Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-2xdlg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-05T18:25:04.208Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Charity Properly Understood”: Changing Ideas about Poor Relief in Liberal Spain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2009

Anrian Shubert
Anrian Shubert
Affiliation:
York University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

When the English cleric Joseph Townsend visited Spain at the end of the eighteenth century, he was impressed by the apparent tolerance with which beggars were treated and by what he called the “excessively generous” way in which charity was distributed. He cited, with both surprise and disapproval, the Bishop of Cordoba, who daily fed some 7,000 people by distributing 1,000 kilograms of bread.1 This image of Spain as a paradise for the poor persisted until well into the nineteenth century. George Borrow, who travelled through the country in the 1830s trying to sell Bibles without much luck, remarked approvingly that poverty was not despised in Spain as it was in other countries:

Yet to the honour of Spain be it spoken, it is one of the few countries in Europe where poverty is never insulted nor looked upon with contempt.…In Spain the very beggar does not feel himself a degraded being for he kisses no one's feet and knows not what it is to be cuffed or spitten upon.

Type
Belief Systems and Political Behavior
Information
Comparative Studies in Society and History , Volume 33 , Issue 1 , January 1991 , pp. 36 - 55
Copyright
Copyright © Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Townsend, J., A Journey Through Spain (London: Dilly 1797), II, 8–9.Google Scholar

2 Borrow, G., The Bible in Spain (London: Nelson, 1893), 117.Google Scholar

3 Real Sociedad Económica de los Amigos del País, FC–25, Archivo del Padre Patác (Gijón).

4 Ibid.

5 Cortázar, G., Alfonso XIII, Hombre de Negocios (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1986), 222–3.Google Scholar

6 B. Bennassar, (Barcelona: Argos, 1986), 132–3.

7 For some points of comparison with the themes mentioned below, see Prochaska, F., Women and Philanthropy in Nineteenth Century England (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980);Google ScholarRyan, M., Cradle of the Middle Class (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981);Google ScholarHewitt, N., Women's Activism and Social Change (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1984);Google Scholar and Owen, D., English Philanthropy, 1660–1960 (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 1964).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8 Woolf, S.J., The Poor in Western Europe in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries (London: Methuen, 1986), 17, 28.Google Scholar On the seventeenth century in Spain, see Martz, L., Poverty and Welfare in Habsburg Spain (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

9 Carr, R., Spain, 1808–1975 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982), 62.Google Scholar

10 Callahan, W.J., “The Problem of Confinement: An Aspect of Poor Relief in Eighteenth Century Spain,” Hispanic American Historical Review, 51:1 (02 1971), 6–7.Google Scholar

11 Soubeyroux, J., “El encuentro del pobre y la sociedad: asistencia y represión en el Madrid del Siglo XVIII,” Estudios de Historia Social, 21:2 (1982), 147–58;Google Scholar Callahan, “Problem of Confinement,” 11–12.

12 Soto, P. Carasa, Pauperismo y Revolutión Burguesa: Burgos, 1750–1900 (Valladolid: Universidad de Vallaaolid, 1987), 406–13.Google Scholar

13 Ibid. 427–8.

14 Ibid., 418–9.

15 Bahamonde, A. and Toro Mérida, J., Burguesía, especulación y cuestión social en el Madrid del Sigh XIX (Madrid: Siglo XXI, 1976), 48.Google Scholar

16 Mendigos, Propositión del Sr. Crespo y Velez para extinguirlos, Archivo del Congreso de los Diputados (Madrid).

17 Real Sociedad Económica de los Amigos del País, FC–25, Archivo del Padre Patac (Gijón).

18 Balbín de Unquera, A., histórica y teórica de la beneficencia (Madrid, 1862), 128.Google Scholar

19 Matritense de los Amigos del País, Sociedad, Memorias sobre la extinción de la mendicidad (Madrid, 1850), 128–9.Google Scholar

20 Arenal, C., El Pauperismo (Madrid: Victoriano Suàrez, 1897),Google Scholar I:90, II:299–302; Arenal, , El Visitador del Pobre (Madrid, 1863), 131.Google Scholar

21 Arenal, , La Beneficencia, la filantropía y la caridad (Madrid, 1861), 163.Google Scholar

22 Mesonero Romanos, R., Escenas Matritenses (Madrid),Google Scholar II:205–6.

23 Canal y Migolla, E., Trabajos municipales (Sevilla, n.d.), ix.Google Scholar

24 y Migolla, Canal, La mendicidad en Sevilla (Sevilla, 1900), 9–10.Google Scholar

25 Sales Ferré, M., Problemas sociales (Madrid, 1910), 228.Google Scholar

26 Canal y Migolla, Trabajos, 95–6, 98.

27 Memoria de la Real Asociación de Beneficencia Domicilaria (Madrid, 1864), 7;Google Scholaribid., (Madrid, 1845), 5.

28 Reglamento de la Asociación de Beneficencia–Cocina Económica de Oviedo (Oviedo, 1900), 3.Google Scholar

29 Llanos Torriglia, F., Ineficacia e incovenientes de la limosna callegjera (Madrid, 1911), 6–8, 17–8,Google Scholar 26.

