Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-767nl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T11:23:02.117Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Exxon at Grand Bois, Louisiana: A Three-Level Analysis of Management Decision Making and Corporate Conduct

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 January 2015

J. Brooke Hamilton III  and
Eric J. Berken
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

In the early 1990s, managers at Exxon decided to seek lower cost disposal in Louisiana for oil-field wastes declared hazardous in Alabama. This decision resulted in injuries to the residents of Grand Bois, Louisiana; the disposal company; Exxon; and the oil industry in the state. Given the need for business and society to manage business operations for mutual benefit, it is essential to understand why businesses injure the public so that similar incidents do not happen again. The authors use three analytical perspectives to suggest how corporations may make unethical decisions without purposefully setting out to do so: their managers may fail to understand changing social expectations for corporate behavior; they may adopt organizational structures, policies, and procedures that block ethical action in the name of efficiency; and they may follow unwritten rules of behavior for career success that exclude ethics. These perspectives suggest that individual Exxon managers may not have been making greed-based decisions, weighing corporate gains against harms to others. The situation more likely involved a failure, for the reasons discussed, to raise ethics questions in making business decisions. This explanation does not make much difference to those injured nor does it absolve those who made the decisions. It does make a difference to society and to companies seeking to understand factors that have to be overcome in any large corporation that wishes to prevent such events from occurring.

Type
Articles
Information
Business Ethics Quarterly , Volume 15 , Issue 3 , July 2005 , pp. 385 - 408
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Business Ethics 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Anand, V., Ashforth, B., and Joshi, M.. 2004. “Business as Usual: The Acceptance and Perpetuation of Corruption in Organizations.” Academy of Management Executive 18(2): 39–53.Google Scholar
Anderson Forest, S., Reed, S., Belton, C., Webb, A., and Wheatley, J.. 2001. “Exxon Unleashed: How the World’s Most Powerful Corporation Plans to Dominate the New Age of Oil Exploration.” Business Week (April 9).Google Scholar
Associated Press. 1998. “Grand Bois May Spark New Waste-Site Rules.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (August 12).Google Scholar
Baton Rouge Advocate. 1998. “Opinion: Agencies Failed at Grand Bois” (April 21).Google Scholar
Bernstein, A. 2000. “Too Much Corporate Power.” BusinessWeek (September 11).Google Scholar
Bowen, M., and Power, F.. 1993. “The Moral Manager: Communicative Ethics and the Exxon Valdez Disaster.” Business Ethics Quarterly 3(1) (April): 97–116.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
The Business Roundtable. 1997. Statement on Corporate Governance, 2–4.Google Scholar
CBS News. 1997. Town Under Siege (videotape). New York: CBS News.Google Scholar
Chambliss, D. 1996. Beyond Caring: Hospitals, Nurses, and the Social Organization of Ethics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chris, R., and Fields-Meyer, T. 1998. “Beginners’ Pluck.” People Weekly 50(7) (August 31): 157.Google Scholar
Colvin, J. 2001. “Value Driven: Should Companies Care?” Fortune (June 11).Google Scholar
Conoco Corporation. 2001. “Conoco Sustainable Growth Report.” Retrieved November 1, 2001, from the World Wide Web: www.sustainablegrowth.conoco.com.Google Scholar
Corporate Watch. 1998. “Big Oil’s Secret Plan to Block the Global Warming Treaty” (April 26). Retrieved September 30, 2001, from the World Wide Web: http://www.igc.org/trac/climate/background/1998/bigoil.html.Google Scholar
Courreges, P. 2001. “Oilfield Waste Rules Presented to Panel.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (November 28).Google Scholar
Crow, P. 1997. “Campbell Wells.” Oil & Gas Journal 95(39) (September 29): 46.Google Scholar
Darley, J. 1996. “How Organizations Socialize Individuals into Evildoing.” In Codes of Conduct: Behavioral Reseach into Business Ethics, ed. Messick, D. M. and Tenbrunsel, A. E.. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 13–43.Google Scholar
