Skip to main content Accessibility help

Biodiversity vs. biocontrol: positive and negative effects of alternative prey on control of slugs by carabid beetles

  • W.O.C. Symondson (a1), S. Cesarini (a1), P.W. Dodd (a1), G.L. Harper (a1), M.W. Bruford (a1), D.M. Glen (a2), C.W. Wiltshire (a3) and J.D. Harwood (a1)...


Environment-friendly farming techniques seek to increase invertebrate biodiversity in part with the intention of encouraging greater numbers of predators that will help to control crop pests. However, in theory, this effect may be negated if the availability of a greater abundance and diversity of alternative prey diverts predators away from feeding on pests. The hypothesis that access to alternative prey can lead to reduced pest suppression under semi-field conditions was tested. Alternative prey type and diversity were manipulated in 70 mesocosms over 7+ weeks in the presence of the carabid Pterostichus melanarius (Illiger), a known predator of slugs, and reproducing populations of the slug Deroceras reticulatum (Müller). Significantly fewer slugs survived where no alternative prey were provided. Maximum slug numbers and biomass were found in treatments containing either carabids plus a high diversity of alternative prey (many species of earthworm and three of Diptera larvae) or a single additional prey (blowfly larvae, Calliphora vomitoria Linnaeus). In these treatments slug numbers and biomass were as high as in plots lacking predators. The effects of alternative prey were taxon-specific. Alternative prey strongly affected carabid fitness in terms of biomass and egg load. The fittest predators (those with access to high alternative prey diversity or C. vomitoria larvae) reduced slug numbers the least. The mean individual slug weights were greater in treatments with alternative prey than where no alternative prey were provided to the carabids. These results suggest that pests may survive and reproduce more rapidly in patches where predators have access to alternative prey.


Corresponding author

*Fax: +44 (0)29 20 874 305 E-mail:


Hide All
Agustí, N., Shayler, S., Harwood, J.D., Vaughan, I.P., Sunderland, K.D. & Symondson, W.O.C. (2003) Collembola as alternative prey sustaining spiders in arable ecosystems: prey detection within predators using molecular markers. Molecular Ecology 12, 34673475.
Bohan, D.A., Bohan, A.C., Glen, D.M., Symondson, W.O.C., Wiltshire, C.W. & Hughes, L. (2000) Spatial dynamics of predation by carabid beetles on slugs. Journal of Animal Ecology 69, 367379.
Bommarco, R. (1998) Reproduction and energy reserves of a predatory carabid beetle relative to agroecosystems complexity. Ecological Applications 8, 846853.
Bommarco, R. (1999) Feeding, reproduction and community impact of a predatory carabid in two agricultural habitats. Oikos 87, 8996.
Buckland, S.M. & Grime, J.P. (2000) The effects of trophic structure and soil fertility on the assembly of plant communities. Oikos 91, 336352.
Chang, G.C. & Kareiva, P. (1999) The case for indigenous generalists in biological control. pp. 103115 in Hawkins, B.A. & Cornell, H.V. (Eds) Theoretical approaches to biological control. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Cornic, J.F. (1973) Etude du régime alimentaire de trois espèces de Carabiques et de ses variations en verger de pommiers. Annales Société Entomologique de France 9, 6987.
Chiverton, P.A. (1987) Predation of Rhopalosiphum padi (Homoptera: Aphididae) by polyphagous predatory arthropods during the aphids' pre-peak period in spring barley. Annals of Applied Biology 111, 257269.
Dodd, C.S., Bruford, M.W., Symondson, W.O.C. & Glen, D.M. (2003) Detection of slug DNA within carabid predators using prey-specific PCR primers. pp. 1320 in Slug and snail pests: agricultural, veterinary and environmental perspectives. Alton, British Crop Protection Council.
El Titi, A. (2003) Effects of tillage on invertebrates in agroecosystems. pp. 261296 in El Titi, A. (Ed.) Soil tillage in agroecosystems. London, CRC Press.
Finch, S. (1996) Effect of beetle size on predation of cabbage root fly eggs by ground beetles. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 81, 199206.
Finke, D.L. & Denno, R.F. (2004) Predator diversity dampens trophic cascades. Nature 429, 407410.
Fisker, E.N. & Toft, S. (2004) Effects of chronic exposure to a toxic prey in a generalist predator. Physiological Entomology 29, 129138.
Fry, J.C. (1993) Biological data analysis: a practical approach. Oxford, IRL Press.
Glen, D.M. & Symondson, W.O.C. (2003) Influence of soil tillage on slugs and their natural enemies. pp. 207227 in El Titi, A. (Ed.) Soil tillage in agroecosystems. London, CRC Press.
Glen, D.M., Wiltshire, C.W. & Milsom, N.F. (1988) Effects of straw disposal on slug problems in cereals. Aspects of Applied Biology 17, 173179.
Glen, D.M., Milsom, N.F. & Wiltshire, C.W. (1989) Effects of seed-bed conditions on slug numbers and damage to winter wheat in a clay soil. Annals of Applied Biology 115, 177190.
Greene, A. (1975) Biology of five species of Cychrini (Coleoptera: Carabidae) in the steppe region of south-eastern Washington. Melanderia 19, 143.
Greenstone, M.H. (1979) Spider behaviour optimises dietary essential amino acid composition. Nature 282, 501503.
Halaj, J. & Wise, D.H. (2002) Impact of a detrital subsidy on trophic cascades in a terrestrial grazing food web. Ecology 83, 31413151.
Harmon, J.P. & Andow, D.A. (2004) Indirect effects between shared prey: predictions for biological control. BioControl 49, 605626.
Harper, G.L., King, R.A., Dodd, C.S., Harwood, J.D., Glen, D.M., Bruford, M.W. & Symondson, W.O.C. (2005) Rapid screening of invertebrate predators for multiple prey DNA targets. Molecular Ecology 14, 819827.
Harwood, J.D., Sunderland, K.D. & Symondson, W.O.C. (2004) Prey selection by linyphiid spiders: molecular tracking of the effects of alternative prey on rates of aphid consumption in the field. Molecular Ecology 13, 35493560.
Holland, J.M. (2004) The environmental consequences of adopting conservation tillage in Europe: reviewing the evidence. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 103, 125.
Holland, J.M. & Reynolds, C.J.M. (2003) The impact of soil cultivation on arthropod (Coleoptera and Araneae) emergence on arable land. Pedobiologia 47, 181191.
Holt, R.D. & Lawton, J.H. (1994) The ecological consequences of shared natural enemies. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 25, 495520.
Jones, A.A. & Selman, B.J. (1985) Microsporidium novacastriensis n. sp., a mircosporidian parasite of the grey field slug, Deroceras reticulatum. Journal of Protozoology 34, 581586.
Kendall, D.A., Chinn, N.E., Glen, D.M., Wiltshire, C.W., Winstone, L. & Tidbold, C. (1995) Effects of soil management on cereal pests and their natural enemies. pp. 83102 in Glen, D.M., Greaves, M.P. & Anderson, H.M. (Eds) Ecology and integrated farming systems. Chichester, John Wiley & Sons.
Kladivko, E.J. (2001) Tillage systems and soil ecology. Soil and Tillage Research 61, 6176.
Köller, K. (2003) Techniques of soil tillage. pp. 125 in El Titi, A. (Ed.) Soil tillage in agroecosystems. London, CRC Press.
Koss, A.M. & Snyder, W.E. (2005) Alternative prey disrupt biocontrol by a guild of generalist predators. Biological Control 32, 243251.
Mayntz, D., Raubenheimer, D., Salomon, M., Toft, S. & Simpson, S.J. (2005) Nutrient-specific foraging in invertebrate predators. Science 307, 111113.
McCann, K.S., Hastings, A. & Huxel, G.R. (1998) Weak trophic interactions and the balance of nature. Nature 395, 794798.
McKemey, A., Symondson, W.O.C., Glen, D.M. & Brain, P. (2001) Effects of slug size on predation by Pterostichus melanarius (Coleoptera: Carabidae). Biocontrol Science and Technology 11, 8393.
McKemey, A., Symondson, W.O.C. & Glen, D.M. (2003) Predation and prey size choice by the carabid beetle Pterostichus melanarius (Coleoptera: Carabidae): the dangers of extrapolating from laboratory to field. Bulletin of Entomological Research 93, 227234.