30 de la Campa, H., La caridady la limosna pública (Oviedo, 1909), 12–4,Google Scholar 26, 31, 47.

31 de Campoamor, R.. Polémicas co1n la democracia (Madrid, 1873), 20, 91.Google Scholar

32 Carabias, Proyecto, 5–6.

33 Arenal, El Visitador, 92–3.

34 Ibid., 116–9, 205–6.

35 Ibid., 116–9; Arenal, Pauperismo, I, 283–8, 306–19. She felt that reading was a useful leisure activity, especially books about history and natural disasters which taught two useful lessons: “That man is nothing and God everything” (Visitador, 163).

36 Corbín Ferrer, M., La Beneficencia en Valencia en el Siglo XIX (Valencia: Ayuntamiento de Valencia, 1980), 87.Google Scholar

37 Sevillana de Caridad, Asociación, Memoria sobre los trabajos realizados en el 1900 (Seville, 1901), 16;Google ScholarMemoria de la Real Asociación (Madrid, 1864), 7.Google Scholar

38 de la Sagra, R., Voyage en Hollande el en Belgique (Paris, 1839), I, 170;Google ScholarArenal, , Cartas a un (Madrid: Victoriano Suarez, 1880), 72.Google Scholar

39 Manifiesto de la Junta de Caridad de Barcelona (Barcelona: Victoriano Suarez, 1842), 16.Google Scholar

40 Berástegui y Montes, S., Historia y situatión actual de la Beneficencia en San Sebastián (San Sebastian, 1894), 201Google Scholar (emphasis is added).

41 Reglamento provisional del Asilo de Mendicidad de San Bernardino (Madrid, 1836).Google Scholar

42 Sociedad Matritense, Memorias, 50, 85, 125, 139; Canal and Migolla, La mendicidad en Sevilla, 10–11; Carabias, N.et al, Proyecto de un Reglamento General para la Beneficencia municipal (Madrid, 1870).Google Scholar

43 Ibid., 49–50.

44 Sociedad Matritense, Memorias, 128; Sales Ferre, Problemas, 25; Arenal, La Beneficencia, 173–4; Elorza, A. and Iglesias, M.C., Burgueses y proletarios (Barcelona, 1973), 187;Google ScholarGarcía Molinas, F., La Mendicidad en Madrid (Madrid, 1916), 19–21.Google Scholar

45 Balbín de Unquera, 210–11, 213.

46 Arenal, La Beneficencia, 81–91, 136–8.

47 Abella, F., Tratado de sanidad y beneficencia (Madrid, 1885), 721.Google Scholar

48 Ibid., 718–20.

49 de Olózaga, S., De la beneficencia en Inglaterra y España (Madrid, 1864), 21, 38–40.Google Scholar

50 Balbín de Unquera, Reseña, 92, 232.

51 Arenal, La Beneficencia, 172.

52 de Caridad de Oviedo, Asociación, Reglamento (Oviedo, 1904).Google Scholar

53 Woolf, The Poor, 35.

54 Ibid., 36.

55 E. M. Nenclares, Legislatión espanola de Beneficencia (Madrid, 1869), 150–60.

56 Diario de las Sesiones de Cortes. Senado (June 28, 1838), 146.

57 Gaceta de Madrid, June 24, 1849.

58 Ibid., June 16, 1873.

59 Abella, Tratado, 722–36.

60 de Gobernación, Ministerio, Nuevos apuntes para el estudio y la organizatión en España de las Instituciones de Beneficencia (Madrid, 1918).Google Scholar

61 Balbín de Unquera, Reseña, 226–7; Sociedad Matritense, Memorias, 99–100, 107–8.

62 Elorza and Iglesias, Burgueses, 190.

63 Arenal, La Benefwencia, 213–23.

64 Romanos, Mesonero, Manual de Madrid (Madrid, 1967), 69.Google Scholar

65 Olózaga, De la beneficencia, 40.

66 Gobernación, Beneficencia, Cartagena, 31.001–3007, Archivo General de la Administratión, Alcalá de Henares.

67 Gobernación, Beneficencia, Murcia, 31.001–3009, AGA.

68 Romanos, Mesonero, Nuevo Manual de Madrid (Madrid, 1967), 436;Google ScholarMemoria de la Real Asociacion (Madrid, 1864).Google Scholar

69 Bahamonde, A. and Toro, J., “Mendicidad y paro en el Madrid de la Restauración,” Estudios de Historia Social, 7 (1978), 364–5.Google Scholar

70 Smith, B., Ladies of the Leisure Class (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1984).Google Scholar

71 Ibid., 145.

72 Ibid., 159.

73 Ibid., 214.

74 Sociedad Matritense, Memorias, 15, 77.

75 Arenal, Visitador, 141.

76 Corbín Ferrer, La Beneficencia, 16, 31–2.

77 Gobemación, Beneficencia, Murcia, 31.001–3009, AGA.

78 Olózaga, De la beneficencia, 14–15, 47–50.

79 Arenal, Pauperismo, I:398–400, II:40.

80 Arenal, Cartas, 9–10, 13, 27–8, 439–40.

81 Carasa Soto, Pauperismo y Revolutión, 639.