DeGeorge, R. 1990. Business Ethics, third edition. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1998a. “Exxon Engineer Testifies in Lawsuit.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (July 22).Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1998b. “Witness Raises Credibility Question.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (August 7).Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1998c. “Grand Bois Defendant Settles with Plaintiffs.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (August 8).Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1998d. “Jury Foreman Says Plaintiffs Case Unproven.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (August 11): A1, A5.Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1999a. “Oilfield Waste Tests to Proceed.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (March 9).Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1999b. “Unsafe Amount of Benzene Found in Oil-field Waste.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (April 2).Google Scholar
Dunne, M. 1999c. “Experts Advise to Close Grand Bois Site.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (May 15).Google Scholar
Economist. 1994. “Inside the Empire of Exxon the Unloved” (March 5).Google Scholar
Economist. 2003. “Christine Casey: Whistle-Blower” (January 18).Google Scholar
Economist. 2004. “Two-Faced Capitalism” (January 22).Google Scholar
Engardio, P., and Belton, C.. 2000. “Global Capitalism: Can it Be Made to Work Better?” Newsweek (November 6): 40.Google Scholar
Ethics Resource Center. 2003. “National Business Ethics Survey” (www.ethics.org).Google Scholar
ExxonMobil. 2005. “Corporate Citizenship,” at http://www2.exxonmobil.com/corporate/Citizenship/Corp_citizenship_home.asp.Google Scholar
France, M. 2001a. “The Litigation Machine.” BusinessWeek (January 29).Google Scholar
France, M. 2001b. “When Big Oil Gets Too Slick.” BusinessWeek (April 9).Google Scholar
Friedman, M. 1970. “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase its Profits.” New York Times Magazine (September 13).Google Scholar
Gaudet, K. 2001. “Leeville Residents Speak Against Oil Waste Treatment Facility.” The Houma Courier (January 23).Google Scholar
Gray, C. 1997. “Pits Cause Stink in Lafourche.” New Orleans Times-Picayune (July 14).Google Scholar
Green, R. 1996. “Responsibility and the Virtual Corporation,” in Is The Good Corporation Dead? ed. Houck, J. and Williams, O.. Lanham, Md.: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 37–47.Google Scholar
Hamilton, J., and Hoch, D.. 1997. “Ethical Standards for Business Lobbying: Some Practical Suggestions.” Business Ethics Quarterly 7(3) (July): 117–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hamilton III, J. B., Smith, M., and Scheck, S. L.. 2002. “Conoco’s Decision: The First Annual President’s Award for Business Ethics.” North American Case Research Journal 22(3) (Summer): 79–95.Google Scholar
Hoch, D., and Hamilton III, J. B.. 1999. “The Hope and Limits of Legal Optimism: A Comment on the Theories of Orts and Nesteruk Regarding the Impact of Law on Corporate Ethics.” Business Ethics Quarterly 9(4) (October): 677–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holmes, S. 2003. “Boeing: What Really Happened?” Business Week 15 (December): 32.Google Scholar
Hymowitz, C. 2002. “Resolving to Let 2003 Be the Year of Leading With Higher Standards.” Wall Street Journal (December 31): A9.Google Scholar
Jackall, R. 1988. Moral Mazes: The World of Corporate Managers. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Jawahar, I., and McLaughlin, G.. 2001. “Toward a Descriptive Stakeholder Theory: An Organizational Life Cycle Approach.” Academy of Management Review 26(3): 397–414.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Krefting, L. 2003. “Review of Ethics and HRD: A New Approach To Leading Responsible Organizations, by Tim Hatcher.” Academy of Management Review 28(3) (July): 512–14.Google Scholar
Lafayette Advertiser. 1997. “Oil Industry Waste Analysis Overdue” (December 28).Google Scholar
Lafayette Advertiser. 2001. “Regulations Result from Grand Bois Experience” (December 13).Google Scholar
Lanier, P. A., Carson, P. P., Carson, K. D., Hamilton III, J. B., and Birkenmeier, B.. 2003. “And All Who Jumped Died: An Examination of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire and its Legacy,” Management Decision & Journal of Management History 41(4): 407–21.Google Scholar
Lorando, M. 1997. “Ed Bradley: Big News in Grand Bois.” New Orleans Times-Picayune (December 21).Google Scholar
