Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-4rdrl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-29T13:15:20.007Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Unionist Politics and Theaftermath of the General Election of 1906: A Reassessment

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

David Dutton
David Dutton
Affiliation:
University of Liverpool
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The internal dissessions and upheavals in the Unionist party following the catastrophic defeat incurred at the general election of 1906 have been the subject of frequent examination by historians. Despite, or perhaps because of, the importance of the issues involved there has been general agreement that questions of policy were at the centre of this struggle. Balfour's official biographer has commented that any rumours of ‘disputed leadership’ were ‘ludicrous in the light of the correspondence that was passing in private’, while Chamberlain's biographer has asserted that he was staking ‘everything on policy’. Recently Dr Judd has suggested that Chamberlain ‘envisaged…a reunited Unionist party…very probably under his leadership not Balfour's’, but he took this analysis no further and Mr Fraser's judgement is typical that what took place was ‘a polite but ruthless struggle for the control of the Unionist party's machinery and policy’. The Birmingham leader is characteristically seen to have played through the whole episode with the straightest of bats, bound above all by personal loyalty to Balfour. Contemporaries, however, saw a different Chamberlain – one whose ruthless ambition bordered on fanaticism. Balfour noted that Chamberlain ‘cannot realize that because he is only thinking of one thing, it does not follow that every one else has the same limited intensity of vision’. Some were prepared to interpret Chamberlain's machinations in terms of a dual personality: ‘You know there are two Joes and that one honestly sees no harm in prosecuting such a manoeuvre’, but others were ready to place more sinister constructions upon them:

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 22 , Issue 4 , December 1979 , pp. 861 - 876
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See particularly Fraser, P., ‘Unionism and tariff reform: the crisis of 1906’, Historical Journal, v, 2 (1962)Google Scholar; and Amery, J., Joseph Chamberlain and the tariff reform campaign (London, 1969)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Mr Amery's study provides the historian with a wealth of material from the Chamberlain papers, but is narrative rather than analytical in nature.

2 Dugdale, B. E. C., Arthur James Balfour (London, 1936), 11, 22Google Scholar.

3 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 800.

4 Judd, D., Radical Joe: a life of Joseph Chamberlain (London, 1977), p. 258Google Scholar.

5 Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 150.

6 Balfour to Sandars, 31 Jan. 1906, Sandars MSS, Bodleian Library, c. 751/137.

7 Sandars to Balfour, 14 May 1906, Balfour MSS, British Library, Add. MSS 49764.

8 R. Cecil to Balfour, 25 Jan. 1906, ibid. 49737, cited Judd, Radical Joe, p. 261.

9 Strachey to Rosebery, 26 April 1910, Strachey MSS, House of Lords Record Office, S/12/7/21.

10 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 796.

11 Churchill to Bonar Law, 6 Feb. 1906, Bonar Law MSS, House of Lords Record Offce, 18/8/13.

12 SirPetrie, C., The life and letters of the Rt Hon. Sir Austen Chamberlain (London, 1939), 1, 178Google Scholar.

13 The Times, 30 Jan. 1906; J. Amery, Chamberlain, p. 789; slightly different figures are given in Zebel, S. H., Balfour, a political biography (Cambridge, 1973), pp. 142–3Google Scholar.

14 Blewett, N., ‘Free Fooders, Balfourites, Whole Hoggers: Factionalism within the Unionist Party, 1906–10’, Historical Journal, xi, 4 (1968), 96Google Scholar.

15 Russell, A. K., Liberal landslide: the general election of 1906 (Newton Abbot, 1973), p. 179Google Scholar.

16 Ibid. p. 181.

17 Askwith, Lord, Lord James of Hereford (London, 1930), p. 293Google Scholar.

18 Akers-Douglas to Sandars, 5 Feb. 1906, Sandars MSS, c. 751/181.

19 Amery, L. S., My political life (London, 1953), 1, 292Google Scholar.

20 Winterton, Lord, Pre-War (London, 1932), pp. 22–3Google Scholar.

21 Ridley to Chamberlain, 22 Jan. 1906, Joseph Chamberlain MSS, Birmingham University Library, 21/2/82, cited Amery, Chamberlain, p. 798.

22 Ridley to Bonar Law, 5 Jan. 1906, Bonar Law MSS, 18/2/10.

23 The full text of this letter is given in Amery, Chamberlain, pp. 821–4.

24 Chamberlain to Balfour, 23 Jan. 1906, J.C. MSS, 21/2/2, cited Amery, Chamberlain, pp. 800–1.

25 Balfour to Chamberlain, 24 Jan. 1906, ibid., cited Amery, Chamberlain, p. 802.

28 Balfour to Sandars, 20 Jan. 1906, Sandars MSS, c. 751/99.

27 Chamberlain to Balfour, 25 Jan. 1906, J.C. MSS, 21/2/4, cited Amery, Chamberlain, pp. 803–5.

28 Chamberlain, to Denison, Colonel, 24 12 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 792Google Scholar.

29 Chamberlain, to Halsbury, Lord, 5 02 1906Google Scholar, Halsbury MSS, B.L. 56372.

30 Chamberlain, to Boraston, , 26 12 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 806–7Google Scholar.

31 Chamberlain, to Evelyn, Cecil, 26 12 1906, J.C. MSS, 21/2/17, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 806Google Scholar.

32 Akers-Douglas, to Sandars, , 5 02 1906Google Scholar, Sandars MSS, c. 751/181.

33 Sandars, to Balfour, , 26 12 1906, Balfour MSS, 49764Google Scholar.

34 Sir A. Fitzroy, Memoirs, (London, undated), I, 279.

35 Sandars, to Balfour, , 27 12 1906, Balfour MSS, 49764Google Scholar.

36 Lansdowne to Balfour, 28 Jan. 1906, cited Newton, Lord, Lord Lansdowne, a biography (London, 1929), p. 348Google Scholar; Amery, Chamberlain, pp. 808–9; Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 157..

37 Sandars, to Balfour, , 29 12 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 798Google Scholar; Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 157..

38 Chamberlain, to MrsEndicott, , 30 12 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 799Google Scholar.

39 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 800.

40 Chamberlain, to Chamberlain, Austen, 10 11 1905, Austen Chamberlain MSS, Birmingham University Library, 17/3/46Google Scholar.

41 Amery, Chamberlain, pp. 771–2.

42 Letter to The Times, 7 11 1905, cited Fraser, , ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 152Google Scholar.

43 Chamberlain, to Mount-Stephen, , 22 12 1905, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 773–4Google Scholar.

44 Chamberlain, to Chaplin, Henry, 9 12 1906, J.C. MSS, 21/2/22, cited Amery, Chamberlain, p. 782Google Scholar.

45 Chamberlain, to Deakin, , 26 04 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 889Google Scholar.

46 Ibid..

47 Blake, R., The Conservative party from Peel to Churchill, (London, 1970), p. 185Google Scholar; Thomas, J. A., The House of Commons 1906–1911 (Cardiff, 1958), p. 6Google Scholar. The figures given exclude Irish and university seats.

48 Ridley, to Chamberlain, , 12 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 842–3Google Scholar.

49 Chaplin, to Chamberlain, , 1 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 810–11Google Scholar.

50 Chamberlain, to Chaplin, , 16 02 1906, J.C. MSS, 21/2/33, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 849Google Scholar.

51 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 861.

52 Cecil, to Balfour, , 25 12 1906, Balfour MSS, 49737Google Scholar.

53 Viscount Cecil of Chelwood, , All the way (London, 1949), p. 102Google Scholar.

54 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 810.

55 Wolverton to Devonshire, 5 Feb. 1906, cited Rempel, R., Unionists divided (Newton Abbot, 1972), 167Google Scholar; Betty Balfour to Alice Balfour, 4 Feb. 1906, cited Judd, D., Balfour and the British Empire (London, 1968), 136Google Scholar.

56 Chamberlain to Halsbury, 5 Feb. 1906, Halsbury MSS, 56372.

57 Pound, R. and Harmsworth, G., Northcliffe (London, 1959), 298Google Scholar.

58 Chamberlain, to Boraston, , 3 02 1906, cited Fraser, , ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 158Google Scholar.

59 The Times, 5 Feb. 1906.

60 St John Brodrick to Selborne, 9 Feb. 1906, Selborne MSS, Bodleian Library, 2/131.

61 Lansdowne, to Balfour, , 4 02 1906, Balfour MSS, 49729, cited Fraser, , ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 159Google Scholar.

62 Halsbury, to Chamberlain, , 4 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 818Google Scholar.

63 See above, p. 863.

64 Chamberlain to Halsbury, 7 Feb. 1906, Halsbury MSS, 56372.

65 Gerald Balfour to Betty Balfour, 8 Feb. 1906, Gerald Balfour MSS, 118 (in the possession of Lord Balfour).

66 Chamberlain, to Ridley, , 6 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 821–4Google Scholar.

67 Chamberlain, to Balfour, , 25 12 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 803Google Scholar.

68 Sandars to Balfour, 27 Jan. 1906, Balfour MSS, 49764.

69 Balfour, to Chamberlain, , 8 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 832–3Google Scholar; Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 160.

70 Chamberlain, to Garvin, , 5 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 814–16Google Scholar.

71 Chamberlain, to Balfour, , 10 02 1906, J.C. MSS, 21/2/8, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 835–8Google Scholar.

72 Gerald Balfour to Betty Balfour, 14 Feb. 1906, Gerald Balfour MSS, 118.

73 Ibid..

74 Salisbury to Selborne, 25 Feb. 1906, Selborne MSS, 5/128.

75 Cecil, H. to Devonshire, , 16 02 1906, cited Rempel, , Unionists, p. 169Google Scholar.

76 Holland, B., The life of Spencer Compton, eighth duke of Devonshire (London, 1911), II, 398Google Scholar.

77 Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, pp. 161, 163.

78 Chamberlain, to Ridley, , 10 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, p. 838Google Scholar.

79 Hewins, W. A. S., Apologia of an imperialist (London, 1929), I, 169Google Scholar.

80 Newton, Lansdowne, p. 352.

81 W. C. Bridgeman, unpublished diary, entry for 15 Feb. 1906.

82 Hewins, Imperialist, I, 169.

83 Ibid. p. 167.

84 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 851.

85 Hewins, Imperialist, I, 169.

86 Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 164.

87 Chamberlain, to Ridley, , 6 02 1906, cited Amery, , Chamberlain, pp. 821–4Google Scholar.

88 Hyde, H. Montgomery, Carson: the life ofSir Edward Carson (London, 1953), 212–13Google Scholar.

89 Salvidge, S., Salvidge of Liverpool (London, 1934), 71Google Scholar.

90 Robert Cecil to Balfour, 14 May 1906, Balfour MSS, 49737.

91 Hugh Cecil to Balfour, 14 Feb. 1906, ibid. 49759.

92 Jones, R. B., ‘The Conservative party 1906–1911’ (Oxford B.Litt. thesis, 1960), p. 42Google Scholar.

93 Robert Cecil to Balfour, 24 May 1906, Balfour MSS, 49737.

94 Arnold Forster to Bonar Law, 24 Apr. 1906, Bonar Law MSS, 18/2/16.

95 Chamberlain to Boraston, 3 02. 1906, cited Amery, Chamberlain, p. 814Google Scholar; Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 158.

96 Sandars to Balfour, 14 May 1906, Balfour MSS, 49764.

97 ‘Notes on political events connected with Mr Chamberlain's Action’ by? Akers-Douglas, July 1906, Sandars MSS, c. 751/252. The next two paragraphs are based upon this interesting document unless otherwise stated.

98 Ridley to Chamberlain, 25 05 1906, cited Amery, Chamberlain, pp. 885–6Google Scholar.

99 Compare this with Chamberlain's assurance to Chaplin that he had done his best to secure his selection for Worcester, but that the local party had insisted instead upon Stanley Baldwin. Chamberlain to Chaplin, 10 06 1906, cited Amery, Chamberlain, p. 886Google Scholar.

100 Amery, Chamberlain, p. 886.

101 Chamberlain to Austen Chamberlain, 4 05 1906, cited Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 164Google Scholar.

102 Fraser, ‘Unionism and tariff reform’, p. 164.

103 Ibid..