King of Dahomey (Houses of Parliament, London, 1863), 10Google Scholar; also see the experience of Burton in 1864: Mission to Gelele, 2:183–84.Google Scholar

9. Mercier, , “The Fon of Dahomey,” 213, 226, 229.Google Scholar

10. The existence of literate Muslims in Dahomey, said to be merchants taken captive on their travels, was already reported in 1727: Snelgrave, William, A New Account of So me Parts of Guinea (London, 1734; reprinted 1971), 80.Google Scholar For Islam in Dahomey see further Law, Robin, “Islam in Dahomey: A Case Study of the Introduction and Influence of Islam in a Peripheral Area of West Africa,” Scottish Journal of Religious Studies, 7(1986), 95–122.Google Scholar

11. An early fascination with literacy was evinced by Agaja, who according to an English trader held captive in Dahomey in 1724, “much love[s] to look in a Book, and commonly carries a Latin Mass-Book, in his Pocket … and when he has a mind to banter any Body out of their Requests, he looks in his Book as studiously as if he understood it, and could employ his Thought on no other Subject, and much affects scrawling on Paper, often sending me his Letters:” letter of Bulfinch Lamb, 27 Nov. 1724, in Smith, William, A New Voyage to Guinea (London, 1744; reprinted 1967), 182–83.Google Scholar For an especially interesting example of written communication by a Dahomian king see the letter of King Adanzan to the Regent of Portugal, 20 Nov. 1804, written for him by a Portuguese held captive in Dahomey, in Verger, Pierre, Flux et réflux de la traite des négres entre le Golfe de Bénin et Bahia de Todos os Santos du XVIIe au XIXe siécle (Paris, 1968), 281–82.Google Scholar

12. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:154–55.Google Scholar Forbes obscurely suggests that this was “a hit at our mission.”

13. Public Record Office, London [hereafter PRO]: FO. 84/1464, C. C. Stafford, for King of Dahomey, to Commodore Hewitt, Whydah, 13 March 1876.

14. For the possiblity of such “feedback” from European published sources into local traditions in the Dahomey area as early as the seventeenth century, see Law, Robin, “Problems of Plagiarism, Harmonization and Misunderstanding in Contemporary European Sources: Early (pre-1680s) Sources for the ‘Slave Coast’ of West Africa,” Paideumz, 33(1987), 346.Google Scholar

15. For studies of bas-relief sculptures on the palace walls of Dahomey and of the heads of official staffs (récades) incorporating allusions to historical events see Waterlot, E. G., Les bas-reliefs des bâtiments royaux d'Abomey (Dahomey), (Paris, 1926)Google Scholar; Adandé, A., Les récades des rois du Dahomey (Dakar, 1962).Google Scholar

16. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:24.Google Scholar

17. Herskovits, /Herskovits, , Dahomsan Narrative, 17.Google Scholar

18. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 8-9, 105, 272.Google Scholar

19. Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, viGoogle Scholar; Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:97.Google Scholar

20. See Dunglas, Edouard, “Contribution à l'histoire du Moyen-Dahomey, I,” Etudes Dahoméennes, 19(1957), 80–81.Google Scholar

21. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 272.Google Scholar

22. Ibid., 9–10.

23. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 1:104Google Scholar; Herskovits, /Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 21.Google Scholar

24. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 1:141, 141n1.Google Scholar

25. Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, xxii.Google Scholar

26. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:12–29.Google Scholar

27. Brue, , “Voyage fait en 1843,” 63Google Scholar; Journal of Lieutenant Forbes on his Mission to Dahomey, 27 May 1850, in Papers Relative to the Reduction of Lagos (Houses of Parliament, London, 1852), inclosure 3 in no. 13.Google Scholar

28. Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, xxii.Google Scholar

29. Herskovits, /Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 21.Google Scholar

30. Forbes, , Dahomey, 1:13, 30Google Scholar; Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 271.Google Scholar

31. Brue, , “Voyage fait en 1843,” 58.Google Scholar

32. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:14Google Scholar; Le Hérissé, , L'ancient royaume du Dahomey, 271.Google Scholar

33. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:21.Google Scholar

34. Brue, , “Voyage fait en 1843,” 63.Google Scholar

35. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 271.Google Scholar

36. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:14.Google Scholar

37. Herskovits, /Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 20–21.Google Scholar

38. Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 2.Google Scholar

39. Duncan, John, Travels in Western Africa in 1845 and 1846 (2 vols.: London, 1847; reprinted 1968), 2:275Google Scholar; Forbes, , Dahomey 1:x.Google Scholar

40. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 272.Google Scholar

41. Herskovits, /Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 21.Google Scholar

42. Argyle, W. J., The Fon of Dahomey (Oxford, 1966), 2.Google Scholar

43. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 12-16, 276–99Google Scholar; cf. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:265–72.Google Scholar

44. Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, xvi.Google Scholar

45. Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 2, 211, 219.Google Scholar

46. Ibid., 219.

47. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 14Google Scholar; cf. Herskovits, , Dahomey, 2:73–74.Google Scholar

48. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:111–12Google Scholar; cf. Le Hérissé, L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 288n2.

49. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 289.Google Scholar

50. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:111, 267.Google Scholar

51. Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 1.Google Scholar

52. Argyle, , The Fon of Dahomey, 2Google Scholar; for a particular instance in which Dahomian traditions are dismissed as “propaganda” see Akinjogbin, I. A., Dahomey and Its Neighbours, 1708-1818 (Cambridge, 1967), 75.Google Scholar

53. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 6–8.Google Scholar

54. Ibid., 351.

55. See esp. Herskovits, , Dahomey, 1:11–14Google Scholar; Argyle, , The Fon of Dahomey, 34–36Google Scholar; Akinjogbin, , Dahomey and Its Neighbours, 199–200.Google Scholar

56. Foà, , Dahomey, 20.Google Scholar

57. PRO: CO.2/11, letter of G. A. Robertson to Lord Bathurst, Cape Coast, 2 Sept. 1820.

58. Brue, , “Voyage fait en 1843,” 61.Google Scholar

59. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:23.Google Scholar

60. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:292–93.Google Scholar

61. The contemporary account of Pires, , Viagem de Africa, 77–79Google Scholar, shows that Adanzan (in this account called “Ariconúm”) had to fight for the throne against an elder brother called “Anibabel” (presumably Ganse). An account recorded in 1803, only six years after the event, already suppressed mention of this civil war, and implied a peaceful succession, stating like Burton later that the eldest son was rejected because of a physical imperfection, though this was allegedly not gibbosity (a hunched back) but a deformity of the toes: M'Leod, John, A Voyage to Africa (London, 1820; reprinted 1971), 39.Google Scholar

62. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 311–12.Google Scholar

63. Letter of Jan Bronssema, Badagry, 11 Aug. 1740, in Elmina Journal, 1 Feb. 1741, in Dantzig, Albert Van, ed. The Dutch and the Guinea Coast, 1674-1742: A Collection of Documents from the General State Archive of the Hague (Accra, 1978), 353.Google Scholar

64. Archives Nationales, Paris [hereafter AN]: C.6/25, letter of Conseil de Direction, Whydah, 18 Feb. 1753.

65. Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 4–6.Google Scholar

66. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 299–300.Google Scholar

67. See Akinjogbin, , Dahomey and Its Neighbours, 60–62.Google Scholar

68. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 295Google Scholar; cf. ibid., 7.

69. Skertchly, J. A., Dahomey As It Is (London, 1874), 450.Google Scholar

70. Bergé, J., “Etude sur le Pays Mahi,” Bulletin du Comité d'études historiques et scientifiques de l'Afrique ôccidentale Française, 11/4 (1928), 719Google Scholar, reporting tradition in the Mahi country, to the north of Dahomey, whither Agbosassa is said to have retired after his unsuccessful bid for the Dahomian throne. The story of Agbosassa's claim to the throne and exile was already recorded in the 1860s by Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:268Google Scholar, but connected with the accession of Akaba rather than of Agaja.

71. Coissy, Anatole, “Un régne de femme dans l'ancien royaume d'Abomey,” Etudes Dahoméennes, 2 (1949), 5–8.Google Scholar

72. PRO: C.113/276, letter of William Baillie, Whydah, 18 Jan. 1718.

73. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 3, 25.Google Scholar

74. Ibid., 12; cf. also ibid., 283.

75. Herskovits, , Dahomey, 2:73.Google Scholar

76. Argyle, , The Fon of Dahomey, 98.Google Scholar

77. Herskovits, , Dahomey, 2:73.Google Scholar

78. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:73.Google Scholar

79. AN: C.6/25, letter of Delisle, Dahomey, 7 Sept. 1728.

80. Ibid.

81. See Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 2:275Google Scholar; Forbes, Dahomey, 2:24.Google Scholar

82. Brue, , “Voyage fait en 1843,” 66Google Scholar; cf. also Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 2:275.Google Scholar

83. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, esp. 318-22 (Gezo's victorious wars), 299–300 (tribute paid by Agaja).Google Scholar

84. Ibid, 312-13.

85. Forbes, , Dahomey, 1:7Google Scholar; cf. ibid., 2:23.

86. Argyle, , The Fon of Dahomey, 35.Google Scholar

87. See esp. Foà, , Dahomey, 12–26.Google Scholar

88. Letter of Lieutenant Forbes to Commodore Fanshawe, 5 Nov. 1849, in Papers Relative to the Reduction of Lagos, inclosure 13 in no. 3.