Louisiana Public Broadcasting (Producer). 1998. Louisiana: The State We’re In [videotape].Google Scholar
Louisiana Office of Conservation. 1999. E&P Waste Testing Emergency Rules. Retrieved March 29, 1999, from the World Wide Web: http://www.dnr.state.la.us/cons/conserin/wastrule/wastrule.ssi.Google Scholar
Martin, J. 2002. Organizational Culture: Mapping the Terrain. Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McMahon, B. 1997. “Oil Waste Site Bill Killed in Committee.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (June 17).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 1997. “Exxon Told to Clean Up and then Used Louisiana as Dumpsite for Waste.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (November 3).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 1998a. Judge Splits Grand Bois Suit, Orders LSU Researcher to Testify.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (May 5).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 1998b. “Expert Witness Says Arsenic in House from Waste Site.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (May 22).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 1998c. “Expert Says Waste Site Not Harmful.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (June 2).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 1998d. “Judge Rules Exxon Can Seek Aid in Grand Bois Award.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (December 1).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 1999. “Waste Hearing Delayed.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (July 29).Google Scholar
McMillan, J. 2000. “Exxon To Pay $325,000 For Documents Sanctions.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (January 20).Google Scholar
McMillan, J., and Dunne, M.. 1998. “Plaintiffs Shocked Jury Didn’t See Harm of Site.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (August 10).Google Scholar
McMillan, J., and Dunne, M.. 1999. “Grand Bois Judge Sets July Hearing.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (May 22).Google Scholar
Metcalf, R. 1997. Questions and Answers: Exploration and Production Wastes (September 18). Baton Rouge, La.: Louisiana Mid Continental Oil Gas Association.Google Scholar
Mitchell, R., Agle, B. R., and Wood, D.. 1997. “Toward a Theory of Stakeholder Identification and Salience: Defining the Principle of Who and What Really Counts.” Academy of Management Review 22(4): 853–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Natural Concept. 2001. Retrieved October 29, 2001, from the World Wide Web: http://iisd.ca/business/naturalconcept.htm.Google Scholar
Paine, L. 1994. “Managing for Organizational Integrity.” Harvard Business Review 72(2) (March/April): 107–17.Google Scholar
Pastin, M. 1986. The Hard Problems of Management: Gaining the Ethics Edge. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, Inc.Google Scholar
Phillips, M. 1999. “World Bank, in Boost to Chad, May Back Exxon-Led Oil Venture.” Wall Street Journal (June 7): A19.Google Scholar
Redman, C. 1998. “DNR Stops On-Site Oilfield-Waste Tests.” The Baton Rouge Advocate (October 8).Google Scholar
Sells, A. 1999. The Power of Exxon. Retrieved September 28, 2001 from the World Wide Web: http://webpages.marshall.edu/~ewen/exxon.htm.Google Scholar
Snyder, D. 1995. “Small Town Refuses to Hold Nose Anymore.” New Orleans Times-Picayune (November 23).Google Scholar
Thomas, T., Schermerhorn, J., and Dienhart, J.. 2004. “Strategic Leadership of Ethical Behavior in Business.” Academy of Management Executive 18(2): 56–66.Google Scholar
New Orleans Times-Picayune. 1995. “Waste Disposer Gets Fined” (May 28).Google Scholar
Unseem, J. 2002. “The 2002 Fortune 500. Exxon’s African Adventure: How to Build a $3.5 Billion Pipeline—With the ‘Help’ of NGOs, the World Bank, and Yes, Chicken Sacrifices.” Fortune 145(8) (April 15): 102–14.Google Scholar
Virgin, B. 2003. “Boeing May Not Practice the Ethics it Preaches.” Editorial Opinion. Seattle Post-Intelligencer (July 31): C1.Google Scholar
Wartick, S., and Wood, D.. 1998. International Business and Society. Malden, Mass.: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Waters, J. 1978. “Catch 20.5: Corporate Morality as an Organizational Phenomenon.” Organizational Dynamics (Spring).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Werhane, P. 1999. Moral Imagination and Management Decision Making. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Zganjar, L. 1998. “Grand Bois Shows Need for Change: Oil Field Waste is Presumed Safe by Law, but Not by Science.” New Orleans Times-Picayune (August 22).Google Scholar