Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

A comparison of modern investment-linked pension savings products

  • Per Linnemann (a1), Kenneth Bruhn (a2) and Mogens Steffensen (a3)

Abstract

This paper is a continuation of and a supplement to the paper by Jørgensen & Linnemann. Both papers deal with TimePension – a (formula-based) smoothed investment-linked annuity pension scheme. Both papers compare TimePension with other pension savings products using stochastic financial simulation. TimePension as well as the financial model and simulation concept being used in both papers were introduced in the paper op cit.

Jørgensen & Linnemann compare TimePension with a traditional with-profits scheme involving bonus entitlement and an investment-linked Unit Link scheme with a fixed proportion of assets invested in equities and other so-called risky assets. Here, TimePension is compared with two investment-linked life-cycle (target date) products. The focus is especially on the decumulation period, and we show that despite the fact that the life-cycle products reduce investment risk in retirement (compared with TimePension’s fixed proportional allocation of assets), the year-over-year stability in benefits provided by TimePension cannot be matched. Even though the overall investment risk on accumulated benefits is at the same level, TimePension provide year-over-year stability, also in case of sharp price changes in the financial market.

Our results show that not only investment profiles define the stability of annuity benefits over time. In addition, more fundamental elements of the product design are important. The perspective on product design and development is Danish, but two of the compared products are generic life-cycle products that exist in equivalent forms in many countries. Similarly, the smoothed income annuities could also become an alternative product design in an international perspective.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Correspondence to: Kenneth Bruhn, SEB Pension, Postboks 100, DK-0900 Copenhagen C, Denmark. Tel: +45 33 28 26 52. E-mail: kbx@sebpension.dk

References

Hide All
Danish Insurance Association. (2008). Samfundsforudsætninger for 2009 – pensionsfremskrivninger (Economic assumptions for 2009 – pension projections). Available at www.finansraadet.dk [accessed October 2014].
Dengsøe, P. (2009). Pension. Nyt Juridisk Forlag, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Engsted, T., Larsen, B.G. & Møller, M. (2011). Anbefalinger om aktieinvesteringer (Recommendations on equity investments). Technical report, The Money and Pension Panel. Danish Financial Authority, Copenhagen.
Faurdal, L. (2006 a). Nye pensionsprodukter vinder frem – er lovgivningen fulgt med? (New pension products are gaining ground – has legislation changed accordingly?). Finans/Invest, 7, 2430.
Faurdal, L. (2006 b). Pensionsprodukter med markedsrente. Nye produkttyper vinder frem – er lovgivningen fulgt med? (Investment-linked pension products. New product types are gaining ground – has legislation changed accordingly?). In L. Andersen & F. Søgaard, (Eds.), 12 perspektiver på pension (12 Perspectives on Pension) pp. 5791. Forlaget Thomsen, Copenhagen.
Gatzert, N. & Schmeiser, H. (2013). New life insurance financial products. In G. Dionne, (Ed.), Handbook of Insurance, 2nd edition. pp. 10611096. Springer, New York, Heidelberg, Dordrecht, London.
Grosen, A. (2005). Nye produkter på det danske pensionsmarked (New products in the Danish pensions market). Finans/Invest, 5, 24.
Grosen, A. & Jørgensen, P.L. (2002). Fokus på pensionkundernes afkastrisiko (Focus on pension customers’ return risk). Finans/Invest, 6, 25.
Grosen, A. & Nielsen, P.H. (2006). Livsindkomsttankegangen vinder frem (Life-income mindset is gaining ground). Finans/Invest, 6, 23.
Guillen, M., Jørgensen, P.L. & Nielsen, J.P. (2006). Return smoothing mechanisms in life and pension insurance: path-dependent contingent claims. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 38, 229252.
Jakobsen, S. (2003). Tidspension som investeringsstrategi (TimePension as investment strategy). Finans/Invest, 3, 1117.
Jørgensen, C. (2005). Danica balance. Finans/Invest, 6, 1719.
Jørgensen, P.L. (2007). Lognormal approximation of path-dependent pension scheme payouts. European Journal of Finance, 13, 595619.
Jørgensen, P.L. & Linnemann, P. (2012). A comparison of three different pension savings products with special emphasis on the payout phase. Annals of Actuarial Science, 6, 137152.
Mowbray, P. (2010). Retirement risk metrics for evaluating target date funds: a scenario modelling framework, Barrie & Hibbert Insights Newsletter, April, 110.
Munk, C., Sørensen, C. & Vinther, T.N. (2004). Dynamic asset allocation under mean-reverting returns, stochastic interest rates, and inflation uncertainty: are popular recommendations consistent with rational behavior? International Review of Economics and Finance, 13, 141166.
Nielsen, J.P. & Jørgensen, P.L. (2002). Tidspension. Finans/Invest, 6, 1621.
Steffensen, M. & Waldstrøm, S. (2009). A two-account model of pension savings contracts. Scandinavian Actuarial Journal, 3, 118.
Svendsen, J. (2010). Pensionerne har kurs mod den store konverteringsbølge (Pensions are heading for the great conversion wave), Berlingske Tidende, Business Section, 30 October, p. 13.
Vasicek, O. (1977). An equilibrium characterization of the term structure. Journal of Financial Economics, 5, 177188.
Wachter, J.A. (2002). Portfolio and consumption decisions under mean-reverting returns: an exact solution for complete markets. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 37, 6391.

Keywords

A comparison of modern investment-linked pension savings products

  • Per Linnemann (a1), Kenneth Bruhn (a2) and Mogens Steffensen (a3)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed