Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-wbk2r Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-08T05:29:34.997Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

An overview of Byzantine Period settlements around Comana Pontica in north-central Turkey

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2016

Burcu Erciyas  and
Emine Sökmen
Burcu Erciyas
Affiliation:
Middle East Technical University, Turkey
Emine Sökmen
Affiliation:
Middle East Technical University, Turkey
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The sanctuary of Comana Pontica in north-central Anatolia, dedicated to a local Anatolian deity, Ma, was a significant part of the Hellenistic kingdom of the Mithradatids which continued to be of some importance under the Roman emperors. During the Byzantine period, as a result of the introduction of, and adaptation to, Christianity in the region, significant changes in settlement pattern/organization at and in the vicinity of Comana took place. This article illustrates these changes through the architectural and archaeological material discovered during surveys and offers a preliminary interpretation of the settlement patterns around Comana in the Byzantine period.

Type
Articles
Information
Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies , Volume 34 , Issue 2 , 2010 , pp. 119 - 141
Copyright
Copyright © The Centre for Byzantine, Ottoman and Modern Greek Studies, University of Birmingham 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For discussions of temple states: Rostovtzeff, M., The Social and Economic History of the Hellenistic World (Oxford 1941) 280, 505-506Google Scholar; Magie, D., Roman Rule in Asia Minor to the End of the Third Century after Christ (Princeton 1950) 146 Google Scholar; Wilson, D. R., The Historical Geography of Bithynia, Paphlagonia and Pontus in the Greek and Roman periods, DPhil thesis (Oxford 1960) 223 Google Scholar; Virgilio, B., Il ‘Tempio Stato’ di Pessinunte fra Pergamo e Roma nel II-I secolo A.C. (Pisa 1981) 49 Google Scholar. There is no archaeological evidence to support the concept of temple states so far. Furthermore, especially the issues of landownership of temples create difficulties in the discussions of the concepts of ‘estate’ and ‘state’. For details of temple lands see Broughton, T.R. S. ‘Roman Asia Minor’, in Frank, T. (ed.), An Economic Survey of Ancient Rome (Baltimore 1938) 499–919 Google Scholar.

2 Dignas, B., Economy of the Sacred in Hellenistic and Roman Asia Minor (Oxford 2002) 227 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Cancik, H. and Schneider, H. (eds), Brill’s New Pauly (Leiden 2006) VIII, 49 Google Scholar; also see note 1 above.

4 Archibald, Z. H.), ‘Setting the scene’, in Archibald, Z. H., et. al. (eds), Hellenistic Economies (New York 2001) 1–9 Google Scholar.

5 There is little information on the worship of the goddess Ma in Anatolia. For details see Çapar, Ö. ‘Yerli bir Anadolu Tanriçasi: Ma’, Dil ve Tarih Coğrafya Dergisi 37 (1995) 583-99Google Scholar. For representation of the goddess on coins of Comana Pontica during the reigns of Caligula, Trajan and Septimus Severus see Amandry, M. and Rémy, B., Comana du Pont sous l’empire romain. Étude historique et corpus monétaire (Milan 1999)Google Scholar.

6 Strabo, Geography, XII.2.3.

7 Procopius, History of the Wars, 1.17.15. Graf, F., ‘Das Götterbild aus dem Taurerland’, Antike Welt 10/4 (1979) 33 Google Scholar.

8 Strabo stated that at Comana Cappadocia people named the cult Ma and the cult was also identified with the cult of Enyo: Strabo, Geography XII. 2.3.

9 Strabo, Geography, XII.3.32.

10 See IGR III, no. 106 (Inscripciones Graecae ad res romanas pertinentes); Cumont, E. and Cumont, F., Studia Pontica II: Voyage d’exploration archéologique dans le Pont et la Petite Arménie (Brussels 1906) 251 Google Scholar; Wilson, The Historical Geography of Bithynia, Paphlagonia and Pontus, 231.

11 Supplementum epigraphicum graecum, XLII (1992) 339; “Wilson, The Historical Geography of Bithynia, Paphlagonia and Pontus, 233; Rémy, B., et al., ‘Rapport de travaux épigraphiques et numismatiques au Musée de Tokat en juillet 1988’, VII. Araştirma Sonuçlari Toplantisi (Ankara 1990) 515-31Google Scholar.

12 Asst. Prof. Dr. Bekir Necati Altin of Niğde University joined our team in 2008 and prepared the map following his on-site observations.

13 The white dots are a representative number of archaeological sites discovered between 2004–2008. They date from the Early Bronze Age through the Turkish medieval period.

14 These excavations have not been published but reports with photographs are available at the Tokat Museum.

15 In 2004, dense Roman pottery spread across an area of approximately 100m in diameter, as well as remains of a vaulted structure, were discovered at the foothills of a hill named Nüğücük. The site has the largest collection of Roman pottery discovered in the vicinity so far and the pottery was dated to the 2nd century A.D. with a few examples of Hellenistic pottery. Erciyas, D. B., ‘Tokat İli Komana Antik Kenti Yüzey Araştirmasi 2004’, XXVII. Araştirma Sonuçlari Toplantisi II. Cilt (Ankara 2006) 13–22 Google Scholar.

16 This rock was the subject of legends about St. Chrysostom. For details see Telfer, W., ‘The cultus of St. Gregory Thaumaturgus’, The Harvard Theological Review 29 (1936) 341 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Bryer, A. and Winfield, D., The Byzantine Monuments and Topography of the Pontos (Washington, D. C. 1985) 21 Google Scholar; Hogarth, D. G. and Munro, J. A. R. ‘Modern and ancient roads in Asia Minor’, Royal Geographical Society, Supplementary Papers, III (1891) 732-35Google Scholar; Anderson, , Studia Pontica, I, 60-7Google Scholar.

18 Freytag, G. W., ‘Geschichte der Dynastien der Hamdaniden in Mosul und Aleppo’, Zeitschrift der deutschen morgenländischen Gesellschaft 10 (1856) 467 Google Scholar; Honigmann, E., ‘Un itinéraire arabe à travers le Pont’, Annuaire de l’Institut de Philologie et Histoire Orientales 4 (1936) 261-71Google Scholar.

19 Bryer and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments, 23.

20 Bryer and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments, 24.

21 Erciyas, D. B., ‘Komana Antik Kenti Yüzey Araştirmasi 2005’, XXIV. Araştirma Sonuçlari Toplantisi II. Cilt (Ankara 2007) 155-66Google Scholar.

22 Strabo, Geography, XII.3.34-35.

23 See Mitchell, S., Anatolia. Land, Men and Gods in Asia Minor (Oxford 1993) II, 37–43 Google Scholar; Chavarria, A. and Lewit, T., ‘Archaeological research on the Late Antique countryside: a bibliographic essay’ in Bowden, W., et. al. (eds.) Recent Research on the Late Antique Countryside (Leiden 2004) 3–51.Google Scholar

24 Trombley, F. R., ‘Paganism in the Greek world at the end of Antiquity: the case of rural Anatolia and Greece’ The Harvard Theological Review 78 (1985) 327-52Google Scholar.

25 Mitchell, Anatolia, 62; Kacar, T., ‘Early Christianity in the Black Sea: an examination of the literary evidence’, Colloquium Anatolicum 7 (2008) 197–215 Google Scholar.

26 For a list of the participants of the Nicaea Council, see Mansi, J. D., Sacrorum Conciliorum Nova et Amplissima Collectio (Florence 1759, 1927) 691–702 Google Scholar; Honigmann, E., ‘The original list of the members of the Council of Nicaea, the Robber-Synod and the Council of Chalcedon’, B 16 (1942) 20–80 Google Scholar.

27 Trombley, F. R., Hellenic Religion and Christianization c.370-529 (Leiden 1994) II, 75 Google Scholar.

28 Pliny, Letters 10.96.

29 Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, 4.23.6,

30 According to Telfer, ‘St. Gregory Thaumaturgus’, 229, there is no information about the establishment of the church of Neocaesarea. However, the panegyric of Gregory of Nyssa which was written to keep the memory of Gregory Thaumaturgus alive, suggests a close link between Neocaesarea and Thaumaturgus. For further details see Telfer, ‘St Gregory Thaumaturgus’, 229.

31 For the election of Alexander by Gregory Thaumaturgus, see G Heil, ‘De Vita Gregoru Thaumaturgi’, in Heil, G. et al, Gregorii Nysseni Sermones Pars II, The Brill Dictionary of Gregory of Nysa (Leiden 1990) 37-8Google Scholar; Sterk, A., ‘On Basil, Moses, and the model bishop: the Cappadocian legacy of leadership’, Church History 67 (1998) 227-53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Foss, and Winfield, , Byzantine Fortifications (Pretoria 1986) 19 Google Scholar; Erciyas, D. B., Wealth, Aristocracy and Propaganda under the Hellenistic Kingdom of the Mithradatids (Leiden 2006) 49 Google Scholar.

33 According to the text, his chapel was situated at Cumialis, possibly a reference to a village named Omala: von Lüdtke, W. W., ‘Das Martyrium des Basiliscus’, Archiv für slaviscbe Philologie 35 (1914) 44-5Google Scholar. In the 2007 survey season, we found a rectangular structure with rooms possibly dating to the Byzantine period. See below, 134 for further information on survey results.

34 Mansi, Sacrorum Conciliorum, 699-700.

35 Cowper, B. H., Syriac Miscellanies; or Extracts relating to the First and Second General Councils, and various other quotations, theological, historical, and classical (London and Edinburgh 1861) 33 Google Scholar.

36 Bateson, M., Origin and early history of double monasteries’ Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, n.s. 13 (1899) 140 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Morrison, E. F., St Basil and his rule: a study in early monasticism (London 1912) 4 Google Scholar; Kopecek, T. A., ‘The social class of the Cappadocian Fathers’ Church History 42/4 (1973) 464–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Also a chapel on the family’s estate at Annesi is mentioned in Rossiter, J. J., ‘Roman villas of the Greek East and the villa in Gregory of Nyssa Ep. 20’ Journal of Roman Archaeology 2 (1989) 101-10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

37 A long discussion about the location of Ibora can be found in Ramsay, W.M., The Historical Geography of Asia Minor (repr. Amsterdam 1962) 326 Google Scholar.

38 Attwater, D., St. John Chrysostom, pastor and preacher (London 1959) 168-9Google Scholar.

39 Telfer, ‘St. Gregory Thaumaturgus’, 341.

40 Lequien, M., Oriens Christianus (Paris 1740) 515-8Google Scholar.

41 Comana was also in the list which was prepared by Hierocles during the reign of Justinian. This list, the Synecdemus, contains the administrative divisions of the Byzantine empire. See Ramsay, The Historical Geography of Asia Minor, 319.

42 Conybeare, F. C., ‘On some Armenian Notitiae’, BZ 5 (1896) 118-36Google Scholar.

43 The Byzantine Pontos has been thoroughly studied by Bryer and Winfield. However, the focus of their monumental work was the empire of Trebizond and thus, they included mostly the coastal part of the Pontos, ethnically the Greek settlements, from Cape Carambis in the west to Bathys (Batumi) in the east. In the south, the borders remained less defined and excluded the territory of Comana and Tokat, providing information only on the nearest town of Neocaesarea: Bryer, and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments, 2. The Tabula Imperii Byzantini series by the Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften deals with the neighbouring regions, such as Paphlagonia and Cappadocia, but a thorough investigation of the area between Cappadocia and Bryer and Winfield’s Pontos is unfortunately lacking. Hild, F. and Restle, M., Kappadokien. Tabula Imperii Byzantini 2 (Vienna 1981)Google Scholar and Belke, K., Paphlagonien und Honōrias. Tabula Imperii Byzantini 9 (Vienna 1996)Google Scholar.

44 Bryer, and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments, 107, Jones, A. H. M., The cities of the eastern Roman provinces (Oxford 1937) 526 Google Scholar.

45 Bryer, and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments, 107.

46 Vryonis, S., The Decline of medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor and the process of Islamization from the eleventh through the fifteenth century (Berkeley 1971) 7 Google Scholar.

47 Vryonis, The Decline of medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor, 160.

48 Vryonis, The Decline of medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor, 161-2.

49 Melikoff, I., La geste de Melik Danişmend (Paris 1960)Google Scholar. The impact of the conflicts between the Turks and the Byzantines on the towns of the Pontos is explained in a detailed manner in Vryonis’ book.

50 Vryonis, The Decline of medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor, 169.

51 This phenomenon will be presented in the conclusion.

52 Melikoff, Danişmendname, 278, 284, 380-1.

53 Haldon, J.F., Constantine Porphyrogenitus, Three Treatises on Imperial Military Expeditions (Vienna 1990) 81 Google Scholar; Foss, C. and Winfield, D. Byzantine Fortifications: an introduction (Pretoria 1986) 19 Google Scholar.

