Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Biological Effects–Based Tools for Monitoring Impacted Surface Waters in the Great Lakes: A Multiagency Program in Support of the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative

  • Drew R. Ekman (a1), Gerald T. Ankley (a2), Vicki S. Blazer (a3), Timothy W. Collette (a1), Natàlia Garcia-Reyero (a4), Luke R. Iwanowicz (a5), Zachary G. Jorgenson (a6), Kathy E. Lee (a7), Pat M. Mazik (a8), David H. Miller (a9), Edward J. Perkins (a10), Edwin T. Smith (a11), Joseph E. Tietge (a2) and Daniel L. Villeneuve (a2)...

Abstract

There is increasing demand for the implementation of effects-based monitoring and surveillance (EBMS) approaches in the Great Lakes Basin to complement traditional chemical monitoring. Herein, we describe an ongoing multiagency effort to develop and implement EBMS tools, particularly with regard to monitoring potentially toxic chemicals and assessing Areas of Concern (AOCs), as envisioned by the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative (GLRI). Our strategy includes use of both targeted and open-ended/discovery techniques, as appropriate to the amount of information available, to guide a priori end point and/or assay selection. Specifically, a combination of in vivo and in vitro tools is employed by using both wild and caged fish (in vivo), and a variety of receptor- and cell-based assays (in vitro). We employ a work flow that progressively emphasizes in vitro tools for long-term or high-intensity monitoring because of their greater practicality (e.g., lower cost, labor) and relying on in vivo assays for initial surveillance and verification. Our strategy takes advantage of the strengths of a diversity of tools, balancing the depth, breadth, and specificity of information they provide against their costs, transferability, and practicality. Finally, a series of illustrative scenarios is examined that align EBMS options with management goals to illustrate the adaptability and scaling of EBMS approaches and how they can be used in management decisions.

Environmental Practice 15:409–426 (2013)

Copyright

Corresponding author

Drew R. Ekman, Research Chemist, National Exposure Research Laboratory, USEPA, Athens, Georgia, 960 College Station Road, Athens, GA, 30605; (phone) 706-355-8250; (fax) 706-355-8302; (e-mail) ekman.drew@epa.gov

References

Hide All
Ankley, G.T., Bencic, D., Breen, M., Collette, T.W., Conolly, R., Denslow, N.D., Edwards, S., Ekman, D.R., Jensen, K.M., Lazorchak, J., Martinovic, D., Miller, D.H., Perkins, E.J., Orlanda, E.F., Garcia-Reyero, N., Villeneuve, D.L., Wang, R.-L., and Watanabe, K.. 2009. Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals in Fish: Developing Exposure Indicators and Predictive Models of Effects Based on Mechanism of Action. Aquatic Toxicology 92(3):168178.
Ankley, G.T., Bennet, R.S., Erickson, R.J., Hoff, D.J., Hornung, M.W., Johnson, R.D., Mount, D.R., Nichols, J.W., Russom, C.L., Schmieder, P.K., Serrano, J.A., Tietge, J.E., and Villeneuve, D.L.. 2010. Adverse Outcome Pathways: A Conceptual Framework to Support Ecotoxicology Research and Risk Assessment. Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry 29(3):730741.
Ankley, G.T., Daston, G.P., Degitz, S.J., Denslow, N.D., Hoke, R.A., Kennedy, S.A., Miracle, A.L., Perkins, E.J., Snape, J., Tillitt, D.E., Tyler, C.R., and Versteeg, D.. 2006. Toxicogenomics in Regulatory Ecotoxicology. Environmental Science & Technology 40(13):40554065.
Bahamonde, P.A., Munkittrick, K.R., and Martyniuk, C.J.. 2013. Intersex in Teleost Fish: Are We Distinguishing Endocrine Disruption from Natural Phenomena? General and Comparative Endocrinology 192:2535.
Basu, N., Ta, C.A., Waye, A., Mao, J., Hewitt, M., Arnason, J.T., and Trudeau, V.L.. 2009. Pulp and Paper Mill Effluents Contain Neuroactive Substances That Potentially Disrupt Neuroendocrine Control of Fish Reproduction. Environmental Science & Technology 43(5):16351641.
Blake, L.S., Martinovic, D., Gray, L.E. Jr., Wilson, V.S., Regal, R.R., Villeneuve, D.L., and Ankley, G.T.. 2010. Characterization of the Androgen-Responsive MDA-kb2 Cell Line for Assessing Complex Environmental Mixtures. Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry 29(6):13671376.
Blanchard, P., Audette, C.V., Hulting, M.L., Basu, I., Brice, K.A., Backus, S.M., Dryfhout-Clark, H., Froude, F., Hites, R.A., Neilson, M., and Wu, R.. 2008. Atmospheric Deposition of Toxic Substances to the Great Lakes: IADN Results through 2005. US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) Report EPA-905-R-08-001. USEPA, Washington, DC, 224 pp. Available at http://www.epa.gov/greatlakes/monitoring/air2/iadn/reports/IADN_Toxics_Deposition_Thru_2005.pdf.
Blazer, V.S., Fournie, J.W., Wolf, J.C., and Wolfe, M.J.. 2006. Diagnostic Criteria for Proliferative Hepatic Lesions in Brown Bullhead Ameiurus nebulosus. Diseases of Aquatic Orgamisms 72(1):1930.
Blazer, V.S., Iwanowicz, L.R., Henderson, H., Mazik, P.M., Jenkins, J.A., Alvarez, D.A., and Young, J.A.. 2012. Reproductive Endocrine Disruption in Smallmouth Bass (Micropterus dolomieu) in the Potomic River Basin: Spatial and Temporal Comparisons of Biological Effects. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 184(7):43094334.
Boobis, A.R., Cohen, S.M., Dellarco, V., McGregor, D., Meek, M.E., Vickers, C., Willcocks, D., and Farland, W.. 2006. IPCS [International Programme of Chemical Safety] Framework for Analyzing the Relevance of a Cancer Mode of Action for Humans. Critical Reviews in Toxicology 36(10):781792.
Boobis, A.R., Doe, J.E., Heinrich-Hirsch, B., Meek, M.E., Munn, S., Ruchirawat, M., Schlatter, J., Seed, J., and Vickers, C.. 2008. IPCS [International Programme of Chemical Safety] Framework for Analyzing the Relevance of a Noncancer Mode of Action for Humans. Critical Reviews in Toxicology 38(2):8796.
Bradbury, S.P., Feijtel, T.C., and Van Leeuwen, C.J.. 2004. Meeting the Scientific Needs of Ecological Risk Assessment in a Regulatory Context. Environmental Science & Technology 38(23):463A470A.