89. Forbes, , Dahomey, 2:89.Google Scholar

90. Cf. Akinjobgin, Dahomey and Its Neighbours, chapter 6.

91. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey 289Google Scholar; cf. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:111, 266–67.Google Scholar

92. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 24–25 (prostration)Google Scholar; 84-86 (fiscal innovations); 74, 290 (judicial centralization); 213 (security of property); 56, 291 (ban on export of native Dahomians); 161 (change in burial customs).

93. Herskovits, /Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 359–61Google Scholar; for cotton cloth see also Herskovits, , Dahomey, 1:16.Google Scholar

94. See esp. Akinjogbin, , Dahomey and Its Neighbours, 24-26, 203–04.Google Scholar

95. Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, xivGoogle Scholar; Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 1:105–06Google Scholar; contrast Foà, , Dahomey, 3–6Google Scholar; Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 288.Google Scholar

96. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:270–71Google Scholar; cf. Forbes, , Dahomey 2:135Google Scholar; contrast Le Hérissé, L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, plan opposite 30.

97. For prostration see e.g. for Allada, , “Journal du Voyage du Sieur Delbée” in Relat on de ce qui s'est passé dans les Isles et Terre ferme de l'Amérique, ed. Clodoré, J. de (Paris, 1671), 2:427Google Scholar; and for Whydah, e.g. Bosman, William, A New and Accurate Description of the Coast of Guinea (London, 1705; reprinted 1967), 365.Google Scholar For royal inheritance rights see for Allada, , Dapper, Olfert, Naukeurige Beschrijvinge der Afrikaensche Gewesten (Amsterdam, 1668), 493Google Scholar; and for Whydah, , Phillips, Thomas, “A Journal of a Voyage made in the Hannibal of London” in Collection of Voyages and Travels, ed. Churchill, Awnsham and Churchill, John (6 vols.: London, 1732), 6:219.Google Scholar

98. This is not to say that all the claimed innovations are spurious. Among the measures attributed to Wegbaja, for example, are the prohibition of earlier customs whereby the heads of the dead were removed and given separate burial, and whereby thieves caught in the act might be legally killed and their heads removed and taken to the local chief: Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 161, 290.Google Scholar Contemporary sources do, in fact, attest both of these practices in Whydah before the Dahomian conquest. For the separate burial of heads see “Relation du Royaume de Judas en Guinée” (anonymous ms of ca. 1714, in Archives d'Outre-Mer, Aix-en–Provence: Dépôt des Fortifications des Colonies, Côtes d'Afrique, ms 104), 68-69; for the killing and decapitation of thieves see Barbot, Jean, “Description des Côtes d'Affrique” (ms of 1688, in PRO: ADM. 7/830), 3:136.Google Scholar These prohibitions, therefore, might well be genuine Dahomian innovations, even if their attribution specifically to Wegbaja is doubtful. The purpose of these prohibitions is difficult to grasp, though they seem to be related to the king's claim (already reported in the eighteenth century by Norris, , Merroirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 8Google Scholar) to “own” the heads of all Dahomians. The traditions allege that Wegbaja wished to prevent the theft of such heads for use as amulets, but it seems possible that the kings of Dahomey sought more generally to suppress (or to monopolize for themselves) the ritual use of heads, including their use in the ancestral cults of the component lineages of Dahomey.

99. For further discussion see Law, , “Ideologies of Kingship,” 336–38.Google Scholar

100. Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 128–30Google Scholar; Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 204–05.Google Scholar

101. See e.g. Bosman, , New and Accurate Description, 366a.Google Scholar

102. AN: B.1/9, f. 125, letter of Bouchel, Whydah, 30 Jan. 1716.

103. Le Hérissé, , L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 274–77.Google Scholar

104. Ronen, Dov, Dahomey: Between Tradition and Modernity (Ithaca, 1975), 20.Google Scholar

105. Akinjogbin, , Dahomey and Its Neighbours, 91.Google Scholar

106. Pires, , Viagem de Africa, 37–40.Google Scholar Although Pires gives the founders of Dahomey and Porto-Novo the otherwise unrecorded names of “Caracuté” and “Buricaxi”, his story is clearly recognizable as a variant of that told later of Dogbagrighenu and Teagbanlin.

107. AN: C.6/25, Pruneau, and Guestard, , “Mémoire pour servir à l'intelligence du commerce de Juda,” 18 March 1750.Google Scholar

108. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 1:104.Google Scholar

109. Foà, , Dahomey, 3–5.Google Scholar

110. Herskovits, , Dahomey, 1:167–69.Google Scholar

111. Le Hérissé, L'ancien royaume du Dahomey, 18n2.

112. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 2:97.Google Scholar

113. For further discussion of Dahomey's attempt to appropriate the legitimacy of the Allada kinship, see Law, , “Ideologies of Kingship,” 327–29.Google Scholar