Skip to main content Accessibility help

Propositionalism about intention: shifting the burden of proof

  • Lucy Campbell (a1)


A widespread view in the philosophy of mind and action holds that intentions are propositional attitudes. Call this view ‘Propositionalism about Intention’. The key alternative holds that intentions have acts, or do-ables, as their contents. Propositionalism is typically accepted by default, rather than argued for in any detail. By appealing to a key metaphysical constraint on any account of intention, I argue that on the contrary, it is the Do-ables View which deserves the status of the default position, and Propositionalism which bears the burden of proof. I go on to show that this burden has not been met in the literature.


Corresponding author

CONTACT Lucy Campbell Faculty of Philosophy, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK


Hide All
Alvarez, M., 2010. Kinds of Reasons: An Essay in the Philosophy of Action. Oxford University Press.
Anscombe, G. E. M., 1957. Intention. Harvard: Harvard University Press.
Anscombe, G. E. M., 1989. Von Wright on Practical Inference. In The Philosophy of Georg Henrik Von Wright, edited by Schilpp, P. A.. The Library of Living Philosophers. La Salle Ill: Open Court.
Aydede, M., 2010. “The Language of Thought Hypothesis.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Baier, A. C., 1970. “Act and Intent.” Journal of Philosophy, 67 (19): 648658.
Broome, J., 2001a. “Are Intentions Reasons? and How Should We Cope with Incommensurate Values?” In Practical Rationality and Preference: Essays for David Gauthier, edited by Morris, C. and Ripstein, A., 98120. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Broome, J., 2001b. “Normative Practical Reasoning.” Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume, 75 (1): 175193.
Broome, J., 2002. “Practical Reasoning.” In Reason and Nature: Essays in the Theory of Rationality, edited by Bermudez, J. L. and Millar, A., 85111. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Castañeda, H.-N., 1972. “Intentions and Intending.” American Philosophical Quarterly, 9 (2): 139149.
Chierchia, G., 1989. “Anaphora and Attitudes De Se.” In Semantics and Contextual Expression, edited by Renate Bartsch, J. F. A., Van Bentham, K., and Van Emde Boas, P., 131, Foris Publications.
Clark, P., 2001. “The Action as Conclusion.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 31 (4): 481505.
Coliva, A., 2016. “The Varieties of Self-Knowledge.” In Palgrave Innovations in Philosophy. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Dancy, J., 2009. “Action, Content, and Inference.” In Wittgenstein and Analytic Philosophy: Essays for PMS Hacker, edited by Hacker, P. M. S. and Hyman, J., 278298. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Davidson, D., 2001. “Mental Events.” In Essays on Actions and Events. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Davis, W., 1984. “A Causal Theory of Intending.” American Philosophical Quarterly, 21 (1): 4354.
Ferrero, L., 2013. “Can I Only Intend My Own Actions?” In Oxford Studies in Agency and Responsibility, 7094. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fodor, J., 1978. “Propositional Attitudes.” The Monist, 61 (4): 501523.
Grice, P., 1971. “Intention and Uncertainty.” Proceedings of the British Academy, 57: 263279.
Hornsby, J., 2016. “Intending, Knowing How, Infinitives.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 46 (1): 117.
Hornsby, J., 2017. “Knowledge How in the Philosophy of Action.” Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement, 80: 87104.
Kroeger, P. R., 2005. Analysing Grammar: An Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lavin, D., 2013. “Must There Be Basic Action?Noûs, 47 (2): 273301.
Lewis, D., 1973. Counterfactuals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Madden, R., 2011. “Intention and the Self.” Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, CXI (3): 325351.
Matthews, P. H., 2014. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Linguistics. 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
McDowell, J., 2010. “What Is the Content of an Intention in Action?Ratio, 23 (4): 415432.
Mueller, A., 1977. “Radical Subjectivity: Morality Versus Utilitarianism.” Ratio, 19 (2): 115132.
Price, A. W., 2016. “Choice and Action in Aristotle.” Phroenesis, 61: 435462.
Radford, C., 1988. “Transformational Grammar: A First Course.” In Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rumfitt, I., 1994. “Frege’s Theory of Predication: An Elaboration and Defense, with Some New Applications.” The Philosophical Review, 103 (4): 599637.
Schroeder, M., 2012. “The Ubiquity of State-Given Reasons.” Ethics, 122 (3): 457488.
Searle, J. R., 1979. “The Intentionality of Intention and Action.” Inquiry, 22 (1–4): 253280.
Searle, J. R., 1983. Intentionality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Shah, N., and Silverstein, M.. 2013. “Reasoning in Stages.” Ethics, 124 (1): 101113.
Stanley, J., 2011. Know How. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Thompson, M., 2008. Life and Action: Elementary Structures of Practice and Practical Thought. Harvard University Press.
Velleman, D., 1989. Practical Reflection. Princeton University Press.
Vermazen, B., 1993. “Objects of Intention.” Philosophical Studies, 71 (3): 223265.
Williamson, T., 2017. “Acting on Knowledge.” In Knowledge-First: Approaches in Epistemology and Mind, edited by Adam Carter, J., Gordon, E. C., and Jarvis, B., 163181. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Propositionalism about intention: shifting the burden of proof

  • Lucy Campbell (a1)


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.