Chang, F., Pagano, J.J., Crimmins, B.S., Milligan, M.S., Xia, X., Hopke, P.K., and Holsen, T.M.. 2012. Temporal Trends of Polychlorinated Biphenyls and Organochlorine Pesticides in Great Lakes Fish: 1999–2009. Science of the Total Environment 439:284290.
Chapman, P.M., Dexter, R.N., and Long, E.R.. 1987. Synoptic Measures of Sediment Contamination, Toxicity, and Infaunal Community Structure (the Sediment Triad) in San Francisco Bay. Marine Ecology Progress Series 37:7596.
Coecke, S., Ahr, H., Blaauboer, B.J., Bremer, S., Casati, S., Castell, J., Combes, R., Corvi, R., Crespi, C.L., Cunningham, M.L., Elaut, G., Eletti, B., Freidig, A., Gennari, A., Ghersi-Egea, J.F., Guillouzo, A., Hartung, T., Hoet, P., Ingelman-Sundger, M., Munn, S., Janssens, W., Ladstetter, B., Leahy, D., Long, A., Meneguz, A., Monshouwer, M., Morath, S., Nagelkerke, F., Pelkonen, O., Ponti, J., Preito, P., Richert, L., Sabbioni, E., Schaak, B., Steiling, W., Testaj, E., Vericat, J.A., and Worth, A.. 2006. Metabolism: A Bottleneck in In Vitro Toxicological Test Development: The Report and Recommendations of ECVAM [European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods] Workshop 54. Alternatives to Laboratory Animals 34(1):4984.
Collette, T.W., Teng, Q., Jensen, K.M., Kahl, M.D., Makynen, E.A., Durhan, E.J., Villeneuve, D.L., Martinovic-Weigelt, D., Ankley, G.T., and Ekman, D.R.. 2010. Impacts of an Anti-androgen and an Androgen/Anti-androgen Mixture on the Metabolite Profile of Male Fathead Minnow Urine. Environmental Science & Technology 44(17):68816886.
Davis, J.M., Collette, T.W., Villeneuve, D.L., Cavallin, J.E., Teng, Q., Jensen, K.M., Kahl, M.D., Mayasich, J.M., Ankley, G.T., and Ekman, D.R.. 2013. A Field-Based Approach for Assessing the Impact of Pulp and Paper Mill Discharge on Endogenous Metabolites of Fathead Minnows (Pimephales promelas). Environmental Science & Technology 47(18):1062810636.
Ekman, D.R., Hartig, P.C., Cardon, M., Skelton, D.M., Teng, Q., Durhan, E.J., Jensen, K.M., Kahl, M.D., Villeneuve, D.L., Gray, L.E. Jr., Collette, T.W., and Ankley, G.T.. 2012. Metabolite Profiling and a Transcriptional Activation Assay Provide Direct Evidence of Androgen Receptor Antagonism by Bisphenol a in Fish. Environmental Science & Technology 46(17):96739680.
Ekman, D.R., Villeneuve, D.L., Teng, Q., Ralston-Hooper, K.J., Martinovic-Weigelt, D., Kahl, M.D., Jensen, K.M., Durhan, E.J., Makynen, E.A., Ankley, G.T., and Collette, T.W.. 2011. Use of Gene Expression, Biochemical and Metabolite Profiles to Enhance Exposure and Effects Assessment of the Model Androgen 17β-Trenbolone in Fish. Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry 30(2):319329.
Garcia-Reyero, N., and Perkins, E.J.. 2011. Systems Biology: Leading the Revolution in Ecotoxicology. Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry 30(2):265273.
Great Lakes Chemicals of Emerging Concern Advisory Work Group to the International Joint Commission (IJC). 2009, August. Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement Priorities 2007–09 Series: Work Group Report on Great Lakes Chemicals of Emerging Concern. IJC, Windsor, Canada, 15 pp. Available at http://www.ijc.org/files/publications/C220.pdf.
Great Lakes Restoration Initiative. 2010, February 21. Great Lakes Restoration Initiative Action Plan. FY2010–FY2014. 41 pp. Available at http://www.epa.gov/glnpo/glri/.
Harris, C.A., Hamilton, P.B., Runnalls, T.J., Vinciotti, V., Henshaw, A., Hodgson, D., Coe, T.S., Jobling, S., Tyler, C.R., and Sumpter, J.P.. 2011. The Consequences of Feminization in Breeding Groups of Wild Fish. Environmental Health Perspectives 119(3):306311.
Hill, B.A. 1965. The Environment and Disease: Association or Causation? Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 58(5):295300.
Hinck, J.E., Blazer, V.S., Schmitt, C.J., Papoulias, D.M., and Tillitt, D.E.. 2009. Widespread Occurrence of Intersex in Black Basses (Micropterus spp.) from U.S. Rivers, 1995–2004. Aquatic Toxicology 95(1):6070.
Johnson, W.E., O'Connor, T.P., Cantillo, A.Y., and Lauenstein, G.G.. 1999, December. Spatial Distribution of Chlorpyrifos and Endosulfan in USA Coastal Waters and the Great Lakes. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Technical Memorandum NOS NCCOS CCMA 140. US Department of Commerce, Silver Spring, MD, 23 pp. Available at http://aquaticcommons.org/2198/.
Kahl, M.D., Villeneuve, D.L., Stevens, K., Schroeder, A., Jensen, K.M., Holmen, B.A., Eid, E., Durhan, E.J., Cavallin, J.E., Berninger, J., and Ankley, G.T.. Submitted. An Inexpensive Temporally-Integrated System for Monitoring Occurrence and Biological Effects of Aquatic Contaminants in the Field.
Kavlock, R.J., Chandler, K., Houch, K.A., Hunter, S., Judson, R., Kleinstreuer, N., Knudsen, T., Martin, M.T., Padilla, S., Reif, D., Richard, A.M., Rotroff, D., Sipes, N., and Dix, D.J.. 2012. Update on EPA's ToxCast Program: Providing High Throughput Decision Support Tools for Chemical Risk Management. Chemical Research in Toxicology 25(7):12871302.
Klecka, G., Persoon, C., and Currie, R.. 2010. Chemicals of Emerging Concern in the Great Lakes Basin: An Analysis of Environmental Exposures. Reviews of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 207:193.
Knudsen, T.B., Houch, K.A., Sipes, N., Singh, A.V., Judons, R., Martin, M.T., Weissman, A., Kleinstreuer, N., Mortensen, H.M., Reif, D., Rabinowitz, J.R., Setzer, R.W., Richard, A.M., Dix, D.J., and Kavlock, R.J.. 2011. Activity Profiles of 309 ToxCast Chemicals Evaluated across 292 Biochemical Targets. Toxicology 282(1-2):115.
Krewski, D., Acosta, D.J. Jr., Andersen, M., Anderson, H., Bailar, J.C. 3rd, Boekelheide, K., Brent, R., Charnley, G., Cheung, B.G., Green, S.J., Kelsey, K.T., Kerkyliet, N.I., Li, A.A., McCray, L., Meyer, O., Patterson, R.D., Pennie, W., Scala, R.A., Solomon, G.M., Stephens, M., Yager, J., and Zeise, L.. 2010. Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: A Vision and a Strategy. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, Part B: Critical Reviews 13(2-4):51138.
Lee, K.E., Langer, S.K., Menheer, M.A., Foreman, W.T., Furlong, E.T., and Smith, S.G.. 2012. Chemicals of Emerging Concern in Water and Bottom Sediment in Great Lakes Areas of Concern, 2010 to 2011—Collection Methods, Analyses Methods, Quality Assurance, and Data. US Geological Survey (USGS) Data Series 723. USGS, Washington, DC, 26 pp. Available at http://pubs.usgs.gov/ds/723/.
Li, A.A., Rockne, K.J., Sturchio, N., Song, W., Ford, J.C., and Wei, H.. 2009. PCBs in Sediments of the Great Lakes—Distribution and Trends, Homolog and Chlorine Patterns, and In Situ Degradation. Environmental Pollution 157(1):141147.
National Research Council. 2007. Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: A Vision and a Strategy. National Academies Press, Washington, DC, 196 pp.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). 2013. Testing of Chemicals: Adverse Outcome Pathways, Molecular Screening and Toxicogenomics. OECD, Paris. http://www.oecd.org/env/ehs/testing/adverse-outcome-pathways-molecular-screening-and-toxicogenomics.htm.
Perkins, E.J., Ankley, G.T., Crofton, K.M., Garcia-Reyero, N., LaLone, C.A., Johnson, M.S., Tietge, J.E., and Villeneuve, D.L.. 2013. Current Perspectives on the Use of Alternative Species in Human Health and Ecological Hazard Assessments. Environmental Health Perspectives 121(9):10021010.
Schrank, C.S., Cormier, S.M., and Blazer, V.S.. 1997. Contaminant Exposure, Biochemical, and Histological Biomarkers in White Suckers from Contaminated and Reference Sites in the Sheboygan River, Wisconsin. Journal of Great Lakes Research 23(2):119130.