Moran, M.D. (2003) Arguments for rejecting the sequential Bonferroni in ecological studies. Oikos 100, 403405.
Murdoch, W.W., Chesson, J. & Chesson, P.L. (1985) Biological control in theory and practice. American Naturalist 125, 344366.
Oberholzer, F. & Frank, T. (2003) Predation by the carabid beetles Pterostichus melanarius and Poecilus cupreus on slugs and slug eggs. Biocontrol Science and Technology 13, 99110.
Oberholzer, F., Escher, N. & Frank, T. (2003) The potential of carabid beetles (Coleoptera) to reduce slug damage to oilseed rape in the laboratory. European Journal of Entomology 100, 8185.
Oelbermann, K. & Scheu, S. (2002) Effects of prey type and mixed diets on survival, growth and development of a generalist predator, Pardosa lugubris. Basic and Applied Ecology 3, 285291.
Perneger, T.V. (1998) What's wrong with Bonferroni adjustments? British Medical Journal 316, 12361238.
Polis, G.A., Myers, C.A. & Holt, R.D. (1989) The ecology and evolution of intraguild predation: potential competitors that eat each other. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 20, 297330.
Pyke, G.H. (1984) Optimal foraging theory: a critical review. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 15, 523575.
Rypstra, A.L. & Marshall, S.D. (2005) Augmentation of soil detritus affects the spider community and herbivory in a soybean agroecosystem. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 116, 149157.
Settle, W.H., Ariawan, H., Astuti, E.T., Cahyana, W., Hakim, A.L., Hindayana, D., Lestari, A.S. & Sartanto, P. (1996) Managing tropical rice pests through conservation of generalist natural enemies and alternative prey. Ecology 77, 19751988.
Sheppard, S.K. & Harwood, J.D. (2005) Advances in molecular ecology: tracking trophic links through predator–prey food webs. Functional Ecology 19, 751762.
Sims, R.W. & Gerard, B.M. (1985) Earthworms. London, E.J. Brill/Dr W. Backhuys.
Stephens, D.W. & Krebs, J.R. (1986) Foraging theory. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
Stinner, B.R. & House, G.J. (1990) Arthropods and other invertebrates in conservation tillage agriculture. Annual Review of Entomology 35, 299318.
Sunderland, K.D. (1975) The diet of some predatory arthropods in cereal crops. Journal of Applied Ecology 17, 389396.
Sunderland, K.D. (2002) Invertebrate pest control by carabids. pp. 165214 in Holland, J.M. (Ed.) The agroecology of carabid beetles. Andover, Intercept.
Sunderland, K.D., Powell, W. & Symondson, W.O.C. (2005) Populations and communities. pp. 299434 in Jervis, M.A. (Ed.) Insects as natural enemies: a practical perspective. Berlin, Springer.
Symondson, W.O.C. (1993) Chemical confinement of slugs: an alternative to electric fences. Journal of Molluscan Studies 59, 259261.
Symondson, W.O.C. (1997) Does Tandonia budapestensis (Mollusca: Pulmonata) contain toxins? Evidence from feeding trials with the slug predator Pterostichus melanarius (Coleoptera: Carabidae). Journal of Molluscan Studies 7, 457465.
Symondson, W.O.C. (2002) Molecular identification of prey in predator diets. Molecular Ecology 11, 627641.
Symondson, W.O.C. (2004) Coleoptera (Carabidae, Drilidae, Lampyridae and Staphylinidae) as predators of terrestrial gastropods. pp. 3784 in Barker, G.M. (Ed.) Natural enemies of terrestrial molluscs. Wallingford, Oxon, CAB International.
Symondson, W.O.C., Glen, D.M.Wiltshire, C.WLangdon, C.J. & Liddell, J.E. (1996) Effects of cultivation techniques and methods of straw disposal on predation by Pterostichus melanarius (Coleoptera: Carabidae) upon slugs (Gastropoda: Pulmonata) in an arable field. Journal of Applied Ecology 33, 741753.
Symondson, W.O.C., Glen, D.M., Erickson, M.L., Liddell, J.E. & Langdon, C.J. (2000) Do earthworms help to sustain the slug predator Pterostichus melanarius (Coleoptera: Carabidae) within crops? Investigations using a monoclonal antibody-based detection system. Molecular Ecology 9, 12791292.
Symondson, W.O.C., Sunderland, K.D. & Greenstone, M.H. (2002a) Can generalist predators be effective biocontrol agents? Annual Review of Entomology 47, 561594.
Symondson, W.O.C., Glen, D.M., Ives, A.R., Langdon, C.J. & Wiltshire, C.W. (2002b) Dynamics of the relationship between a generalist predator and slugs over five years. Ecology 83, 137147.
Thomas, C.F.G., Parkinson, L. & Marshall, E.J.P. (1998) Isolating the components of activity-density for the carabid beetle Pterostichus melanarius in farmland. Oecologia 116, 103112.
Thomas, R.S. (2002) An immunological and behavioural study of the role of carabid beetle larvae as pest control agents in cereal crops. PhD thesis, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK.
Thorbeck, P. & Bilde, T. (2004) Reduced numbers of generalist arthropod predators after crop management. Journal of Applied Ecology 41, 526538.
Tod, M.E. (1973) Notes on beetle predators of molluscs. Entomologist 106, 196201.
Toft, S. & Wise, D.H. (1999) Growth, development and survival of a generalist predators fed single- and mixed-species diets of different quality. Oecologia 119, 191197.
Wilson, M.J., Glen, D.M. & George, S.K. (1993) The rhabditid nematode Phasmarhabditis hermaphrodita as a potential biological control agent for slugs. Biocontrol Science and Technology 3, 503511.
Winder, L., Alexander, C.J., Holland, J.M., Woolley, C. & Perry, J. (2005a) Modelling the dynamic spatio-temporal response of predators to transient prey patches in the field. Ecology Letters 4, 568576.
Winder, L., Alexander, C.J., Holland, J.M., Symondson, W.O.C., Perry, J. & Woolley, C. (2005b) Predatory activity and spatial pattern: the response of generalist carabids to their aphid prey. Journal of Animal Ecology 74, 443454.


Biodiversity vs. biocontrol: positive and negative effects of alternative prey on control of slugs by carabid beetles

  • W.O.C. Symondson (a1), S. Cesarini (a1), P.W. Dodd (a1), G.L. Harper (a1), M.W. Bruford (a1), D.M. Glen (a2), C.W. Wiltshire (a3) and J.D. Harwood (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed