Skip to main content Accessibility help

Wildlife trade and consumer preference for species rarity: an examination of caged-bird markets in Sumatra

  • Vijesh V. Krishna (a1), Kevin Darras (a2), Ingo Grass (a2), Yeni A. Mulyani (a3), Dewi M. Prawiradilaga (a4), Teja Tscharntke (a2) and Matin Qaim (a5)...


This study examines conservation effects of wildlife trade using demand and supply data from caged-bird markets in Sumatra, Indonesia. When consumers have a strong preference for species rarity, trade could result in wildlife overexploitation and species extinction. Results from a choice experiment show that buyers of caged birds indeed value species rarity. However, not all rare species are equally preferred. Species that are frequently traded lose their rarity value, even if rare in the wild. Analysis of time-series data collected from traders over a period of 20 months between 2013 and 2015 reveals an inelastic supply function for rare species, with market arrivals being insensitive to price changes. This may be due to a declining stock of rare species in the wild. Bird trade together with habitat loss can lead to extinction of a number of rare species in Indonesia. Several policy approaches on regulating caged-bird markets are discussed.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the or variations. ‘’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Wildlife trade and consumer preference for species rarity: an examination of caged-bird markets in Sumatra
      Available formats

      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Wildlife trade and consumer preference for species rarity: an examination of caged-bird markets in Sumatra
      Available formats

      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Wildlife trade and consumer preference for species rarity: an examination of caged-bird markets in Sumatra
      Available formats


This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (, which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. Email:


Hide All
Angulo, E and Courchamp, F (2009) Rare species are valued big time. PLoS ONE 4, e5215.
Angulo, E, Deves, A-L, Saint Jalmes, M and Courchamp, F (2009) Fatal attraction: rare species in the spotlight. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 276, 13311337.
Arellano, M and Bond, S (1991) Some tests of specification for panel data: Monte Carlo evidence and an application to employment equations. The Review of Economic Studies 58, 277297.
Becker, N, Choresh, Y, Bahat, O and Inbar, M (2009) Economic analysis of feeding stations as a means to preserve an endangered species: the case of Griffon Vulture (Gyps fulvus) in Israel. Journal for Nature Conservation 17, 199211.
Belbachir, F, Pettorelli, N, Wacher, T, Belbachir-Bazi, A, Durant, SM and Hofreiter, M (2015) Monitoring rarity: the critically endangered Saharan Cheetah as a flagship species for a threatened ecosystem. PLoS ONE 10, e0115136.
Berec, L, Angulo, E and Courchamp, F (2007) Multiple Allee effects and population management. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 22, 185191.
Brook, BW and Sodhi, NS (2006) Conservation biology: rarity bites. Nature 444, 555556.
Burivalova, Z, Lee, TM, Hua, F, Lee, JSH, Prawiradilaga, DM and Wilcove, DS (2017) Understanding consumer preferences and demography in order to reduce the domestic trade in wild-caught birds. Biological Conservation 209, 423431.
Capitanio, F, Gatto, E and Millemaci, E (2016) CAP payments and spatial diversity in cereal crops: an analysis of Italian farms. Land Use Policy 54, 574582.
Carlsson, F and Martinsson, P (2003) Design techniques for stated preference methods in health economics. Health Economics 12, 281294.
Chen, F (2016) Poachers and snobs: demand for rarity and the effects of antipoaching policies. Conservation Letters 9, 6569.
Chng, SCL, Eaton, JA, Krishnasamy, K, Shepherd, CR and Nijman, V (2015) In the Market for Extinction: an Inventory of Jakarta's Bird Markets. Petaling Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia: TRAFFIC Southeast Asia.
Cisneros-Montemayor, AM and Vincent, ACJ (2016) Science, society, and flagship species: social and political history as keys to conservation outcomes in the Gulf of California. Ecology and Society 21, 9.
Clavero, M (2016) Species substitutions driven by anthropogenic positive feedbacks: Spanish crayfish species as a case study. Biological Conservation 193, 8085.
Clough, Y, Krishna, VV, Corre, MD, Darras, K, Denmead, LH, Meijide, A, Moser, S, Musshoff, O, Steinebach, S, Veldkamp, E, Allen, K, Barnes, AD, Breidenbach, N, Brose, U, Buchori, D, Daniel, R, Finkeldey, R, Harahap, I, Hertel, D, Holtkamp, AM, Hörandl, E, Irawan, B, Jaya, INS, Jochum, M, Klarner, B, Knohl, A, Kotowska, MM, Krashevska, V, Kreft, H, Kurniawan, S, Leuschner, C, Maraun, M, Melati, DN, Opfermann, N, Pérez-Cruzado, C, Prabowo, WE, Rembold, K, Rizali, A, Rubiana, R, Schneider, D, Tjitrosoedirdjo, SS, Tjoa, A, Tscharntke, T and Scheu, S (2016) Land-use choices follow profitability at the expense of ecological functions in Indonesian smallholder landscapes. Nature Communications 7, article number: 131137.
Coltman, DW, O'Donoghue, P, Jorgenson, JT, Hogg, JT, Strobeck, C and Festa-Bianchet, M (2003) Undesirable evolutionary consequences of trophy hunting. Nature 426, 655658.
Courchamp, F, Angulo, E, Rivalan, P, Hall, RJ, Signoret, L, Bull, L and Meinard, Y (2006) Rarity value and species extinction: the anthropogenic Allee effect. PLoS Biology 4, e415.
Courchamp, F, Berec, L and Gascoigne, J (2008) Allee Effects in Ecology and Conservation. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.
Dalerum, F, Miranda, M, Muñiz, C and Rodríguez, P (2018) Effects of scarcity, aesthetics and ecology on wildlife auction prices of large African mammals. Ambio 47, 7885.
Gault, A, Meinard, Y and Courchamp, F (2008) Consumers' taste for rarity drives sturgeons to extinction. Conservation Letters 1, 199207.
Gordon, SH (1991) The economic theory of a common-property resource: the fishery. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 53, 231252.
Greiner, R (2016) Factors influencing farmers' participation in contractual biodiversity conservation: a choice experiment with northern Australian pastoralists. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 60, 121.
Guttery, MR, Messmer, TA, Brunson, MW, Robinson, JD and Dahlgren, DK (2016) Declining populations of greater sage-grouse: hunter motivations when numbers are low. Animal Conservation 19, 2634.
Hall, RJ, Milner-Gulland, EJ and Courchamp, F (2008) Endangering the endangered: the effects of perceived rarity on species exploitation. Conservation Letters 1, 7581.
Hanley, N, Sheremet, O, Bozzola, M and MacMillan, DC (2018) The allure of the illegal: choice modeling of rhino horn demand in Vietnam. Conservation Letters 11, 18.
Harris, RB, Cooney, R and Leader-Williams, N (2013) Application of the anthropogenic Allee effect model to trophy hunting as a conservation tool. Conservation Biology 27, 945951.
Harris, JBC, Green, JMH, Prawiradilaga, DM, Giam, X, Giyanto, , Hikmatullah, D, Putra, CA and Wilcove, DS (2015) Using market data and expert opinion to identify overexploited species in the wild bird trade. Biological Conservation 187, 5160.
Harris, JBC, Tingley, MW, Hua, F, Yong, DL, Adeney, JM, Lee, TM, Marthy, W, Prawiradilaga, DM, Sekercioglu, CH, Suyadi, , Winarni, N and Wilcove, DS (2016) Measuring the impact of the pet trade on Indonesian birds. Conservation Biology 31, 394405.
Hensher, DA and Greene, WH (2003) The mixed logit model: the state of practice. Transportation 30, 133176.
Hsiang, S and Sekar, N (2016) Does Legalization Reduce Black Market Activity? Evidence From A Global Ivory Experiment and Elephant Poaching Data: NBER Working Paper Series 22314. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
Jepson, P and Ladle, RJ (2005) Bird-keeping in Indonesia: conservation impacts and the potential for substitution-based conservation responses. Oryx 39, 442448.
Johnston, RJ, Jarvis, D, Wallmo, K and Lew, DK (2015) Multiscale spatial pattern in nonuse willingness to pay: applications to threatened and endangered marine species. Land Economics 91, 739761.
Kontoleon, A and Swanson, T (2003) The willingness to pay for property rights for the giant panda: can a charismatic species be an instrument for nature conservation? Land Economics 79, 483499.
Kremer, M and Morcom, C (2000) Elephants. The American Economic Review 90, 212234.
Krishna, VV, Kubitza, C, Pascual, U and Qaim, M (2017) Land markets, property rights, and deforestation: insights from Indonesia. World Development 99, 335349.
Kubitza, C, Krishna, VV, Urban, K, Alamsyah, Z and Qaim, M (2018) Land property rights, agricultural intensification, and deforestation in Indonesia. Ecological Economics 147, 312321.
Lee, RJ, Gorog, AJ, Dwiyahreni, A, Siwu, S, Riley, J, Alexander, H, Paoli, GD and Ramono, W (2005) Wildlife trade and implications for law enforcement in Indonesia: a case study from North Sulawesi. Biological Conservation 123, 477488.
Lew, DK and Wallmo, K (2011) External tests of scope and embedding in stated preference choice experiments: an application to endangered species valuation. Environmental and Resource Economics 48, 123.
Lew, DK and Wallmo, K (2017) Temporal stability of stated preferences for endangered species protection from choice experiments. Ecological Economics 131, 8797.
Lyons, JA and Natusch, DJD (2013) Effects of consumer preferences for rarity on the harvest of wild populations within a species. Ecological Economics 93, 278283.
Moorhouse, TP, Balaskas, M, D'Cruze, NC and Macdonald, DW (2017) Information could reduce consumer demand for exotic pets. Conservation Letters 10, 337345.
Njikam, O (2016) Trade liberalization, labor market regulations and labor demand in Cameroon. International Review of Economics & Finance 43, 525541.
Ostrom, E, Burger, J, Field, CB, Norgaard, RB and Policansky, D (1999) Revisiting the commons: local lessons, global challenges. Science 284, 278282.
Pacifico, D (2012) Fitting nonparametric mixed logit models via expectation-maximization algorithm. Stata Journal 12, 284298.
Palazy, L, Bonenfant, C, Gaillard, JM and Courchamp, F (2012) Rarity, trophy hunting and ungulates. Animal Conservation 15, 411.
Pallante, G, Drucker, AG and Sthapit, S (2016) Assessing the potential for niche market development to contribute to farmers' livelihoods and agrobiodiversity conservation: insights from the finger millet case study in Nepal. Ecological Economics 130, 92105.
Robinson, JM (2001) The dynamics of avicultural markets. Environmental Conservation 28, 7684.
Shepherd, CR, Sukumaran, J and Wich, SA (2004) Open Season: an Analysis of the Pet Trade in Medan, Sumatra 1997–2001. Selangor, Malaysia: TRAFFIC Southeast Asia.
Slone, TH, Orsak, LJ and Malver, O (1997) A comparison of price, rarity and cost of butterfly specimens: implications for the insect trade and for habitat conservation. Ecological Economics 21, 7785.
Su, S, Cassey, P, Vall-Llosera, M and Blackburn, TM (2015) Going cheap: determinants of bird price in the Taiwanese pet market. PLoS ONE 10, e0127482.
Sun, C-HJ, Chiang, F-S, Guillotreau, P, Squires, D, Webster, DG and Owens, M (2017) Fewer fish for higher profits? Price response and economic incentives in global tuna fisheries management. Environmental and Resource Economics 66, 749764.
Symes, WS, Edwards, DP, Miettinen, J, Rheindt, FE and Carrasco, LR (2018) Combined impacts of deforestation and wildlife trade on tropical biodiversity are severely underestimated. Nature Communications 9, 4052.
Tournant, P, Joseph, L, Goka, K and Courchamp, F (2012) The rarity and overexploitation paradox: stag beetle collections in Japan. Biodiversity and Conservation 21, 14251440.
Train, KA (2009) Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation, 2nd Edn. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Veblen, T (1899) The Theory of the Leisure Class: an Economic Study of Institutions. New York: MacMillan.
Vogdrup-Schmidt, M, Abatayo, AL, Shogren, JF, Strange, N and Thorsen, BJ (2019) Factors affecting support for transnational conservation targeting migratory species. Ecological Economics 157, 156164.
Wilson-Wilde, L (2010) Wildlife crime: a global problem. Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology 6, 221222.
Wittemyer, G, Northrup, JM, Blanc, J, Douglas-Hamilton, I, Omondi, P and Burnham, KP (2014) Illegal killing for ivory drives global decline in African elephants. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 111, 1311713121.


Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Krishna et al. supplementary material
Krishna et al. supplementary material 1

 PDF (5.0 MB)
5.0 MB

Wildlife trade and consumer preference for species rarity: an examination of caged-bird markets in Sumatra

  • Vijesh V. Krishna (a1), Kevin Darras (a2), Ingo Grass (a2), Yeni A. Mulyani (a3), Dewi M. Prawiradilaga (a4), Teja Tscharntke (a2) and Matin Qaim (a5)...


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.