54 The changes in settlement pattern from the Roman to the Late Antique period has been demonstrated in Erciyas, D. B Ankan, ‘Studies in the archaeology of Hellenistic Pontus: the settlements, monuments, and coinage of Mithradates VI and his predecessors’, (Cincinnati 2001) 70-1 (PhD dissertation, University of Cincinnati)Google Scholar. The study is based on the data provided by the various survey projects in the area.

55 Bryer, and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments, 16.

56 Crow, J. and Hill, S, ‘The Byzantine fortifications of Amastris in Paphlagonia’ Anatolian Studies 45 (1995)Google Scholar; Crow, J. and Bryer, A., ‘Survey in Trabzon and Gümüşhane Vilayets, Turkey’ DOT 51 (1997) 283-9Google Scholar; Lafli, E. and Zäh, A., ‘Archäologische Forschungen im byzantinischen Hadrianoúpolis in Paphlagonien’ BZ 101 (2008) 681–713 Google Scholar; The Euchaitai Avkat Project http://www.princeton.edu/avkat/links/Report2007final.pdf

57 D.B. Erciyas, Wealth, Aristocracy and Propaganda, 29-115.

58 Marek, C., Stadt, Ära und Territorium in Pontus-Bithynia und nord-Galatia (Tübingen 1993)Google Scholar; Marek, C., Pontus et Bithynia. Die Römischen Provinzen im norden Kleinasiens (Mainz 2003)Google Scholar; Tezgör, D. Kassab and Dereli, F., ‘Sinop-Demirci Amfora Atölyeleri 2000 Kazisi’ XXIII. Kazi Sonuçlan Toplantisi II.Cilt (Ankara 2002) 235-42Google Scholar; Doonan, O. and Gantos, A. J., et al., ‘Sinop ve Çevresi Arkeolojik Yüzey Araştirmasi 1999’ XVIII. Araştirma Sonuçlan Toplantisi I.Cilt (Ankara 2001) 137-48Google Scholar; Doonan, O.P., Sinop Landscapes: exploring connections in a Black Sea hinterland (Philadelphia 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Summerer, L., ‘Pompeipolis (Paflagonya) 2006 yili Çalişmalari’ XXIX. Kazi Sonuçlari Toplantisi III.Cilt (Ankara 2008) 243-64Google Scholar; Lafli, E., ‘Terra Sigillatae from Hadrianoupolis in Paphlagonia’ XXIX. Kazi Sonuçlan Toplantisi III.Cilt (Ankara 2008) 285-98Google Scholar.

59 Erciyas, D. Burcu, ‘Tokat İli Komana Antik Kenti Yüzey Araştirmasi 2004’ XXIII. Araştirma Sonuçlan Toplantisi II.Cilt (Ankara 2005) 13–22 Google Scholar.

60 Eyice, S.,’Contributions à Phistoire de l’art byzantin: quatre édifices inédits ou mal connus’, Cahiers Archéologiques 10 (1959) 254 Google Scholar.

61 Eyice, S.,’Bizans Mimarisinde Diş Cephelerde Kullamlan Bazi Keramoplastik Süsler (Süs Çömlekleri)’ Ayasofya Müzesi Yilliği 3 (1961) 26–27 Google Scholar; Filow, B. D., Die altbulgarische Kunst (Bern 1919) 20-2Google Scholar; Crow, J. and Hill, S.,’The Byzantine fortifications of Amastris in Paphlagonia’, Anatolian Studies 45 (1995) 260 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 The dates suggested for the ceramics in this article have derived from a preliminary study by Mr. Will Anderson during his very brief visit to the site in 2008. We would like to thank him for his contributions.

63 Anderson, Studia Vontica, I, 63.

64 Witte-Orr, J., ‘Bricks and tiles from the Triangular Tower at Amorium’, in Böhlendorf-Arslan, B., et al. (eds), Çanak: Late Antique and Medieval Pottery and Tiles in Mediterranean Archaeological Contexts (Byzas 7) (Istanbul 2007) 295–308 Google Scholar.

65 We are thankful to the Tokat Museum director and staff who generously shared this information and provided photographs of the seal.

66 Such as Bryer, and Winfield, Byzantine Monuments; Foss, and Winfield, Byzantine Fortifications; Crow and Hill, ‘The Byzantine fortifications of Amastris’.