Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-rkxrd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-18T21:34:15.012Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Church Disestablishment as a Factor in the General Election of 1885

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Alan Simon
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The general election of 1885 has been described as ‘the nearest point ever attained to the accomplishment of disestablishment in England’; and it is a curious fact that the very considerable part played by the Church question in this election has largely escaped notice. For this the suddenness with which the issue of Irish Home Rule came to dominate the political scene after the election is primarily responsible. Yet for all its brevity - it was effectively only during the last few weeks of an extended election campaign that the controversy over disestablishment became dominant — the agitation over the question was both fierce and ferocious; and was closely bound up with the name of Joseph Chamberlain.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 18 , Issue 4 , December 1975 , pp. 791 - 820
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1975

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Morgan, Kenneth, Wales in British Politics 1868–1922 (Cardiff, 1963), p. 64.Google Scholar

2 Garvin, J. L., The Life of Joseph Chamberlain, II (London, 1933), 75–6Google Scholar

3 Howard, C. H. D., ‘Joseph Chamberlain and the “Unauthorized Programme”’, E.H.R. LXV (1950), 477–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar Hamer, D. A., in the introduction to his useful new edition of The Radical Programme (Brighton, 1971), scarcely mentions disestablishment, although ‘Religious Equality’ is the subject of the longest chapter in the Programme.Google Scholar

4 The Times, 2 Dec. 1885, 9C–d.Google Scholar

5 K. O. Morgan, Wales in British Politics, p. 61.

6 The material in the rest of this paragraph is taken from Kellas, James, ‘The Liberal Party and the Scottish Church Disestablishment Crisis’, E.H.R. LXXIX (1964), 31–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

7 Marsh, P. T., The Victorian Church in Decline (London, 1969), p. 147.Google Scholar

8 Ibid. pp. 138, 144–5.

9 The Times, I July 1885, 8a.Google Scholar

10 The Times, 4 July 1885, 9a, 29 July 1885, 10f, 10 Aug. 1885, 6c, 15 Aug. 1885, 7f. Spectator, 22 Aug. 1885, pp. 1094–5.Google Scholar

11 Record, 31 July 1885, pp. 756–7.Google Scholar

12 Ibid. II Sept. 1885, pp. 894–9. The figure of 403 over-simplified, as the paper acknowledged, the differences in degree among them. Thus a substantial number of candidates made their support conditional upon whether the question was officially adopted by the leaders of the party, or whether the country in general favoured it, or some similar vague phrase. Only a small minority were hard-core Liberationists. Additionally, among the 403 listed as being in favour, 14 were in favour of Scottish disestablishment only, and 10 for Scotland and Wales only; while curiously among the 37 listed as being opposed, II were opposed only to English disestablishment, and another 3 only to English and Welsh disestablishment.

13 Nonconformist, 17 Sept. 1885, p. 882.Google Scholar

14 Record, 28 Aug. 1885, p. 849.Google Scholar See also ibid. II Sept. 1885, p. 891; Nonconformist, 10 Sept. 1885, p. 859.Google Scholar

15 The Times, 4 July 1885, 9d–f.Google Scholar

16 Ibid, to Aug. 1885, 6a–c, 5 Sept. 1885, 6a–f, 18 Sept. 1885, 7b–e.

17 Morgan, op. cit. p. 63.

18 Daily News, n Sept. 1885.Google Scholar

19 The Times, 19 Sept. 1885, 8a–d.Google Scholar

20 Nonconformist, 24 Sept. 1885, pp. 903–4.Google Scholar

21 The Times, 19 Sept. 1885, 9a–b.Google Scholar

22 Ibid. 21 Sept. 1885, 8b–c; 2 Oct. 1885, 8c–d.

23 Standard, 19 Sept. 1885,Google Scholar 4g–h; st. James's Gazette, 18 Sept. 1885, p. 3;Google Scholar Morning Post, 19 Sept. 1885,Google Scholar 4e–f; Church Times, 25 Sept. 1885, p. 711; Spectator, 19 Sept. 1885, p. 1217.Google Scholar

24 Record, 25 Sept. 1885, pp. 952–3.Google Scholar Akers-Douglas reported in The Times, 26 Sept. 1885,Google Scholar 10b. Archbishop Benson regarded it with ‘the greatest surprise and shame. If (Gladstone) had boldly negatived the idea, it would have reassured every one’, Benson, A. C., The Life of Edward White Benson, II (London, 1899), 63.Google Scholar

25 The Times, 30 Sept. 1885, 10a–b.Google Scholar

26 Speeches of the Rt. Hon. Joseph Chamberlain, ed. Lucy, Henry (London, 1885), pp. 96–7.Google Scholar

27 Ibid. p. 160.

28 The Times, 31 July 1885, 8d.Google Scholar

29 Nonconformist, 20 Aug. 1885, p. 810.Google Scholar

30 Chamberlain, Joseph, A Political Memoir, ed. Howard, C. H. D. (London, 1953), p. 133.Google Scholar

31 Scotsman, 16 Sept. 1885, 7c.Google Scholar

32 Lucy, Speeches of Chamberlain, pp. 196–206.

33 Church Review, 18 Sept. 1885, p. 461;Google Scholar Manchester Guardian, 17 Sept. 1885, 5a–b;Google Scholar see also The Times, 16 Sept. 1885, 9b–c;Google Scholar Scotsman, 16 Sept. 1885, 6b–c;Google Scholar Daily News, 17 Sept. 1885, 5a–b;Google Scholar Glasgow Herald, 16 Sept. 1885, 6b–d.Google Scholar

34 Chamberlain to Gladstone, 7 Nov. 1885, GP Add. MSS 44126, fos. 121–2.

35 The Times, 28 Sept. 1885, 6e.Google Scholar

36 The Times, 2 Oct. 1885, 7a.Google Scholar

37 Lucy, Speeches of Chamberlain, pp. 226–36.

38 The Times, 2 Oct. 1885, 7e.Google Scholar

39 Ibid. 3 Oct. 1885, 12a–b.

40 Gladstone to Granville, 8 Oct. 1885, The Political Correspondence of Mr Gladstone and Lord Granville, 1876–1886, ed. Ramm, Agatha, II (Oxford, 1962), 404.Google Scholar

41 It should also be remembered in this context that Chamberlain was simultaneously under I pressure at Bradford over his attitude on free education - involving the immediate grant of I funds to voluntary schools without immediate public control - and had indeed been repudiated; by the conference on this. See Simon, Alan, ‘Joseph Chamberlain and Free Education in the; Election by 1885’ History of Education, II, 1 (1973), 56–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

42 Harcourt to Chamberlain, 30 Sept. 1885, JCP5/38/34. I am grateful to the University of j Birmingham for permission to quote.

43 Chamberlain to Harcourt, 5 Oct. 1885, Harcourt Papers.

44 The Times, 8 Oct. 1885, 7a–e.Google Scholar

45 Standard, 7 Oct. 1885, 5a–b.Google Scholar

46 St James's Gazette, 12 Sept. 1885, p. 4; 28 Sept. 1885, p. 3.Google Scholar

47 Morning Post, 18 Sept. 1885, 4e–f; 28 Sept. 1885, 4f–g.Google Scholar

48 Record, 25 Sept. 1885, p. 949.Google Scholar

49 The Times, 15 Oct. 1885, 3a–d.Google Scholar

50 ibid. 2 Oct. 1885, 8d.

51 Pall Mall Gazette, 16 Oct. 1885, p. 1;Google Scholar Record, 16 Oct. 1885, p. 1049.Google Scholar

52 The Times, 15 Oct. 1885, 10f;Google Scholar Record, 25 Sept. 1885, p. 949.Google Scholar

53 Lucy, Speeches of Chamberlain, p. 240.

54 The Times, 16 Oct. 1885, 7a–d.

55 Ibid. 16 Oct. 1885, 7d.

56 Ibid. 12 Oct. 1885, 12a; 14 Oct. 1885, IOC.

57 Ibid. 17 Oct. 1885, 9e; 21 Oct. 1885, 7a–c. For similar statements by leading Conservatives see ibid. 17 Oct. 1885, 7d–e; 21 Oct. 1885, 7d-e; 24 Oct. 1885, 9f; 27 Oct. 1885, 6c, oi; 28 Oct. 1885, 8a; 29 Oct. 1885, 6d; 31 Oct. 1885, 6e, 7a–d.

58 Ibid. 22 Oct. 1885, 13f; Church Times, 30 Oct. 1885, p. 843.

59 Ibid. 18 Sept. 1885, pp. 700–701, 16 Oct. 1885, pp. 733–4; 23 Oct. 1885, P. 803.

60 Record, 30 Oct. 1885, p. 1105.Google Scholar

61 Pall Mall Gazette, 31 Oct. 1885, p. 1.Google Scholar

62 Standard, 21 Oct. 1885, 4h–5a.

63 The Times, 5 Nov. 1885, 9a–c.

64 Ibid. 4 Nov. 1885, 9f.

65 Ibid. 5 Nov. 1885, 8a–d.

66 Lefevre to Chamberlain, 5 Nov. 1885, JCP5/52/6.

67 Dilke to Chamberlain, 2 Nov. 1885, JCP5/24/141.

68 Childers to Mundella, II Nov. 1885, Mundella Papers.

69 The Times, 26 Oct. 1885, 7d.

70 Ibid. 5 Nov. 1885, 10d.

71 Ibid. 31 Oct. 1885, 10a–d.

72 Ibid. 2 Nov. 1885, 9e.

73 Daily News, 9 Nov. 1885, 5a–b. See also ibid. 31 Oct. 1885, 4h–5a; 2 Nov. 1885, 5a–b; 5 Nov. 1885, 4h–5a. Manchester Guardian, 17 Oct. 1885, 5b–c; 22 Oct. 1885, 5c; 10 Nov. 1885, 5c. Daily Chronicle, 31 Oct. 1885, 4d–e; 12 Nov. 1885, 4e–f; 13 Nov. 1885, 4e–f.

74 Church Times, 30 Oct. 1885, p. 823.Google Scholar

75 The Times, 4 Nov. 1885, 6e–f.Google Scholar

76 Ibid. 5 Nov. 1885, 8a–d.

77 Ibid. 9 Nov. 1885, 10b–d.

78 Ibid. 9 Nov. 1885 9b–c.

79 St James's Gazette, 9 Nov. 1885, p. 3;Google Scholar Standard, 9 Nov. 1885, 5b–c;Google Scholar Daily Telegraph, 9 Nov. 1885, 4g–h;Google Scholar Pall Mall Gazette, 9 Nov. 1885, P. 3.Google Scholar

80 MacColl to Salisbury, II Nov. 1885, Russell, G. W. E., Malcolm MacColl, Memoirs and Correspondence (London, 1914), p. 117.Google Scholar

81 Glasgow Herald, 12 Nov. 1885, 4b–c.Google Scholar

82 Pall Mall Gazette, 5 Nov. 1885, p. 1.Google Scholar

83 The Times, 9 Nov. 1885, 8b–c.Google Scholar

84 Ibid., 4 Nov. 1885, 9a–b.

85 Record, 23 Oct. 1885, pp. 1081–2.Google Scholar

86 See Savage, Donald, ‘Scottish Politics, 1885–6’, Scottish Historical Review, XL (1961), 118–35.Google Scholar

87 Spectator, 24 Oct. 1885, pp. 1401–1402.Google Scholar

88 Rosebery to Gladstone, 6 Nov. 1885, GP Add.MSS 44288, fos. 265–8.

89 Gladstone to Chamberlain, 6 Nov. 1885, JCP5/34/44 (partly printed in Howard, Pol.Mem., PP. 134–5).

90 Chamberlain to Gladstone, 7 Nov. 1885, GP Add. MSS 44126, fos. 121–2.

91 Chamberlain to Morley, 8 Nov. 1885, JCP5/54/657.

92 Gladstone to Rainy, 3 Nov. 1885, Simpson, P. Carnegie, The Life of Principal Rainy, II (London, 1909), 33–4.Google Scholar

93 Morley, , Gladstone (London, 1903), III, 248.Google Scholar

94 The Times, 12 Nov. 1885, 6a–e.Google Scholar

95 Ibid. 12 Nov. 1885, 6a.

96 Churchill to Salisbury, 12 Nov. 1885, Salisbury Papers.

97 Reginald Macleod to Churchill, 13 Nov. 1885, Salisbury Papers.

98 The Times, 20 Nov. 1885, 8a.Google Scholar

99 Ibid. 16 Nov. 1885, 10a.

100 On 12 November the Scottish Disestablishment Association issued a statement signed by Rainy and Cairns declaring that only pro-disestablishment candidates should be supported, and similar instructions were issued by the National Liberal Federation on 17 November. In the event however only one seat was lost to the Conservatives through a split Liberal vote. See Kellas, , E.H.R. LXXIX (1964), 37–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

101 Standard, 13 Nov. 1885, 5a–b.Google Scholar

102 The Times, 13 Nov. 1885, 12a.Google Scholar

103 Ibid. 14 Nov. 1885, 7a–c, 7f.

104 Ibid. 14 Nov. 1885, 6d.

105 Ibid. 19 Nov. 1885, 7d.

106 Dilke to Chamberlain, 19 Nov. 1885, JCP5/24/145.

107 The Times, 21 Nov. 1885, 6b.Google Scholar

108 Ibid. 12 Nov. 1885, 10a.

109 Ibid. 29 July 1885, 10f. Nonconformist, 12 Nov. 1885, Supplement, p. 4.

110 Church Times, 13 Nov. 1885, p. 867.Google Scholar

111 The Times, 23 Nov. 1885, 4.Google Scholar

112 Ibid. 24 Nov. 1885, 7b–d.

113 Record, 20 Nov. 1885, p. 1177.Google Scholar

114 The Times, 7 Dec. 1885, 7a–c.

115 Ibid. 28 Nov. 1885, 6d.

116 Ibid. 24 Nov. 1885, 6d–e.

117 Ibid. 2 Dec. 1885, ioe; Childers to Mundella (undated), Armytage, W. H. G., A. J. Mundella, 1825–1897 (London, 1951), pp. 231–2; Lefevre to Chamberlain, 28 Nov. 1885, JCP5/52/7.Google Scholar

118 He won by 4,291 votes to his opponent's 4,116. For the activities of the Church in his constituency see The Times, 26 Nov. 1885, 8d.

119 Spectator, 28 Nov. 1885, p. 1572.Google Scholar

120 Record, 27 Nov. 1885, p. 1201.Google Scholar

121 Church Times, II, 18 Dec. 1885, pp. 969, 993.Google Scholar

122 The Times, 2 Dec. 1885, 9c–d.Google Scholar

123 Standard, 24 Nov. 1885, 4h.Google Scholar

124 Chamberlain to Dilke, 29 Nov. 1885, Gwynn, S. and Tuckwell, G. M., The Life of Sir Charles Dilke, II (London, 1917), 193.Google Scholar

125 The Times, 4 Dec. 1885, 12b.Google Scholar

126 Harcourt to Hartington, 4 Dec. 1885, Devonshire Papers 340/1842.

127 Dilke to Chamberlain, 30 Nov. 1885, JCP5/24/147.

128 The Private Diaries of the Rt. Hon. Sir Algernon West, ed. Hutchinson, Horace G. (London, 1922), p. 353.Google Scholar

129 Dilke's diary, 5–7 Dec. 1885, DP Add.MSS 43927, fo. 19.

130 Record, 20 Nov. 1885, p. 1177.Google Scholar

131 Nonconformist, 5, 26 Nov. 1885, pp. 1065, 1127.Google Scholar

132 Ibid. 3 Dec. 1885, p. 1169.

133 Ibid. 12 Nov. 1885, p. 1093. See also ibid. 12 Nov. 1885, pp. 1093–4, 26 Nov. 1885, supplement, pp. 7–8, 3 Dec. 1885, pp. 1165–9, 10 Dec. 1885, p. 1185, supplement, pp. 1–3.

134 Russell, G. W. E., One Look Back (London, 1911), pp. 187–9.Google Scholar

135 Lefevre to Chamberlain, 28 Nov. 1885, JCP5/52/7.

136 Acton to Mary Gladstone, 28 Nov. 1885, Letters of Lord Acton to Mary Gladstone, ed. Paul, Herbert (London, 1913), p. 172.Google Scholar

137 MacDonnell, J. C., The Life and Correspondence of William Connor Magee, II (London, 1896), 217.Google Scholar

138 Benson, op. cit. II, 63.

139 Daily Chronicle, 12 Nov. 1885, 4e–f.

140 Benson, Life of E. W. Benson, II, 64.

141 The Times, II Dec. 1885, 8c–d.Google Scholar

142 Benson, Life of E. W. Benson, II, 63.

143 The Times, 10 Dec. 1885, 6c.Google Scholar

144 Pall Mall Gazette, 14 Dec. 1885, p. 2.Google Scholar

145 Amery, J., Joseph Chamberlain and the Tariff Reform Campaign (London, 1969), p. III.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

146 Fraser, p., Joseph Chamberlain; Radicalism and Empire, 1868–1914 (London, 1966), p. xii.Google Scholar

147 The Times, 24 Nov. 1885, 7b–d.Google Scholar

148 The Times, 24 Nov. 1885, 7b–d.Google Scholar

149 Gladstone to Granville, 8 Oct. 1885, Ramm, op. cit. II, 404.

150 St James's Gazette, 18 Nov. 1885, PP. 3–4.Google Scholar