Stavreva, D.A., George, A.A., Klausmeyer, P., Varticovski, L., Sack, D., Voss, T.C., Schiltz, R.L., Blazer, V.S., Iwanowicz, L.R., and Hager, G.L.. 2012. Prevalent Glucocorticoid and Androgen Activity in US Water Sources. Scientific Reports 2:937 (8 pp). Available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3515810/.
Teng, Q., Ekman, D.R., Huang, W., and Collette, T.W.. 2013. Impacts of 17α-Ethynylestradiol Exposure on Metabolite Profiles of Zebrafish (Danio rerio) Liver Cells. Aquatic Toxicology 130131:184191.
Tyler, C.R., van der Eerden, B., Jobling, S., Panter, G., and Sumpter, J.P.. 1996. Measurement of Vitellogenin, a Biomarker for Exposure to Oestrogenic Chemicals in a Wide Variety of Cyprinid Fish. Journal of Comparative Physiology B 166(7):418426.
US and Canada International Joint Commission (IJC). 1978, November 22. Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement of 1978. 30 United States Treaty (UST) 1383, Treaties and Other International Acts Series (TIAS) No. 9257. IJC, Washington, DC, and Ottawa. Available at http://www.epa.gov/glnpo/glwqa/.
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 2011. ORD [Office of Research and Development] Framework on Adverse Outcome Pathways to Be Used by OECD to Improve Chemical Safety Assessments. USEPA, Washington, DC. Available at http://www.epa.gov/nheerl/articles/2011/Chemical_Safety_Assessments.html.
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 2013a. Great Lakes Areas of Concern. USEPA, Washington, DC. http://www.epa.gov/grtlakes/aoc/.
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 2013b. Great Lakes Areas of Concern [Map]. USEPA, Washington, DC, 1 p.http://www.epa.gov/glnpo/aoc/images/aoc-glbasin-map-20130215.pdf.
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 2013c. ToxCastDB Data Collection List. USEPA, Washington DC. http://actor.epa.gov/actor/faces/ToxCastDB/DataCollectionList.jsp.
Villeneuve, D.L., and Garcia-Reyero, N.. 2011. Predictive Ecotoxicology in the 21st Century. Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry 30(1):18.
Wehmas, L.C., Cavallin, J.E., Durhan, E.J., Kahl, M.D., Martinovic-Weigelt, M., Mayasich, J., Tuominen, T., Villeneuve, D.L., and Ankley, G.T.. 2011. Screening Complex Effluents for Estrogenic Activity with the T47d-Kbluc Cell Bioassay: Assay Optimization and Comparison to In Vivo Responses in Fish. Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry 30(2):439445.
Weller, M.G. 2012. A Unifying Review of Bioassay-Guided Fractionation, Effect-Directed Analysis and Related Techniques. Sensors 12(7):91819209.
Wheeler, J.R., Gimeno, S., Crane, M., Lopez-Juez, E., and Morritt, D.. 2005. Vitellogenin: A Review of Analytical Methods to Detect (Anti) Estrogenic Activity in Fish. Toxicology Mechanisms and Methods 15(4):293306.
Wilson, V.S., Bobseine, K., and Gray, L.E. Jr. 2004. Development and Characterization of a Cell Line that Stably Expresses an Estrogen Responsive Luciferase Reporter for the Detection of Estrogen Receptor Agonists and Antagonists. Toxicological Sciences 81(1):6977.
Wilson, V.S., Bobseine, K., Lambright, C., and Jr, L.E. Gray. 2002. A Novel Cell Line, MDA-kb2, That Stably Expresses an Androgen- and Glucocorticoid-Responsive Reporter for the Detection of Hormone Receptor Agonists and Antagonists. Toxicological Sciences 66(1):6981.

Biological Effects–Based Tools for Monitoring Impacted Surface Waters in the Great Lakes: A Multiagency Program in Support of the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative

  • Drew R. Ekman (a1), Gerald T. Ankley (a2), Vicki S. Blazer (a3), Timothy W. Collette (a1), Natàlia Garcia-Reyero (a4), Luke R. Iwanowicz (a5), Zachary G. Jorgenson (a6), Kathy E. Lee (a7), Pat M. Mazik (a8), David H. Miller (a9), Edward J. Perkins (a10), Edwin T. Smith (a11), Joseph E. Tietge (a2) and Daniel L. Villeneuve (a2)...

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed